Why and how is abortion a state's rights issue?

Yes, those OPPORTUNITIES (not the services themselves) are a right.

No I do want equal opportunities. It's the equal outcomes that 'progressive" leftist promote that I want nothing to do with.

Progressive states like CA and NY could do that now, but they won't and are hemorrhaging their workers and companies to more moderate if not red places at record rates while crime, poverty and homelessness skyrocket. So best of luck to them with that.

What's any of this got to do with 10A protecting a states right to regulate that which the feds do not??
Wrong again. Read the Court cases...and then come to the Adult Table
 
I'm not the one pretending citizens united makes 10A go away. LOL



No, you haven't.

They're unrelated and have nothing to do with 10A existing.
Nausea and stupidity, a book by this dude.

Nobody is denying the 10th amendment, moron
 
Coercion pretty explicitly means you're not donating.

Coercion and force as when they hold you down and take blood when suspected of a crime, happens every day in the USA.

As for harvesting your organs, that would arguably very much violate the eighth amendment. But the progressives in China are big on that one so there is hope for Democrats to get the same power one day.

Did you think this reply made sense?
 
The 10th amendment doesn't answer her questions no matter how many times you say the words
Yes, it does, it's the actual amendment that makes abortion almost entirely a state issue.

No matter how much she or you points at unrelated cases and try to ignore 10A.
 
What were you searching for when you stumbled upon an Erotic Story site run by hardcore Liberals - and then to only post on the Politics Board?
Sci-Fi mostly, but I like non-human, mind control and horror.

Also as a liberal I got nothing against liberals.

Politics interests me, so does consuming smut, creating it, not so much.
 
Yes, it does, it's the actual amendment that makes abortion almost entirely a state issue.

No matter how much she or you points at unrelated cases and try to ignore 10A.
I didn't say abortion was or was not a 10th amendment issue. I said it doesn't answer her questions.

The other issues should also be 10th amendment questions based on your own responses and yet they aren't and that's the fuckong problem. If you actually are able to read, you'd get it....but you rely on cliff notes versions of shit and refuse to acknowledge her very basic points and then claim victory.

You didn't win any argument here....you just made yourself a fool right off the bat. 👍
 
You mean your failure.
It's not up to me to make your case for you.

There is no connection, the cases are unrelated. States get to regulate things the feds don't because the 10th amendment of the Constitution, the highest law of the land, very explicitly and directly says so.
 
It's not up to me to make your case for you.

There is no connection, the cases are unrelated. States get to regulate things the feds don't because the 10th amendment of the Constitution, the highest law of the land, very explicitly and directly says so.
They are connected.

You're just a moron.
 
It's not up to me to make your case for you.

There is no connection, the cases are unrelated. States get to regulate things the feds don't because the 10th amendment of the Constitution, the highest law of the land, very explicitly and directly says so.

You don't seem to understand the concept. It's not my case that needs being made. It's the case for state's rights for abortion that needs to be made. It's not been. You have failed. Just like those before you who have come on and blustered about what amounts to essentially talking points.

I'm asking why and how is abortion a state's rights issue, especially given other relevant parts of US and state law. It's not been answered.
 
Back
Top