Pollitical Corectness

But the ONLY reason that a white would refer to a black as a "Nigger" would be to to demean them and de humanize them
 
Mountain Man said:
But the ONLY reason that a white would refer to a black as a "Nigger" would be to to demean them and de humanize them

ROFLMAO oh for the love of god spare me from fools.... I had two friends when I was living in nashville one white one black both worked with me at Lowe's the white guy called the black guy nigger and the black guy called the white guy ass holedumb fuck etc... and they went out and partied together every night were best of friends in fact...

mountain man you have a verry small view of the world...

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
My take on PC.

It's a perversion of the language and an imposition of a thought process on the speaker based on what word is used as opposed to how the word is used.

Some of it is slang based, some of it is straight out of Webster's Unabridged.

Blind is out. Visually challenged is 'in'. But for the life of me I can find now derogatory conotation to the word 'blind' regardless of the sensibilities of others. It is not negative, it just describes a physical condition over which the victim and the sympathizer have no earthly control. They both mean the same thing and I can find no comfort being redered by using the polysyllabic form. The same is true for the deaf.

I happen to agree with pp_man on the hyphenation syndrome. As a matter of fact so does William Rasberry, a liberal columnist for the Washington Post. It's gone beyond ridiculous. The use, or rather overuse, of hyphenations encourages 'groupism' and 'cultism'. The very barriers that we were once attempting to break down. I have no difficulty in 'pride of heritage'. I have great difficulty when a citizen feels that only by identifying themselves with a group are they to be afforded any respect or justice. By implication an inability to feel any self-worth without an indentification phrase. A white immigrant of Boor descent from South Africa has more entitlement to the use of African-American than a 4 generation citizen. The same can be said for an American citizen of Italian descent. It is a tag line that is used that allegedly tells one about the person that identifies themselves as such, but in reality tells us nothing. Nothing at all about their character and that is the only thing that matters.

Now those that think there is no enforcement of PC should read the articles by David Horowitz concerning his trials and tribulations in attempting to bring honest intellectual debates about sensitive subjects to the campuses of many major Universties. He was censored by the majority of campus newspapers and in some cases the newpaper office was broken into, ransacked, and the newpapers burned before they could be distributed. So much for the 1st. ammendment, and honest debate on current issues. Apparently, according to the behavior of the University inteligenstia, contrary views an opinions are NOT to be tolerated or debated. They are to be censored and attacked.

While Meop was somewhat ackward in his phrasing, there is nothing wrong with his core opinion.

Ishmael
 
Meop...

you call me simple and foolish...yet

you equate the word nigger and bigot (see deffinitions above)

then you compare calling a gf beating fellon gangbanger and two friends calling eachother names...

simple indeed
:rolleyes:
 
Mountain Man said:
Meop...
you call me simple and foolish...yet
you equate the word nigger and bigot (see deffinitions above)
then you compare calling a gf beating fellon gangbanger and two friends calling eachother names...
simple indeed
:rolleyes:

That definition is not how the word is used.

I've know white men I would happily label nigger, because what a nigger is besides that definition is a state of mind.

It is the lack of both education and simple common sence which sadly is quite uncomon these days... it is anger and fear and stupidity twisted around a core of ignoance.

lol I would probably call most of the KKK niggers, don't judge me unless you are prepared to be judged...

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
I honestly think it's funny none of you have dared tried to take a hack at what Ishmael wrote... what a well written argument to tough for you?

sigh *shakes head*

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
and you didnt give your opinion to my last reply :)


in my opinion people have a different view of what political correctness is ... in my most basic understanding it means an ideal of not wanting to hurt peoples feelings ... in that way its good ... when it gets blown up to be more then that in some circumstances i agree it can be bad ... but i wouldnt call that political correctness ... thats just people having their on agenda and using political correctness as their weapon

as i said before the phrase has suffered poor publicity of late especially in america
 
sexy-girl said:
and you didnt give your opinion to my last reply :)

in my opinion people have a different view of what political correctness is ... in my most basic understanding it means an ideal of not wanting to hurt peoples feelings ... in that way its good ... when it gets blown up to be more then that in some circumstances i agree it can be bad ... but i wouldnt call that political correctness ... thats just people having their on agenda and using political correctness as their weapon

as i said before the phrase has suffered poor publicity of late especially in america

I agree :)

I am a Libertarian pollitically I think everyone's ideas and person space should be respected but sigh I get really upset with the liberals who want to restrict peoples freedom and they love to do it sigh....

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
The fact is that Ishmael is not arguing the same thing that you have been for most of this thread. When I invited you to narrow down your topic and get to the real issue, you declined and continued to speak in generalizations.

As far as Ishmael's opinions, they have some merit (in this case). Political correctness is aimed at regulating the intent of speech, which cannot really be done. It is easy to argue the extreme end of PC is bad, because there are certainly some ridiculous examples out there. I have never been corrected when I have used an un-PC term because the intent has not been to criticize or partition.

And as far as David Horowitz, there are few more blatant self promoters out there. His intention was never to "bring honest intellectual debates about sensitive subjects to the campuses..." but rather to put statements out there that he knew would inflame and get his name better recognition.
 
Dougy said:

And as far as David Horowitz, there are few more blatant self promoters out there. His intention was never to "bring honest intellectual debates about sensitive subjects to the campuses..." but rather to put statements out there that he knew would inflame and get his name better recognition.

And that, quite frankly, is the point. You attacked the author, not the ideas. It is the motive of ALL authors of political bent to get their ideas to as wide an audience as possible. While Horowitz uses every trick in the book, after all he invented some of them, that does not detract from the substance of his subject. Discerning readers can discriminate hyperbole from logic and attack the logic.

Ishmael
 
Quite frankly it has been too long since this issue originally came up. It is a good year old, I have been through it before and don't care to dredge the subject up again.
 
Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debate.

Originally posted by meop79 <snip> and the fact is that if it is ok to attack whites because they have been on top for the last couple hundred years in this country but it's not ok to attack any other minority what you're creating is another persecuted minority... if you can't see that you are more foolish than I think you are
First off, I've got to agree with Mountain Man - too much hyperbole dude! It often makes your arguments very hard to follow (of course maybe that was your diabolical plan all along ;)). Anyway, your suggestion that we whites are in danger of becoming a persecuted minority goes beyond mere hyperbole: it's totally misleading, and lends false credence to your argument.

Although it's easy (and tempting) for those of us in privileged classes to ignore it, the fact that we are reaping the rewards of systemic oppression becomes blatantly obvious the moment you look at some hard data. Have you looked at the race and sex breakdowns for things like average income, poverty, health, education, standard of living, etc.? You should check them out (from what ever your national stats agency is, not some off-the-wall interest group).

Unless you're planning to argue that blacks, women, homosexuals, and other minority groups are inherently inferior to white men, then I can't see how you could explain the huge discrepancies between these groups without concluding that whites are at a great advantage to all other races, and straight white men are at the uncontested top of the social pecking order. A white person being killed for being white does not make our race persecuted, neither does a white person being refused a job due to affirmative action - to claim 'persecuted minority' status requires that you show that your group is consistently disadvantaged within society - not pointing out particular instances where things did not go a white person's way.

And about the whole 'nigger' thing - there is a big difference between two members of a disadvantaged group calling each other 'nigger', and a member of the ruling class calling them by that term. I'm mystified as to why you don't see this, it seems self evident - but if you want I will back my claim up (I'm not going to bother here, 'cause I think this post is plenty long enough already ;) ).


Oh, and it seems to be a kinda unpopular position here, but I'm in favour of anti-hate speech laws! I don't think speech that causes serious harm to others ought to have any protection (and inciting violence against other people is causing serious harm in my book). Other people's right to not be attacked, or have molotov cocktails thrown in their windows, out weighs free speech any day of the week. And unlike anti-obscenity laws, we actually have good evidence that hate speech really is linked to violence against the groups it targets.
 
Ishmael said:


And that, quite frankly, is the point. You attacked the author, not the ideas. It is the motive of ALL authors of political bent to get their ideas to as wide an audience as possible. While Horowitz uses every trick in the book, after all he invented some of them, that does not detract from the substance of his subject. Discerning readers can discriminate hyperbole from logic and attack the logic.

Ishmael
What? How could the use of hyperbole and other emotive tactics do anything other than detract from his claims?! Not only does it show he is trying to win his audience to his side through trickery (which shows that he is more interested in obtaining agreement with his views that engaging in debate), it means that anyone wanting to engage him in serious debate must first go through the annoying task of reconstructing his arguments before they can even begin to address them.
 
Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debate.

crysede said:

First off, I've got to agree with Mountain Man - too much hyperbole dude! It often makes your arguments very hard to follow (of course maybe that was your diabolical plan all along ;)). Anyway, your suggestion that we whites are in danger of becoming a persecuted minority goes beyond mere hyperbole: it's totally misleading, and lends false credence to your argument.

Although it's easy (and tempting) for those of us in privileged classes to ignore it, the fact that we are reaping the rewards of systemic oppression becomes blatantly obvious the moment you look at some hard data. Have you looked at the race and sex breakdowns for things like average income, poverty, health, education, standard of living, etc.? You should check them out (from what ever your national stats agency is, not some off-the-wall interest group).

Unless you're planning to argue that blacks, women, homosexuals, and other minority groups are inherently inferior to white men, then I can't see how you could explain the huge discrepancies between these groups without concluding that whites are at a great advantage to all other races, and straight white men are at the uncontested top of the social pecking order. A white person being killed for being white does not make our race persecuted, neither does a white person being refused a job due to affirmative action - to claim 'persecuted minority' status requires that you show that your group is consistently disadvantaged within society - not pointing out particular instances where things did not go a white person's way.

And about the whole 'nigger' thing - there is a big difference between two members of a disadvantaged group calling each other 'nigger', and a member of the ruling class calling them by that term. I'm mystified as to why you don't see this, it seems self evident - but if you want I will back my claim up (I'm not going to bother here, 'cause I think this post is plenty long enough already ;) ).


Oh, and it seems to be a kinda unpopular position here, but I'm in favour of anti-hate speech laws! I don't think speech that causes serious harm to others ought to have any protection (and inciting violence against other people is causing serious harm in my book). Other people's right to not be attacked, or have molotov cocktails thrown in their windows, out weighs free speech any day of the week. And unlike anti-obscenity laws, we actually have good evidence that hate speech really is linked to violence against the groups it targets.

One of the largest horse shit loads of hyperbole I've read in a while.

White males are oppressors and even one else is a 'victim'. What an unmitigated bunch of Politically Correct crap that is.

Education and logic just ain't what it used to be.

Ishmael
 
meop79 said:
Hi crysede,

You aren't seriously espousing that PC is a good thing? :confused:

Meop79@yahoo.com
*checking through my post quickly*

Nope, just taking issue with some of your supporting premises (or perhaps they were tangents, didn't bother to work that out). :)

*evil subversive grin* But I do think some degree of PC can be defended as a good thing. I'm not sure if it's the PC your against though - I do agree at the political PCism has gone way overboard.
 
crysede said:

What? How could the use of hyperbole and other emotive tactics do anything other than detract from his claims?! Not only does it show he is trying to win his audience to his side through trickery (which shows that he is more interested in obtaining agreement with his views that engaging in debate), it means that anyone wanting to engage him in serious debate must first go through the annoying task of reconstructing his arguments before they can even begin to address them.

He specified 10 pertinent questions. Answer the questions please.

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debat

Ishmael said:


One of the largest horse shit loads of hyperbole I've read in a while.

White males are oppressors and even one else is a 'victim'. What an unmitigated bunch of Politically Correct crap that is.

Education and logic just ain't what it used to be.

Ishmael
Aren't you going to refute it then? That's how debates usually work. The above certainly doesn't show that I'm wrong, it's just your opinion.
 
Crysede I'm disapointed. From talking with you previously I would have thought you had more intelectual integrity than that....

One and only one thing I can agree with.

And that is the education system is SHIT in this country. But and I'm sure this will piss people off but the problem stems from the liberals who are s interested in getting social harmony and "protecting" kids from being hurt by their own test scores that this country no longer teaches the majority of it's lower and middle classes.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
crysede said:

*checking through my post quickly*
Nope, just taking issue with some of your supporting premises (or perhaps they were tangents, didn't bother to work that out). :)
*evil subversive grin* But I do think some degree of PC can be defended as a good thing. I'm not sure if it's the PC your against though - I do agree at the political PCism has gone way overboard.

hmmmmm well ok.....

But what you said in that post is scary.... and it is the type of attitude that has caused alot of problems recently and I don't understand it... suporting hate speach laws?

*shakes head*

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
I'm not sure what you mean by intellectual integrity. I have opinions that I have thought out carefully; and though they may differ from your opinions, what I say I believe is actually what I believe, and I am willing give my reasons for holding those opinions so people can challenge me on them. What more is needed for intellectual integrity?
 
crysede said:
I'm not sure what you mean by intellectual integrity. I have opinions that I have thought out carefully; and though they may differ from your opinions, what I say I believe is actually what I believe, and I am willing give my reasons for holding those opinions so people can challenge me on them. What more is needed for intellectual integrity?

Allright. then why exactly do you think hate speach laws are a good thing? do you believe they lessen social tension?

or don't you understand that those laws piss even me off and I'm about as far from racist as you can get.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: Re: Re: Thanks for the cool thread meop! I do love sinking my fangs into a good debat

crysede said:

Aren't you going to refute it then? That's how debates usually work. The above certainly doesn't show that I'm wrong, it's just your opinion.

All the Queens of England. Cleopatra. The female that was elected president of Pakistan, a Muslim nation of all things. Joan of Arc. All the Empress's of China. Nefertiti. Shacka Zulu. Booker T. Washington, George Washington Carver, Dr. Martin Luther King. Golda Meir. Fredrick Douglas. All leaders, none white males.

You may have to work a little harder, but nothing is stopping anyone.

Oppressed my ass.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
He specified 10 pertinent questions. Answer the questions please.

Ishmael
Send me a copy of them and I'll answer them if you want - though I can't imagine you actually have any interest in my answers.

meop79 said:
Allright. then why exactly do you think hate speach laws are a good thing? do you believe they lessen social tension?

or don't you understand that those laws piss even me off and I'm about as far from racist as you can get.
I understand that they piss you off, and I'm not supporting them because they do, or because I'm trying to piss you off - I actually do agree with them. Like I said in my first post, I think that speech that incites violence (and I'm not talking about obscure 'social tension', I mean concrete violence) should be censored. I think that people's right to personal safety should trump the right of free speech when the two rights conflict.
 
Back
Top