Pollitical Corectness

Speach that incites violence is allready against the law it's called insiting to violence it can be a felony if the violence is bad enough....

Why not simply enforce the laws we have?

meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debat

Ishmael said:


All the Queens of England. Cleopatra. The female that was elected president of Pakistan, a Muslim nation of all things. Joan of Arc. All the Empress's of China. Nefertiti. Shacka Zulu. Booker T. Washington, George Washington Carver, Dr. Martin Luther King. Golda Meir. Fredrick Douglas. All leaders, none white males.

You may have to work a little harder, but nothing is stopping anyone.

Oppressed my ass.

Ishmael

These are exceptions - not the rule in history. You could list just as many instances and laws that kept women oppressed until the 20th century. There was something *stopping* them. Laws against women holding property, being able to vote or own anything themselves. White men in modern society have never had to work for basic freedoms as hard as minorities and women have. Why? Because of the laws white men passed.

Don't try to mix your own brand of revisionist history with a modern day issue. It doesn't work.
 
crysede said:

Send me a copy of them and I'll answer them if you want - though I can't imagine you actually have any interest in my answers.


I understand that they piss you off, and I'm not supporting them because they do, or because I'm trying to piss you off - I actually do agree with them. Like I said in my first post, I think that speech that incites violence (and I'm not talking about obscure 'social tension', I mean concrete violence) should be censored. I think that people's right to personal safety should trump the right of free speech when the two rights conflict.

OK, I'll post the questions.

Regarding 'hate' speech. Who's the judge? Where's the 1st. amendment? It's like hate crimes. Bullshit, pure bullshit.

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debat

celiaKitten said:


These are exceptions - not the rule in history. You could list just as many instances and laws that kept women oppressed until the 20th century. There was something *stopping* them. Laws against women holding property, being able to vote or own anything themselves. White men in modern society have never had to work for basic freedoms as hard as minorities and women have. Why? Because of the laws white men passed.

Don't try to mix your own brand of revisionist history with a modern day issue. It doesn't work.

I actually agree with this....

Those were mostly exceptions but the fact that he's wrong in this doesn't make her right either....

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a go

Ishmael said:
All the Queens of England. Cleopatra. The female that was elected president of Pakistan, a Muslim nation of all things. Joan of Arc. All the Empress's of China. Nefertiti. Shacka Zulu. Booker T. Washington, George Washington Carver, Dr. Martin Luther King. Golda Meir. Fredrick Douglas. All leaders, none white males.

You may have to work a little harder, but nothing is stopping anyone.

Oppressed my ass.

Ishmael
If members of a certain race (or sex, ect.) have to work harder simply because of their race, then it seems to me that their race fits the definition of oppressed quite well.

And how does the success of a few women, or a few blacks, prove that they are not oppressed as a group? The fact that successful one are seen as noteworth exceptions suggests the very opposite.
 
lavender up to a point you are right the problem is that the truth is that it is being taken to far it's being taken to far every day,a good example is how alot of people in the work place have to tip toe around alot of people they work with not because they are bad people or bigots or even uneducated or crude but because if they say anything that could even be slightly construed as sexist or racist they could lose thier jobs.

This is ridiculous. But it's happening every day.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good deba

meop79 said:


I actually agree with this....

Those were mostly exceptions but the fact that he's wrong in this doesn't make her right either....

Meop79@yahoo.com

Not saying that at all. I don't agree with either one of them actually.

I just wanted to put that in, because his post didn't help his argument.
 
meop79 said:
Speach that incites violence is allready against the law it's called insiting to violence it can be a felony if the violence is bad enough....

Why not simply enforce the laws we have?

meop79@yahoo.com
I think the difference between our counties' legal systems maybe causing some of our problems here. It sounds like your 'inciting to violence' law might be my 'hate speech law'.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debat

celiaKitten said:


These are exceptions - not the rule in history. You could list just as many instances and laws that kept women oppressed until the 20th century. There was something *stopping* them. Laws against women holding property, being able to vote or own anything themselves. White men in modern society have never had to work for basic freedoms as hard as minorities and women have. Why? Because of the laws white men passed.

Don't try to mix your own brand of revisionist history with a modern day issue. It doesn't work.

Oh bullshit. Then and now. Determined women and minorites have always found a way to excellence.

And I can tell you this. No advocate of PC will ever be elected to the presidency or appointed the CEO of a publicly traded company. Why? Easy, investors and voters want someone that pays attention to business or the needs of the country. Not their own little whining agenda. I started running into the PC stuff in the mid 80's. I eliminated all that advocated that philosophy from consideration for management postition and actively encouraged the more strident to seek employment elsewhere. I had a company to run for the benefit of all the employees, not a social playground for people more interested in whining than doing their job and helping others do the same.

PC advocates are slamming their own doors in their own face. It is a refusal to take responsibility for your own life and your own mistakes. It demonstrates a profound lack of character.

Ishmael
 
Crysede there is a big difference between inciting to riot or inciting to violence and a law that says it is illegal to say things that someone might construe as racist or "hurtfull"

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good deba

Ishmael said:


Oh bullshit. Then and now. Determined women and minorites have always found a way to excellence.

And I can tell you this. No advocate of PC will ever be elected to the presidency or appointed the CEO of a publicly traded company. Why? Easy, investors and voters want someone that pays attention to business or the needs of the country. Not their own little whining agenda. I started running into the PC stuff in the mid 80's. I eliminated all that advocated that philosophy from consideration for management postition and actively encouraged the more strident to seek employment elsewhere. I had a company to run for the benefit of all the employees, not a social playground for people more interested in whining than doing their job and helping others do the same.

PC advocates are slamming their own doors in their own face. It is a refusal to take responsibility for your own life and your own mistakes. It demonstrates a profound lack of character.

Ishmael

:rolleyes: You make it sound like women and minorities were not *oppressed* they were just *lazy* and didn't work hard enough. I'm not for someone riding their minority status to success without hard work, that's not what I said. All I said was that you can't dismiss the oppression of so many by pointing out the handful that actually made it.
 
I use words that may be considered politically incorrect or bigoted(is that a word?) every day. Know what? I don't care. I'm a big boy and I know that I have to live with the consequences of what I say and deal with the reactions of others. Granted, I watch what I say--to a degree, but I don't pander to every special issues group in the world who hates any particular word I use and the way I use it. I wouldn't go around work(for example...I don't work) spouting off 'nigger' and 'queer.' That's just stupid, I know I could lose my job over it. But as far as my personal life, I use whichever word I choose. All part of free speech and being an adult in the USA.

Are certain words harmful? Sure thing. Should they be? I don't know. People certainly need thicker skins. Maybe I don't fully understand the situation, maybe I can't grasp it since I've always been a healthy, white, middle-upper class white male. Them's the brealks. I understand personal politeness. Hence my 'work' example. But with my family, my friends, and even here at Lit, I speak how I wish, regardless of what people might think, even if it's not popular at the time. My friends and I call each other racial slurs all the time. We're all of different races. We use racial slurs that fit the persons race, and ones that don't ie, me calling a black friend a 'cracker'.

Like I said, I'm an adult, I'll live with the consequences of the words I use.

Simple.

Pie.
 
meop79 said:
Crysede there is a big difference between inciting to riot or inciting to violence and a law that says it is illegal to say things that someone might construe as racist or "hurtfull"

Meop79@yahoo.com
Our law is against speech that incites violence against others. You are allowed to say racist things if you want, as long as you don't encourage your readers to go kill black people, burn their homes down, or things of that nature.
 
RastaPope - EXACTLY! Key phrase: you take on the consequences your words bring.

I agree with you. Say what you want - but understand what the consequences are.
 
lavender said:
Is that true Ishmael? You are definitely showing that you are out of touch with corporate America. Let's look at corporate America and it's links to law firms. Law firms are supporting diversity programs and women's initiatives to make sure they recruit and retain attorneys that are ethnic and gender minorities. There was much resistance at first. Then, it was proven to these male-dominated firms, that this is what corporations want. More women and minorities are leading corporations on a daily basis. Due to this, it has become increasingly important to corporate America that the firms and businesses they make contracts with also support such progressive programs. These goes far beyond simple discrimination.

There are firms in Texas, in TEXAS, that do not hire a summer associate because their language is offensive and against political correctness. There is one firm who looked negatively on a person who told an anti-gay joke. There are other firms who don't hire someone because they demonstrated a lack of tolerance for racial minorities. These things, word choice, political correctness DOES matter on a national level. A corporate CEO cannot be successful in our market today if their company and their executives are not politically correct, to some extent. Additionally, there is not a single elected official outside of recent history's David Duke and some long time politicans who could get away with using un-PC terminology. It's a fact of fucking life.

Just check out this little quip from an article. Nah, elected and appointed judges don't carry any weight in our society. Ishmael, when are you going to join the rest of corporate America in understanding that the ways of the country are different now?

"Gender neutrality in judicial-opinion writing is official policy in the New York State Unified Court System. As the court's anti-gender-bias committee has explained, "all of us who work in the courts or work in the court system [must] avoid unintended slights or compromises to the ideal of justice." [FN1] What of practitioners, for whom internal court policy is not binding? Should they write gender neutrally? Yes. If you do not believe me, ask any successful law man. He, she, he or she, his or her, they, and all their henchpersons will tell you that I am right.
Some believe that gender neutrality is part of an unfortunate, passing phase of political correctness. To each her own, but they are wrong. It is a fortunate phase--and one here to stay. Sexist writing offends readers of both genders. Discriminatory beliefs are reflected in discriminatory writing, and discriminatory writing perpetuates discrimination. Sexism is also often double discrimination. Consider the old-fashioned labels Jewess and Negress. Have you ever heard of a Christianess, a whitess, or a Caucasianess? And who can forget the expression "woman lawyer"? Perhaps one reason no one used lawyerette is that women were excluded from the profession when ette suffixes were popular."

At what point did I say that I was not hiring and promoting ethnic minorities and women? Half of my engineering dept. was minorities and women.

See how silly you look when you 'assume'?

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:


At what point did I say that I was not hiring and promoting ethnic minorities and women? Half of my engineering dept. was minorities and women.

See how silly you look when you 'assume'?

Ishmael

Now that's irony coming from you, who consistantly argues off topic.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs i

Ishmael said:


Oh bullshit. Then and now. Determined women and minorites have always found a way to excellence. <snip>
The fact that some determined members of minorities made it in no way supports your conclusion that any determined member of a minority will make it - unless you either have evidence that there were no determined woman who were prevented from making it - or are defining those who were determined based on whether they made it or not, in which case your reasoning is circular and thus your argument invalid.
 
Perhaps someone more learn-ed and wiser than I can answer a question for me.


Race quotas as far as employees go. Is this an actual law, or something instituted by an individual company?
 
lavender said:




To refuse to promote someone because they support political correctness is ridiculous.

A point we disagree on. But I believe that there will be hell to pay. It seems to be starting now, doesn't it?

"It's not my fault, Joey (the acountants) made me do it." It's all so very juvenile really.

And once more, you failed to read carefully. The practicing of PC is one thing. The strident demands that others do also is quite another. I'm not running a welfare house for political activists. And the ones I weeded out were the 'whiners'. If they can't take responsibility for their own life, they sure as hell are not going to be entrusted with the welfare of my company, or their fellow employees.

On the other hand, I fired my most technically competent manager for sexual harrasment. No if's and's or but's. Not because it was the PC thing to do, rather that it's just bad business to allow that to occur. You don't shit where you eat.

Ishmael


Ishmael
 
Back
Top