Constructive Living

A logical challenge in certain circumstances is a different thing from an attack.

Perhaps but when you started using terms like OZlike, questioning the flaws in my brain, and then implying that I was delusional I thought that was an attack.

Equal in our struggles is what I am disagreeing with. I am asking you to provide evidence or rational thought that backs up how we are equal.

The same way I ask people to explain to me how the concept of heaven, hell, karma, spirit, eternity, redemption, punishment...are practically applied in their lives.

Here is rational thought for you.
Looking at the pattern of history that stretches out over time it's very clear that humanity has developed it's cultures as an expression of who we are and the basic physical and emotional needs that we have. Without this culture it all boils down to the fact that we are all just people living and procreating on a rock we have called the Earth. That right there makes us equal. We can create all the social constructs we want but it doesn't change the fact that each of us shares blueprints for the same basic physical structure, and that we all eat, shit, sleep, and feel.

When I say being equal in our struggles I mean each of us has something in our life that causes us pain and suffering. This is part of the human condition. No one's life is completely hunky dory, and no one is spared some kind of suffering. We all have things that cause stress and pain to us. In my case I have lived for the last 15 years with a fairly serious case of Rheumatoid Arthritis. This and the ensuing treatment has caused untolled stress on my life. You on the flipside may have had any number of things happen to you that have caused you the same level of stress. The residents that I work with on a daily basis have lived their lives with various physical and mental conditions that have caused a great deal of stress on their body, minds, and hearts.

Leaving out the whole idea about reincarnation, I can conclude is that these things just are. It's something we have to accept about being human. You may argue that the crack baby suffers more than we do because of the life he/she is forced to live by circumstance, but in the end it boils down to simply that all of us suffer, all of us feel joy, all of us deal with it as best we can with the tools that we've been given by life.

As far heaven, hell, karma, spirit, eternity, redemption, punishment and applying it to our daily lives? I only speak to karma and spirit. The rest are religious concepts that have no bearing on what I believe and eternity is not a concept that I feel that I need to be concerned about on a daily basis. Buddhism gives the best definition of karma in my mind. Your actions have consequences in this world. If you choose to be mean to someone then in the end that person will most likely be mean back or someone else will on their behalf. John Watson and BF Skinner based their whole career as psychologists on the premise of cause and effect. It's been proven time and time again in laboratory studies. Karma is more than that ultimately, but in our day to day lives that's how it counts.

In terms of spirit, there are so many ways in which you can understand that word. As far as applying it to daily life I see that my spirit, my soul, as being the basic essense of me. It's there all the time and is the part of me that learns.

Ultimately I think that there's a place for patience, sense and understanding, and an equal and valid place for anger, waste and cluelessness.

I think they're all part of it, and to value patience, sense and understanding over all, is not (in my opinion and tactics) the choice I make because I don't think they're always valid.

Your talking about emotional reactions here. I see no reason as to why you or I can't feel any of those feeling in any given place, but in the end what purpose does it serve for me to remain angry at the crack babies mother for making a choice that I wouldn't choose to make? It does me and the baby no good. She did what she did and there is nothing I can do to change it. I can only help the baby who is suffering.

I don't think equality is real. I think it's a comforting thought. I try to eliminate comforting thoughts in my own practice, because if I rely on them, I start to fill in too many blanks. The human mind has evolved to recognize pattern and solve problems. Sometimes the pattern is there. Sometimes it's not and I obsess on the piece of an imaginary puzzle that if I could just get it, all things will make sense, but the puzzle itself is an imaginary construct. It's pretty, and it might even be real, but ultimately it's not useful to anything but my own ego. My forays into abnormal psychology can make myth and dogma seem too much like delusion when it's taken literally. Taken in smaller doses, it's of value. Made absolute and sure, I think it becomes a crutch.

To me lack of equality is simply a social constuct. To me for some that is the comforting thought. I can make myself feel better with the concept that because I have money and I can afford to buy so much more than others and can comfort myself with the thought that I am some how much better. In reality my life is simply different. I still have any number of other issue that I need to deal with. It just happens that money is not one of them. I can also comfort myself with the thought that some how I am better or better off because I am not handicapped, but in truth I am no better or worse than they in the sense that I have other things that I have to deal with in my life because I'm not handicapped.

As far as the puzzles of life, some times it's about the best fit for you and what you need to keep yourself sane and to make it so you can live your life. It often times doesn't have to be real for anyone else. Only you. In that it has value for your personal experience that's all that matters. As far as absolute and sure, I never said that anything about it was absolute and sure, only that this what I know and believe now. If I am presented with enough compelling evidence otherwise I could change my mind.

Patience, understanding and forgiveness for the long term, yes. I think that the key to progress isn't absolute closure or understanding, but the tactical ability to accept less than an absolute, forgive life and myself for its imperfection, and move on.

That's the point of this thread. Constructive Living. The difference between what we think and what we do, and which one is of more ultimate value to the beings around us. I discarded karma and "the big picture" because it made me feel insulated from the true horror that I see around me and that I experience. I used the idea like a drug, to give me a destiny and a focus. This is what I did, I'm not saying you're doing it. I'm pointing out how certain thoughts can lead to delusion if you rely on them too much without swapping out other thought processes that are more practical.

This is me living and being constructive in the thread spirit. The thoughts you are expressing, I've encountered in my spiritual path, and I've questioned them and challenging them as I'm questioning and challenging you. It is not personal. It's theoretical.

I certainly don't think your intentions in the beginning were not get personal but I think you did after a point when you started to question my logic and began throwing out things like the flaws in my brain and the whole OZ-like thing. Yeah I think it got personal. You're asking about how this became about my life, it's become about your life too. When one debates they speak from a perspective of their own study, reflection, and personal experience. What it boils down to on this thread is that you and are debating our life paths and each is very personal and as such emotional.

As far as Constructive Living or my version of it, the whole idea is that you are constucting your life so that it meets the needs of what you need to do to survive. I feel, however, that in order to do that I have to understand who I am and how I function. If I fail to do that then how can I construct anything that works for me? I have to answer questions about how do certain events in my life impact me and how do I deal with them so that I can move on. Some of these principles mentioned here may be useful in the day to day, but they don't solve the bigger problem. While I can use the ego boast that I get from the short term fix of having accomplished something to help me feel better, the other feelings and emotions about that other bigger thing is still there waiting to creep up on me and effecting how I function in the world. This in turn makes my life less satisfactory. I agree in the end that I have to make my own closure in life which is something I'm struggling with now.

I would like you to consider that in my own particular way, I'm not attacking, but attempting to provide an insight into a process that I worked long and hard on, and I am presenting a solution to the problem, not more problems.
Reci, can you consider that may be I am doing the same thing? In my way I'm putting out questions to you about how you view your situation. How do you or do you every deal with the bigger picture issues? Even Psychology will tell you that it has to be done. While I believe that it's important to deal with issues on a day to day level, where does your concept of Constructive Living deal with the over all big picture issues that need to get addressed for one's own sanity.

Paradoxically I believe that the key to being of true service here, is that less is more. Focusing on real problems. Hunger. Pain. Suffering. Relieving those. That's my practice. Not telling people that their hunger, pain or suffering means something. Allowing it to be just what it is, horrible and meaningless and deserving of compassion, not judgment that makes it all okay somehow.

I'm not saying that it is okay. I'm saying like you that it is what is. The difference between what you and see what that "is" is. You're philosophy seems hung up to me on how horrible and meaningless it is but yet in reality every human experience as meaning for the individual person going through it and many times for others observing. Character and understanding often deepen from having going through these things. As Nietzsche said "That which does not kill us makes us stronger". Do I want people to suffer? No. Do I think it horrible that they do? Yes. Is the fact that it happened meaningless? No. I agree though that often those things don't have to happen and what we should be focused on is how do we help the individual person and in the future anyone else.

Because people expect a BIG paycheck for all their hunger and suffering and pain. And I don't think they're going to get it, and I think that sucks.

You have to give up your paycheck for it to be service to individual, unique human beings and not service to an idea that's going to pay off like the Karmic Lottery someday.

It sounds to me like you think that this should be our right and due. That we should get what we want from all this pain and suffering. Whoever said that life owed us anything? The Karmic payoff comes through our own actions and our own struggle. We learn what we can from this experience and apply it to practical solutions. If you are hungry and suffering then you need to figure out what you're going to do about that. If someone helps you along the way you know that the best way to pay them back is to help them out in their time of need or help others in a similar situation. If you don't like it that anyone goes through that then be one of those people that helps out.
 
Perhaps but when you started using terms like OZlike, questioning the flaws in my brain, and then implying that I was delusional I thought that was an attack.

It was a joke. Withdrawn. In my defense, this is how I talk to myself. I know no other way. I think I'm funny! Clearly not.

Here is rational thought for you.
Looking at the pattern of history that stretches out over time it's very clear that humanity has developed it's cultures as an expression of who we are and the basic physical and emotional needs that we have. Without this culture it all boils down to the fact that we are all just people living and procreating on a rock we have called the Earth. That right there makes us equal. We can create all the social constructs we want but it doesn't change the fact that each of us shares blueprints for the same basic physical structure, and that we all eat, shit, sleep, and feel.

When I say being equal in our struggles I mean each of us has something in our life that causes us pain and suffering. This is part of the human condition. No one's life is completely hunky dory, and no one is spared some kind of suffering. We all have things that cause stress and pain to us. In my case I have lived for the last 15 years with a fairly serious case of Rheumatoid Arthritis. This and the ensuing treatment has caused untolled stress on my life. You on the flipside may have had any number of things happen to you that have caused you the same level of stress. The residents that I work with on a daily basis have lived their lives with various physical and mental conditions that have caused a great deal of stress on their body, minds, and hearts.

Leaving out the whole idea about reincarnation, I can conclude is that these things just are. It's something we have to accept about being human. You may argue that the crack baby suffers more than we do because of the life he/she is forced to live by circumstance, but in the end it boils down to simply that all of us suffer, all of us feel joy, all of us deal with it as best we can with the tools that we've been given by life.

As far heaven, hell, karma, spirit, eternity, redemption, punishment and applying it to our daily lives? I only speak to karma and spirit. The rest are religious concepts that have no bearing on what I believe and eternity is not a concept that I feel that I need to be concerned about on a daily basis. Buddhism gives the best definition of karma in my mind. Your actions have consequences in this world. If you choose to be mean to someone then in the end that person will most likely be mean back or someone else will on their behalf. John Watson and BF Skinner based their whole career as psychologists on the premise of cause and effect. It's been proven time and time again in laboratory studies. Karma is more than that ultimately, but in our day to day lives that's how it counts.

In terms of spirit, there are so many ways in which you can understand that word. As far as applying it to daily life I see that my spirit, my soul, as being the basic essense of me. It's there all the time and is the part of me that learns.

Okay. I hear you. I don't agree with your logic. But in this case you're presenting faith. That's what I'm saying I don't have.

I don't think that things are equal and that's where we differ. I think you're making your choices based on personal faith, and it's okay to leave it at that. It's not a question of reason then. It's something you believe that is nontransferable. It's something I tried believing that did not ring true for me, so I'm sharing my thought process. Your faith is your own, you are welcome to it and I hope it works for you in good will. It is not something that works for me.

My suggestion would be to simply say you believe in it, rather than try to provide examples, as your examples are not something that can be submitted to reason.

It's like a Christian explaining how and why Heaven is what it is. "Why?" "Because the book said so." "But people wrote the book." "No. God wrote the book." "Okay. I'm done."

There is no reasoning with faith. That's its nature.

Your talking about emotional reactions here. I see no reason as to why you or I can't feel any of those feeling in any given place, but in the end what purpose does it serve for me to remain angry at the crack babies mother for making a choice that I wouldn't choose to make? It does me and the baby no good. She did what she did and there is nothing I can do to change it. I can only help the baby who is suffering.

That's more what I'm getting at here, except I'm not proposing even being angry at the mother. I stated that "humanity is the crack baby" and that we're really mired in a poor set of tools to solve the problems we have facing us.

I'm not proposing anger at the crack baby. I'm proposing anger at and opposition to the pattern and the way things work. You're proposing faith that it will all work out somehow, and I don't believe that.

I'm proposing anger at God, essentially. Criticism and attempting to change and fix things here and now. Not acceptance of some pattern that ultimately will work itself out.

I'm angry on your behalf as well as mine, as well as the mother of the crack baby, as well as the crack baby itself.

To me lack of equality is simply a social constuct. To me for some that is the comforting thought. I can make myself feel better with the concept that because I have money and I can afford to buy so much more than others and can comfort myself with the thought that I am some how much better. In reality my life is simply different. I still have any number of other issue that I need to deal with. It just happens that money is not one of them. I can also comfort myself with the thought that some how I am better or better off because I am not handicapped, but in truth I am no better or worse than they in the sense that I have other things that I have to deal with in my life because I'm not handicapped.

As far as the puzzles of life, some times it's about the best fit for you and what you need to keep yourself sane and to make it so you can live your life. It often times doesn't have to be real for anyone else. Only you. In that it has value for your personal experience that's all that matters. As far as absolute and sure, I never said that anything about it was absolute and sure, only that this what I know and believe now. If I am presented with enough compelling evidence otherwise I could change my mind.

Cool. I'm with you here. Embracing the inequality is really what I'm looking for. Equality is fine in its theoretical place. But the essential experience of humanity is of inequality.

That's exactly what I'm saying and I'm glad you see it. Keeping yourself sane isn't a bad thing. It's a noble effort. Employing fantasy and comfort is fine when you're keeping yourself sane.

Spreading it to others so that they can be deluded with you, not so much. I'm not accusing you of doing this. I'm saying it's a weakness of general humanity.

As far as Constructive Living or my version of it, the whole idea is that you are constucting your life so that it meets the needs of what you need to do to survive. I feel, however, that in order to do that I have to understand who I am and how I function. If I fail to do that then how can I construct anything that works for me? I have to answer questions about how do certain events in my life impact me and how do I deal with them so that I can move on. Some of these principles mentioned here may be useful in the day to day, but they don't solve the bigger problem. While I can use the ego boast that I get from the short term fix of having accomplished something to help me feel better, the other feelings and emotions about that other bigger thing is still there waiting to creep up on me and effecting how I function in the world. This in turn makes my life less satisfactory. I agree in the end that I have to make my own closure in life which is something I'm struggling with now.

Reci, can you consider that may be I am doing the same thing? In my way I'm putting out questions to you about how you view your situation. How do you or do you every deal with the bigger picture issues? Even Psychology will tell you that it has to be done. While I believe that it's important to deal with issues on a day to day level, where does your concept of Constructive Living deal with the over all big picture issues that need to get addressed for one's own sanity.

I'm really not telling you that what you're doing doesn't work. I'm supplying an alternative theory for when what you're doing fails to work on a particular problem. Actually trying to demonstrate a thought tool I use, and see if it might be of use to you on what you appear to be struggling with.

I spent my early life on "bigger picture" issues. I no longer concern myself with them. This isn't giving up. This is time and resource management.

I travel to the sea, I observe the sea, I consider being part of the sea. I do not drink it. It makes you crazy.

I'm not saying that it is okay. I'm saying like you that it is what is. The difference between what you and see what that "is" is. You're philosophy seems hung up to me on how horrible and meaningless it is but yet in reality every human experience as meaning for the individual person going through it and many times for others observing. Character and understanding often deepen from having going through these things. As Nietzsche said "That which does not kill us makes us stronger". Do I want people to suffer? No. Do I think it horrible that they do? Yes. Is the fact that it happened meaningless? No. I agree though that often those things don't have to happen and what we should be focused on is how do we help the individual person and in the future anyone else.

It sounds to me like you think that this should be our right and due. That we should get what we want from all this pain and suffering. Whoever said that life owed us anything? The Karmic payoff comes through our own actions and our own struggle. We learn what we can from this experience and apply it to practical solutions. If you are hungry and suffering then you need to figure out what you're going to do about that. If someone helps you along the way you know that the best way to pay them back is to help them out in their time of need or help others in a similar situation. If you don't like it that anyone goes through that then be one of those people that helps out.

My philosophy doesn't deny how awful and horrible everything is. I don't shield myself from it.

My philosophy doesn't deny how wonderful and awesome everything is. I don't shield myself from it.

I think the two sayings "God doesn't give us something we can't handle" and "That which does not kill us only makes us stronger" are demonstrably wrong if we're talking medical and physical science. I think they're encouraging to those who are somewhat struggling with something, but they're ultimately bullshit and detrimental advice to those who have far more than they can handle, and haven't been killed, but have been maimed irreparably.

I'm proposing that you're shielding yourself from acting on ugly incomplete things by by wanting to know the answer to everything before you take exactly the right action. You end up not acting. Specifically not acting in your own best interests and always wanting to know what God or the Universe or someone else wants before you bother to ask yourself what YOU want.

I'm saying every now and then you got to say "Fuck it" to the perceived or intuited "larger plan" and do things your own way.

I say this with all the love and support I would give to someone who cooks feasts for others and is an ascetic. Why? Why do you want to give so much and take so little for yourself?

The individual is a part of the plan. The needs of the individual have to be important to the larger plan. I'm asking you directly why you honor the voice of the Universe that you believe you hear, over your own, which you can definitely hear?

I believe this to be part of the puzzle, I'm offering it. I am not particularly attached to how you think I feel about it or my intentions. They're good. It's a valid piece. Take it or don't take it, but don't act as if I'm doing it somehow to demean you. I'm trying to get you to pay attention.
 
I just discovered that book about a year ago, maybe? An easy read, and I feel the same way about reading it and forgetting it.

I need to dig it out again. I'm only half agreeable.

Perg: Good thread. Awareness is something I definitely need to work on.
Glad you're enjoying it. I'm happy to suggest exercises for you to try if you want.
HB said:
As far as Constructive Living or my version of it, the whole idea is that you are constucting your life so that it meets the needs of what you need to do to survive. I feel, however, that in order to do that I have to understand who I am and how I function. If I fail to do that then how can I construct anything that works for me? I have to answer questions about how do certain events in my life impact me and how do I deal with them so that I can move on. Some of these principles mentioned here may be useful in the day to day, but they don't solve the bigger problem. While I can use the ego boast that I get from the short term fix of having accomplished something to help me feel better, the other feelings and emotions about that other bigger thing is still there waiting to creep up on me and effecting how I function in the world. This in turn makes my life less satisfactory. I agree in the end that I have to make my own closure in life which is something I'm struggling with now.

I'm not sure that David would agree with your definition of what CL is. I think his answer would be that CL is a set of tools that allow you to be better at whatever you decide to do. That's the beauty of it; CL could make you a better priest or nun or nurse or social worker, or a better assassin of democratically elected leaders of sovereign states. The reflection piece tends to lead people to be more in line with most systems of ethics, but it doesn't have to.

David is funny talking about counseling and such stuff. He has a Ph.D in clinical psych, and has practiced. He say that he never did anything with a client that a good friend with no psych training couldn't do. He laughs when people talk about wanting to like their jobs. "You think I like my job? I get paid to listen to people whine all day." Sounds a bit like Dennis Leary's stfu therapy sometimes.

Here's another thing he says that people often have strong reactions to. He says there's no such thing as the disease of alcoholism. He points out that if it's a disease, it's the only one that can be cured by not "doing this" and then pantomimes taking a drink. He doesn't to my knowledge deny that changes in brain chemistry occur, and that there can be very powerful cravings and such stuff as DT's. He's not an idiot who doesn't believe in science.

Sometimes CL sounds really cold and asympathetic, but it turns out somehow that people who practice it seriously are some of the warmest, kindest, most thoughtful and supportive folks I've ever met.
 
Morita's primary insight can be summed up as follows: No matter how you feel, you can still act. This is one of those controversial ideas. We are trained almost from birth in the West to believe that feelings drive behavior. Morita disagreed, and he had ample personal evidence of this. We all do; we've all had times when we felt one way an acted another. Been really pissed but spoke calmly and politely. Really didn't want to get out of bed and did anyway. There's a series of three statements from Morita which are the complement to the Naikan ones, below:

Accept your feelings.

Know your purpose.

Do what needs to be done.
True, but most people don't want to act based on reason or thought, they want to act based on emotion (feelings) - it is just easier for them. The problem isn't so much acknowledgment of this fact (although it is a real problem), it is that people are lazy.

Moreover, those in power (whether the government, media or business) very strongly want people to act on emotion and not rational thought. That is how they acquire and maintain their power - whether it be the power of a government position, the power of selling the news/entertainment, or the power of selling you mouthwash through the fear of bad breath. It is all based on emotion.
 
True, but most people don't want to act based on reason or thought, they want to act based on emotion (feelings) - it is just easier for them. The problem isn't so much acknowledgment of this fact (although it is a real problem), it is that people are lazy.

Moreover, those in power (whether the government, media or business) very strongly want people to act on emotion and not rational thought. That is how they acquire and maintain their power - whether it be the power of a government position, the power of selling the news/entertainment, or the power of selling you mouthwash through the fear of bad breath. It is all based on emotion.

I'm not sure it's always easier, but I think it's often more comfortable.

The other sort of paradox that arises is how the hell can you know what you want? What we desire often arises from the irrational.
 
...can I have both?

I'd hate to make one feel bad by not picking them.

Sure. Since it's mother's day, try the mom-naikan exercise I described on the first page. Maybe an hour, if you can spare it. First ten years of your life.

Let's see...you might find this one interesting. Choose a drawer in your house, take everything out of it, clean the stuff, clean the drawer, decide what belongs there, and put everything away neatly.
 
Sure. Since it's mother's day, try the mom-naikan exercise I described on the first page. Maybe an hour, if you can spare it. First ten years of your life.

Let's see...you might find this one interesting. Choose a drawer in your house, take everything out of it, clean the stuff, clean the drawer, decide what belongs there, and put everything away neatly.

Okay. I can't find anything named mom-naikan exactly: This one?

Every evening for twenty minutes or so, reflect on your day by making three columns on a sheet of paper. One is entitled "What have I given?" In this column, write down every specific, concrete, measurable thing you gave. A hug, money, a ride, a smile, a cigarette, your time and energy (ie, I helped Batchy with her garden for one hour), etc. Things not to include: anything not measurable or not concrete. "I loved my wife all day." (unless, I suppose, you actually fucked her all day)

Second column: "What have I received?" Same rules apply. "Perg helped me with the garden for an hour."

Third column: "What troubles or difficulties have I caused?" Same rules. "I cut off someone in traffic." "I called for service on my refrigerator." Yep, I know, it's their job, but you're still causing the person to work, right?

Also, the drawer thing might not help. This year I've cleaned out every single drawer of my own possessions or community possessions.

So everything's clean. Even the "junk" drawer, now in organized containers.

Should I do a drawer of my son or my daughter? That's the only stuff not clean and in order.

Or do I recall my "junk drawer" experience?

Every meaningful act I need to do in a day is on a list - by day - down to "check mail" or "pay bills" or "work 10 hours" "do the dishes" "gardening" "help son with homework"

Every day I make a list and do all those things.

They're what I think absolutely has to be done. When I'm done with them, I'm done with my day. I relax.
 
Action list for today:

Gardening - front yard
cook a starch or a dessert
do the dishes
Help my son with his list (that includes his homework, chore, bath, cleaning room, etc. for him)
Clean the garage
Pay the bills
do the laundry
water plants
put trash by the curb
check phone messages
exercise 30 minutes
Read my son a book
Work 10 hours
 
Actions I take that are not listed because they're habit:

Three meals a day, about 450 calories apiece composed of a protein/grain/fruit and vegetable. 450 calories free to do what I wanna do with. Eat at about 6 am, noon and 6 pm.
Take vitamins/medications on time.
Wake up on time and get to work on time and go to bed on time.
Bathe/get dressed

That's stuff I have to do every day just to exist as a healthy human being.

The "list" is stuff I do for others or only on a few days a week.
 
Reci, I think you're closer to the ideal than I am. I mentioned the mom exercise in passing and didn't really describe it. You take the three questions and answer them for the first ten years of your life, specific to your relationship with your mom. What did you give her, what did she give you, what troubles or difficulties did you cause her? A variant is to calculate the amount of money she spent on you, or to calculate the number of times she changed your diapers, or the number of meals she made for you. You can also calculate the amount you spent on her, and the number of meals you made for her. Or both. It's easy to see that Naikan was originally created by a Buddhist accountant.

Okay, a different action exercise then. How about an attention one? Try to be completely trackless for the next three hours. Leave every room that you enter exactly as it was when you entered it (obviously, if you enter with the idea of cleaning the place, this doesn't make any sense). If that doesn't fit with your day especially well, then try performing a task in complete silence. No incidental noises, no talking, no sounds of footsteps, etc. Cleaning the garage and watering plants would both be excellent challenges. Remember that it's a learning exercise, intended to focus your attention, not a test of your worth as a human being. If you make a sound, get back on the horse and pay closer attention, don't judge yourself a failure. That's really important.
 
I'm not sure it's always easier, but I think it's often more comfortable.

The other sort of paradox that arises is how the hell can you know what you want? What we desire often arises from the irrational.

Most of the time it is easier because it doesn't require rational thought; we just go with what we feel. Rational thought is actually hard, and I don't mean metaphysically; science has shown that rational/logical thought require concentration and energy - it is fatiguing. Just going with emotion is orders of magnitude easier - rational thought requires practice and effort.

As for purpose/objectives, yes desire comes from the irrational, but with thought we can determine what we want and whether it is good for us and other people. If someone does me harm and I want revenge, then if I think about it rationally I can recognize that as an emotion that usually isn't good for me and override it - since it isn't good for me then it conflicts with my emotional desire to be happy and content. I recognize the better emotion and choose it over the bad emotion. I am usually not completely successful in overriding the bad, but I am usually successful enough to not let the bad emotion be detrimental.

I am not saying people need to go around being stoic automatons like Spock on Star Trek, but rather that they don't let their emotions drive their actions - emotions should help use with our objectives, but our capacity for rational thought should be used to govern our actions and thoughts.
 
Most of the time it is easier because it doesn't require rational thought; we just go with what we feel. Rational thought is actually hard, and I don't mean metaphysically; science has shown that rational/logical thought require concentration and energy - it is fatiguing. Just going with emotion is orders of magnitude easier - rational thought requires practice and effort.

As for purpose/objectives, yes desire comes from the irrational, but with thought we can determine what we want and whether it is good for us and other people. If someone does me harm and I want revenge, then if I think about it rationally I can recognize that as an emotion that usually isn't good for me and override it - since it isn't good for me then it conflicts with my emotional desire to be happy and content. I recognize the better emotion and choose it over the bad emotion. I am usually not completely successful in overriding the bad, but I am usually successful enough to not let the bad emotion be detrimental.

I am not saying people need to go around being stoic automatons like Spock on Star Trek, but rather that they don't let their emotions drive their actions - emotions should help use with our objectives, but our capacity for rational thought should be used to govern our actions and thoughts.

No argument here from me, especially in the context of a thread on CL. Your last paragraph is fairly dogma to CL folks. "Feelings give us good information, but they don't tell us everything." ~David Reynolds

What's interesting is that people sometimes react to CL theory by saying it's disrespectful of feelings. Many CL folks would say that it's more respectful of them, because CL almost never sets out with a purpose of changing feelings, manipulating them. That happens, but it's seen as a sort of side benefit.
 
Reci, I think you're closer to the ideal than I am. I mentioned the mom exercise in passing and didn't really describe it. You take the three questions and answer them for the first ten years of your life, specific to your relationship with your mom. What did you give her, what did she give you, what troubles or difficulties did you cause her? A variant is to calculate the amount of money she spent on you, or to calculate the number of times she changed your diapers, or the number of meals she made for you. You can also calculate the amount you spent on her, and the number of meals you made for her. Or both. It's easy to see that Naikan was originally created by a Buddhist accountant.

Okay, a different action exercise then. How about an attention one? Try to be completely trackless for the next three hours. Leave every room that you enter exactly as it was when you entered it (obviously, if you enter with the idea of cleaning the place, this doesn't make any sense). If that doesn't fit with your day especially well, then try performing a task in complete silence. No incidental noises, no talking, no sounds of footsteps, etc. Cleaning the garage and watering plants would both be excellent challenges. Remember that it's a learning exercise, intended to focus your attention, not a test of your worth as a human being. If you make a sound, get back on the horse and pay closer attention, don't judge yourself a failure. That's really important.

I am aware of the principles because you're describing how I live my life. No thought wasted. No harm done, or if harm is done, minimized to the best of my ability. I'm not going to live in a grass hut, but I'm not going to drive an SUV. Somewhere practical, in the middle, tailored to a minimum of waste and a maximum of utility.

I don't have any hidden vices, I don't drink, smoke, take drugs, violate my marriage vows or plot harm to others. I work at home and care for my kids. I may actually still be doing harm (take my conversation with HornyBabe, I might have to consider her as someone I harmed today because of harsh speech, and take that into account in the next time I speak to her, and put it into perspective with the way I think or speak in general. Maybe I harmed you by diluting your message and hijacking your thread? I'll try to take the hints and get it right one way or the other.) My main vice is harsh language, which I'm keeping because it's fun and I like to talk to people like me. It's my main indulgence in the seven deadly sins because otherwise I don't imbibe. That's mostly seen on Lit. Otherwise it's just me being obnoxious and laughing inside my own head, which is fun enough in itself.

I have every ability to be a perfect servant to every other human being, completely understand them and do everything their way. I don't bother sometimes as I wish to retain my humanity and have some of my own opinions. That's my concession to fun and character and not being an automaton. I still like TV and movies and pop culture, though I tend to watch cooking shows and the Discovery channel. I like learning things.

I do not watch or read the news. But I get it from my husband one way or the other.

I'm vaguely disappointed we just ordered a bottle of Absinthe and I didn't like it. I'm not goth enough, dammit.

The main conflict I have with living this way is that while I'm healthy and happy, I have absolutely nothing in common with anybody else unless they're living in a monastery. I try to do my best and not complain and that can make me appear Stepford or somehow abused by my husband? Who couldn't care less if I did any of this by the way, but he likes the cooking and the clean. So do I. Which is why I keep doing it.

I have to say that my head is often very quiet (believe it or not.)

I've progressed from chatter in my head to doing what needs to be done, as I noticed the chatter was distracting from my ability to pay attention in the moment.

My experience with being in pain with migraines taught me that the best thing to do often is shut the hell up and just breathe. It's useful.

I adore silence and focus on action. In my head that's often what I get because I've worked hard in a lifetime to have nothing in particular to chatter about except how to execute the next thing that needs to be done. Which I don't think about while I'm doing something else. If I think about the mail while I'm taking care of the plants, I might miss that there's a dead leaf or a spider making a web or a wet spot on the floor if I'm unconscious about what I'm doing.

That's the main drawback to living an ideal and attempting to embody it. There's not so much company in the real world. Oh well!

The main beautiful thing about composing lists is that I can adjust them, they change, my needs change, and I can be aware of that change and in control of it.

I could keep it all in my head, but then my head's crowded and it's easier to put it on paper.

The exercises sound great. Sounds right up my alley and I am accustomed to doing good things in silence and not thinking about them.

I'll think about my mom tonight when I have some free time to just sit and be quiet, which I do for several hours a night. I close the door, turn on a fan (white noise) and just watch TV, meditate, or read a book. I'll add an extra step tonight.
 
Feelings are for feeling.


There's a prevalent Western notion that when we have a strong feeling, we need to do something about it. We don't. We can just feel the feeling, and do something with a more reasoned purpose.

There's another one, that we did something because we had a particular feeling.

"Why did you hit him?"

"Because I was pissed at him."

Well, no. You hit him because you made a decision to hit him. You may have made that decision based on your feelings, but there's not a direct causative relationship there.

"I was really angry, so I hit him."

Again, no. You were really angry and you hit him. Behavior and feelings are separate things.

Interestingly, when I was leaning about CL and working with emotionally disturbed kids, the kids picked this stuff up quickly. The slowest group to get it was the therapists. Their training in classical psychosocial models had them wired to believe in the link to feelings. It was the focus of much of their therapeutic interventions and sessions.

"How were you feeling when you hit him?"

The kids liked it better that we would say stuff like, "I understand that you were really angry, and I think I might have felt that way also. The consequences for hitting someone in this program are the following."

Made sense to them.

"Look, Andre, I know you're really sad that your mom can't come see you this weekend. It makes me feel sad, too. Let's make your bed, because we still have to get that done before breakfast."
 
I am aware of the principles because you're describing how I live my life. No thought wasted. No harm done, or if harm is done, minimized to the best of my ability. I'm not going to live in a grass hut, but I'm not going to drive an SUV. Somewhere practical, in the middle, tailored to a minimum of waste and a maximum of utility.

I don't have any hidden vices, I don't drink, smoke, take drugs, violate my marriage vows or plot harm to others. I work at home and care for my kids. I may actually still be doing harm (take my conversation with HornyBabe, I might have to consider her as someone I harmed today because of harsh speech, and take that into account in the next time I speak to her, and put it into perspective with the way I think or speak in general. Maybe I harmed you by diluting your message and hijacking your thread? I'll try to take the hints and get it right one way or the other.) My main vice is harsh language, which I'm keeping because it's fun and I like to talk to people like me. It's my main indulgence in the seven deadly sins because otherwise I don't imbibe. That's mostly seen on Lit. Otherwise it's just me being obnoxious and laughing inside my own head, which is fun enough in itself.

I have every ability to be a perfect servant to every other human being, completely understand them and do everything their way. I don't bother sometimes as I wish to retain my humanity and have some of my own opinions. That's my concession to fun and character and not being an automaton. I still like TV and movies and pop culture, though I tend to watch cooking shows and the Discovery channel. I like learning things.

I do not watch or read the news. But I get it from my husband one way or the other.

I'm vaguely disappointed we just ordered a bottle of Absinthe and I didn't like it. I'm not goth enough, dammit.

The main conflict I have with living this way is that while I'm healthy and happy, I have absolutely nothing in common with anybody else unless they're living in a monastery. I try to do my best and not complain and that can make me appear Stepford or somehow abused by my husband? Who couldn't care less if I did any of this by the way, but he likes the cooking and the clean. So do I. Which is why I keep doing it.

I have to say that my head is often very quiet (believe it or not.)

I've progressed from chatter in my head to doing what needs to be done, as I noticed the chatter was distracting from my ability to pay attention in the moment.

My experience with being in pain with migraines taught me that the best thing to do often is shut the hell up and just breathe. It's useful.

I adore silence and focus on action. In my head that's often what I get because I've worked hard in a lifetime to have nothing in particular to chatter about except how to execute the next thing that needs to be done. Which I don't think about while I'm doing something else. If I think about the mail while I'm taking care of the plants, I might miss that there's a dead leaf or a spider making a web or a wet spot on the floor if I'm unconscious about what I'm doing.

That's the main drawback to living an ideal and attempting to embody it. There's not so much company in the real world. Oh well!

The main beautiful thing about composing lists is that I can adjust them, they change, my needs change, and I can be aware of that change and in control of it.

I could keep it all in my head, but then my head's crowded and it's easier to put it on paper.

The exercises sound great. Sounds right up my alley and I am accustomed to doing good things in silence and not thinking about them.

I'll think about my mom tonight when I have some free time to just sit and be quiet, which I do for several hours a night. I close the door, turn on a fan (white noise) and just watch TV, meditate, or read a book. I'll add an extra step tonight.

You're a model of CL thinking. Seriously, what you describe here is a human being who's practicing practically textbook CL. It doesn't surprise me that you're like that; what's surprising is the extent to which your habits match the theory. I've had brief periods where I was that way. They are among the most successful and ...what's the word...serene times of my life. I started this thread in part as a way of reminding myself of some of those principles. I find that I need some external structure to do really well, or at least that it's easier. I succeed in the military for that reason.

I hear you on the "nothing in common." Sometimes people I met who were way into CL seemed like freaks to me. Like monks, exactly, except they weren't in monasteries. They made me uncomfortable. Then once I was practicing aggressively, I felt a little distant from everyone, like they didn't get it. Drove atmas nuts for years. Probably contributed to my divorce from my first wife. Made people look at me funny. I toned it down a bit, probably as much from laziness as anything, and I felt less isolated.
 
Feelings are for feeling.

Tie in again to Charlotte Joko Beck and to the "do not take things personally" tenet from the Four Agreements. Here's one of my favorite Dharma talks from Charlotte. Enough so that one of my shorthand things to calm myself down is "it's all an empty rowboat."

The Empty Rowboat

You've been saving all your extra money for a long, long time and you've just bought yourself a brand-new boat. it's a little rowboat; shiny and clean, not a scratch on it, not a speck of dirt to mar its beautifully-painted surface, no algae, no rust on the locks, not even a grain of sand inside it. it's never been in the water. it's immaculate. pristine. you're very proud of it.

The next morning, you get up before the sun and head out to your favorite lake; you can't wait to try your new rowboat. as you reach the launch and start to back the boat trailer into the water, the sun is just starting to color the sky over the eastern shore of the lake. you put your boat gently into the water, park your car, and head back to the launch. the air is perfectly still; there's not a sound except for your deck shoes crunching in the gravel and the distant call of a water bird somewhere off in the distance. you feel totally at peace. at one with nature. everything's right in your world. you smile.

The lake is covered with a thick mist that hangs just above the surface of the water; you think you've never seen anything quite so beautiful... you walk out on the dock to where your pride and joy is tethered and you step in, then reach back, untie the lines, pull in the bumpers, and push off. as you drift away from shore, the mist envelopes you, and you feel as though you could be the only person on the face of the earth. you set the oars into their locks, and you start to pull.

You fall into a rhythm, and continue to row steadily until you're well out onto the lake, then you decide to simply let the boat drift where it will and just sit back and enjoy the peace and quiet. the only sound now is the almost inaudible sound of the water gently lapping at the sides of your boat, and with the thick mist surrounding you, you feel almost as though you're floating in a cloud... you can't imagine feeling more peaceful than you do right at this moment...

When suddenly, through the mist just ahead, you see an old, weather-beaten rowboat heading straight at you! you think, "what's wrong with this idiot?! he's going to run right into me!" you can't believe this! you've only had your new boat for a few hours, and already, some inconsiderate ass is trying to wreck it on you! you shout, "hey! what the hell's wrong with you?!?! watch where you're going!!!" you're so mad! your fists are clenched, you're actually shaking with rage, and you can't wait until this jerk gets close enough to where you can reach him so you can punch him in the nose!

Then you see that the other rowboat is empty. you take one of your oars and you push the old, weather-beaten derelict away from your shiny new rowboat, and it continues to drift past you without touching you at all.

In that moment, when you realized that the other rowboat was empty, what happened to your anger? Where did it go?

Realize that life is an empty rowboat: life is not "out to get you", it doesn't want to hurt you, or make you feel sad, or angry, or anything at all; life has no intention. it just is. if you're feeling angry, or sad, or afraid, or even if you're feeling happy, or at peace, or full of love, it's not because life is "making" you feel that way; it's because that's how you're choosing to feel about life in this moment.
 
Okay. I hear you. I don't agree with your logic. But in this case you're presenting faith. That's what I'm saying I don't have.

My suggestion would be to simply say you believe in it, rather than try to provide examples, as your examples are not something that can be submitted to reason.

Interesting, everything that I was suggesting in the part that you quoted was based on observation and study of human nature. I even threw in Skinner and Watson to make a point. What was said was not about faith it was about observable facts and events in human nature. Cause and effect is a basic scientific principle.


That's more what I'm getting at here, except I'm not proposing even being angry at the mother. I stated that "humanity is the crack baby" and that we're really mired in a poor set of tools to solve the problems we have facing us.

I'm not proposing anger at the crack baby. I'm proposing anger at and opposition to the pattern and the way things work. You're proposing faith that it will all work out somehow, and I don't believe that.

Actually if you think that then you've missed my point entirely. I'm not proposing that at all, what I am proposing is that we ourselves are the agent of change and only we can solve the problem. In fact the very last thing in that passage was "She did what she did and there is nothing I can do to change it. I can only help the baby who is suffering"

I also don't believe that we are given a poor set of tools. I think we are given some very good ones. We simply choose not to see that they are there for whatever reason. Some of us like wallowing in pity and not taking action. The tools and keys are there. It's up to us to find them.



I travel to the sea, I observe the sea, I consider being part of the sea. I do not drink it. It makes you crazy.

And what I'm proposing, what Psychology as a science proposes, is looking at the bigger picture issues doesn't have to make you crazy. It can make you clear and strong.



I think the two sayings "God doesn't give us something we can't handle" and "That which does not kill us only makes us stronger" are demonstrably wrong if we're talking medical and physical science. I think they're encouraging to those who are somewhat struggling with something, but they're ultimately bullshit and detrimental advice to those who have far more than they can handle, and haven't been killed, but have been maimed irreparably.

Actually I see what your saying as being insulting to the people how have survived serious physical illness and gone on to live and live well because they worked their way through it and realised what resources they did have within themselves. What your doing is flouting against established psychological principles that have been around for decades by saying this. You also are ignoring tons of statistical data showing that having a positive attitude about your life (which is essentially about having faith in yourself) can create a more postive experience and can be beneficial to your physical health.

I'm proposing that you're shielding yourself from acting on ugly incomplete things by by wanting to know the answer to everything before you take exactly the right action. You end up not acting. Specifically not acting in your own best interests and always wanting to know what God or the Universe or someone else wants before you bother to ask yourself what YOU want.

Nope sorry not at all what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that I have to be the one to take action. I have to think about myself, my life, and what I want to do. I can seek advice and support from others, but in the end what happens is up to me.

I say this with all the love and support I would give to someone who cooks feasts for others and is an ascetic. Why? Why do you want to give so much and take so little for yourself?
Having this philosophy that I have is not about giving to others it's about giving to myself because I know that giving to myself is what I need to do more of. Largely because the only person that really cares about me in the end is me. I can have a partner in this lifetime, but ultimately he's not the one sitting up at three am soul searching about me, I am.


The individual is a part of the plan. The needs of the individual have to be important to the larger plan. I'm asking you directly why you honor the voice of the Universe that you believe you hear, over your own, which you can definitely hear?

That's the point Reci. I don't honor it over my own. It's support that's offered out there nothing more nothing less. I can take it or leave it. It is simply another opnion in the processes of solving the puzzle that only I can solve for myself.
 
You're a model of CL thinking. Seriously, what you describe here is a human being who's practicing practically textbook CL. It doesn't surprise me that you're like that; what's surprising is the extent to which your habits match the theory. I've had brief periods where I was that way. They are among the most successful and ...what's the word...serene times of my life. I started this thread in part as a way of reminding myself of some of those principles. I find that I need some external structure to do really well, or at least that it's easier. I succeed in the military for that reason.

I hear you on the "nothing in common." Sometimes people I met who were way into CL seemed like freaks to me. Like monks, exactly, except they weren't in monasteries. They made me uncomfortable. Then once I was practicing aggressively, I felt a little distant from everyone, like they didn't get it. Drove atmas nuts for years. Probably contributed to my divorce from my first wife. Made people look at me funny. I toned it down a bit, probably as much from laziness as anything, and I felt less isolated.

I've compromised that I speak human, but I don't think or live human.

I'm bilingual?

The hardest part between making the transition back from "being perfect and doing everything" is why it's easier to be "enlightened" on a mountain top but difficult in the world (which is why I chose to do it because I consider myself up to a challenge)

Then the work comes in just taking care of people and letting them be whiny little bitches about it and that's okay. There's a whole compassion thing that comes with it. Yes! There's a whiny little bitch epiphany. Actually Thaddeus Golas said it best when he said (paraphrase, he's not well known, I can't copy and paste): "The hardest spiritual teaching is to allow others to make mistakes and be stupid. Fortunately the opportunity to learn this lesson is presented to us often every day."

The test of tolerance is your tolerance of intolerance? I'm still getting it, but I'm better at it than I used to be (Lit helps with this)

Overcoming my resentment of being "the only one" doing good things was something I had to seriously overcome. I used to belong to lots of communities that were more ethereal...but living in the real world like a real person and making it work has been a goal of mine. Not being isolated or cut off. I am in the world and of it, when mostly I just wanted to get the hell out of it, but thought that was cheating. I've assimilated.

Granted, I have no friends I get along with in real life (except Ulaven, who somehow loves me despite the weird)

...but YOU people I like!

Well..some of you.

The Internet is my window to the world, otherwise I smile and nod and realize how people like to complain about drama, but they don't like to be responsible for it or fix it. And many people who seek teachers and methods are really only seeking someone to be their mommy or daddy.

Then there's the whole phase of just thinking "Am I being perfect because I'm just boring and lame and don't have anything else interesting to do, like a coke habit?"

Spiritual progress is interesting. Not saying it's easy or fun, but it's interesting.
 
I'm not sure that David would agree with your definition of what CL is. I think his answer would be that CL is a set of tools that allow you to be better at whatever you decide to do. That's the beauty of it; CL could make you a better priest or nun or nurse or social worker, or a better assassin of democratically elected leaders of sovereign states. The reflection piece tends to lead people to be more in line with most systems of ethics, but it doesn't have to.
In all honesty I wasn't really talking about The CL philosophy simply an idea of what the words mean to me.
It goes back to my question then of how can you practice these principles if your don't know yourself well enough to implement them. I can certainly agree that applying the philosophy can help you do better in your life, but I don't feel that it's the be all and end all of having a better life.


Here's another thing he says that people often have strong reactions to. He says there's no such thing as the disease of alcoholism. He points out that if it's a disease, it's the only one that can be cured by not "doing this" and then pantomimes taking a drink. He doesn't to my knowledge deny that changes in brain chemistry occur, and that there can be very powerful cravings and such stuff as DT's. He's not an idiot who doesn't believe in science.

I actually agree with him on this. I see alcoholism as not a disease, but as a choice that one makes because our bodies make it a very easy one. The goal is to stop taking the drink, but the road leading up to finding out why you do it is the where the tough part comes in. It's made doubly so by how are bodies are effected by it.

Sometimes CL sounds really cold and asympathetic, but it turns out somehow that people who practice it seriously are some of the warmest, kindest, most thoughtful and supportive folks I've ever met.

I would bet they are. It sounds like the goal here is to improve your life and to make things more positive. To be able to do that you have to have the attitude that you can do this and not be afraid to look at yourself and your habits.
 
Tie in again to Charlotte Joko Beck and to the "do not take things personally" tenet from the Four Agreements. Here's one of my favorite Dharma talks from Charlotte. Enough so that one of my shorthand things to calm myself down is "it's all an empty rowboat."

The Empty Rowboat

You've been saving all your extra money for a long, long time and you've just bought yourself a brand-new boat. it's a little rowboat; shiny and clean, not a scratch on it, not a speck of dirt to mar its beautifully-painted surface, no algae, no rust on the locks, not even a grain of sand inside it. it's never been in the water. it's immaculate. pristine. you're very proud of it.

The next morning, you get up before the sun and head out to your favorite lake; you can't wait to try your new rowboat. as you reach the launch and start to back the boat trailer into the water, the sun is just starting to color the sky over the eastern shore of the lake. you put your boat gently into the water, park your car, and head back to the launch. the air is perfectly still; there's not a sound except for your deck shoes crunching in the gravel and the distant call of a water bird somewhere off in the distance. you feel totally at peace. at one with nature. everything's right in your world. you smile.

The lake is covered with a thick mist that hangs just above the surface of the water; you think you've never seen anything quite so beautiful... you walk out on the dock to where your pride and joy is tethered and you step in, then reach back, untie the lines, pull in the bumpers, and push off. as you drift away from shore, the mist envelopes you, and you feel as though you could be the only person on the face of the earth. you set the oars into their locks, and you start to pull.

You fall into a rhythm, and continue to row steadily until you're well out onto the lake, then you decide to simply let the boat drift where it will and just sit back and enjoy the peace and quiet. the only sound now is the almost inaudible sound of the water gently lapping at the sides of your boat, and with the thick mist surrounding you, you feel almost as though you're floating in a cloud... you can't imagine feeling more peaceful than you do right at this moment...

When suddenly, through the mist just ahead, you see an old, weather-beaten rowboat heading straight at you! you think, "what's wrong with this idiot?! he's going to run right into me!" you can't believe this! you've only had your new boat for a few hours, and already, some inconsiderate ass is trying to wreck it on you! you shout, "hey! what the hell's wrong with you?!?! watch where you're going!!!" you're so mad! your fists are clenched, you're actually shaking with rage, and you can't wait until this jerk gets close enough to where you can reach him so you can punch him in the nose!

Then you see that the other rowboat is empty. you take one of your oars and you push the old, weather-beaten derelict away from your shiny new rowboat, and it continues to drift past you without touching you at all.

In that moment, when you realized that the other rowboat was empty, what happened to your anger? Where did it go?

Realize that life is an empty rowboat: life is not "out to get you", it doesn't want to hurt you, or make you feel sad, or angry, or anything at all; life has no intention. it just is. if you're feeling angry, or sad, or afraid, or even if you're feeling happy, or at peace, or full of love, it's not because life is "making" you feel that way; it's because that's how you're choosing to feel about life in this moment.

This is lovely. It's a lot like something atmas was saying a few months ago about being angry in traffic.

The two passages I bolded are an interesting contrast. In the context of CL theory, the first is a common sort of question. I'll address it, sort of, in another post.

The second sort of disagrees with CL theory, in that I doubt anyone in CL would say that we can choose to feel a certain way. We certainly can, however, choose the context in which we view the world, and that can influence feelings in a powerful way, which is really the larger point of the fable anyway. Fables are another favorite tool of CL.
 
You are not a battery.


There's an extremely pervasive and prevalent idea that we store feelings. All that anger gets bottled up in some sort of storage tank, and when you add too much, it just explodes out.


Bunk.

It doesn't jive with human experience. There are lots of intense feelings we experience that don't act that way. If anger can, why not fear? Why not love?

Feelings fade over time unless they get restimulated somehow.

Think of a tragedy. A pet or a loved one died. A relationship ended. Are your feelings about it as intense today as they were when you lay on the couch crying? Of course not. Do you still feel sad? Possibly, though I find that with enough time, I don't. I no longer feel especially sad about Smaug, the cat I grew up with, who was torn to pieces by the neighborhood dogs. I was a wreck at the time.

Sure, you got really irritated at that bureaucrat. That feeling isn't stored in you somewhere. It's just that the next time you have to deal with him, he's irritating again, and you're really focused on that feeling.

Besides, we like anger. It's powerful. We indulge it as an excuse to take power in some way. We use it as a threat; "Don't piss me off!"

Feelings can't hurt you. Behavior can.
 
I've compromised that I speak human, but I don't think or live human.

I'm bilingual?

The hardest part between making the transition back from "being perfect and doing everything" is why it's easier to be "enlightened" on a mountain top but difficult in the world (which is why I chose to do it because I consider myself up to a challenge)

Then the work comes in just taking care of people and letting them be whiny little bitches about it and that's okay. There's a whole compassion thing that comes with it. Yes! There's a whiny little bitch epiphany. Actually Thaddeus Golas said it best when he said (paraphrase, he's not well known, I can't copy and paste): "The hardest spiritual teaching is to allow others to make mistakes and be stupid. Fortunately the opportunity to learn this lesson is presented to us often every day."

The test of tolerance is your tolerance of intolerance? I'm still getting it, but I'm better at it than I used to be (Lit helps with this)

Overcoming my resentment of being "the only one" doing good things was something I had to seriously overcome. I used to belong to lots of communities that were more ethereal...but living in the real world like a real person and making it work has been a goal of mine. Not being isolated or cut off. I am in the world and of it, when mostly I just wanted to get the hell out of it, but thought that was cheating. I've assimilated.

Granted, I have no friends I get along with in real life (except Ulaven, who somehow loves me despite the weird)

...but YOU people I like!

Well..some of you.

The Internet is my window to the world, otherwise I smile and nod and realize how people like to complain about drama, but they don't like to be responsible for it or fix it. And many people who seek teachers and methods are really only seeking someone to be their mommy or daddy.

Then there's the whole phase of just thinking "Am I being perfect because I'm just boring and lame and don't have anything else interesting to do, like a coke habit?"

Spiritual progress is interesting. Not saying it's easy or fun, but it's interesting.

It sure as hell is. What little I've done has been endlessly "interesting."
 
Back
Top