Constructive Living

1) In all honesty I wasn't really talking about The CL philosophy simply an idea of what the words mean to me.
It goes back to my question then of how can you practice these principles if your don't know yourself well enough to implement them. I can certainly agree that applying the philosophy can help you do better in your life, but I don't feel that it's the be all and end all of having a better life.




2) I actually agree with him on this. I see alcoholism as not a disease, but as a choice that one makes because our bodies make it a very easy one. The goal is to stop taking the drink, but the road leading up to finding out why you do it is the where the tough part comes in. It's made doubly so by how are bodies are effected by it.



3) I would bet they are. It sounds like the goal here is to improve your life and to make things more positive. To be able to do that you have to have the attitude that you can do this and not be afraid to look at yourself and your habits.

1) I think "knowing yourself" is valuable to an extent, but it becomes like a hobby for some people, a distraction from actually doing anything. CL tries really hard to get people to stop all that self-focus. People spend massive amounts of time thinking about themselves. You can only have insight once. After that it's no longer insightful, it's just repetition of something you already know.

2) I disagree that finding out why you do it is important. I think you need to stop drinking if it's a problem. Then you can address other stuff. That we drink because of something is less important to me than that we drink so much we cause ourselves harm. Besides, we're back to that causative thinking again here. Behavior is not caused by feelings.

3) There are really two goals to CL. One is to be better at whatever you decide to do. The other is to recognize your position in the universe, to accept reality as it is.
 
This is lovely. It's a lot like something atmas was saying a few months ago about being angry in traffic.

The two passages I bolded are an interesting contrast. In the context of CL theory, the first is a common sort of question. I'll address it, sort of, in another post.

The second sort of disagrees with CL theory, in that I doubt anyone in CL would say that we can choose to feel a certain way. We certainly can, however, choose the context in which we view the world, and that can influence feelings in a powerful way, which is really the larger point of the fable anyway. Fables are another favorite tool of CL.

Depends on how you define choice, maybe.

I don't think you choose initial conditions - the first time a situation or a thought or a feeling hits you.

From that point on though, once you have familiarity with those conditions, thoughts and feelings, you can tailor your responses to them.

There'd be no such thing as "acquired taste" otherwise.

If you hated it the first time, how do you acquire the taste for it if not by attempting it over and over again?

I think thought process and experience can definitely countour and refine how we feel, it's all relative to how we choose to proceed with that feeling.

People who experience a crush the first time - some of them shut other people out to avoid being hurt again, some people open themselves wider to the concept of love so that the experience of the love is a more positive experience than that of the inevitable pain of caring for someone.

So although you might not have a choice about how you respond the first time you taste love, you can choose to acquire a taste and get to know it, or avoid it forever completely.

Experience with something alters our perception of it.

I'm on the fence about this one because it's a continuum. Every sensation and feeling is influenced by the ones before, which were influenced all by choices.

I do think in a way that we choose, I don't think we know WHAT we're choosing necessarily.
 
Depends on how you define choice, maybe.

I don't think you choose initial conditions - the first time a situation or a thought or a feeling hits you.

From that point on though, once you have familiarity with those conditions, thoughts and feelings, you can tailor your responses to them.

There'd be no such thing as "acquired taste" otherwise.

If you hated it the first time, how do you acquire the taste for it if not by attempting it over and over again?

I think thought process and experience can definitely countour and refine how we feel, it's all relative to how we choose to proceed with that feeling.

People who experience a crush the first time - some of them shut other people out to avoid being hurt again, some people open themselves wider to the concept of love so that the experience of the love is a more positive experience than that of the inevitable pain of caring for someone.

So although you might not have a choice about how you respond the first time you taste love, you can choose to acquire a taste and get to know it, or avoid it forever completely.

Experience with something alters our perception of it.

I'm on the fence about this one because it's a continuum. Every sensation and feeling is influenced by the ones before, which were influenced all by choices.

I do think in a way that we choose, I don't think we know WHAT we're choosing necessarily.

Hmmm. I don't think feelings are predictable, though. I know there have been lots of times that I've experienced something for a second time and reacted completely differently. I say I love climbing, but there are days when I hate it. I say I hate doing dishes, but there have been times I've enjoyed it. That said, I think common sense would tell us that there are things we can rely on to be enjoyable and things we can rely on to be unpleasant. Experience teaches us this. I think the point, for CL, is to live more purposefully, and that can often be counted upon to be also more happily.

the path this thread is traveling is quite enjoyable.

Yeah, it really is, in no small part thanks to a couple of long-winded friends of mine.
 
Hmmm. I don't think feelings are predictable, though. I know there have been lots of times that I've experienced something for a second time and reacted completely differently. I say I love climbing, but there are days when I hate it. I say I hate doing dishes, but there have been times I've enjoyed it. That said, I think common sense would tell us that there are things we can rely on to be enjoyable and things we can rely on to be unpleasant. Experience teaches us this. I think the point, for CL, is to live more purposefully, and that can often be counted upon to be also more happily.

Well, for me I'm adding and subtracting thoughts to get a result.

I have to incorporate a command to counteract a feeling. "I don't want to get out of bed." is a nobrainer, obvious every morning.

I can think "You have to. You can't stay in bed!"
"Want to."

What works best for me is "Time to get up. Get up." I had to TELL myself this for a while. Now I just do it without thinking. I have to actually tell myself to shut up and not talk about it internally. Because it won't do anything but make the inevitable harder to do.

But I have to ultimately agree with the command. Eventually the "I don't want to get out of bed" is no longer something I think. Alarm clock goes off. I push the button. I get out of bed.

This is a HUGE deal for me, because I'm a sweet talker and I can talk myself into taking a day off in 30 seconds flat. To get things done the most effective thing I know is to tell myself to shut up.

The ultimate result of this entire process is that you're getting rid of a thought, even if a feeling is the same - the actual feeling is "sleepy" - and the thought spurred from that is "I don't want to get up."

There are feelings, and then there are desires spurred from those feelings, there are thoughts spurred from those feelings, and actions we take to further or deny constructive or destructive goals. Staying in bed all day long has consequences.

"Sleepy" has to be followed by a whole litany of shorthanded thought and choices that culminate in a decision to act responsibly. The feeling is true. "Sleepy"

You have to THINK to get yourself past sleepy into "Get up" without it being an unpleasant experience.

There's a huge amount of work into making something contrary from something that arises naturally from our feelings - into something that arises from reason and goals.

You're essentially rewiring your brain to recognize a bunch of symbols. Sleepy. BUT - Alarm clock. Schedule. Job. Paycheck. Up.

Once you recognize an inevitable action, developing a convincing shorthand that builds a good habit is vital.

I don't think you ever get rid of "sleepy" - but you get rid of the negative thoughts about "sleepy" and get on with your day.

There's all sorts of ways to escape responsibility. I could be a bitch in the morning, I could hate my job, I could complain a lot, I could agree more with the "Sleepy" than the command "get up" or the action. I could refuse to get enough sleep, I could rely on caffeine or drugs in order to resentfully be alert...I could resent my job and somehow plot to screw them over for what they "did" to me.

Or I could just...get enough sleep, be awake, be aware, do what needs to be done and do my job and appreciate my paycheck.

There's a difference between pain and suffering. Life is pain, but we create in many ways, our own suffering.
 
Last edited:
1) I think "knowing yourself" is valuable to an extent, but it becomes like a hobby for some people, a distraction from actually doing anything. CL tries really hard to get people to stop all that self-focus. People spend massive amounts of time thinking about themselves. You can only have insight once. After that it's no longer insightful, it's just repetition of something you already know.

I can agree with that to an extent. I don't believe in doing it obsessively, but I believe the person who you are is a constant process. You learn new things than can change you over time. I think what your suggesting with CL can be a good thing as it can be a great tool to help you do better with your life. I like the idea of setting a daily goal for yourself to achieve.

2) I disagree that finding out why you do it is important. I think you need to stop drinking if it's a problem. Then you can address other stuff. That we drink because of something is less important to me than that we drink so much we cause ourselves harm.
I understand your point on this, but when it comes to actual practice it's not so easy. Consider the fact that AAA is full of people that relapse. There is a cycle here that needs to be broken. A cycle of things that leads to you taking a drink to solve your problem. If you don't do that psychology has proven that you will drink again or you will find something to replace it.

Besides, we're back to that causative thinking again here. Behavior is not caused by feelings.

One of the biggest criticisms of both Skinner's and Watson's behaviorism is that it didn't take into account the internal process that goes on when making a decision to act. It also doesn't give enough credit to life experience being part of how one acts. It's not so simple and straight forward as to behavior being caused by feelings, but they do influence how people act.


3) There are really two goals to CL. One is to be better at whatever you decide to do. The other is to recognize your position in the universe, to accept reality as it is.

Interesting idea and I think a good one.
 
Well, for me I'm adding and subtracting thoughts to get a result.

I have to incorporate a command to counteract a feeling. "I don't want to get out of bed." is a nobrainer, obvious every morning.

I can think "You have to. You can't stay in bed!"
"Want to."

What works best for me is "Time to get up. Get up." I had to TELL myself this for a while. Now I just do it without thinking. I have to actually tell myself to shut up and not talk about it internally. Because it won't do anything but make the inevitable harder to do.

But I have to ultimately agree with the command. Eventually the "I don't want to get out of bed" is no longer something I think. Alarm clock goes off. I push the button. I get out of bed.

This is a HUGE deal for me, because I'm a sweet talker and I can talk myself into taking a day off in 30 seconds flat. To get things done the most effective thing I know is to tell myself to shut up.

The ultimate result of this entire process is that you're getting rid of a thought, even if a feeling is the same - the actual feeling is "sleepy" - and the thought spurred from that is "I don't want to get up."

There are feelings, and then there are desires spurred from those feelings, there are thoughts spurred from those feelings, and actions we take to further or deny constructive or destructive goals. Staying in bed all day long has consequences.

"Sleepy" has to be followed by a whole litany of shorthanded thought and choices that culminate in a decision to act responsibly. The feeling is true. "Sleepy"

You have to THINK to get yourself past sleepy into "Get up" without it being an unpleasant experience.

There's a huge amount of work into making something contrary from something that arises naturally from our feelings - into something that arises from reason and goals.

You're essentially rewiring your brain to recognize a bunch of symbols. Sleepy. BUT - Alarm clock. Schedule. Job. Paycheck. Up.

Once you recognize an inevitable action, developing a convincing shorthand that builds a good habit is vital.

I don't think you ever get rid of "sleepy" - but you get rid of the negative thoughts about "sleepy" and get on with your day.

There's all sorts of ways to escape responsibility. I could be a bitch in the morning, I could hate my job, I could complain a lot, I could agree more with the "Sleepy" than the command "get up" or the action. I could refuse to get enough sleep, I could rely on caffeine or drugs in order to resentfully be alert...I could resent my job and somehow plot to screw them over for what they "did" to me.

Or I could just...get enough sleep, be awake, be aware, do what needs to be done and do my job and appreciate my paycheck.

There's a difference between pain and suffering. Life is pain, but we create in many ways, our own suffering.
This makes sense. I think CL doesn't generally try to analyze this deeply; a CL instructor would maybe assign some exercises to get you to get up on time, but probably not think too much about all the chains of thoughts and feelings involved. I remember during our early training, one o my friends said specifically that he had a really hard time not hitting the snooze button to the extent that he was sometimes late for work. Greg gave him his phone number and said he had to call him for permission to stay in bed. Problem solved. Greg said the answer would always be "Yes." There was something about the formality of calling him that dissuaded my friend. Shame, embarrassment, a desire not to disturb Greg and his wife, whatever it was, it worked like a charm.
I can agree with that to an extent. I don't believe in doing it obsessively, but I believe the person who you are is a constant process. You learn new things than can change you over time. I think what your suggesting with CL can be a good thing as it can be a great tool to help you do better with your life. I like the idea of setting a daily goal for yourself to achieve.
I think most people in CL would question what "knowing who you are" means, exactly, and precisely what benefit it would have.


I understand your point on this, but when it comes to actual practice it's not so easy. Consider the fact that AAA is full of people that relapse. There is a cycle here that needs to be broken. A cycle of things that leads to you taking a drink to solve your problem. If you don't do that psychology has proven that you will drink again or you will find something to replace it.
Sure, there are people who relapse. I just don't know that it's always "taking a drink to solve your problem." And one of the first pieces of advice given to newbs in AA is "Don't pick up." Meaning, don't engage in the behavior of drinking. Even AA, with all its focus on "Let go and let God" and "powerless to control our lives" recognizes that fundamentally, we have control over whether we put ethanol in our bloodstreams.



One of the biggest criticisms of both Skinner's and Watson's behaviorism is that it didn't take into account the internal process that goes on when making a decision to act. It also doesn't give enough credit to life experience being part of how one acts. It's not so simple and straight forward as to behavior being caused by feelings, but they do influence how people act.
True, they have influence, but it's influence that we choose to allow them to have. We're not controlled by our feelings any more than to the extent that we choose to be. I had a student once who insisted that his depressed roommate just could not, was not physically capable, get out of bed. I asked him what he thought would happen if I lit the bed on fire. He laughed at me, said it was absurd, but the point is valid. He had arms and legs and control of them; he was choosing to stay in bed, making a decision based on the awful feeling of deep depression. I wouldn't say it would be easy, just that it would be possible for him to get out of bed.
 
Let reality esteem replace self esteem.


The self-esteem "movement" developed out of a desire for kids to feel good about themselves. Well, fair enough. But it went a little too far, when we started trying to get kids to feel good about something they did, when everyone, especially the kid, knew it wasn't such a good job. Reality esteem would have people look at the reality. "I did this." Not, "I did this well, or poorly." Just the facts, man. I did this. You can decide if it's something you want to do again, by whatever criteria you want, but it's a good start to look at exactly what it is. Kids appreciate this sort of reality-based analysis, in my experience. And one of the great things was that when a kid broke the rules, all the judgment was gone; we just said, "You hit him, and this is what the program says happens when someone hits someone." We didn't say "You're a rotten violent little bastard." Sometimes we had to say, "You hit people really often; you should change that behavior." Things in the program were concrete, and the kids thrived with that. We had plenty of attention for them, and plenty of affection in most cases, and there was no gray area with what was acceptable behavior and what wasn't.




An exercise for people who want to stop doing something: Add up the money you spend on it in a given week, or month, or year. Then look at what else you could do with that amount of money. Could you go on a cruise with your cigarette budget?

Or time. How much time do you spend on Lit? Could you learn to play an instrument in that amount of time?
 
Working with attention...

Before I started climbing, I'd look at a cliff and say, "I wish I knew how to rock climb. How do they do that?"

Now I look at a cliff and see hand and footholds. Sometimes, I've looked up at very hard climbs, and not been able to see any holds. Just looks like smooth rock. Then I see someone working on the climb, and I can see the holds by watching them. They have more experience, or talent, or whatever, but they're able to see things I missed when I looked. The more we do stuff, the narrower our focus gets, the better our attention gets. We become better, the closer we pay attention to what we're doing.

A former colleague had atrocious handwriting. After a few months of CL in the workplace, his handwriting had morphed into the prettiest handwriting I ever saw from a guy with no calligraphy training. I asked him what he did. Practice at home? "I just started paying attention."

The place I used to teach medicine for had a sort of tradition. At the first meeting we'd have the students introduce themselves. Name, a few details, name. Then we'd go around the room and repeat all the names. Sort of a parlor trick. People would often ask us how we did it, remembered all thirty names in one go. I found that if I listened really closely to the person, their name stuck with me. I used to pretend I was hearing someone's mensetsu, the interview one does at the end of a Naikan meditation. You're supposed to listen as if it were the Buddha himself giving you a personal lesson. I just paid attention. When you meet people, do you remember their name? Try not thinking about yourself, what sort of impression you're making, and think instead about the person you're meeting.
 
This makes sense. I think CL doesn't generally try to analyze this deeply; a CL instructor would maybe assign some exercises to get you to get up on time, but probably not think too much about all the chains of thoughts and feelings involved. I remember during our early training, one o my friends said specifically that he had a really hard time not hitting the snooze button to the extent that he was sometimes late for work. Greg gave him his phone number and said he had to call him for permission to stay in bed. Problem solved. Greg said the answer would always be "Yes." There was something about the formality of calling him that dissuaded my friend. Shame, embarrassment, a desire not to disturb Greg and his wife, whatever it was, it worked like a charm.

Your friend has a conscience and an ounce of shame. I think that's necessary too. Being entirely aware of how positive the change is, and shaming yourself into making it. No reason to progress if you're a sociopathic narcissist and everything you do is perfect.

"Seriously, you can't exercise at all? Not even 10 minutes at a time? Oh COME ON."

That's how I got myself to exercise finally. Gym memberships, exercise bike, nothing...all burned out. I'm however NOT going to admit to myself that it's impossible for me to at least dance in place 10 minutes at a time, 3 times a day. I can't do that. I would laugh and laugh...what a loser.

Partly why I see how some of this stuff has been considered a trap to some teachers. Described once as a "subtle form of athleticism" by Charlotte Joko Beck and I keep that phrase in mind too.

However, to a certain extent I use a bit of the same philosophy in what I do. It's up to me, it's clearly my choice, and if I complain about it, I'll feel like a...whiny little bitch.

I'm fairly proud of what I've done, the discipline I manage to maintain. All I get done in a day, I worked hard for it.

It isn't, however, yet, thoughtless and effortless. There's still ego and problems and a form of one-upmanship I need to shed. I still need to work very hard at this, against myself and my thoughts, to get them done without extraneous pride or praise or focus on comparisons to other ways of doing things.

I was reading "Being Good" the other day and I had a "Well, God damn it" moment.

"Good health should not be an end in itself, but a means to spiritual growth. The health of our bodies should not become a preoccupation. Vanity about the body or fussines about what foods may or may not be eaten are sensual indulgences just as much as sloth or gluttony are."

And here I am with my neat-o list and perfect diet scheme. Dammit. More work to do. Does that qualify as obsession, or just preoccupation? Do I get a karmic discount?

I recognize the truth, but I am not there yet.

Reminders like this are a rueful nudge in the right direction.

I still want to be proud of tying my shoes.

But this personal pride is extraneous. Being this way is only a starting point according to many, many teachers and paths.

I am learning how not to sabotage myself. I haven't yet learned how to be of true benefit above and beyond the absolute basics.
 
A Thousand Waves is the title of one of David's books on CL stuff. He called it that partly because he grew up in southern California, and he remembers body surfing. You look back at the beach to see who's watching and get slammed by a wave. You stand up, embarrassed, and look back to see who saw you get slammed by a wave. And you get slammed again.

Where is your attention? Is it on the next wave or the last one?
 
*subscribing*

Just popping in to take note. I get the feeling this is something important for me, now.

Will be back when I can get a single neuron to fire.
 
Because people expect a BIG paycheck for all their hunger and suffering and pain. And I don't think they're going to get it, and I think that sucks.

You have to give up your paycheck for it to be service to individual, unique human beings and not service to an idea that's going to pay off like the Karmic Lottery someday.
It was so much easier to think this way as a kid. And actually BELIEVE with conviction that this was the way it's written in stone. I mean, "they" taught you to believe it, right? I miss it sometimes, y'know. I like being an adult for the most part, but sometimes I really miss my life being simple like that.

An exercise for people who want to stop doing something: Add up the money you spend on it in a given week, or month, or year. Then look at what else you could do with that amount of money. Could you go on a cruise with your cigarette budget?

Or time. How much time do you spend on Lit? Could you learn to play an instrument in that amount of time?

Well...there IS that theory of unified physics and applied quantum particles that I've been putting off finishing...invisibility cloaking devices, wormhole generators and time machines don't invent themselves, after all! :D
 
Your friend has a conscience and an ounce of shame. I think that's necessary too. Being entirely aware of how positive the change is, and shaming yourself into making it. No reason to progress if you're a sociopathic narcissist and everything you do is perfect.

"Seriously, you can't exercise at all? Not even 10 minutes at a time? Oh COME ON."

That's how I got myself to exercise finally. Gym memberships, exercise bike, nothing...all burned out. I'm however NOT going to admit to myself that it's impossible for me to at least dance in place 10 minutes at a time, 3 times a day. I can't do that. I would laugh and laugh...what a loser.

Partly why I see how some of this stuff has been considered a trap to some teachers. Described once as a "subtle form of athleticism" by Charlotte Joko Beck and I keep that phrase in mind too.

However, to a certain extent I use a bit of the same philosophy in what I do. It's up to me, it's clearly my choice, and if I complain about it, I'll feel like a...whiny little bitch.

I'm fairly proud of what I've done, the discipline I manage to maintain. All I get done in a day, I worked hard for it.

It isn't, however, yet, thoughtless and effortless. There's still ego and problems and a form of one-upmanship I need to shed. I still need to work very hard at this, against myself and my thoughts, to get them done without extraneous pride or praise or focus on comparisons to other ways of doing things.

I was reading "Being Good" the other day and I had a "Well, God damn it" moment.

"Good health should not be an end in itself, but a means to spiritual growth. The health of our bodies should not become a preoccupation. Vanity about the body or fussines about what foods may or may not be eaten are sensual indulgences just as much as sloth or gluttony are."

And here I am with my neat-o list and perfect diet scheme. Dammit. More work to do. Does that qualify as obsession, or just preoccupation? Do I get a karmic discount?

I recognize the truth, but I am not there yet.

Reminders like this are a rueful nudge in the right direction.

I still want to be proud of tying my shoes.

But this personal pride is extraneous. Being this way is only a starting point according to many, many teachers and paths.

I am learning how not to sabotage myself. I haven't yet learned how to be of true benefit above and beyond the absolute basics.

That's the path, all right, from what I can see from back here way, way behind you. It's a three up, two down thing, too. We're none of us perfect.

A former lover and I had a conversation about volunteering as EMT's...how people would praise us for it. It gave us some pride to be of service to the community, to the sick and injured. But there was a lot of ego in it, too. I'm a hero! Well, you may be in a position to have an opportunity to be heroic, I suppose, but really what you are is a glorified taxi service. We did it because of the coolness factor, the adrenaline rush, as much as anything else.

And, so what? The sick and injured still got taken care of.
 
*subscribing*

Just popping in to take note. I get the feeling this is something important for me, now.

Will be back when I can get a single neuron to fire.
*empties a chair*
Well...there IS that theory of unified physics and applied quantum particles that I've been putting off finishing...invisibility cloaking devices, wormhole generators and time machines don't invent themselves, after all! :D

There you go, man. Git after it!
 
It was so much easier to think this way as a kid. And actually BELIEVE with conviction that this was the way it's written in stone. I mean, "they" taught you to believe it, right? I miss it sometimes, y'know. I like being an adult for the most part, but sometimes I really miss my life being simple like that.

I used to think that I deserved migraines. I must have been a REALLY, REALLY bad person. Really bad.

Then I got to thinking that it was just sorta messed up, I couldn't have been that bad. It doesn't make sense. Even if I were God and someone had just done the worst possible thing I could think of...repeatedly...it just didn't make any sense, if I were all powerful, to be punishing someone for something they didn't remember doing. Seemed cruel. Seemed like torture. I don't like torture. I took a firm stand to decide that pain wasn't attached to deep meaning and that all the time I'd been in pain was...just...lost, meaningless, and I should stop keeping score.

It was either kill myself over the horror of it all, or just say "fine. whatever." and enjoy when I wasn't in screaming horrible pain.

Since I'd already tried to kill myself at least once and it didn't take, I've chosen the latter.

It's actually worked out really well, I wish I'd thought of it earlier.
 
That's the path, all right, from what I can see from back here way, way behind you. It's a three up, two down thing, too. We're none of us perfect.

A former lover and I had a conversation about volunteering as EMT's...how people would praise us for it. It gave us some pride to be of service to the community, to the sick and injured. But there was a lot of ego in it, too. I'm a hero! Well, you may be in a position to have an opportunity to be heroic, I suppose, but really what you are is a glorified taxi service. We did it because of the coolness factor, the adrenaline rush, as much as anything else.

And, so what? The sick and injured still got taken care of.

I'm glad with my work, it's something I'd do for charity. That's how I actually think of it - if I'm not paid enough, consider the rest and the overtime as charity.

It's medical records. Making sure someone's medical records are transcribed properly. It's hard and it's thankless. And I'm actually glad to be doing it and getting paid for it.

I've had jobs where I didn't feel...at the end of the day...that I was doing any good. Now at least I know I'm doing something beneficial in theory at least. Nobody ever meets me or knows that I'm trying to do my best on a small detail that is usually overlooked as existing at all.

It's the perfect job for the practice I'm trying to create for myself.

I guess I idealize the power of the unseen good deed, but it's working for me so far, no need to discard it just yet. I'm sure it's gonna have to go eventually, but for now...

Again, here we have this incredible lameness Stepford factor.

"Oh..that poor girl. Someone put her out of her misery."

"Shut up! I'm happy dammit!"

"Suuure you are, honey. Sure you are."
 
I think most people in CL would question what "knowing who you are" means, exactly, and precisely what benefit it would have.
I can only speak for myself on this. It means learning who I am and how I deal with things so that I can interrupt the process and have a better reaction in all areas of your life. It's dealing with fundamentally flawed thinking and recognizing that it is so. Eventually I think that's were your CL would have benefit. Once you've recognized that thinking is flawed you then correcting that thinking to something that better serves you and your life.


Sure, there are people who relapse. I just don't know that it's always "taking a drink to solve your problem." And one of the first pieces of advice given to newbs in AA is "Don't pick up." Meaning, don't engage in the behavior of drinking. Even AA, with all its focus on "Let go and let God" and "powerless to control our lives" recognizes that fundamentally, we have control over whether we put ethanol in our bloodstreams.

I'm not saying that you don't have control. I'm saying it's about the means of making sure that control stays firm and your thinking remains in line with the idea that it's bad and needs to stop. One thing that AA also recognizes is that people have to be ready to come there. They have to have hit rock bottom and achieved the realization that they have to stop or they will loose or already have lost everything.



True, they have influence, but it's influence that we choose to allow them to have. We're not controlled by our feelings any more than to the extent that we choose to be. I had a student once who insisted that his depressed roommate just could not, was not physically capable, get out of bed. I asked him what he thought would happen if I lit the bed on fire. He laughed at me, said it was absurd, but the point is valid. He had arms and legs and control of them; he was choosing to stay in bed, making a decision based on the awful feeling of deep depression. I wouldn't say it would be easy, just that it would be possible for him to get out of bed.
Great story. :D and so true

I've found that there is a realization process that 's involved seeing how much feelings do influence things, but you are essentially right.
 
I'm glad with my work, it's something I'd do for charity. That's how I actually think of it - if I'm not paid enough, consider the rest and the overtime as charity.

It's medical records. Making sure someone's medical records are transcribed properly. It's hard and it's thankless. And I'm actually glad to be doing it and getting paid for it.

I've had jobs where I didn't feel...at the end of the day...that I was doing any good. Now at least I know I'm doing something beneficial in theory at least. Nobody ever meets me or knows that I'm trying to do my best on a small detail that is usually overlooked as existing at all.

It's the perfect job for the practice I'm trying to create for myself.

I guess I idealize the power of the unseen good deed, but it's working for me so far, no need to discard it just yet. I'm sure it's gonna have to go eventually, but for now...

Again, here we have this incredible lameness Stepford factor.

"Oh..that poor girl. Someone put her out of her misery."

"Shut up! I'm happy dammit!"

"Suuure you are, honey. Sure you are."

Ahahaha...you poor thing. You're obviously delusional. No one could be happy in that situation.

I can only speak for myself on this. It means learning who I am and how I deal with things so that I can interrupt the process and have a better reaction in all areas of your life. It's dealing with fundamentally flawed thinking and recognizing that it is so. Eventually I think that's were your CL would have benefit. Once you've recognized that thinking is flawed you then correcting that thinking to something that better serves you and your life.
There are certainly exercises that help with that sort of insight, and ones that help with putting the decisions in motion.




I'm not saying that you don't have control. I'm saying it's about the means of making sure that control stays firm and your thinking remains in line with the idea that it's bad and needs to stop. One thing that AA also recognizes is that people have to be ready to come there. They have to have hit rock bottom and achieved the realization that they have to stop or they will loose or already have lost everything.
That's true. "The elevator only goes down, but you can get off any time you want."




Great story. :D and so true

I've found that there is a realization process that 's involved seeing how much feelings do influence things, but you are essentially right.

That conversation made this other woman cry.

That realization is the core of a lot of CL principles.
 
Ahahaha...you poor thing. You're obviously delusional. No one could be happy in that situation.

This is what they tell me!

Fortunately I am dense and I don't listen much, so it's not a problem.

I would make a crappy schizophrenic. "Go kill those people!" "Fuck off. Why?" "Because?" "Lame."
 
Do you really want to be happy all the time?

Look! *grin* My house is burning down. My arm is on fire. *smile* I think my cat is in there burning to death. *chuckle* I'm so happy.


Make any sense at all? Of course not. Happiness, like all other emotional states, is transitory. Rather than making a transitory and unpredictable condition a goal, why not choose things you actually can control, and that make some sort of sense?

Try writing down a goal you have. Make it measurable and achievable. Then write down the first step you have to take to achieve it.


Then take that step.
 
This is what they tell me!

Fortunately I am dense and I don't listen much, so it's not a problem.

I would make a crappy schizophrenic. "Go kill those people!" "Fuck off. Why?" "Because?" "Lame."

Comfortably numb?

My experience with schizophrenics is that they do question the voices, but the voices are pretty convincing.

Actually, you reminded me of something. Greg was, for a while, thinking about that issue, and he was having trouble deciding whether voices in someone's head were different in any practical way from other impulses. If he wanted to eat a piece of cake, went his reasoning, then how was that different from hallucinating a voice saying "Eat cake?" His wife Linda, also a CL instructor, worked at the time with mental health patients. I think she thought it was different.
 
Back
Top