Pollitical Corectness

Reality Check: PC and Profiling

First let me state I mean no particular insult or offense to anyone based upon their race, creed, nation of origin, sexualy orientation or choice of beverage, should that have excluded anyone then please check the box marked 'other'.
I live in the Midwest, Indiana properly, Indianapolis specificly, thanks to all the federal and state enforced PC hiring practices and the equally PC compliant policies of the Immigration and Naturalization Service in recognizing illegal aliens now as 'undocumented workers', the local economy is a shambles.
I am a college educated white male over thirty-five who, other than my military service granting me Veteran status, is placed quite far back in the applicant pool of any prospective employer, private sector or local/state/federal government.
The fear of litigation, both civil and government sponsored has made the human resource department of any business adopt the PC platform out of fear of discrimination being cried by any applicant not hired who claims to be a member of a minority or special interest group.
My personal experience in one instance was of the local (City-County operated) library system interviewing and hiring me for a position at a recently opened branch and before my first day of work arrived I was told my employment status had been voided as a newly adopted policy of 'cultural diversity' made the branch manger, under orders from the HR department, reshuffle the cross-section of applicants hired as 'to better represent the neighborhood demographics (based on census data) and to serve the needs of the community' was the explanation.
Needless to say I was appalled to find this a practice I had no recourse to address as in order to keep state and federaly funded grant monies, the library service had to accept the hiring guidelines established by said agencies.
Another incident that dropped my job was reporting to an employment interview with the local phone company. Before I was even allowed to complete the required pre-interview paperwook it I was told that if I did not declare a racial-ethic group by checking one of the boxes given, one would be assigned to me by the person overseeing the interview process.
Should I care to make the effort, I could easily satisy the Bureau of Indian Affairs requirements and obtain the documents establishing myself as a member of a federaly recognized minority and receive all the benefits and protections under that umbrella but I choose not to play such games.
I want to be hired based upon my abilities and the merits of my character and experience, not on the sum of boxes checked upon an application or for the prospective employers fear of my actions should I be passed over for the job offered.
We really screwed up when the Equal Rights Amendment was not better lobbied in the late '70s/early '80s, too many special interests groups were too concerned that making everyone equal in the eyes of the law would cost their causes political power or the loss of funds which were orininaly distributed to even out what was claimed to be the unbalanced playing fields in employment , education and housing.
For the longest time in my life I could never understand what could bring a rational mind to hate someone different from them. And for that matter, why one goes as far as to support any groups that were founded on such an ideology, sadly now I'm starting to understand why. What is even more frightening to me is I begin to wonder where my support should be placed.....
 
crysede said:
Sorry I've taken so long to reply, I haven't managed to get on the computer till tonight. I'll address your demographic question first (I'll respond to your latest post tomorrow morning).

The data you present is completely meaningless. I'm sure you would have seen this had you reflected upon what the data actually was, but like most of us do, I expect you trusted the 'expert' source. If there is one thing I've learned, it's that these expert sources - on both the political left and right (sadly, there seem to be equal numbers of cheats and liars on both sides) - must never be trusted implicitly: far too often they engage in the sort of despicable tactic that your source has.

You are of course aware that your country has very tough immigration standards: a black person, or anyone else for that matter, cannot just become an American because they want to. Except for the small percentage that are granted citizenship as refuges, the remainder of blacks that are allowed in have skills and education far in excess of the average white American.

Because the demographic data did not go his/her way, your source decided to 'fake' some data, by comparing the mean income of the average white, to the mean income of the well above average black. Obviously, this is a ridiculous comparison - you have to compare the mean income of immigrant blacks to the mean income of immigrant whites! I'll bet he/she didn't bother separating out Hispanic whites either, just to make the income difference look even greater.

The kind of people that are willing to resort to this sort of blatant dishonesty (thereby giving all statistics a bad name) are a pet peeve of mine, if you hadn't noticed. lol

The best way to get accurate information, is to go to the source: the US Census Bureau. The Bureau has a vast amount of information online (click here to go to the Bureau's home page). For example, a proper comparison of the mean income of Americans by race and gender is (US Census Bureau, Income Tables, Table P-3, 2000):

----------------------- Men -------------- Women
Non-Hispanic whites -- 43,926 ------------ 23,254
Black -----------------28,395 ------------ 20,635
Hispanic whites ------- 25,863 ------------ 16,687

(If the Hispanic and non-Hispanic whites are combined, the mean salary for 'whites' becomes 41,727 for men and 22,564 for women.)

To an extent you've made my point for me.

Let me address the immigration thing first. The US dropped the quota system biasd towards Europeans back in the 70's. The system is now heavily biased in favor of blacks and orientals. Education certainly is a consideration. Most of the African blacks are highly educated, the Jamiacan's somewhat so, very much less so the Haitians. (Remember, we had a huge wave of Haitian immigrants during the first part of the Clinton years.) So that part of your hypothesis is correct. But they have also brought with them a highly developed work ethic and a desire to succeed. I also suspect that being black from a predominantly black nation 'blinds' them to percieved 'oppression' and consequently they tske minor setbacks in stride and continue to move forward.

You are also quite right on the way the mere numbers can be 'massaged'. They can be used to gleen an indication of a problem, but they certainly cannot be used to make a determination as to what that problem really is. Further, there may not be a problem at all, just numbers reflecting normal societal practices.

There are two things that have been directly linked to success in the United States. Facility with the English language. Written and spoken. And persuing an unbroken career. Facility with English certainly does reflect on a person's education, however that does not necessarily require that that education be a formal education. Or even a higher education. Speaking with an accent is not an impediment here. The unbroken career is an other issue and has more to do with gender than race or place of national origin. Many women take time out from their career for child bearing and rearing. As it turns out, the more financially secure the woman is, with or without partner, the longer this career break will be. This basically puts them in a holding pattern with regard to their peers and it's not unusual for this to have an effect on their rate of advancement.

Many women will put their marriages and family ahead of their career. That is a personal choice and there is no one to bless or blame here. (Unless the husband is a tyrant, but he was her choice too, wasn't he? And the business owner can hardly be held responsible for that condition.) She is trading financial gains for flexibility in working hours or a lenient attitude towards personal time off to take care of family business. These choices have an effect on salary. The is also the choice of carreer's. A majority women choose work in the 'care giver/educator' sectors. For the most part these are relatively low paying jobs. (There are exceptions, here in Orlando there is a shortage of RN's. Not only are they very well paid, hospitals are offering a $10,000.00 signing bonus and 32 hour work weeks.) These jobs do not pay, and will not pay, what the worker believes they are worth, they pay what the market has determined they are worth.

Sooooo, while statistics might indicate areas of research and where we might begin to research our questions, they do not provide any underlying information as to the reasons for the numbers, nor can anyone draw an conclusions from the raw ,or massaged, numbers.

But that is NOT what this thread is about. It's about the individuals/groups that shout down, censor, and demonized others that hold with dissenting views. No discourse is allowed, no logic, no examinations of the facts. Just totalitarian behavior based on feelings.

Ishmael
 
Let's do PC 101 for Dummies.

We used to have a culture of mores, customs, and law. We had a concept called manners. Some people were ill-mannered.

Then came the moral relativists. They didn't like people judging them, their lifestyle, and most of all, they felt personal responsibility was a burden. They decided to free the individual from stodgy, old mores and customs.

To do this, they had to work very hard to make law more important than mores and customs.

Being ill-mannered is now a criminal offense...
 
SINthysist said:
Let's do PC 101 for Dummies.
We used to have a culture of mores, customs, and law. We had a concept called manners. Some people were ill-mannered.
Then came the moral relativists. They didn't like people judging them, their lifestyle, and most of all, they felt personal responsibility was a burden. They decided to free the individual from stodgy, old mores and customs.
To do this, they had to work very hard to make law more important than mores and customs.
Being ill-mannered is now a criminal offense...

Exactly....

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: mettre aux oubliettes

crysede said:

That 80% figure has been artificially inflated by the study's unscrupulous author who is blatantly ignoring the fact that Japanese did not, in fact, make any move until December. And even if we take this into account, their incomes still fail to reflect this so-called empyreanism. Therefore you argument is worse than circular: it's polyhedronal.

According to a recent US Census update persons of African descent living in the city limits of:

Detroit 741,789 out of 901,109=82.32%
Atlanta 240,420 out of 365,658=65.77%
New Orleans 319,795 out of 467,033=68.47%
Washington DC 335,250 out of 536,497=62.49%
Baltimore 402,082 out of 625,401=64.29%
Cleveland 255,292 out of 463,677=55.06%
St Louis 178,383 out of 337,557=52.85%
In NYC 2,163,658 out of 7.8mil
Chicago 1,003,113 out of 2.8mil

Team them up with those LATs and they are systematically taking over our urban centers. When is Congress going to address this issue? The JAPs tried to seize downtowns with capital, this is a much more potent threat.
 
Get out your broom .... become politically correct .... and sweep everything under the rug
 
Ishmael said:
To an extent you've made my point for me.
Somehow I knew you were going to say this the moment I mentioned skills! :D But actually, if you examine my statements in 'Volume II: Inherent Inferiority' you will see that you and are making very different points about skills. (If you do not see this, let me know and I will explain it in more detail).
I also suspect that being black from a predominantly black nation 'blinds' them to percieved 'oppression' and consequently they tske minor setbacks in stride and continue to move forward.
Actually, being from a nation in which they are not oppressed, makes them extremely aware - and often very perplexed by - the discrimination they face here, and you would be hard pressed to find a statistically significant number who would agree that the obstacles they have faced as a result of discrimination have been minor.

Personally, if I were stopped and harassed by police simple because I was a black person driving a nice car in a nice neighbourhood (and I assume, with all the court cases to the contrary, and some police chief's admitting as much, you are not going to try claim that profiling does not exist), I would not feel that was minor. I would feel my rights had been violated. If I were more likely to be shot by police simply because of my skin colour, I would not see that as minor. If I were one of the Amerindians picked up by police in one of our larger Canadian cities, and then dumped off at town limits - miles away from any shelter - in nothing but a T-shirt and pants at -30 C (-22 F), I would not consider this a minor set back. (This is a practice that the police of that city have been engaging in to cut down on the number of 'drunken indians' - the practice was finally brought to light when a man that had been 'disposed of' amazingly managed to survive the walk back into town.)
You are also quite right on the way the mere numbers can be 'massaged'.
No, I was not talking about massaging the data - I regard that as a bad practice as well of course (another reason why I like to use data from the US Census Bureau and StatsCan - they provide their raw data, their methods, full details of any modifiers used, and their data are subject to rigorous independent review).

However, in no way does 'massaging data' compare with the dishonesty of the practice your source was engaging in - they were not massaging data, they were falsifying evidence with the intent to convince people of a falsehood. That is not 'massaging existing data' to make it fit your model more closely, that is inventing data that does not exist. The data they purported to be giving, involved the totally fallacious equating of two different classes ('classes' is used here in the mathematical, not social, sense of the term).
They can be used to gleen an indication of a problem, but they certainly cannot be used to make a determination as to what that problem really is. Further, there may not be a problem at all, just numbers reflecting normal societal practices.
OK, before I reply to this I want to make sure you are actually making this strange claim: that the fact the black men are paid 65% of what white men are paid, and that blacks are more than twice as likely than whites to live in poverty, just shows normal societal practices, not that there is a problem? For now I will assume that you did not mean to imply this.
There are two things that have been directly linked to success in the United States.... The unbroken career is an other issue and has more to do with gender than race or place of national origin. Many women take time out from their career for child bearing and rearing. As it turns out, the more financially secure the woman is, with or without partner, the longer this career break will be. This basically puts them in a holding pattern with regard to their peers and it's not unusual for this to have an effect on their rate of advancement.
If you look up the mean incomes for men and women working full-time, and compare it based on the number of years they have worked full time, you will see that women average less than men consistently, after 1, 2, 5, 10, 20 or more years of uninterrupted full-time employment. Thus taking time out for child rearing is clearly not the cause.
Many women will put their marriages and family ahead of their career. That is a personal choice and there is no one to bless or blame here. (Unless the husband is a tyrant, but he was her choice too, wasn't he?And the business owner can hardly be held responsible for that condition.)
Unless you tell me otherwise, I am going to assume you do not mean to claim that if a women is in an abusive relationship it is because she choose to be abused.
Sooooo, while statistics might indicate areas of research and where we might begin to research our questions, they do not provide any underlying information as to the reasons for the numbers, nor can anyone draw an conclusions from the raw ,or massaged, numbers.
You can, of course, draw conclusions from the raw data. This is quit simple to do (and science is founded on this practice): all you have to do is come up with theories to explain that data. Then, based on further data, and logic, you determine which is the most reasonable explanation. Please refer back to this post in which I went through this process for this argument, explaining each step.
But that is NOT what this thread is about. It's about the individuals/groups that shout down, censor, and demonized others that hold with dissenting views. No discourse is allowed, no logic, no examinations of the facts. Just totalitarian behavior based on feelings.
No, this thread is about political correctness. While politicians, and other unsavoury characters, may subvert the intent of PC for the purpose of demonizing others; that is not what PC is about! The bizarre extremist-PC they have created, is a ridiculous parody of what political correctness is really about. PC is about recognizing that language is a powerful tool that can be used to stifle the voices of others (as you clearly agree - since you say voices are being stifled by the use of extremist-PC language), and therefore that language can be used to support discrimination and oppression, or to combat them.

Our debate has rested upon one issue: whether or not oppression exists. Given the sum total of your posts, I am pleased to say that I can now demonstrate that it does, using only facts that you have asserted yourself, and the laws of logic.

[edited to add] I must have edited my post after you read it - I was trying to shorten the thing up a bit, so I deleted my comment about language, since it was a rather trivial thing for me to be objecting to. But since you talked about it, I'd better add it again, my statement was: Speaking with an accent has been rather convincingly shown to been an impediment in my opinion - what is your evidence for claiming otherwise
 
Last edited:
Since we have often been at odds over the logical validity of my arguments, I will give this one in semi-formal logic, so you can clearly see that its logical form is valid (therefore, if you wish to challenge my claims, it must via the veracity of my premises). I apologize in advance for the painful detail I'm about to go into - I just want to make sure that there are no ambiguities whatsoever in my argument.

ANALYTIC (ie, true by virtue of meaning) TRUTHS
a) Discrimination: the favouring of certain groups over others on a basis other than merit (in other words: to subject members of certain groups to an ongoing, and specific type, of unfairness)
b) Oppression: the subjection to ongoing injustice
c) Ongoing injustice: subject to ongoing unfairness
note on my use of 'ongoing': the term is here used to mean events that are not single occurrences, and that can be reasonably expected to continue to occur in the foreseeable future.

SYNTHETIC TRUTHS YOU HAVE ASSERTED
d) Discrimination exists
e) Society should not permit discrimination since it is unfair

MY ARGUMENT IN ENGLISH
  1. You assert that discrimination exist.
  2. By the definition of discrimination, this means that you hold that certain groups are favoured others on a basis other than merit.
  3. Therefore you hold that, within our society, members of certain groups are subject to an ongoing (specific type) of unfairness.
  4. Following from premise 3, by the definition of unfairness you must hold that members of certain groups are subject to an ongoing injustice.
  5. Following from premise 4, by the definition of oppression this means you must hold that members of certain groups are oppressed.
DEFINITION OF SYMBOLS
o - oppression
d - discrimination
Ix - x is 'to subject to ongoing injustice'
Ux - x is 'to subject to ongoing unfairness'
iff - 'if and only if' (ie, the 'biconditional')

DEMONSTRATION OF THE VALIDITY OF MY ARGUMENT IN SEMI-FORMAL LOGIC
  1. d ----------------------------- [your assertion]
  2. Ud ---------------------------- [by definition of 'discrimination']
  3. (for all x)(Ix iff Ux) ------------ [by definition of 'ongoing injustice']
  4. Id ---------------------------- [1, 2: biconditional elimination (aka: MP + Equiv)]
  5. (for all x)[(x = o) iff Ix] -------- [by definition of 'oppression']
  6. d = o ------------------------- [4, 5: biconditional elimination]
  7. o ----------------------------- [6: identity relation]
To disprove my conclusion, you must demonstrate either that my argument is invalid, or that one of the analytic or synthetic truths (labelled a through e) is false. Since the argument is clearly of a valid logical form (you can review the laws I have used [url, you have already assented to the analytic truths, and you yourself are the one who asserted the synthetic ones, you cannot disprove my conclusion.

Are you quite sure you understand the definition of 'oppression'? To be honest, in response to my post 'Volume II: Inherent Inferiority', I had expected to you to say that you had been operating under a mistaken idea of what the definition of oppression was. I was rather surprised when you assented to the definition, and yet still held that oppression did not exist, since this means you have annihilated your own argument by turning it into a reductio ad absurdum.
 
All you have to do is live and work among the immigrants. Miami is a very international city. The Haitians, Jamaicans, and others from the islands have thrived there. You don't need demographics to observe.

Single people on the average do not do as well as married people. (Change that to people without steady partners if you will.) Women do suffer more than men. Go back and revisit my educational skills statement. In the United States over 70% of the births in the black community are out of wedlock. Add to that poor or little education and you have a formula for personal disaster. These are life choices, NOT systematic oppression.

Criminal activity is inversely proportional to education. A person that is not qualified to hold a job in hi-tech, or whatever, regardless of gender or ethnicity, will not get a high paying job. That is NOT systematic oppression.

The driving in an 'upscale' neighborhood IS a valid point. On the other hand, the statistics are in the policemen's favor. Stopping a car is prudent. Rudeness or aggressive behavior on the part of the police is inexcusable and should be grounds for dismissal. Unfortunately, in many cases it is not. However, that does NOT prevent the minority from seeking and maintaining a well paying job. It is NOT a violation of civil rights. And it is NOT systematic oppression.

The "Source" that you speak of is based on valid data. The fact that it was incomplete may or may not be disengenuous. The statement was used to illustrate a point about 'statistics'. Much like the statistician who drowned in a lake whose mean depth was 6 inches.

The 65% number takes us back to education and qualifications. There are no few small numbers of black commentators that are trying to pound the point home that it is the lack of education that is holding the black man back more so than any systematic oppression by any other group. The dropout rate for black freshmen entering the New York City school system this year (those that will quit school before graduating) is 27%. The good news is that the number is dropping. It used to approach 40%. You are not going to get that high paying job in big industry, or small industry for that matter, if you cannot even produce a high school diploma. Again, I don't care what your gender or ethnic background is.

As far as the 'unbroken' career details. Please do go into detail. And don't talk about 'job hopping' or sabaticals. Talk to me about extended abscences from any sort of related stimuli.

I've never seen or found an accent to be an impediment. (Actually I take that back. "Hamlet" down with a southern US twang might be a bit to much for any audience.) Quite frankly, there is a trend to hiring multi-linguals and most americans are to damn lazy to really master a foriegn language. The fact that someone has an accent does not hinder their ability to communicate in a lucid and understandable manner. But the point still remains that in study after study, facility with the English language is one of the biggest single factors in a persons ability to obtain and dhold a well paying position. This is the basis for eliminating the dual language track at many of our public school systems. While the foriegn student advances more rapidly in their native tongue (no surprise there is there?). As soon as their out of school and on the street they find that there is no market for someone that can't speak the language.

Yes, you can develope theories for the indications of the raw data. But you then go out in the real world and impirically test those theories. If the theories can be repeated by other researchers and supported by a jury of peers and sustained by a preponderence of support by the scientific community, then you have something. As long as those deductions are being debated by the community you have no 'proofs', just working theories.

What you are speaking of is intellectual debate over indicators and the reasons therefore. That is an honest endeavor. Screaming the opposition down and assigning perjorative labels is NOT.

In the end, I think that the groups that you are discussing would be better served by focusing inward. Looking at themselves in an honest light and assesing what they are doing to hold themselves back. After that self-inventory if it is found that there are systematic acts taking place, the groups in question will not only be aware of the specific acts, but will be able to make more than generalized recomendations to correct them.

Ishmael
 
crysede said:
Since we have often been at odds over the logical validity of my arguments, I will give this one in semi-formal logic, so you can clearly see that its logical form is valid (therefore, if you wish to challenge my claims, it must via the veracity of my premises). I apologize in advance for the painful detail I'm about to go into - I just want to make sure that there are no ambiguities whatsoever in my argument.

ANALYTIC (ie, true by virtue of meaning) TRUTHS
a) Discrimination: the favouring of certain groups over others on a basis other than merit (in other words: to subject members of certain groups to an ongoing, and specific type, of unfairness)
b) Oppression: the subjection to ongoing injustice
c) Ongoing injustice: subject to ongoing unfairness
note on my use of 'ongoing': the term is here used to mean events that are not single occurrences, and that can be reasonably expected to continue to occur in the foreseeable future.

SYNTHETIC TRUTHS YOU HAVE ASSERTED
d) Discrimination exists
e) Society should not permit discrimination since it is unfair

MY ARGUMENT IN ENGLISH
  1. You assert that discrimination exist.
  2. By the definition of discrimination, this means that you hold that certain groups are favoured others on a basis other than merit.
  3. Therefore you hold that, within our society, members of certain groups are subject to an ongoing (specific type) of unfairness.
  4. Following from premise 3, by the definition of unfairness you must hold that members of certain groups are subject to an ongoing injustice.
  5. Following from premise 4, by the definition of oppression this means you must hold that members of certain groups are oppressed.
DEFINITION OF SYMBOLS
o - oppression
d - discrimination
Ix - x is 'to subject to ongoing injustice'
Ux - x is 'to subject to ongoing unfairness'
iff - 'if and only if' (ie, the 'biconditional')

DEMONSTRATION OF THE VALIDITY OF MY ARGUMENT IN SEMI-FORMAL LOGIC
  1. d ----------------------------- [your assertion]
  2. Ud ---------------------------- [by definition of 'discrimination']
  3. (for all x)(Ix iff Ux) ------------ [by definition of 'ongoing injustice']
  4. Id ---------------------------- [1, 2: biconditional elimination (aka: MP + Equiv)]
  5. (for all x)[(x = o) iff Ix] -------- [by definition of 'oppression']
  6. d = o ------------------------- [4, 5: biconditional elimination]
  7. o ----------------------------- [6: identity relation]
To disprove my conclusion, you must demonstrate either that my argument is invalid, or that one of the analytic or synthetic truths (labelled a through e) is false. Since the argument is clearly of a valid logical form (you can review the laws I have used [url, you have already assented to the analytic truths, and you yourself are the one who asserted the synthetic ones, you cannot disprove my conclusion.

Are you quite sure you understand the definition of 'oppression'? To be honest, in response to my post 'Volume II: Inherent Inferiority', I had expected to you to say that you had been operating under a mistaken idea of what the definition of oppression was. I was rather surprised when you assented to the definition, and yet still held that oppression did not exist, since this means you have annihilated your own argument by turning it into a reductio ad absurdum.

Amusing.

We both know that a formula is only as sdvalid as it's starting point and it's assumptions. Regardless of the fact that I disagree with your definition of "ongoing injustice", I can with equal validity state the following;

A = any group based on ethnicity or gender.

B = the two sigma peak for the social dynamics of that group.

C = the financial success of any particular segment of curve B

How do we test the social dynamics? We prepare a questionaire based on life choices and apply that questionaire to a significantly relevant number of any group. (The 'A' factor.) Are you married? Do you have any children? Were they born in or out of wedlock? Did you graduate from High School? College? Is your degree in the sciences? Law? Social Services? Education? A whole list of question. You assign a numerical weight to the answers. This will give you a two sigma curve of arbitrary numerical value. (The 'B' factor being the peak of the two sigma curve.) You then perform the same study with a different group. It matters not whether the curve shifts to the right or left. You now have demonstated differences in group choices, choices based on peer pressure more than systematic imposition. (If you haven't already guessed the numeric value is only to be able to see differences, it's relative and higher or lower is of no significance at all.)

Compare those peaks to the mean income for the group. That developes 'C'.

My hypothesis is that you will find a considerably larger coorelation of life choices to income than you will gender or ethnicity.

My methodology is better than yours in that it presumes nothing. I do have a working hypothesis, but I have no presumption of outcome, nor is it based on accepting the definition of certain words or phrases.

Ishmael
 
Re: Hey Zircon...

Lost Cause said:
Your reply was interesting, and just reinforced my position against PC and the facists supporting it. At the end of your post you forgot to say, "Sieg Heil"!
Go to the thread on "what era would you live in?" You can then enter "Germany-1922 to 1939' you have a great mentality for "Krystal Nacht".
:D

Lost Cause,

I've no idea what "Krystal Nacht" means. You're right, I did forget "Sieg Heil" in the end. And to think I actually like Hitler's hair style, since I'm balding like him...

:D Z
 
Re: I'm a commie, nazi pinko, socialist! Muahahahahah

crysede said:
Right, 'cause the Nazi's were so very, very against hate speech - oh, and were terribly PC too, insisting that all the death camps have affirmative action to make sure homosexuals and the mentally handicapped got proportional representation.

And Hitler, that tireless fighter for minority rights, was extremely concerned about the lack of Catholics in the camps as well. Those impassioned speeches he made, concerning the oppression within society that prevented Catholics from being gassed and incinerated would bring a tear to the eye of any advocate of PC.

Organized Religion like Catholicism ought to be gassed, raped and burned too. But that's just me. And Taxed just like everyone else. I bet that if you taxed the church, you could prolly eliminate the national deficit.

Z
 
Re: Re: I'm a commie, nazi pinko, socialist! Muahahahahah

Zircon said:


Organized Religion like Catholicism ought to be gassed, raped and burned too. But that's just me. And Taxed just like everyone else. I bet that if you taxed the church, you could prolly eliminate the national deficit.

Z

Which church? All of them?

Ishmael
 
Re: Re: Re: I'm a commie, nazi pinko, socialist! Muahahahahah

Ishmael said:


Which church? All of them?

Ishmael

Sure Ishmael. All of them. I believe that donations to Churches are not taxed. And they keep asking for money. Why do churches themselves need money since they are not taxed? Does religion actually need money? I thought that God is Free, FOC...

Z
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: I'm a commie, nazi pinko, socialist! Muahahahahah

Zircon said:


Sure Ishmael. All of them. I believe that donations to Churches are not taxed. And they keep asking for money. Why do churches themselves need money since they are not taxed? Does religion actually need money? I thought that God is Free, FOC...

Z

Yep, God is free. The missions that the churches run in this country and in the developing countries are not.

If you really want to see the shit hit the fan, attack the churches. You will see a true unification of the Jews, Christians, and the Muslims. And you won't like the outcome.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
Amusing.

We both know that a formula is only as sdvalid as it's starting point and it's assumptions. Regardless of the fact that I disagree with your definition of "ongoing injustice", I can with equal validity state the following;
Ishmael--

This thread is way too entertaining for me to want to meddle. There is little I could add to this subject, for I don't have the first hand experience of the PC:ism you are all talking about. I live in a country (Portugal) with a clear predominance of white catholics, but with an historically multi-ethnical multi-cultural society. Racial issues have never really constituted a problem (for some reason, you hear a lot about the Spanish Inquisition and very little of the Portuguese). PCism doesn't exist to this extent, and nobody really takes it seriously. Even the proposals for women quotas in public offices and parliaments are laughed upon. I don't imagine how the mere suggestion of terms like African-Portuguese would be received, because a large number of whites were actually born in Africa and are proud of it.

I'm just intervening because I think that this is becoming almost ridiculous. I think that even the most vehement of your partisans must be beginning to vacillate before you continued failure to present logical arguments! I'm sorry, but I just can't understand how can you fail to accept that definition of ongoing injustice.

For what I could understand, Crysede's definitions were fairly common sense!
c) Ongoing injustice: subject to ongoing unfairness
I'm actually perplexed that anyone can contest this. In most languages in the world (I can get you more detailed information on this) there isn't even a distinction between these two words. In Portuguese I would translate both of them as injustiça! Merriam-Webster online dictionary says:

Main Entry: in·jus·tice
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin injustitia, from injustus unjust, from in- + justus just
Date: 14th century
1 : absence of justice : violation of right or of the rights of another : UNFAIRNESS
2 : an unjust act : WRONG

Main Entry: un·fair
Function: adjective
Date: 1700
1 : marked by injustice, partiality, or deception : UNJUST
2 : not equitable in business dealings
- un·fair·ness noun

I'm sorry, I must be dumb. How can anyone disagree with "ongoing injustice" = "ongoing unfairness"? I mean, if I wanted to really take your side in this issue, you're not making things easy, are you? Could you at least try to use some logic thought in your replies? It's kind of sad witnissing this sort of one sided debate...
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: I'm a commie, nazi pinko, socialist! Muahahahahah

Ishmael said:


Yep, God is free. The missions that the churches run in this country and in the developing countries are not.

If you really want to see the shit hit the fan, attack the churches. You will see a true unification of the Jews, Christians, and the Muslims. And you won't like the outcome.

Ishmael

Acutally what's there not to like? There's God, there are those tenets to tell you to do good, especially for your fellow man/woman. And not forgetting the tenet of turning the other cheek when someone spite you...

I'm attacking the churches/mosques/synagoues/temples where the greedy bastards hide behind/in.

Z
 
Lauren.Hynde said:
Ishmael--

This thread is way too entertaining for me to want to meddle. There is little I could add to this subject, for I don't have the first hand experience of the PC:ism you are all talking about. I live in a country (Portugal) with a clear predominance of white catholics, but with an historically multi-ethnical multi-cultural society. Racial issues have never really constituted a problem (for some reason, you hear a lot about the Spanish Inquisition and very little of the Portuguese). PCism doesn't exist to this extent, and nobody really takes it seriously. Even the proposals for women quotas in public offices and parliaments are laughed upon. I don't imagine how the mere suggestion of terms like African-Portuguese would be received, because a large number of whites were actually born in Africa and are proud of it.

I'm just intervening because I think that this is becoming almost ridiculous. I think that even the most vehement of your partisans must be beginning to vacillate before you continued failure to present logical arguments! I'm sorry, but I just can't understand how can you fail to accept that definition of ongoing injustice.

For what I could understand, Crysede's definitions were fairly common sense!I'm actually perplexed that anyone can contest this. In most languages in the world (I can get you more detailed information on this) there isn't even a distinction between these two words. In Portuguese I would translate both of them as injustiça! Merriam-Webster online dictionary says:

Main Entry: in·jus·tice
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin injustitia, from injustus unjust, from in- + justus just
Date: 14th century
1 : absence of justice : violation of right or of the rights of another : UNFAIRNESS
2 : an unjust act : WRONG

Main Entry: un·fair
Function: adjective
Date: 1700
1 : marked by injustice, partiality, or deception : UNJUST
2 : not equitable in business dealings
- un·fair·ness noun

I'm sorry, I must be dumb. How can anyone disagree with "ongoing injustice" = "ongoing unfairness"? I mean, if I wanted to really take your side in this issue, you're not making things easy, are you? Could you at least try to use some logic thought in your replies? It's kind of sad witnissing this sort of one sided debate...

Without having to dispute the dictionary, I can tell you that 'justice' is in the eyes of the believer. Justice for one is injustice for the other. It is the root of most of the religious wars.

The mere statement of "it's unjust" does not make it 'unjust'. Nor does the statement that it's "just" make it so.

And that is the heart of the debate that I have with crysede. Inorder to impirically "prove" something to be true, it must be uncoupled from preconceptions and beliefs. Her definitions maybe dictionary correct, but they are relative terms. Justice to you is not the same as justice to a South American Indian. And your advanced societal status does not give you the right to claim supremacy. To do so makes you as guilty of arrogance as those that you might accuse.

Ishmael
 
Religion & Money

Just one thing about the religious confessions. I don't know what's the policy of other countries, but Portugal is a laic state. That means that under the constitution all religious confession are subject to equal treatment. In this case, they all get taxed. There is a concordat with the Roman Catholic Church conceeding them some special previledges as a form of compensation for the confiscation of church properties at the start of the Republic back in 1910, but that document is about to lose validaty in 3 years. Why should religious confessions be treated any different than any comercial enterprise?
 
Re: Religion & Money

Lauren.Hynde said:
Just one thing about the religious confessions. I don't know what's the policy of other countries, but Portugal is a laic state. That means that under the constitution all religious confession are subject to equal treatment. In this case, they all get taxed. There is a concordat with the Roman Catholic Church conceeding them some special previledges as a form of compensation for the confiscation of church properties at the start of the Republic back in 1910, but that document is about to lose validaty in 3 years. Why should religious confessions be treated any different than any comercial enterprise?

Exactly. I'd gladly pay money to see that happen...

Z
 
Ishmael said:


Without having to dispute the dictionary, I can tell you that 'justice' is in the eyes of the believer. Justice for one is injustice for the other. It is the root of most of the religious wars.

The mere statement of "it's unjust" does not make it 'unjust'. Nor does the statement that it's "just" make it so.

And that is the heart of the debate that I have with crysede. Inorder to impirically "prove" something to be true, it must be uncoupled from preconceptions and beliefs. Her definitions maybe dictionary correct, but they are relative terms. Justice to you is not the same as justice to a South American Indian. And your advanced societal status does not give you the right to claim supremacy. To do so makes you as guilty of arrogance as those that you might accuse.

Ishmael
I know I can't be a part of an advanced society by any standards. I must be really dumb. Can you explain to me, AGAIN, but this time really slow, howcome "unjust" differs from "unfair"? Because that's the only issue I addressed in my post. Your refusal of the concept of "ongoing injustice" being equivalent to that of "ongoing unfairness".

Are you starting to see what I mean about logical thought? Could you make your rebutes a bit less tangent? You're making this move in circles...
 
Last edited:
Lauren.Hynde said:
I know I can't be a part of an advanced society by any standards. I must be really dumb. Can you explain to me, AGAIN, but this time really slow, how "unjust" differs from "unfair"? Because that's the only issue I addressed in my post. Your refusal of the concept of "ongoing injustice" being equivalent to that of "ongoing unfairness".

Are you starting to see what I mean about logical thought? Could you make your rebutes a bit less tangent? You're making this move in circles...

Symantically the term unjust and unfair are the same and both are relative.

Crysede's hypothesis is that unjust = unfair = oppression. This conclusion on her part is arrived at based on statistics. Further she gets to be the judge on what is fair and what is not.

My hypothesis is that the matter is much more complicated and has as much or more to do with social dynamics and choices that are made within a group (societal) regimen. I judge nothing as far as fairness is concerned, I contend that groups make choices as much as individuals do and that there are consequences to those choices.

Ishmael
 
Ad Nauseum....

*Any problems with this, and you can refer to my sig line.

In National Socialist Germany and the Soviet Union, there were no First Amendment rights. No one could voice an opinion contrary to the politically correct views enforced by the Gestapo and the KGB. Media and education were used to instill politically correct thinking and bring denunciation upon anyone who departed from politically correct thinking.

This is precisely the situation that exists today in the vast majority of American colleges and universities. Verbal and facial expressions that are contrary to political correctness result in sensitivity training (a form of brainwashing) or expulsion for the offender, who may have done nothing more than laugh. If the source of mirth is an ethnic joke, a blonde joke or a hilarious claim by a multiculturalist, the hapless offender discovers that his constitutional protections do not exist.

In Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, there were victim groups that were championed and oppressor groups that were suppressed. In Germany, the "victims" were Aryans, who were said to be under the financial hegemony of Jews. In the Soviet Union, the hegemonic group was the bourgeoisie, who allegedly held sway over an oppressed proletariat. In both countries, victims were permitted to exercise violent language and actions against oppressors.

In the United States today, white heterosexual able-bodied males constitute the hegemonic group. Everyone else is a member of a victim group.

In Germany and the Soviet Union, the abstract and imaginary group roles of oppressor and victim were given a frightful reality by ideologues. Race and class categories became the basis for discrimination and new legal systems that favored victims' groups with preferences.

On American campuses, multicultural ideology has revived the concepts of race and class oppression, and added new ones based on gender and sexual orientation. Men oppress women, and heterosexuals oppress homosexuals.

According to multiculturalists, our culture and values reflect nothing but the arbitrary domination of society by white heterosexual males. University of Pennsylvania professor Alan Kors says that, thanks to multiculturalism, "half a century after the defeat of Nazism, we distinguish by blood and we equate blood with culture." We now think like Nazis and explain our society and culture in terms of race (and gender) hegemony.

Tyrannical states attack the family. Both the Nazis and Communists are infamous for state intrusions in family affairs. In the United States, similar bureaucratic and political intrusions come from family courts. Most Americans are unaware of the existence of these relatively new "courts." Howard University professor Stephen Baskerville is the leading authority on these courts. He says family courts are "the most dangerous institution posing a threat to constitutional rights in our society. The only parallels are the ideological-bureaucratic dictatorships of the last century."

Family courts claim immunity from the Constitution and from scrutiny by federal courts. Baskerville describes them as follows: "Their proceedings are secret and unrecorded. Their orders are enforced by bureaucratic police who do not wear uniforms and whose sole responsibility is to conduct surveillance over families and private lives. As such, these police are akin to secret police. By the very nature of their jurisdiction, these courts and police are the most intrusive and invasive arm of government, and yet they are accountable to virtually no one. Such an institution is intolerable in a free society."

Recently a family court judge ordered the parents of a 7-year-old boy in Berne, N.Y., to put their child on Ritalin, a behavior-control drug. The alternative was to be found guilty of "educational neglect," an offense that would open the possibility of their child being seized by Child Protective Services -- a Hillary Clinton "village" institution straight from the pages of the Gestapo. The child suffered serious side effects from the drug, but parents no longer have the right to decide what is best for their children.

Tyrannical states assault the individual in the inner recesses of his consciousness. He is not permitted to think certain thoughts or to express a prohibited thought privately to anyone.

Recently, Janice Barton encountered a Spanish-speaking couple while leaving a restaurant in Manistee, Mich. She turned to her mother and said, "I wish these (ethnic slur) would learn to speak English." An off-duty deputy sheriff overheard the private remark, followed the woman to her car and noted her tag number. Janice Barton was sentenced to 45 days in jail for her thought crime.

This couldn't happen in a free country. (or Germany in the '30s)






:D
 
Re: Ad Nauseum....

Lost Cause said:
*Any problems with this, and you can refer to my sig line.

In National Socialist Germany and the Soviet Union, there were no First Amendment rights. No one could voice an opinion contrary to the politically correct views enforced by the Gestapo and the KGB. Media and education were used to instill politically correct thinking and bring denunciation upon anyone who departed from politically correct thinking.

This is precisely the situation that exists today in the vast majority of American colleges and universities. Verbal and facial expressions that are contrary to political correctness result in sensitivity training (a form of brainwashing) or expulsion for the offender, who may have done nothing more than laugh. If the source of mirth is an ethnic joke, a blonde joke or a hilarious claim by a multiculturalist, the hapless offender discovers that his constitutional protections do not exist.

In Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, there were victim groups that were championed and oppressor groups that were suppressed. In Germany, the "victims" were Aryans, who were said to be under the financial hegemony of Jews. In the Soviet Union, the hegemonic group was the bourgeoisie, who allegedly held sway over an oppressed proletariat. In both countries, victims were permitted to exercise violent language and actions against oppressors.

In the United States today, white heterosexual able-bodied males constitute the hegemonic group. Everyone else is a member of a victim group.

In Germany and the Soviet Union, the abstract and imaginary group roles of oppressor and victim were given a frightful reality by ideologues. Race and class categories became the basis for discrimination and new legal systems that favored victims' groups with preferences.

On American campuses, multicultural ideology has revived the concepts of race and class oppression, and added new ones based on gender and sexual orientation. Men oppress women, and heterosexuals oppress homosexuals.

According to multiculturalists, our culture and values reflect nothing but the arbitrary domination of society by white heterosexual males. University of Pennsylvania professor Alan Kors says that, thanks to multiculturalism, "half a century after the defeat of Nazism, we distinguish by blood and we equate blood with culture." We now think like Nazis and explain our society and culture in terms of race (and gender) hegemony.

Tyrannical states attack the family. Both the Nazis and Communists are infamous for state intrusions in family affairs. In the United States, similar bureaucratic and political intrusions come from family courts. Most Americans are unaware of the existence of these relatively new "courts." Howard University professor Stephen Baskerville is the leading authority on these courts. He says family courts are "the most dangerous institution posing a threat to constitutional rights in our society. The only parallels are the ideological-bureaucratic dictatorships of the last century."

Family courts claim immunity from the Constitution and from scrutiny by federal courts. Baskerville describes them as follows: "Their proceedings are secret and unrecorded. Their orders are enforced by bureaucratic police who do not wear uniforms and whose sole responsibility is to conduct surveillance over families and private lives. As such, these police are akin to secret police. By the very nature of their jurisdiction, these courts and police are the most intrusive and invasive arm of government, and yet they are accountable to virtually no one. Such an institution is intolerable in a free society."

Recently a family court judge ordered the parents of a 7-year-old boy in Berne, N.Y., to put their child on Ritalin, a behavior-control drug. The alternative was to be found guilty of "educational neglect," an offense that would open the possibility of their child being seized by Child Protective Services -- a Hillary Clinton "village" institution straight from the pages of the Gestapo. The child suffered serious side effects from the drug, but parents no longer have the right to decide what is best for their children.

Tyrannical states assault the individual in the inner recesses of his consciousness. He is not permitted to think certain thoughts or to express a prohibited thought privately to anyone.

Recently, Janice Barton encountered a Spanish-speaking couple while leaving a restaurant in Manistee, Mich. She turned to her mother and said, "I wish these (ethnic slur) would learn to speak English." An off-duty deputy sheriff overheard the private remark, followed the woman to her car and noted her tag number. Janice Barton was sentenced to 45 days in jail for her thought crime.

This couldn't happen in a free country. (or Germany in the '30s)






:D

And so it goes.

Ishmael
 
Back
Top