Constructive Living

Comfortably numb?

My experience with schizophrenics is that they do question the voices, but the voices are pretty convincing.

Actually, you reminded me of something. Greg was, for a while, thinking about that issue, and he was having trouble deciding whether voices in someone's head were different in any practical way from other impulses. If he wanted to eat a piece of cake, went his reasoning, then how was that different from hallucinating a voice saying "Eat cake?" His wife Linda, also a CL instructor, worked at the time with mental health patients. I think she thought it was different.

I am a fan of "Most Evil" on the Investigation Discovery channel.

If you haven't watched, it's a series on the works of forensic psychiatrist Michael Stone. He analyzes criminals and their crimes according to a scale of 1 to 22.

So on his scale, if you're mentally ill and you commit an evil act, that places you somewhere on the scale, but not at 22.

22 is saved for someone like Ted Bundy who was sane and cold and malicious. Knew exactly what he was doing and just liked hurting and killing and did it for fun.

Ed Gein was mentally ill and hardly in control of his faculties, he ends up somewhere lower. Probably 16 or so.

Anyway, on this show they had a profile of a functional MRI study of schizophrenics. (I like functional MRI's in theory, but not in court...)

Through the brain activity, it looked like schizophrenics were unable to differentiate between "someone else said that" and "I said that" - a simple, basic brain process that's missing.

That makes the most sense to me.

What I've described about arguing with myself, I know that's all internal.

If I were lacking that process, I wouldn't be able to differentiate between my own thoughts and external stimuli.

I don't think that it's hearing internal voices that's the problem. It's not being able to differentiate internal from external, random thought from compulsive command.

Simple brain processes where bridges are out.

I actually love the list of evil motivations and results from 1 to 22, so I'm gonna post:

01 Those who kill in self-defense and do not show psychopathic tendencies

02 Jealous lovers who, though egocentric or immature, are not psychopathic

03 Willing companions of killers: aberrant personality — probably impulse-ridden, with antisocial traits

04 Kill in self-defense, but had been extremely provocative towards the victim

05 Traumatized, desperate people who kill abusive relatives and others (like to support a drug habit) but lack significant traits. Genuinely remorseful.

06 Impetuous, hotheaded murderers, yet without marked psychopathic features

07 Highly narcissistic, not distinctly psychopathic people with a psychotic core who kill people close to them (jealousy an underlying motive)

08 Non psychopathic people with smoldering rage who kill when rage is ignited

09 Jealous lovers with psychopathic features

10 Killers of people who were "in the way" or who killed, for example, witnesses (egocentric but not distinctly psychopathic)

11 Psychopathic killers of people "in the way"

12 Power-hungry psychopaths who killed when they were "cornered"

13 Killers with inadequate, rage-filled personalities who "snapped"

14 Ruthlessly self-centered psychopathic schemers

15 Psychopathic "cold-blooded" spree or multiple murders

16 Psychopaths committing multiple vicious acts

17 Sexually perverse serial murderers, torture-murderers (among the males, rape is the primary motive with murder to hide the evidence; Systematic torture is not a primary factor)

18 Torture-murderers with murder the primary motive

19 Psychopaths driven to terrorism, subjugation, intimidation and rape, (short of murder)

20 Torture murderers with torture as the primary motive but in psychotic personalities

21 Psychopaths preoccupied with torture in the extreme, but not known to have committed murder

22 Psychopathic torture-murderers, with torture their primary motive, sexual homicide
 
Last edited:
I am a fan of "Most Evil" on the Investigation Discovery channel.

If you haven't watched, it's a series on the works of forensic psychiatrist Michael Stone. He analyzes criminals and their crimes according to a scale of 1 to 22.

So on his scale, if you're mentally ill and you commit an evil act, that places you somewhere on the scale, but not at 22.

22 is saved for someone like Ted Bundy who was sane and cold and malicious. Knew exactly what he was doing and just liked hurting and killing and did it for fun.

Ed Gein was mentally ill and hardly in control of his faculties, he ends up somewhere lower. Probably 16 or so.

Anyway, on this show they had a profile of a functional MRI study of schizophrenics. (I like functional MRI's in theory, but not in court...)

Through the brain activity, it looked like schizophrenics were unable to differentiate between "someone else said that" and "I said that" - a simple, basic brain process that's missing.

That makes the most sense to me.

What I've described about arguing with myself, I know that's all internal.

If I were lacking that process, I wouldn't be able to differentiate between my own thoughts and external stimuli.

I don't think that it's hearing internal voices that's the problem. It's not being able to differentiate internal from external, random thought from compulsive command.

Simple brain processes where bridges are out.

I actually love the list of evil motivations and results from 1 to 22, so I'm gonna post:

01 Those who kill in self-defense and do not show psychopathic tendencies

02 Jealous lovers who, though egocentric or immature, are not psychopathic

03 Willing companions of killers: aberrant personality — probably impulse-ridden, with antisocial traits

04 Kill in self-defense, but had been extremely provocative towards the victim

05 Traumatized, desperate people who kill abusive relatives and others (like to support a drug habit) but lack significant traits. Genuinely remorseful.

06 Impetuous, hotheaded murderers, yet without marked psychopathic features

07 Highly narcissistic, not distinctly psychopathic people with a psychotic core who kill people close to them (jealousy an underlying motive)

08 Non psychopathic people with smoldering rage who kill when rage is ignited

09 Jealous lovers with psychopathic features

10 Killers of people who were "in the way" or who killed, for example, witnesses (egocentric but not distinctly psychopathic)

11 Psychopathic killers of people "in the way"

12 Power-hungry psychopaths who killed when they were "cornered"

13 Killers with inadequate, rage-filled personalities who "snapped"

14 Ruthlessly self-centered psychopathic schemers

15 Psychopathic "cold-blooded" spree or multiple murders

16 Psychopaths committing multiple vicious acts

17 Sexually perverse serial murderers, torture-murderers (among the males, rape is the primary motive with murder to hide the evidence; Systematic torture is not a primary factor)

18 Torture-murderers with murder the primary motive

19 Psychopaths driven to terrorism, subjugation, intimidation and rape, (short of murder)

20 Torture murderers with torture as the primary motive but in psychotic personalities

21 Psychopaths preoccupied with torture in the extreme, but not known to have committed murder

22 Psychopathic torture-murderers, with torture their primary motive, sexual homicide

Jeez.

In keeping with the thread, however, I feel compelled to point out that pervasive idea again: "with smoldering rage." "Rage-filled personalities." That's classic "feelings battery" thinking.
 
Jeez.

In keeping with the thread, however, I feel compelled to point out that pervasive idea again: "with smoldering rage." "Rage-filled personalities." That's classic "feelings battery" thinking.

We need a scale of Good.

1. Sorta thinks that maybe you're not so bad.

2. Isn't entirely begrudging that you're allowed to breathe

...

Layers of forgiveness. You can't be totally good if you're mentally favored, either. You end up somewhere near 14 also.

14. Vaguely deluded and not particularly observant person with favorable brain chemistry that makes them seem just slightly high and annoyingly happy all the time.
 
We need a scale of Good.

1. Sorta thinks that maybe you're not so bad.

2. Isn't entirely begrudging that you're allowed to breathe

...

Layers of forgiveness. You can't be totally good if you're mentally favored, either. You end up somewhere near 14 also.

14. Vaguely deluded and not particularly observant person with favorable brain chemistry that makes them seem just slightly high and annoyingly happy all the time.

Bwahahahaha!
 
Do you really want to be happy all the time?

Look! *grin* My house is burning down. My arm is on fire. *smile* I think my cat is in there burning to death. *chuckle* I'm so happy.


Make any sense at all? Of course not. Happiness, like all other emotional states, is transitory. Rather than making a transitory and unpredictable condition a goal, why not choose things you actually can control, and that make some sort of sense?

Try writing down a goal you have. Make it measurable and achievable. Then write down the first step you have to take to achieve it.


Then take that step.

The most popular undergraduate course at Harvard has grown into a best-selling book entitled Happy, or Happier or something like that. The main contention is that happy is not a destination. Okay, this is a bit hackneyed.
The point is, the goal should never be to be happy; a goal could be, though, to be happier. This presumes that the person with their arm on fire has at some point in their life experienced a sense of happiness.
With the house burning down (an interesting choice of example considering an anniversary approaching in 2 days), the immediate goal is not to reach happiness, there are more pressing things.
But a less immediate but certainly more pervasive goal can be to find ways to be a little bit happier at any given moment.
That fact notwithstanding
 
Ahahaha...you poor thing. You're obviously delusional. No one could be happy in that situation.

Now, is it possible that "happy" could be a state, not necessarily an emotion?

I've had a lot of shitty days in the past month or so. Even so, if someone were to ask if I'm happy, I answer without hesitation, "yes."

Sure, if my house were burning down and a reporter asked me at the scene if I were happy, I'd probably not answer affirmatively. But if happiness is the undercurrent to my life, does it matter if there are bad days?

Maybe I just have a skewed concept of it.
 
Now, is it possible that "happy" could be a state, not necessarily an emotion?

I've had a lot of shitty days in the past month or so. Even so, if someone were to ask if I'm happy, I answer without hesitation, "yes."

Sure, if my house were burning down and a reporter asked me at the scene if I were happy, I'd probably not answer affirmatively. But if happiness is the undercurrent to my life, does it matter if there are bad days?

Maybe I just have a skewed concept of it.
happy is an emotion.

contentment is a state.
 
happy is an emotion.

contentment is a state.

I thought contentment was somewhat synonymous with satisfied?

I'm pretty much perpetually happy. I do, however, want more in life, though.
 
Great Thread.

I agree with alot of your CL principles and much of what Redicva has been posting as well.
I have always felt or known that I am the only one that can effect change for myself and to do so I have to be mindful of my current behavior ( and emotions which seem to influence so much of our behavior if we let them) and then actively choose to act in a different or changed manor.
In a sense it seems that to evolve into a better person our "truer" self we need to be able to take that step above emotion and act inedpendant of it. That is not to say that we don't feel because of course we do..it is part of human nature, but not to let those feelings rule our lives and define our being.
Of course whenever I have thoughts like this I always wined up questioning things in the cyclical pattern my poor brain has always been inclined to.
Like why then do we have any feelings? what biological or evolutionary point do they really have if we are truly more at peace when we can behave in spite of them? I know I would not want to be with out them.***** would certainly not be as sweet if I never new sorrow or joy. So then of course I lean back towards thinking it is feeling that is truly the point of life...and the out the window goes all my evolving to a higher state through action concepts.

I was wondering what are some of your thoughts on feelings? What role do you feel they play in our existence and how do they fit in for instance with a theory like CL?

Also what of the basic psychological ideas of someone like skinner who felt all behavior/action was based on a reward. Is the reward feelings? What do you feel the reward is for your actions if it is not emotionally based, or do you simply refute theories like Skinner's as bunk?

I hope some off that made sense..I tend to ramble when something has really engaged my neurons.
 
I thought contentment was somewhat synonymous with satisfied?

I'm pretty much perpetually happy. I do, however, want more in life, though.

contentment, in my book, is the freedom from remaining entrenched in negative emotions, and, if you are obsessive or manic, positive ones as well.
 
contentment, in my book, is the freedom from remaining entrenched in negative emotions, and, if you are obsessive or manic, positive ones as well.

Oh, now that's pretty fucking nifty.

Thanks.
 
The most popular undergraduate course at Harvard has grown into a best-selling book entitled Happy, or Happier or something like that. The main contention is that happy is not a destination. Okay, this is a bit hackneyed.
The point is, the goal should never be to be happy; a goal could be, though, to be happier. This presumes that the person with their arm on fire has at some point in their life experienced a sense of happiness.
With the house burning down (an interesting choice of example considering an anniversary approaching in 2 days), the immediate goal is not to reach happiness, there are more pressing things.
But a less immediate but certainly more pervasive goal can be to find ways to be a little bit happier at any given moment.
That fact notwithstanding
Makes sense to me, to a point, and you and I have had this discussion. I think from a strict CL viewpoint, the goal of "being happier at any given point" would be considered outside your direct control. The practical upshot, however, would likely be exactly that.
I think, therefore I'm thinking?
Indeed. Descartes wasn't all that far off in the beginning...
Now, is it possible that "happy" could be a state, not necessarily an emotion?

I've had a lot of shitty days in the past month or so. Even so, if someone were to ask if I'm happy, I answer without hesitation, "yes."

Sure, if my house were burning down and a reporter asked me at the scene if I were happy, I'd probably not answer affirmatively. But if happiness is the undercurrent to my life, does it matter if there are bad days?

Maybe I just have a skewed concept of it.

happy is an emotion.

contentment is a state.

I thought contentment was somewhat synonymous with satisfied?

I'm pretty much perpetually happy. I do, however, want more in life, though.
I have to agree with Hester here. "Happy" to me means a specific emotion. "Content" means a lasting state, with a lot of variation, but an overall positive sort of sense. I could easily be wrong about that; it's really a discussion of how you define the words.
Great Thread.

I agree with alot of your CL principles and much of what Redicva has been posting as well.
I have always felt or known that I am the only one that can effect change for myself and to do so I have to be mindful of my current behavior ( and emotions which seem to influence so much of our behavior if we let them) and then actively choose to act in a different or changed manor.
In a sense it seems that to evolve into a better person our "truer" self we need to be able to take that step above emotion and act inedpendant of it. That is not to say that we don't feel because of course we do..it is part of human nature, but not to let those feelings rule our lives and define our being.
Of course whenever I have thoughts like this I always wined up questioning things in the cyclical pattern my poor brain has always been inclined to.
Like why then do we have any feelings? what biological or evolutionary point do they really have if we are truly more at peace when we can behave in spite of them? I know I would not want to be with out them.***** would certainly not be as sweet if I never new sorrow or joy. So then of course I lean back towards thinking it is feeling that is truly the point of life...and the out the window goes all my evolving to a higher state through action concepts.

I was wondering what are some of your thoughts on feelings? What role do you feel they play in our existence and how do they fit in for instance with a theory like CL?

Also what of the basic psychological ideas of someone like skinner who felt all behavior/action was based on a reward. Is the reward feelings? What do you feel the reward is for your actions if it is not emotionally based, or do you simply refute theories like Skinner's as bunk?

I hope some off that made sense..I tend to ramble when something has really engaged my neurons.
To answer the question in your second paragraph from a CL perspective, I'd say we have feelings to give us information. Pain is indicative that something is not right; contentment says that everything's okay right now. I, and every other CL person I know, embrace feelings as part of the richness of life.

I don't know Skinner's stuff very well at all. To answer based on what you say in your question, I'd have to say that very often we do behave in such a way as to create a feeling we desire. The reward, however, might be "I behaved in such a way as to move closer to my goals." A kind of satisfaction in what you have done in working toward a goal. It seems intuitive that humans are going to act in a way that makes them feel like they're doing something right. What CL does is give an opportunity to behave based on a more rational set of criteria. It's not necessarily better.
contentment, in my book, is the freedom from remaining entrenched in negative emotions, and, if you are obsessive or manic, positive ones as well.

Oh, now that's pretty fucking nifty.

Thanks.

I like Hester's definition. The shift of attention inherent is basic to CL theory. I would add that in order to achieve that freedom, one needs to learn on a very fundamental level the difference between feelings and behavior.
 
I like what I'm reading Perg.

I did not follow through on the cigarette thing (but still have managed to not smoke, Ok I had 3....in 2 weeks...)
maybe I should.

I also have an issue with the clear precise succint reasoning and thoughts.
My thoughts are consistently fuzzy with multiple choice options.
 
I like what I'm reading Perg.

I did not follow through on the cigarette thing (but still have managed to not smoke, Ok I had 3....in 2 weeks...)
maybe I should.

I also have an issue with the clear precise succint reasoning and thoughts.
My thoughts are consistently fuzzy with multiple choice options.

Well, fuck, 3 in 2 weeks is fucking phenomenal. Who needs some guy on a website, if you can do that on your own? Smoke 3 cigs every two weeks for the rest of your life if you want. They won't have much effect on your health.

Glad you like it. It seems sensible to me, and it was helpful.

My thoughts are like that also. That's why this shit is helpful to me. I get to decide what I want to pat attention to, what I want to work towards.
 
Also what of the basic psychological ideas of someone like skinner who felt all behavior/action was based on a reward. Is the reward feelings? What do you feel the reward is for your actions if it is not emotionally based, or do you simply refute theories like Skinner's as bunk?

I don't think that Skinner is wrong, but I don't think he's entirely right. I think his theory is incomplete and not involving the areas of reason that at least some humans are capable of developing.

I'd say that the behavior of dogs is more closely adherent to Skinner's theories. Action/reward, one for one. That works because a human is involved with the reasoning of the action and the reward. But it's not necessarily in the dog's best interest, it's just a one for one knee jerk of their brain that's in fact used against them. I've met a few dogs that would benefit from chewing off the hand that feeds them, shaking off some sweater they're forced to wear, and getting a personal identity with teeth.

In humans, drug abuse is what results from the purest form of action-reward in brain chemistry. There's no correlation to reality and in fact it's destructive. Take a drug, feel pleasure. Also completely ignore reality.

So action-reward is a brain function, but it's demonstrably not always in your best interest.

Being able to make that calculation and do unpleasant things because they're good for you, and avoid doing pleasant things because they're bad for you is part of compensating for a natural brain chemistry process that can be improved through the application of reason and observation and synthesis of a theory of better survival.

I don't think a dog is necessarily capable of making reasonable choices that defy action-reward. I think some humans are.
 
Last edited:
What an interesting read.

And as I did, two thoughts stood out. Note I'm not assigning value judgements to either one - it's more a stream of conscience thang.

One: Zen, like therapy in general, largely seems to be a selfish and introspective past time.

Two: Life's not so much what happens to us, but how we react.

I am scheduled to have a difficult and unpleasant discussion with my immediate line manager tomorrow, with her boss (and mine too, I suppose) as mediator.

While her behavior is questionable, my reactions to her provocations are also worthy of scrutiny. I shall bear that in mind.
 
What an interesting read.

And as I did, two thoughts stood out. Note I'm not assigning value judgements to either one - it's more a stream of conscience thang.

One: Zen, like therapy in general, largely seems to be a selfish and introspective past time.

Two: Life's not so much what happens to us, but how we react.

I am scheduled to have a difficult and unpleasant discussion with my immediate line manager tomorrow, with her boss (and mine too, I suppose) as mediator.

While her behavior is questionable, my reactions to her provocations are also worthy of scrutiny. I shall bear that in mind.

I think you're right that Zen can be entirely introspective and selfish. That's why there are warnings interspersed throughout the practice. Which unfortunately aren't often heard or heeded.

There are however stages. Like the oxen pictures, each stage needs the previous one to exist, and in the end you've gone full circle from being miserable with what you have to being fulfilled by what you have and using it to your best benefit.

I think of it more as weeding the garden. It looks destructive and cold, but it's in fact keeping the ground clear and setting the tone for what you want to grow.

If you overweed and no thought or action grows, it's a barren practice.

If you use the techniques to selectively create an environment where constructive thought and action can thrive, that's where I think it shines.
 
A question that Naikan doesn't bother to ask, sometimes referred to as "The Fourth Question:" "What troubles or difficulties have been caused to me?"

The guy who founded Naikan (I really should look the bastard's name up at some point) figured we spent enough time on that one already. He was seeking a kind of balance, trying to get people to focus outside themselves. Do we really need a structured exercise of some kind to realize when we've been inconvenienced or hurt?

David tells the story of a therapy session in which the client wanted to talk about a childhood experience. When he was little, his father would cross his legs and the little boy would sit on his foot like a horse, and dad would bounce him up and down. One day the boy asked to play this game, and the dad said "No, you're too big now."

The therapist wanted to focus on the feelings of rejection the boy experienced. David asked why not focus on the hundreds of times they had a pleasant and affectionate interaction? Why is one more important than the other?
 
Shinkeshitsu.

"Shinks." People or thoughts can be "shinky."

At the end of our ten day training, I gave Greg and Linda a thank you card. Greg took some time looking at the front of it, which was just the words "Thank You" in large silver print, then opened it, read it, and handed it to Linda, who asked him what he was looking at. He said he had been looking at the typeface (he'd just gotten a new printer or something). I said I had been afraid the ink had bled through the front of the card. Linda replied "Oh my God what a shinky thought!" with laughter in he eyes.

So what does it mean? Well, as usual, it's hard to translate. It's a kind of paranoia, which mostly manifests itself in whimsical fears that derive from nothing at all. Why the hell would the ink bleed through the card? I was in my late twenties or early thirties by then, and never in all that time had I seen that happen. But Greg was looking at that card so intently that I just knew something was wrong.

I see this sort of thing all the time. A friend's wife leaves a book of erotic short stories on the bedside table. He immediately thinks she's bored with him or having an affair or whatever. You walk into a room and people laugh. You immediately check your hair or to see if your fly is unzipped. It must be A) about you and B) bad.


How often have you had this sort of experience? Selfish, ain't it? Silly, too.
 
I've read too much and now my brain is tired. I shall go rest it for a while and contemplate what I have learned. Interesting stuff, Perg. And you do draw in the best debaters, don't you?
 
I've read too much and now my brain is tired. I shall go rest it for a while and contemplate what I have learned. Interesting stuff, Perg. And you do draw in the best debaters, don't you?

On occasion, I'm blessed to have the smart kids play in my yard.
 
On occasion, I'm blessed to have the smart kids play in my yard.


On returning from playing in the dirt in the backyard (with help from the orange kitten), I must say that doing stuff can be very good relaxation sometimes.
 
Back
Top