What would you people have done:

johnhancock

Virgin
Joined
Dec 6, 2004
Posts
16
This girl a friend of mine knows (this guy is freaking Romeo of the ‘net, I kid you not. I think he’s actually hiding his harem from me cause he knows I’ll take them from him :)) is invited to our Friday night “guys night in” of sorts. There’s always women there but whatever.

So this girl I don’t know and assume my friend (let’s call him John) is dating starts talking to me. Nice no-pressure conversation until she drops a bomb: “hey, have you checked your match.com lately? I’d forgotten I’d posted a profile there for the hell of it a couple months before. Totally forgot about it. I say no, she says she saw me on there and would like to hang out sometime. “Cool, no problem” I say and think, getting her email. We set up something for Tuesday of the next week and get together. We end up hitting a local bookstore cause we’re both broke students. (It’s also a GREAT way to learn about each other I think – SO many options for conversation) I found out that, among other things, she’s got a thing for a type of music I hated at the time (but tolerate and even like now thanks to her and my brother). She also wasn’t into much of anything I was except target shooting. I swear that is the only commonality.

So once I deposit her safely back at her house, she and I get in a bit of a tongue battle and move inside once we notice some perv neighbor is watching. She takes me up to her room, etc. etc.

At this point I’m torn between the fact there’s another friend I know (Rob – I kid you not, all my friends have ordinary names it seems) would be TOTALLY into this girl in a huge way. They like the same shit – movies, music, and I figured they’d be more compatible then I seemed to feel with her at the moment.

I declined her generous offer of several probably very pleasurable acts and went home. We quickly scheduled a “sleepover” for the next Friday after the requisite get-together. I feared that she wouldn’t stick around and hang out with me if I told her that I was basically “handing her off” to another guy I know, and only keeping in contact with her because my schedule didn’t allow me to introduce her yet. I wanted to do this all sneaky-like without her knowing. (I didn’t and still don’t want recognition for getting them together. That kind of act requires one to speak at the wedding, and at the time I was very attention/social function-afraid, I’m less so now. Plus I didn’t want to add another rejection to her list of stressors, she’d had enough of that apparently and I didn’t want her to have to deal with mine too). At this point I was still torn between wanting her for myself and wanting to give her the best shot at happiness. I was having one hell of an internal struggle.

That fateful day came and due to some depression-inducing stressors in my life, I wasn’t in the best of moods. I know I said some inappropriate things, but nothing that got me in too much trouble. I figured I was safe. The girl had gone from sitting next to Rob to sitting in his lap in a matter of 2 hours. She hadn’t gotten into my lap the previous Friday and I wasn’t surprised or disappointed to see my little maneuvering thing worked.

Then all hell broke loose. Rob left, everyone else retired to another room to watch John play some game on his XBOX and I was alone with the girl. She turns on a porn show I can’t recall at the moment and proceeds to straddle me and resume where we left off the night before. I made some lame excuse that probably hurt her (though I didn’t try to, I was confused as her actions suggested she didn’t want Rob) and left.

9 months later the girl and Rob are still together. We never talk except for the courtesy “hello” and she doesn’t make any effort to further our once-friendship. She says that she and Rob are perfect for each other and are very happy. I’m thrilled that my one and hopefully only matchmaking endeavor worked out well, and wish them the best.

My question is this: I’d like to know what you all would have done given what I’ve typed here. Please include as much detail as you are willing. It would be greatly appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Before me and my buddy were married we used to pass women around like joints. To quote Snoop "Y'know it ain't no fun, if the homies can't have none."
 
foxy said:
I didn't make it past the third paragraph.

Brevity, dood.


I made it only through the first paragraph before I was scrolling down to see how long this would be. Too long is the answer.
 
Then all hell broke loose. Rob left, everyone else retired to another room to watch John play some game on his XBOX and I was alone with the girl. She turns on a porn show I can’t recall at the moment and proceeds to straddle me and resume where we left off the night before. I made some lame excuse that probably hurt her (though I didn’t try to, I was confused as her actions suggested she didn’t want Rob) and left.

Ok you should have screwed her silly....that is what she wanted...but is Rob that good a friend? Don't loose any sleep over it......comfort yourself with the thought that she probably had some STD or something..


:rolleyes:
 
foxy said:
You probably have to read as much stuff as I do as part of the working day!

That post definitely needed an exec summary *nods*

He met a girl who was perfect for his friend, they almost fucked, he introduced her to his friend, they got along wonderfully, she tried to fuck him again, he said no.
 
johnhancock said:
My question is this: I’d like to know what you all would have done given what I’ve typed here. Please include as much detail as you are willing. It would be greatly appreciated.

I would hope that by the time you finished writing all that, you would have grown up some, so assuming my wish has come true, if I would have been in your shoes, I would have been adult enough to say 'Hey, I think you're a great girl, and I have this terrific friend that I think you would get along with famously'....I'm a woman, so I can say 'famously'.

With that, I would set up a meeting with her in full knowledge of what I have in mind, introduced them, hung out til I saw that they were getting along, and then skated out to 'another engagement', and let things happen naturally from there.

Basically, you should have just been straight with them both from the beginning. Had it not worked out, would you be so proud of your 'accomplishment'?

For me, I think you're a pig for letting her straddle you when you just saw her with your friend, especially now that they are so happy together. Granted, you hardly knew her, but you owed your friend a bit of respect as far as that went, even though they weren't 'dating', you had no interest in her in the least, so to me, she was just another notch for you.

But again, that's just me.
 
foxy said:
See!

Instinctively, I knew he shoulda done her.

You are so vewy beautiful :rose:

Awwww, pffft.

Thank you.



But yeah, always go for the sure thing, that's my motto.
 
I haven't a clue what I'd have done. Probably fuck her, because I never know where my next meal is coming from, if you know what I mean.

You are truly a pimp if you can take a date to the library.
 
Marathonman; I don't have any, John does. And dun't know, don't care, I'm more into cars.

Bent: you're right, this happened a while ago, in which I have grown up and got off that god-aweful combo of make-me-happy meds and acutain, both of which when used together caused mood swings. But hey, I'm pimple free and better for it. And rest assured I won't pull any stupid shit like that again. If you look closer, I did get the heck out when she started stradling me; "lame excuse" and all...

Thanks for your input guys, I'm feeling better about the whole sh*tstorm...
 
It's Christmas, if you want to feel better buy her a rubber chicken and tie a note around the neck that says something like "I know I hurt your feelings way back when, but I really did think Rob would be able to make you happy and I wanted to give him the room to try. But I'm a guy, so I fucked it up. Please accept this chicken as a symbol of my male realtionship stupidity."

She'll laugh, you'll laugh, Rob'll laugh.........or beat you with the chicken....

It's all good.
 
Xenobia: I can't tell, is that a serious suggestion or just funny? 'cause taking into account the people involved it might actually work...
 
Last edited:
johnhancock said:
My question is this: I’d like to know what you all would have done given what I’ve typed here. Please include as much detail as you are willing. It would be greatly appreciated.

I would have used a more active voice in my writing style. Used shorter, less complex sentences.

As for the situation, I would have throat fucked her thoroughly before having my buddy join for a threesome, before passing her on to my buddy.

You were too eager to pass her on to Rob, if they were that well matched, it would have happened without having to shove her at him.
 
johnhancock said:
This girl a friend of mine knows (this guy is freaking Romeo of the ‘net, I kid you not. I think he’s actually hiding his harem from me cause he knows I’ll take them from him :)) is invited to our Friday night “guys night in” of sorts. There’s always women there but whatever.

Huh?
 
I'd have been temtped to ask a bunch of strangers for advice to see if anybody would take me seriously.
 
Good Grief

Has anyone ever told you that you think too much and have female tendancies in your writing style as well as your thought process?
 
Re: Re: What would you people have done:

MNGuy said:
I would have used a more active voice in my writing style. Used shorter, less complex sentences.

As for the situation, I would have throat fucked her thoroughly before having my buddy join for a threesome, before passing her on to my buddy.

You were too eager to pass her on to Rob, if they were that well matched, it would have happened without having to shove her at him.

Bingo.
 
Bent said:


For me, I think you're a pig for letting her straddle you when you just saw her with your friend, especially now that they are so happy together. Granted, you hardly knew her, but you owed your friend a bit of respect as far as that went, even though they weren't 'dating', you had no interest in her in the least, so to me, she was just another notch for you.

But again, that's just me.

Screw that she straddled him... Sounds like an open invite to me. Anyway, you may have hurt her feelings, but you shouldn't have to apoligize when she was the one to come on to you.
 
Back
Top