Pollitical Corectness

This is "unscientific" of course, but, how many of the young women out there aged 20-30 have felt that a government official or other official (like a boss or other non-family person) have steered them into a career choice?
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
This is "unscientific" of course, but, how many of the young women out there aged 20-30 have felt that a government official or other official (like a boss or other non-family person) have steered them into a career choice?
Why do you restrain it to "government official or other official (like a boss or other non-family person)"? I think the biggest and most effective pressure group of all is one's own family. How many of the young women out there aged 20-30 have felt steered into settling down with a nice alpha-male and breed?
 
Last edited:
If ever there were a few words that should be spelled correctly,

it's "political correctness."
 
Hi LTGR, I don't have time to reply to your post just now (I'll do it by tomorrow, promise) - but I just wanted to point out that 'burden' does not imply an agent doing the burdening, you can be burdened by inanimate things, after all ;). But anyway, it doesn't matter - it makes no difference if the word 'oppression' doesn't mean the same thing to you as it does to me - just so long as it is clear to you what I mean, we can debate it. If you prefer, we can agree to call what I have been calling 'oppression', grue instead. :D

I was never using dictionary definitions to support my position with regards to grue, I used them to clarify to Ishmael (and then to you) exactly what I meant by grue.

Systemic grue can only be passive in the sense of agency, because it is part of the social structure, and society is not an agent in any traditional sense of the word. If you are arguing that grue must always be done consciously by agents, then you are claiming that systemic grue cannot exist.

I think that, looking back in history, you'd have to be willing to concede that there have been societies in which there was obviously systemic grue (consider the caste of 'untouchables' in India). Indeed, I think looking back at the history of our own society there are many incontestable examples of systemic grue (such as the segregation laws). So it is clear (in my opinion) that it is possible for grue to be systemic. I'll have to leave it at this for now.



*smooches Lauren* and no, still not on trill - going to go to bed. I can't handle the no sleep thing - I'm such a wus lol - three days in a row of 4 hours sleep is killin' me, gonna get a good night's sleep tonight if I have to tie myself to the bed :D
 
crysede said:
*smooches Lauren* and no, still not on trill - going to go to bed. I can't handle the no sleep thing - I'm such a wus lol - three days in a row of 4 hours sleep is killin' me, gonna get a good night's sleep tonight if I have to tie myself to the bed :D
:heart: :kiss: *smooch* Need help with that? I've got some experience in tying people to beds, you know... :D

(Sweet dreams, babe)
 
Lauren.Hynde said:
Why do you restrain it to "government official or other official (like a boss or other non-family person)"? I think the biggest and most effective pressure group of all is one own's family. How many of the young women out there aged 20-30 have felt steered into settling down with a nice alpha-male and breed?

True, often it is family providing the pressure. There are are couple reasons that I exclude family. First, "family" is both masculine and femine and we've been talking about masculine "oppression". Second, if masculine career counselors, teachers, or anyone else who is not part of a person's family to "steer" women into lower paying jobs on purpose as part of a policy, that would certainly be a systematic problem (that could probably be corrected through legislation). However, if family is doing the pressure, particulary male and female family members...I'm hesitant to want to even try to think about "legislating" something like that. If your mother tells you that you'd be happier in your life to settle down with an alpha-male...or even an alpha female for that matter...who am I or who is the government to go in and give her direction? If that was the case, I feel the mother isn't doing the right thing, but I'm not going to tell her that..it's her daughter.

It's a weak position, I admit...but it makes things less complex to leave family out.
 
OK, OK, I lied - one more comment before bed: I've been talking about systemic grue, not masculine grue!!

God it's hard to shut up...

I think I may need your help after all Lauren, you have sturdy rope I assume? I'm a fighter and I won't go down easy :D ;)
 
crysede said:
Hi LTGR, I don't have time to reply to your post just now (I'll do it by tomorrow, promise) - but I just wanted to point out that 'burden' does not imply an agent doing the burdening, you can be burdened by inanimate things, after all ;). But anyway, it doesn't matter - it makes no difference if the word 'oppression' doesn't mean the same thing to you as it does to me - just so long as it is clear to you what I mean, we can debate it. If you prefer, we can agree to call what I have been calling 'oppression', grue instead. :D

I was never using dictionary definitions to support my position with regards to grue, I used them to clarify to Ishmael (and then to you) exactly what I meant by grue.

Systemic grue can only be passive in the sense of agency, because it is part of the social structure, and society is not an agent in any traditional sense of the word. If you are arguing that grue must always be done consciously by agents, then you are claiming that systemic grue cannot exist.

I think that, looking back in history, you'd have to be willing to concede that there have been societies in which there was obviously systemic grue (consider the caste of 'untouchables' in India). Indeed, I think looking back at the history of our own society there are many incontestable examples of systemic grue (such as the segregation laws). So it is clear (in my opinion) that it is possible for grue to be systemic. I'll have to leave it at this for now.

I think there's a lot of merit in this crusade that you've got going on. I have only minor disagreements on it EXCEPT for your use of the word "Oppression" to describe it. It makes me feel guilty for a crime that I didn't commit. I am not "crushing or burdening by abuse of power" anyone and neither is Ish. I don't like to feel guilty. I'm an encourager...not an oppressor.

I don't have the word grue in my college dictionary and I still don't feel like walking upstairs. I guess I can look it up on-line.

I also don't agree with you that it's entirely systemic because that implies that the individual is not making choices. I think people have a lot of choice over what fields they enter and there are a lot of factors that go into those choices (family for example). Some of the factors MIGHT be systemic and outside of family and I'll help you pursue those and understand them better. In fact, I'll race ya.

But for the factors related to family choice, individual choice or "evolutionary coping strategy," I won't help much beyond being curious about the results that you find.
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
It's a weak position, I admit...but it makes things less complex to leave family out.
:D In that case, let's not. If you admit family to be often the agent of pressure, you can't forget about it just because.
LovetoGiveRoses said:
True, often it is family providing the pressure. There are are couple reasons that I exclude family. First, "family" is both masculine and femine and we've been talking about masculine "oppression". Second, if masculine career counselors, teachers, or anyone else who is not part of a person's family to "steer" women into lower paying jobs on purpose as part of a policy, that would certainly be a systematic problem (that could probably be corrected through legislation). However, if family is doing the pressure, particulary male and female family members...I'm hesitant to want to even try to think about "legislating" something like that. If your mother tells you that you'd be happier in your life to settle down with an alpha-male...or even an alpha female for that matter...who am I or who is the government to go in and give her direction? If that was the case, I feel the mother isn't doing the right thing, but I'm not going to tell her that..it's her daughter.
First, let me tell you that up until now, no one ever said a word about masculine "oppression". There was talk about oppressed women, but nobody said it was an all-male conscious conspiracy. And of course nobody has said anything about legislating thought, but there is a thing called education. I know that Ishmael thinks education is the parents' responsability and the state should stay clear from it (that's why he's been diligently avoiding to answer my posts) ;) but it's my position that an adequate education policy (and that is, in most countries, legislatable matter) would be a huge step in the right direction...
 
Last edited:
As for Ish and the point about skewing the curve. I know that one person's income doesn't skew a population of 283 Million people. I'm sometimes daffy when I haven't slept enough, but not usually that daffy. <as he says AFLAC>. He is representative of a large group of high earning men that are skewing the "average" wage of male wage earners up.
 
crysede said:
I think I may need your help after all Lauren, you have sturdy rope I assume? I'm a fighter and I won't go down easy :D ;)
Well, I'm expecting you to go down, but I wouldn't want it to be easy anyway :catroar:
 
There was talk about oppressed women, but nobody said it was an all-male conscious conspiracy.

Yes, that was one of the main points of Cry's earlier posts. Let me see if I can find them and post them here.
 
Last edited:
I haven't found it yet.

I do want to talk about education eventually Lauren. I know a little about it and you know a lot. I have to go through pages 11-15 in a little more detail since I was away then. <going back and finding those points>
 
Lauren.Hynde said:
Well, I'm expecting you to go down, but I wouldn't want it to be easy anyway :catroar:

:p Oh, oh, sorry, I got your meaning confused with something else. Sorry. :D (well, this is an "erotic" site).
 
crysede said:

I guess I'd say that you participate in oppression when you benefit (regardless of whether you admit to receiving, or want to receive, this benefit) from the subjugation of someone else. But I'd want to be very careful about using the word 'oppressor' since that, to me at least, implies that you are acting in order to subjugate people - I think this is rather rare, discrimination is nearly always hidden within other concerns.

Here, she gives a definition of the word "Oppressor" (which is related to "Oppress" and "Oppression") but then she casts doubt upon herself for using the word because she admits that it implies "acting in order to subjegate people"

This "acting..." is consistent with the American Dictionary definition of "Oppression".. "To Subject" as well as the Webster definition of "Oppress" ... To crush or burden through an abuse of power...

Her definition.."I guess I'd say that you participate in oppression when you benefit (regardless of whether you admit to receiving, or want to receive, this benefit) from the subjugation of someone else. " is incorrect against the definition in either dictionary. She is correct when she says it "implies acting....

My old dictionary says subjugate means.."to bring under control of subjection, conquer." Do men conquer women? Would women thrive in an environment without men to subjegate them? This implies action and a victim/victimizer relationship also.

If you say that women are "oppressed"...then who is left to do the oppressing except men? If you are going to use a different word that doesn't imply "To crush or burden through and abuse of power"...then that's a different thing entirely.

I concluded that the "target" was men because the initial statistics presented as evidence of the "oppression" was a comparison of income between men and women and the ensuing discussion, especially the discussion of most leaders being men and only a few being women. I didn't think you meant to imply that some women are participating with men to "To crush or burden through and abuse of power"...

At the end she says... discrimination is nearly always hidden within other concerns. and I'm not sure what she exactly means with that. Is it that "oppression" does indeed exist and that it's hidden (a hidden conspiracy) or is it simply that women are discriminated against and not really "oppressed".

A discussion of discrimination against women is an entirely different thing because up until now we've been talking about "oppression" of women.

I am not "Oppressing" anyone, except maybe my caged birds.

I am happy to further explore the causal factors (with facts or simple discussion) in the difference in average income between men and women. I'd feel much better examining the causal factors. If we find discrimination has a role, then lets talk about it in specific terms and situations. However, I don't want to start out by saying....If there's a difference in earnings..it must be due to discrimination. Lets uncover the next level of facts before jumping to a conclusion.

I don't want to talk about discrimination as a starting point...it implies victim/victimizer relationship. I tire of this "culture of victimization" thing.
 
Last edited:
LovetoGiveRoses said:


Here, she gives a definition of the word "Oppressor" (which is related to "Oppress" and "Oppression") but then she casts doubt upon herself for using the word because she admits that it implies "acting in order to subjegate people"

This "acting..." is consistent with the American Dictionary definition of "Oppression".. "To Subject" as well as the Webster definition of "Oppress" ... To crush or burden through an abuse of power...

Her definition.."I guess I'd say that you participate in oppression when you benefit (regardless of whether you admit to receiving, or want to receive, this benefit) from the subjugation of someone else. " is incorrect against the definition in either dictionary.

I am not "Oppressing" anyone, except maybe my caged birds.
Hey, you did it! Well, crysede was wrong! :cool:
(Although, to her benefit, she did start the post with the expression I guess. That's not very normal...)

Clearly, you can be part of the oppressed and still be an oppressor. I'm talking, for example, about women that were, as you assert, steered into a determined social position and made believe that it's the right status for them. Or what Malcolm X of the early days called "the house negro"...

Honnestly, that doesn't mean that her definition is wrong, it is possible that all those benefiting from the oppression are participating of it (it does make some sense, if you think about it) and I'm prepared to accept it if she can produce a good argument for it (I know I can), but it's excluding a huge sector of the, wouldn't call it oppressors, but agents and accomplices of oppression, that's for sure.
 
AARRRRRRRGGGGGGG
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
GGGGH
HHHHHHH
HHHHHHHHHHH
HHHHH



resume.

:cool:
 
Last edited:
Koala, could you edit to insert a couple spaces in your frustration exclaimation so that the text wraps and we can read the other posts?
 
Let's not talk in victim/victimization terms any more unless we find specific instances of it, lets deal with it, but not start with it. Let's start with "causal factors" or something similar.

If a mother advises her daughter to marry Joe instead of going to medical school I don't think that it's "oppression". It might be foolish if the daughter indeed has the will, the ability and the drive to do it, but it's still not oppression. If her father advises her of the same thing, I don't think its discrimination.

By inviting me to participate in the discussion and starting out with the words oppression or discrimination, you're saying "you're guilty, we know it, now, lets go prove it together." It's not really an appealing invitation.

Looking at "causal factors" for example, is much more inviting.
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
Here, she gives a definition of the word "Oppressor" (which is related to "Oppress" and "Oppression") but then she casts doubt upon herself for using the word because she admits that it implies "acting in order to subjegate people"
lol I said it implies this to me, ie, I was letting you know I was my understanding of this term deviates from the dictionary. I find this to be a loaded term, whereas I do not find oppression to be a loaded term (and honestly, the reason why is irrelevant, but I'll tell you if you want) so I don't feel comfortable using it. As I've mentioned on several occasions in this thread - I see nothing wrong with using words differently from their standard usage, as long as you make sure everyone else knows that you are doing so.

But why on earth are we still talking about definitions? :confused: I told you it is irrelevant to me what we call it.
crysede said:
It makes no difference if the word 'oppression' doesn't mean the same thing to you as it does to me - just so long as it is clear to you what I mean, we can debate it. If you prefer, we can agree to call what I have been calling 'oppression', 'grue' instead.
And you don't have to go look up 'grue', it's not really a word ;) - I started using it because you said you didn't like to use the word oppression. If you don't like 'grue' either, we could call it 'Charley', or 'sljfeoiw' for all I care lol. I'm interested in the issue, not the label.

The only reason I brought up definitions was to explain my use of the term oppression - the definitions are totally irrelevant to my claims about oppression/grue/Charley/sljfeoiw (or whatever you want to label it).

OK, I'm saying this one more time just to make sure: the word you use does not matter, it is what you mean by it that matters!!


And that rope wasn't strong enough Lauren - told you I'm a fighter (or maybe it was just that you got distracted when I went down and didn't tie the knots as tight as you should have ;) ).
 
I've gone to bed at 3am each of the last two nights. Tomorrow I have to work. It's midnight here and I need to get some sleep. I look forward to continuing later.

Good night. :)
 
Back
Top