Prostitution- The morality thread

Of course, I could make a number of arguments as to why its a moral evil.

1. Sanctity of marriage and the family unit.

A man looking to cheat doesn't need a prostitute to do this (although it does make it a helluva lot easier for him to do so).

2. Harm to family finances when one partner is an addict (similar to other vices like gambling or drugs).

This would be true of any addiction (as you correctly noted). The ability to moderate or succumb to addiction would depend on the individual and not so much the vice.

3. Linking of financial greed with human intimacy (keeping intimacy about pure intentions like love and commitment not money).

^^^This is the recurring icky argument I hear. The whole association of sex with all things pure and holy. Odd that even on a porn board, so many individuals keep repeating this.

4. associated crime and neighborhood decade, particularly when there's low end prostitution in a neighborhood.

Legalizing prostitution, and regulating it with norms that require individuals to conduct their business only in private should remedy this (in theory).

5. Finally, the anti-prostitution feminists' argument that men "should not have ready access to women's bodies."

Hahahaha... Let's get LJ here to tell us how women shouldn't have ready access to men's bodies. ;)
It would be naive of me to say that all prostitutes have the option of being picky about who their clients are.
 
Prostitution, at least between different sexes having PIV intercourse also has the possibility of creating human life and that elevates it beyond a normal service that is bartered. That is also what makes sex sacred on some levels as well.
 
Prostitution, at least between different sexes having PIV intercourse also has the possibility of creating human life and that elevates it beyond a normal service that is bartered. That is also what makes sex sacred on some levels as well.

You know I've seen so many street children here with light eyes and light hair and I would wondering about this trend. Someone pointed out to me that they were the result of sex tourism.
 
Of course, I could make a number of arguments as to why its a moral evil.

As in the other thread, I'm going to offer my 2c (for whatever it's worth) and try to stay out of the heavy debate rather than get dragged in. *lol*

First, my overall thought... I don't see it as a simple evil vs good thing. Subjects that involve any sort of marital infidelity are so often simplified to black vs. white, but when you dig into them, there are often grey areas. Since many escort (or prostitute) clients are married, it's understandable that one of the main arguments would be...

1. Sanctity of marriage and the family unit.

It's a very good point that seeking anything outside of the relationship has the potential to damage the relationship, so violates the sanctity of the union.

But, society rests the burden of culpability for any cheating/infidelity on the shoulders of the "cheater"... and it's so often not that simple. In every case, it may be different, but in a lot of cases it does not happen in a vacuum just simply because of a slimy nature within the cheater that drives them to fuck around. A lot of people who seek outside of their relationship will say, "I know it's not right... I'd rather find it within the relationship... but..." What follows is often an explanation of some core marital problem that the person wishes weren't there (issues in the relationship, withholding of intimacy by the spouse, etc), but is frustrated with a lack of resolution.

The problem is, some give up too easily, not trying to seek out the counseling and not putting the effort in, themselves, to better the relationship from their end. Others have, but find unwillingness in their partner to meet part way. In either case, though, the point is that infidelity doesn't happen in a vacuum in a lot of cases.

A friend (female) once put up a great blog piece that applies to both genders, but was written to women. The gist was that complacency within the relationship is not a good thing... keeping your partner emotionally and sexually satisfied is the best prevention of infidelity. Both men and women have a tendency to relax after the honeymoon stage of the relationship and assume that the spouse is now "theirs" and that they somehow don't need to continue to work to keep the relationship and the spouses healthy and happy.

So, I don't really see it as a simple thing, nor a culpability shouldered solely on the back of the cheater. It's a symptom of a breakdown in the shared responsibility of the relationship and pointing fingers is less productive than turning attention to the relationship itself to examine whether the sanctity of the marriage had been lost in that breakdown even before anyone strayed.

But, here's the thing...

At least in my opinion, the bigger threat to a marriage is a romantic affair. Sex is sex, but when the person's heart strays and wanders into deep emotional territory, things get a hell of a lot more messy and that's where there's more threat to the marriage. With more emotional involvement, the person straying is more likely to lose sight of marital priorities and more likely to disengage totally from the marriage even to the point of leaving the spouse for the new "love of his/her life."

I realize this is arguing "lesser of two evils," so to speak, but the option of something that is highly unlikely to develop beyond a sexual arrangement is actually less potentially damaging to the relationship. In our minds, seeing a "professional" may seem sleazy, but would we rather that the spouse put themselves into a situation where feelings may suddenly hit them and deepen to the point that it becomes a full blown romantic affair? The "professional" actually offers something that comes with that boundary.

Just food for thought to consider. Personally, I'd be more worried about the office relationship or some guy she meets at a bar than I would be about something that has that inherent drawn line.

2. Harm to family finances when one partner is an addict (similar to other vices like gambling or drugs).

True. It's like anything, though... a certain segment may be addicts, but like any addiction, it's not the subject of the addiction that's the problem. Even without service providers, that addiction will be fed in one way or another, in one venue or another. Like I say above about infidelity, it's important to look at the root problem and treat that as part of any solution.

3. Linking of financial greed with human intimacy (keeping intimacy about pure intentions like love and commitment not money).

This IS a big one, yes. I can totally understand the argument, so if anything, I'm playing devils advocate to a degree since I see it both ways.

I think injecting "greed" into it exaggerates. It's interesting that we'd say someone works in the grocery store or a doctor's office to provide sustenance for themselves (and their family, if they have one), yet reach right for the word "greed" when it comes to something like this.

There are different tiers to the prostitution umbrella. A lot of people immediately think of the street walkers on the bottom tier, but there are escorts / call girls who cater to different levels of financial income (all the way up to executive level call girls running at near four digits per hour). It's very difficult to simplify prostitution into one blanket driving motivation.

On the bottom tier, it's more likely to feed a drug habit and/or be a matter of survival. But, even in the top tiers, reasons and attitudes about it may vary... but, even in cases of greed, greed is more the problem than the trade itself. There are many other careers in which greed may inject immorality into the person's ethical conduct... there are crooked politicians and yet there are ethical politicians (well, at least a couple :cool: ... somewhere... probably).

I used to know a top tier service provider who... yes, she liked the material things... but, she saw what she was doing as providing for a need in her clients, who she saw as "mini boyfriends." In her mind, the only difference between what she was doing and what a psychologist does is societally determined taboos residual from puritanical cultural norms.

In other words, to her the "moral majority" determine what moral is, but opinions of morality vary based on perspective. Some outside of the "moral majority" feel that as long as there is consent, the choice is up to those consenting adults.

Again, I can see it both ways. Just offering whatever food for thought.

4. associated crime and neighborhood decade, particularly when there's low end prostitution in a neighborhood.

I'm glad you made the distinction of "low end" and that's true. I think that the deeper consideration is that poverty is the issue. Poverty breeds desperation and escapism, so drug abuse and desperate acts for income (crime) run rampant within that poverty. It becomes a Mecca for vices, whether they be drugs or sex.

I wonder if just taking the sex out of the equation (somehow magically vanishing all prostitution) would have a great effect on things. It's a symptom, but isn't it just a head of a greater hydra?

5. Finally, the anti-prostitution feminists' argument that men "should not have ready access to women's bodies."

Ironically, many of them probably fall into the pro-choice camp of "women should be able to choose what to do with their own bodies." It's interesting to argue that others should not dictate personal choices with regard to one's own body based on others' views of morality, yet use their own moral opinions as reasons why no woman should choose to use her body in prostitution.

I don't know if I'm just completely missing something there or not. I mean, I understand the view that a person should hold their body and intimacy as sacred and not denigrate themselves. I get it. But, I don't like the double standard of "your morals shouldn't impose on my bodily choices, but you should not be allowed to do things with your body that I find morally degrading."

If that pro-choice stance stands for abortion, that touchstone of personal choice should stand in the case of prostitution.
 
Back
Top