Recidiva
Harastal
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2005
- Posts
- 89,726
Comfortably numb?
My experience with schizophrenics is that they do question the voices, but the voices are pretty convincing.
Actually, you reminded me of something. Greg was, for a while, thinking about that issue, and he was having trouble deciding whether voices in someone's head were different in any practical way from other impulses. If he wanted to eat a piece of cake, went his reasoning, then how was that different from hallucinating a voice saying "Eat cake?" His wife Linda, also a CL instructor, worked at the time with mental health patients. I think she thought it was different.
I am a fan of "Most Evil" on the Investigation Discovery channel.
If you haven't watched, it's a series on the works of forensic psychiatrist Michael Stone. He analyzes criminals and their crimes according to a scale of 1 to 22.
So on his scale, if you're mentally ill and you commit an evil act, that places you somewhere on the scale, but not at 22.
22 is saved for someone like Ted Bundy who was sane and cold and malicious. Knew exactly what he was doing and just liked hurting and killing and did it for fun.
Ed Gein was mentally ill and hardly in control of his faculties, he ends up somewhere lower. Probably 16 or so.
Anyway, on this show they had a profile of a functional MRI study of schizophrenics. (I like functional MRI's in theory, but not in court...)
Through the brain activity, it looked like schizophrenics were unable to differentiate between "someone else said that" and "I said that" - a simple, basic brain process that's missing.
That makes the most sense to me.
What I've described about arguing with myself, I know that's all internal.
If I were lacking that process, I wouldn't be able to differentiate between my own thoughts and external stimuli.
I don't think that it's hearing internal voices that's the problem. It's not being able to differentiate internal from external, random thought from compulsive command.
Simple brain processes where bridges are out.
I actually love the list of evil motivations and results from 1 to 22, so I'm gonna post:
01 Those who kill in self-defense and do not show psychopathic tendencies
02 Jealous lovers who, though egocentric or immature, are not psychopathic
03 Willing companions of killers: aberrant personality — probably impulse-ridden, with antisocial traits
04 Kill in self-defense, but had been extremely provocative towards the victim
05 Traumatized, desperate people who kill abusive relatives and others (like to support a drug habit) but lack significant traits. Genuinely remorseful.
06 Impetuous, hotheaded murderers, yet without marked psychopathic features
07 Highly narcissistic, not distinctly psychopathic people with a psychotic core who kill people close to them (jealousy an underlying motive)
08 Non psychopathic people with smoldering rage who kill when rage is ignited
09 Jealous lovers with psychopathic features
10 Killers of people who were "in the way" or who killed, for example, witnesses (egocentric but not distinctly psychopathic)
11 Psychopathic killers of people "in the way"
12 Power-hungry psychopaths who killed when they were "cornered"
13 Killers with inadequate, rage-filled personalities who "snapped"
14 Ruthlessly self-centered psychopathic schemers
15 Psychopathic "cold-blooded" spree or multiple murders
16 Psychopaths committing multiple vicious acts
17 Sexually perverse serial murderers, torture-murderers (among the males, rape is the primary motive with murder to hide the evidence; Systematic torture is not a primary factor)
18 Torture-murderers with murder the primary motive
19 Psychopaths driven to terrorism, subjugation, intimidation and rape, (short of murder)
20 Torture murderers with torture as the primary motive but in psychotic personalities
21 Psychopaths preoccupied with torture in the extreme, but not known to have committed murder
22 Psychopathic torture-murderers, with torture their primary motive, sexual homicide
Last edited: