HB1965
Litster
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2007
- Posts
- 27,794
A logical challenge in certain circumstances is a different thing from an attack.
Perhaps but when you started using terms like OZlike, questioning the flaws in my brain, and then implying that I was delusional I thought that was an attack.
Equal in our struggles is what I am disagreeing with. I am asking you to provide evidence or rational thought that backs up how we are equal.
The same way I ask people to explain to me how the concept of heaven, hell, karma, spirit, eternity, redemption, punishment...are practically applied in their lives.
Here is rational thought for you.
Looking at the pattern of history that stretches out over time it's very clear that humanity has developed it's cultures as an expression of who we are and the basic physical and emotional needs that we have. Without this culture it all boils down to the fact that we are all just people living and procreating on a rock we have called the Earth. That right there makes us equal. We can create all the social constructs we want but it doesn't change the fact that each of us shares blueprints for the same basic physical structure, and that we all eat, shit, sleep, and feel.
When I say being equal in our struggles I mean each of us has something in our life that causes us pain and suffering. This is part of the human condition. No one's life is completely hunky dory, and no one is spared some kind of suffering. We all have things that cause stress and pain to us. In my case I have lived for the last 15 years with a fairly serious case of Rheumatoid Arthritis. This and the ensuing treatment has caused untolled stress on my life. You on the flipside may have had any number of things happen to you that have caused you the same level of stress. The residents that I work with on a daily basis have lived their lives with various physical and mental conditions that have caused a great deal of stress on their body, minds, and hearts.
Leaving out the whole idea about reincarnation, I can conclude is that these things just are. It's something we have to accept about being human. You may argue that the crack baby suffers more than we do because of the life he/she is forced to live by circumstance, but in the end it boils down to simply that all of us suffer, all of us feel joy, all of us deal with it as best we can with the tools that we've been given by life.
As far heaven, hell, karma, spirit, eternity, redemption, punishment and applying it to our daily lives? I only speak to karma and spirit. The rest are religious concepts that have no bearing on what I believe and eternity is not a concept that I feel that I need to be concerned about on a daily basis. Buddhism gives the best definition of karma in my mind. Your actions have consequences in this world. If you choose to be mean to someone then in the end that person will most likely be mean back or someone else will on their behalf. John Watson and BF Skinner based their whole career as psychologists on the premise of cause and effect. It's been proven time and time again in laboratory studies. Karma is more than that ultimately, but in our day to day lives that's how it counts.
In terms of spirit, there are so many ways in which you can understand that word. As far as applying it to daily life I see that my spirit, my soul, as being the basic essense of me. It's there all the time and is the part of me that learns.
Ultimately I think that there's a place for patience, sense and understanding, and an equal and valid place for anger, waste and cluelessness.
I think they're all part of it, and to value patience, sense and understanding over all, is not (in my opinion and tactics) the choice I make because I don't think they're always valid.
Your talking about emotional reactions here. I see no reason as to why you or I can't feel any of those feeling in any given place, but in the end what purpose does it serve for me to remain angry at the crack babies mother for making a choice that I wouldn't choose to make? It does me and the baby no good. She did what she did and there is nothing I can do to change it. I can only help the baby who is suffering.
I don't think equality is real. I think it's a comforting thought. I try to eliminate comforting thoughts in my own practice, because if I rely on them, I start to fill in too many blanks. The human mind has evolved to recognize pattern and solve problems. Sometimes the pattern is there. Sometimes it's not and I obsess on the piece of an imaginary puzzle that if I could just get it, all things will make sense, but the puzzle itself is an imaginary construct. It's pretty, and it might even be real, but ultimately it's not useful to anything but my own ego. My forays into abnormal psychology can make myth and dogma seem too much like delusion when it's taken literally. Taken in smaller doses, it's of value. Made absolute and sure, I think it becomes a crutch.
To me lack of equality is simply a social constuct. To me for some that is the comforting thought. I can make myself feel better with the concept that because I have money and I can afford to buy so much more than others and can comfort myself with the thought that I am some how much better. In reality my life is simply different. I still have any number of other issue that I need to deal with. It just happens that money is not one of them. I can also comfort myself with the thought that some how I am better or better off because I am not handicapped, but in truth I am no better or worse than they in the sense that I have other things that I have to deal with in my life because I'm not handicapped.
As far as the puzzles of life, some times it's about the best fit for you and what you need to keep yourself sane and to make it so you can live your life. It often times doesn't have to be real for anyone else. Only you. In that it has value for your personal experience that's all that matters. As far as absolute and sure, I never said that anything about it was absolute and sure, only that this what I know and believe now. If I am presented with enough compelling evidence otherwise I could change my mind.
Patience, understanding and forgiveness for the long term, yes. I think that the key to progress isn't absolute closure or understanding, but the tactical ability to accept less than an absolute, forgive life and myself for its imperfection, and move on.
That's the point of this thread. Constructive Living. The difference between what we think and what we do, and which one is of more ultimate value to the beings around us. I discarded karma and "the big picture" because it made me feel insulated from the true horror that I see around me and that I experience. I used the idea like a drug, to give me a destiny and a focus. This is what I did, I'm not saying you're doing it. I'm pointing out how certain thoughts can lead to delusion if you rely on them too much without swapping out other thought processes that are more practical.
This is me living and being constructive in the thread spirit. The thoughts you are expressing, I've encountered in my spiritual path, and I've questioned them and challenging them as I'm questioning and challenging you. It is not personal. It's theoretical.
I certainly don't think your intentions in the beginning were not get personal but I think you did after a point when you started to question my logic and began throwing out things like the flaws in my brain and the whole OZ-like thing. Yeah I think it got personal. You're asking about how this became about my life, it's become about your life too. When one debates they speak from a perspective of their own study, reflection, and personal experience. What it boils down to on this thread is that you and are debating our life paths and each is very personal and as such emotional.
As far as Constructive Living or my version of it, the whole idea is that you are constucting your life so that it meets the needs of what you need to do to survive. I feel, however, that in order to do that I have to understand who I am and how I function. If I fail to do that then how can I construct anything that works for me? I have to answer questions about how do certain events in my life impact me and how do I deal with them so that I can move on. Some of these principles mentioned here may be useful in the day to day, but they don't solve the bigger problem. While I can use the ego boast that I get from the short term fix of having accomplished something to help me feel better, the other feelings and emotions about that other bigger thing is still there waiting to creep up on me and effecting how I function in the world. This in turn makes my life less satisfactory. I agree in the end that I have to make my own closure in life which is something I'm struggling with now.
Reci, can you consider that may be I am doing the same thing? In my way I'm putting out questions to you about how you view your situation. How do you or do you every deal with the bigger picture issues? Even Psychology will tell you that it has to be done. While I believe that it's important to deal with issues on a day to day level, where does your concept of Constructive Living deal with the over all big picture issues that need to get addressed for one's own sanity.I would like you to consider that in my own particular way, I'm not attacking, but attempting to provide an insight into a process that I worked long and hard on, and I am presenting a solution to the problem, not more problems.
Paradoxically I believe that the key to being of true service here, is that less is more. Focusing on real problems. Hunger. Pain. Suffering. Relieving those. That's my practice. Not telling people that their hunger, pain or suffering means something. Allowing it to be just what it is, horrible and meaningless and deserving of compassion, not judgment that makes it all okay somehow.
I'm not saying that it is okay. I'm saying like you that it is what is. The difference between what you and see what that "is" is. You're philosophy seems hung up to me on how horrible and meaningless it is but yet in reality every human experience as meaning for the individual person going through it and many times for others observing. Character and understanding often deepen from having going through these things. As Nietzsche said "That which does not kill us makes us stronger". Do I want people to suffer? No. Do I think it horrible that they do? Yes. Is the fact that it happened meaningless? No. I agree though that often those things don't have to happen and what we should be focused on is how do we help the individual person and in the future anyone else.
Because people expect a BIG paycheck for all their hunger and suffering and pain. And I don't think they're going to get it, and I think that sucks.
You have to give up your paycheck for it to be service to individual, unique human beings and not service to an idea that's going to pay off like the Karmic Lottery someday.
It sounds to me like you think that this should be our right and due. That we should get what we want from all this pain and suffering. Whoever said that life owed us anything? The Karmic payoff comes through our own actions and our own struggle. We learn what we can from this experience and apply it to practical solutions. If you are hungry and suffering then you need to figure out what you're going to do about that. If someone helps you along the way you know that the best way to pay them back is to help them out in their time of need or help others in a similar situation. If you don't like it that anyone goes through that then be one of those people that helps out.