Prostitution- The morality thread

So, there is already a thread which questions the need to legalize prostitution. But, the objections that I saw there were mostly based on ethics and morality.

I am pretty sure most people will say that it is morally reprehensible etc. Wondering if there are any counter claims. Or are our moral compasses in sync on this point?

I agree with Saint Thomas Aquinas that prostitution is a necessary social evil.
 
Look, I understand all of that. The overwhelming majority of girls working prostitution world wide are little more than slaves. Some sold into by their parents, some literally abducted and indoctrinated, some enslaved to drugs before the sex slave part starts. And if there's a reason to have prostitution be illegal, this is it. But it's not going to go away until you make a commitment to nail the public officials that turn a blind eye, or ever worse profit from it.

But there is a high end and those women are attractive, intelligent and independent. Hell, there's also the middle ground that works out of suburbia. Bored housewives looking for a little extra 'pin' money or just some kicks.

Ishmael

Look, we all understand what I posted.




But there is a high end? Hahaha!

So what you're saying is that we shouldn't concern ourselves with how shitty prostitution is and just focus on the intelligent, independent and/or the bored prostitutes.

Great.

:D
 
Prostitution is less immoral than other forms of extra-marital and pre-marital sex because it is more formal. In fact, it can be considered a form of "temporary marriage" in that the customer (usually a man) gives money or other goods to the provider (usually a woman). This is the normal idea behind a marriage as well, only on a much longer basis.
 
Look, we all understand what I posted.




But there is a high end? Hahaha!

So what you're saying is that we shouldn't concern ourselves with how shitty prostitution is and just focus on the intelligent, independent and/or the bored prostitutes.

Great.

:D

No, that's not what I'm saying.

Ishmael
 
re: OP

To tie in with your other thread and Objectivism.

If you strip morality and subjectivism away, then it is just a contract, a barter, an exchange in which both sides have pros and cons (and the unconsidered, as in all transactions; rarely do both parties know everything about the goods traded).

The details of the trade are the stuff of privacy and civil litigations (maybe criminal charges for theft by deceit or failure to uphold the contract) not the stuff of regulation for moral purport.

At best, a locality should be able to say, not in these places can you transact business [publicly], not, you cannot transact business [on private property with private property].
 
To tie in with your other thread and Objectivism.

If you strip morality and subjectivism away, then it is just a contract, a barter, an exchange in which both sides have pros and cons (and the unconsidered, as in all transactions; rarely do both parties know everything about the goods traded).

The details of the trade are the stuff of privacy and civil litigations (maybe criminal charges for theft by deceit or failure to uphold the contract) not the stuff of regulation for moral purport.

At best, a locality should be able to say, not in these places can you transact business [publicly], not, you cannot transact business [on private property with private property].

Thank you.

There was already a thread discussing the need for legalization. However the objections to it were mainly made on moral grounds. So, I founded to explore the theme - a social study if you will- to get a better understanding of why some people find it icky while others see it as just another trade.
 
Prostitution is less immoral than other forms of extra-marital and pre-marital sex because it is more formal. In fact, it can be considered a form of "temporary marriage" in that the customer (usually a man) gives money or other goods to the provider (usually a woman). This is the normal idea behind a marriage as well, only on a much longer basis.

I agree with this in some ways. In a relationship, it is an exchange of favours, while as a business it is an exchange of service for a price.




I think I need to hear some moral objections, because it feels like no one thinks that prostitution is a 'bad' thing.
 
I think I see it as an icky trade.

But then I grew up as a good-looking young man in the 60s and 70s where young women were being told to liberate themselves and to go fornicate freely, like a man...

So paying for it was almost NOT an option!

;) ;) :D
 
I think I see it as an icky trade.

But then I grew up as a good-looking young man in the 60s and 70s where young women were being told to liberate themselves and to go fornicate freely, like a man...

So paying for it was almost NOT an option!

;) ;) :D

Freakonomics did a piece about how the sexual revolution decimated the prostitution industry.
 
I think I see it as an icky trade.

But then I grew up as a good-looking young man in the 60s and 70s where young women were being told to liberate themselves and to go fornicate freely, like a man...

So paying for it was almost NOT an option!

;) ;) :D


You expect us to buy that. :rolleyes:


Please post pics.

:cool:
 
I agree with this in some ways. In a relationship, it is an exchange of favours, while as a business it is an exchange of service for a price.




I think I need to hear some moral objections, because it feels like no one thinks that prostitution is a 'bad' thing.

The objections are tied in with the bottom end of the trade. While I have no moral objection to prostitution per se', the girls/women trapped at the bottom are subjected to slavery, severe mental and physical abuse, extortion, (in some cases) the forced use of dangerous drugs, etc. All manner of abuses which I'm sure we can agree are morally bankrupt. Further in many cases this leads to the corruption of public officials as well. So the problems associated with prostitution extend far beyond the trade itself.

Many see legalization as a solution, and to a certain extent it may well be. How much of a solution would be dependent upon how much regulation the state would place upon the trade. Using liquor as an example, in the 60's Alabama sold liquor at state owned stores, the prices were exorbitant. Consequently there was a thriving industry in illegal liquor. Or take the example of cigarettes. New York (and many other states) have enacted usurious taxes on cigarettes, all in the name of 'the good of the smoker'. Obviously using the tax system to discourage smoking. All well and good, but all they've managed to accomplish is to undermine their own tax base and promote a black market trade in cigarettes. So while the legalization of the trade might indeed have benefits, history indicates that the will act in greed (taxes) while at the same time selling the public on the expanded benefits that these increased taxes will offer. ie. the health and counseling of those in the trade, no new taxes in other areas, etc. They will kill the goose while enabling a growing underground market in the trade. In order to pull legalization off enlightened leadership will be required and a continuous string of enlightened leaders at that and I just don't see that happening.

Ishmael
 
The objections are tied in with the bottom end of the trade. While I have no moral objection to prostitution per se', the girls/women trapped at the bottom are subjected to slavery, severe mental and physical abuse, extortion, (in some cases) the forced use of dangerous drugs, etc. All manner of abuses which I'm sure we can agree are morally bankrupt. Further in many cases this leads to the corruption of public officials as well. So the problems associated with prostitution extend far beyond the trade itself.

Many see legalization as a solution, and to a certain extent it may well be. How much of a solution would be dependent upon how much regulation the state would place upon the trade.


So at least in your case (and I believe some others on this thread), the real objection is to the conditions that drives people into the flesh trade and the exploitation (which most appear to claim) which seems almost intrinsic to the profession.


The more I read this thread, the more it sounds to me like everyone is saying that the act of prostitution itself is a neutral on the moral compass.
 
So at least in your case (and I believe some others on this thread), the real objection is to the conditions that drives people into the flesh trade and the exploitation (which most appear to claim) which seems almost intrinsic to the profession.


The more I read this thread, the more it sounds to me like everyone is saying that the act of prostitution itself is a neutral on the moral compass.

It's neutral in practice, but it eliminates a negative.

It's like saying a toilet is a required thing. It's not the best thing or a favorite conversation subject, but it gets rid of shit.

I think people require sex to differing degrees and it's not up to me to say if it's three times a day or once a year.

If a three times a day person has the cash and if they don't have sex they're a raving lunatic, then please. PLEASE. Go see a hooker of whatever proclivity you want.

It's ridding the world of the buildup of anxiety and the more likelihood that they're going to take it out on another human being in a way other than sexually.
 
It's neutral in practice, but it eliminates a negative.

It's like saying a toilet is a required thing. It's not the best thing or a favorite conversation subject, but it gets rid of shit.

I think people require sex to differing degrees and it's not up to me to say if it's three times a day or once a year.

If a three times a day person has the cash and if they don't have sex they're a raving lunatic, then please. PLEASE. Go see a hooker of whatever proclivity you want.

It's ridding the world of the buildup of anxiety and the more likelihood that they're going to take it out on another human being in a way other than sexually.


We are in agreement on this. I guess a porn board wouldn't really have the kind of people who would make a decent enough argument on why prostitution is a moral evil. :)
 
We are in agreement on this. I guess a porn board wouldn't really have the kind of people who would make a decent enough argument on why prostitution is a moral evil. :)

Nobody really can. They just feel strongly about it, which I get, sex inspires strong feelings.

I tell my kids "this is too important to be embarrassed about and unable to discuss" and I think it also applies here.
 
We are in agreement on this. I guess a porn board wouldn't really have the kind of people who would make a decent enough argument on why prostitution is a moral evil. :)

Of course, I could make a number of arguments as to why its a moral evil.

1. Sanctity of marriage and the family unit.
2. Harm to family finances when one partner is an addict (similar to other vices like gambling or drugs).
3. Linking of financial greed with human intimacy (keeping intimacy about pure intentions like love and commitment not money).
4. associated crime and neighborhood decade, particularly when there's low end prostitution in a neighborhood.
5. Finally, the anti-prostitution feminists' argument that men "should not have ready access to women's bodies."
 
I think it's an irrepressible market that should be legalized, taxed, and regulated, but if I'm being 100% honest, something about the commodification of sex makes me uncomfortable. I hope never to sell it, pay for it, or use it expressly to get something that I want (except for more sex, or like, money or something), and I can't entirely understand the motivations and emotions of people who do.
 
So, there is already a thread which questions the need to legalize prostitution. But, the objections that I saw there were mostly based on ethics and morality.

I am pretty sure most people will say that it is morally reprehensible etc. Wondering if there are any counter claims. Or are our moral compasses in sync on this point?


I question the need to illegalize prostitution.
 
lance! is this a flying visit or should I restock the holy water?
 
Back
Top