lovecraft68
Bad Doggie
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2009
- Posts
- 42,033
The only downside of breaking the 'rules' of subject matter is that some readers could object, downvote and leave a negative but reasonable comment that influences other readers. I had that reaction for a Halloween contest story featuring costumes and ghosts but not the traditional US-style 'Halloween' itself.
As I have pointed out before, these are story contests. The rules mean that you can't enter a poem.
I highly doubt the readers care, Ogg. Maybe another author might pick up on it and comment, but in general? They're just reading a story in a category they like-as I doubt anyone reads stories just because they are in a contest-and vote accordingly.
Last Halloween Laurel let in a Christmas story. Santa in the title, the tag. X-mas all the way. I have no idea why the author did that...they're prolific, maybe they submitted the wrong story then figured what the hell let it ride?
Point is Laurel let it through showing she pretty much looks at nothing with contest stories and just rushes them through, but more on topic? I saw not one comment saying 'Um, this is a Halloween contest?" and the score was decent showing no indication it was unduly bombed.
It may have been different in the past, but my impression now is we could post something that has nothing to do with the topic and there will be little to no 'calling out' of that.