SINthysist
Rural Racist Homophobe
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2001
- Posts
- 11,940
I haven't seen him post anywhere...
Give him some time.
Give him some time.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
crysede said:PC, as I understand it, has to do with oppression and the recognition that language can be used to subordinate. Recognition of differences does not have to be done in a way that subordinates; you can recognize that blacks are not whites by calling them 'blacks', rather than 'niggers'; you can recognize that a woman is not a man by calling her Ms So-and-so rather than 'dear'. PC is about not using language to label one group as inferior when differences exist - men and women are different, but that does not mean men are better (as has been the historical assumption, with women seen as deviations from the norm).

Let me come back to this one. Affirmative action can be a government policy. I'm thinking about race and gender quotas for public administration sectors and such. It's a shitty policy, but that's not the point right now. But wouldn't you think that it's considered PC for private corporations to implement affirmative action, even if they're not legally obliged to? PC-ism doesn't begin and end with language, I think...crysede said:
I don't consider this the actual real life application of the principles of PC: this is the real life application of the principles of affirmative action. The real life application of PC is no longer calling business women by their first names (or 'dear') while calling business men by their last names.
Affirmative action and PC are both responses to the recognition that our society is discriminatory - but they are two different responses. PC is what was in the first post: a change in mindset reflecting the recognition that language is a powerful tool that can be used to oppress others. I think it is attacking discrimination at a much more fundamental (and effective) level, since it is addressing a means of oppression (that of discriminatory use of language). Affirmative action is attacking a symptom of oppression, rather than a cause, and I'm not convinced this treat-the-symptoms approach will really be very affective at combatting oppression.
[edited because without the not in the last sentence, that last paragraph made no sense]

Well hotdamn! I actually had to fiddle with that one a bit to make it work - and all I fucked up was little 'a'! Sounds good to me babeLauren.Hynde said:If he doesn't, do you want to pick a random topic and discuss it? I miss my debate team![]()
Should we try to find something we disagree on? Or one of us just play devil's advocate and argue against their own position on something?DEVIANT!!Sandia said:Crysede, you are much too reasonable to argue with.
However, I reserve the right to get in the last word,
by calling you "dear." Kehe.

Oh...sorry Dill, did you say something? I was....distracted by the intense need to get a nice thick popsicle to suck on... These sudden cravings will hit me at the darnedest timesDillinger said:Actually, I find there is very little that is correct about politics.
"You still haven't told me what bikes you've got, you puny socialist false-messiah of the unwashed masses."Lost Cause said:"The common good comes before the private good."
- Nazi slogan
![]()
.

Gee, babe. I don't know. It would be nice to find relevant discordant views, but I love playing devil's advocate.crysede said:
Well hotdamn! I actually had to fiddle with that one a bit to make it work - and all I fucked up was little 'a'! Sounds good to me babeShould we try to find something we disagree on? Or one of us just play devil's advocate and argue against their own position on something?

crysede said:
And PC as a social philosophy begins and ends with language. But since the issue of PC became popular with politicians, the term has been used as an adjective to refer the sorts of things that the political group supporting PC also tended to support. But that doesn't make those things 'PC' just like calling some policy 'conservative' because Conservatives support it, doesn't mean the policy is really against changing the status quo. That's why I've been careful to distinguish between the social theory PC, and the political creation labelled PC.
I think you're boring all-white doggie is oppressively fluffy!Lauren.Hynde said:Gee, babe. I don't know. It would be nice to find relevant discordant views, but I love playing devil's advocate.![]()
Most corporations here in Canada are far too busy merging and buying up their competitors in a fascist fashion to be bothered with pesky little things like general society. And that's the anti-PC crowds definition of PC, so if that's what you've got on your streets, sureThe fact remains that, no matter what you call it, corporations promote this behaviour in an almost fascist fashion because their administrations think that's what the general society regards as the morally correct thing to do. Isn't that the definition (on the streets, not in the textbooks) of what's PC?


Don't think I hadn't thought of that, but I always check my facts before making smartass remarkscrysede said:[edited to add]Before you make any smartass remarks about Lost Cause's post - my comments to Z last night in orp were about a '51 Panhead, not a '53, so there![]()

Cool, a smart smartass! heheheLauren.Hynde said:Don't think I hadn't thought of that, but I always check my facts before making smartass remarks![]()





Oppression 101:LovetoGiveRoses said:Hello Cry,
You are a skilled researcher and a smart cookie.
Please tell me more about the oppression. How does it happen? Is the oppression the entire reason for the statistics that you mentioned..the lack of economic equality between men and women?

Hi LTGR, how are you doing this morningLovetoGiveRoses said:Please tell me more about the oppression. How does it happen? Is the oppression the entire reason for the statistics that you mentioned..the lack of economic equality between men and women?
crysede said:Lauren - I love ya you watery tart!![]()
Hi LTGR, how are you doing this morning
I think it could be the entire reason for social inequality - but I tend to favour a middle ground position unless the evidence very clearly points to an all-or-nothing type answer - so I think it's more likely that oppression interacts with other factors. That's not a position I can argue though, since I can't point to any other factors that are clearly not related to oppression lol, so that's just my opinion. As to how it can be gotten rid of - a lot of hard work! By it's very nature oppression is something that is built into societies, so it's often damn hard to even see it, let alone get rid of it. I don't know if it's even possible to get rid of it entirely - but whether we can or not, at least we should try.