meop79
Wandering.....
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2002
- Posts
- 26,945
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
meop79 said:Shrug I wanted John McCain....
meop79 said:
Pollitically Corect: A way of acting which is defined by a greater interest in the consideration of the pollitical and social consequences of an action that either the rightness or the intelligence of said action.
Meop79@yahoo.com
Ishmael said:
My experience has been that if you confront a PC'r with a logical argument, or facts to the contrary to their position, they do not produce a counter-argument. They attack the speaker. This is done by calling names etc.
Ishmael said:
One of the largest horse shit loads of hyperbole I've read in a while.
What an unmitigated bunch of Politically Correct crap that is.
Education and logic just ain't what it used to be.
Ishmael
meop79 said:Pollitical Corectness: (Adj) the act or action defined as being pollitically corrert.
Pollitically Corect: A way of acting which is defined by a greater interest in the consideration of the pollitical and social consequences of an action that either the rightness or the intelligence of said action.
Meop79@yahoo.com
I hope that wasn't aimed at me, attacking from the shadows ain't my style.meop79 said:
Interesting perspective considering the fact that I gave you an argument that was clear, simple, presented my factual evidence, and was logically valid - and your response was simply to hurl a few insults, saying that it was a load of horse manure, and that I was uneducated in an attempt to discredit me.Ishmael said:My experience has been that if you confront a PC'r with a logical argument, or facts to the contrary to their position, they do not produce a counter-argument. They attack the speaker. This is done by calling names etc. In effect, by discrediting the speaker they somehow discredit the thought. It's quite irritating. Keeping that in mind, it's interesting to tune into C-SPAN on occasion and watch the two minute speeches on the floor of the house. Have a pad of paper and a pencil handy and as each rep. gets up to speak, mark down whether they are attacking/supporting an idea, or a person. It's an interesting little excersize.
Ishmael
crysede said:
If members of a certain race (or sex, ect.) have to work harder simply because of their race, then it seems to me that their race fits the definition of oppressed quite well.
And how does the success of a few women, or a few blacks, prove that they are not oppressed as a group? The fact that successful one are seen as noteworth exceptions suggests the very opposite.
Interesting perspective considering the fact that I gave you an argument that was clear, simple, presented my factual evidence, and was logically valid - and your response was simply to hurl a few insults, saying that it was a load of horse manure, and that I was uneducated in an attempt to discredit me.
Then, when you finally did produce a (logically invalid) counter-argument, rather than just attacking me, you never even mentioned the logical form of my argument (let alone show that it contained a single logical error)!
All you did was attack the truth of my premises (the truth value of which are entirely irrelevant in determining whether an argument is logically valid or not - if in doubt, consult any logic textbook concerning 'validity' vs. 'soundness' of an argument).
I didn't actually find your name calling irritating though, I guess I just have a thick skin.
The fact that I consider your ideas to be horse shit, does not mean that I have have called you a name. In fact, there are probably areas where we are in total agreement. The fact that I do not agree with you in certain areas does not diminish you as a human being in my eyes. It would take far more than, in my humble opinion, your misguided views on PC to do that.
Actually, I thought you were referring to the politicians and activists you talked about watching on C-SPAN. I found your comments about them to be ironic, not because I thought you were referring to me, but because you had used the very same tactics you were decrying so vehemently.And last but not least, you assumed that I was refering to you in the last post. Not neccessarily. There are others far more indoctrinated than you here.
Last time I checked demographics counted as facts, and that's what I presented as the factual support for my argument. I didn't post them of course - entering in all that data would take hours; it would be for Canada (since I didn't keep a copy of the data for the US last time I had to use this information), and thus probably not satisfactory to you; plus the data in question is very easy to get a hold of if you want to see for yourself (local libraries should have copies, or you can contact the statistics dept. or agency of your government).Originally posted by Ishmael Let's start with the fact that you presented no evidence at all. You presented personal statements in the form of 'facts. Lavy presented facts.
I'm not sure what the point of this premise is: the fact that blacks aren't disadvantaged in non-Western cultures has no bearing on whether or not they are disadvantaged in Western cultures.There have been, and still are societies today in which the male has no property rights. Everything belongs to the woman. There are societies today in which the black man is the dominant political force. The first independent nation outside of the United States formed in the western hemishpere was, and still is, a nation of blacks (Haiti). The oppression of the black race started in Africa by black tribes that sold others into slavery. Whites have been, and still are sold into slavery. The American Indian practiced slavery long before the arrival of the white man.
If you are defining those possessing character and strength as those who do, in fact, wield power, then your argument is circular (thus invalid).Women of character and strength have always weilded power. Power in a different form, but power none the less. If you choose to look at history through a tinted lense, you will always get a distorted view.
I didn't delve into history, and the only time I've mentioned it is in response to you when you brought the subject of history up. I have not used history to defend my arguments. (Unless you consider the events of the last decade or two to be history - in which case no problem, that reference can be removed: my argument did not actually need reference to anything past the most recent demographic data to be valid).Further, past history is no excuse for current behavior or thoughts. It is up to the individual to thrive or fall on their own merits. Legitimate beefs are when a government sanctions a religion, race, or culture to the exclusion of others. That can no longer be said to be true in the United States.
crysede said:
I didn't delve into history, and the only time I've mentioned it is in response to you when you brought the subject of history up. I have not used history to defend my arguments. (Unless you consider the events of the last decade or two to be history - in which case no problem, that reference can be removed: my argument did not actually need reference to anything past the most recent demographic data to be valid).
What is the 'it' that this is the crux of? I can only find three possible meanings you might have intended (the first is the one that your above statement most clearly seems to be intended to express - but since that makes no sense, I have considered two possible alternatives as well):Ishmael said:And there is the crux of it. You have no sense of history, so your comments concerning "always" are just your own 'spin' on what you believe.
There are only two major sects of Islam, Sunni (about 90% of Muslims) and Sh'ite (about 9%). In neither of these is there any sub-sect that worships Aisha - to do so would be blasphemy. The core of Islam is very clear: there is no God but God, and Muhammad is His Prophet - if you do not assent to this, you are not a Muslim.Women have always weilded immense political power. An entire, and major, sub-sect of Islam is based on the beliefs of a woman and is even named for her.
Is this something you are asserting? If so, would you care to explain why the vast majority of important figures in recorded history (ie, what is written in history texts) show history revolving around men? I have written many papers on historically important female figures - and have done countless hours of research in order to track them down. It is not as easy task. Where as male political/religious/social leaders, reformers, revolutionaries, scientists, authors, poets, philosophers, artists, etc. are a dime a dozen, finding examples of more than a handful of well-known women in these capacities is a herculean task.There are as many great turning points in history that revolve around a woman as there are those that revolve around men.
sd412 said:Um... So you're saying that because I call people "African-Americans" instead of "Niggers" that other people are less likely to come to America?
Laurel said:
You'd probably lose your job if you went around calling the Black people there "niggers". However, you'd probably lose your job if you went around calling people "assholes". However, if you lost your job on that basis that you held racist beliefs, even if you did not act improperly, you could probably sue. I'm no lawyer, but I would think you'd have a case for discrimination.

I never said no women have ever succeeded, nor did I say no blacks have ever succeeded. I do not use universals in this manner, I know better - they are far too easy to counter.The first self-made black millionare was a woman.
If you refer back to my initial posts (on pages 5 and 6 I believe), you will see that I have never claimed that people who did not try to achieve something, did not succeed because they were oppressed.There are more instances than one can count of women rising to positions of power. But they worked for those positions. Earned them. No one is entitled to anything. If a woman were to run for president today whose ideals and philosophy appealed to the majority of voters, she would be elected. But she better be tough, because the opposition is going to use everything they have against her. And if she were to lose, it would NOT be because she was a woman. It would be because the majority of the electorate rejected her ideas.
The fact of the matter is that the majority of women are not interested in running for politics. Or having a career. That is their choice to make, not yours or anyone elses. That also means that there will be fewer of them to represent the people. And that is the job, not representing your sex, or your ethnic background, representing ALL of the people in your district.
And if there are women out there that would like to run for office, or have a career, and don't because they decided that they are "oppressed". Well, they quit before they even started. And if they complain, they're just whiners. They are entirely lacking in character.
You have consistently been claiming that oppression does not exist. This means you must hold one of the two following positions.Non-discrimination policy with teeth makes sense.
What you are now debating is 'affirmative action', another new topic. 'Affirmative action' is one of our societies attempts to deal with the fact that there are oppressed minorities within it. Whether or not AA works has nothing to do with whether or not there are, in fact, oppressed minorities. I think AA, implemented on the procedural level, is generally misdirected and doomed to failure - but the fact that I do not think AA is a particularly good response to oppression, does not mean I do not think oppression exists; nor have you proved oppression doesn't exist by giving evidence to show that AA does not generally work.Reverse discrimination is nothing more than retribution perpetrated on parties that for the most part were never guilty. It breeds resentment and diminishes any real accomplishment that the 'favored' individual may have really done. Because there will always be the thought in the back of many's mind that "She's only got that job because of the quota's." And there will always be the doubt in the persons mind that maybe what they're saying is right.
After having tried that for years and years. State after state is dumping that policy. They too are seeing the damage done. Only the Politically Correct Universities are holding on to that theory. Tooth and nail.
For years MIT recruited lower income minority students to the university on full scholarships. They 'normed' the SAT scores inorder to enroll these individuals. After 15 years of a 80% drop out rate at the sophmore level, they are changing their policy too. These individuals would have been able to cut the mustard at a lesser university, but now they're branded as failures. MIT was faced with lowering it's academic standards, or quit recruiting people not qualified to attend. Harvard has gone the opposite direction.
I agree, demographic data does not reflect desires or skills, and cannot be used to assert anything about such. Since my first argument seems to have been somewhat unclear, I'll restate it in more detail. My argument from demographic data is as follows:PS Demographic data does not reflect desires or skills. It's just numbers. In my field of expertise there are fewer and fewer qualified women every year. That means that there are fewer and fewer women in the pool that would make qualified managers. Lavy and I have already been down this road.
SINthysist said:Great thread.
Especially Laurel arguing for censorship and against free speech.
Laurel said:
What are you babbling about?
Go back and read my posts a little closer.
meop79 said:We have and you did.