Pollitical Corectness

You are a big bad censor. You keep putting white out on my monitor.

Knock if off.
 
KillerMuffin said:
You are a big bad censor. You keep putting white out on my monitor.

Knock if off.
Ban her! Quick!

Let's take a poll: how many of you think Ishmael will ever respond to Crysede's posts?
 
After reviewing Laurel's post, it is my sad duty to report, that she is, in fact, tyrant.

She viciously oppressed non-PC individuals, by suggesting there was a flaw in the argument that PC'ism was oppressing white people because they would be called a 'bigot' if they called a black person a 'nigger'.

Well Laurel, what do you have to say for yourself in the face of this damming evidence?
 
chuckle.... yes she did... Ok so I didn't actually go back and reread her posts shrug that was the way they came across anyway...

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Pray tell , Crysede...what she could possibly say in light of this evidence :

Quote from the Censorship Queen AKA Laurel

"I know the UK and places like France have hate speech laws, and that's unfair. I don't support that at all. I think controlling what people say only worsens the problems and deprives people of their right to an opinion. Uncool."
 
Good Lord, she's in favour of censoring hate speech laws?!

And she looked so innocent with those kitten AV's . . .
 
Re: The Never Ending Reply, Part II

crysede said:

Last time I checked demographics counted as facts, and that's what I presented as the factual support for my argument. I didn't post them of course - entering in all that data would take hours; it would be for Canada (since I didn't keep a copy of the data for the US last time I had to use this information), and thus probably not satisfactory to you; plus the data in question is very easy to get a hold of if you want to see for yourself (local libraries should have copies, or you can contact the statistics dept. or agency of your government).


I'm not sure what the point of this premise is: the fact that blacks aren't disadvantaged in non-Western cultures has no bearing on whether or not they are disadvantaged in Western cultures.


OK We'll use your demographic data. Please explain why the mean income of immigrant blacks. Haitian, Jamaican, African, is higher than the mean
income of whites in the United States?

For extra credit, relate that to oppresion.

Iahmael
 
Re: Re: The Never Ending Reply, Part II

Ishmael said:


OK We'll use your demographic data. Please explain why the mean income of immigrant blacks. Haitian, Jamaican, African, is higher than the mean
income of whites in the United States?

For extra credit, relate that to oppresion.

Iahmael
Wait a second, you aren't going to even bother to try to answer a single one of my questions? If you are admitting that you can't answer them, and are giving up your previous position, then you need to explain what your new position is.

It is my opinion that my previous two posts defeated your arguments that oppression does not, and has not, existed. Do you concur? You need to either admit this, or answer the questions I posed to you.

I will probably cave in and answer your question tomorrow anyway, though - even if you have continued to refuse to deal with my last two posts. I hate to leave a question un-replied to. I'm going to check on those figures myself first though, you haven't had the best track record when it comes to citing facts ;)
 
I have never postulated that discrimination has never existed. Nor do I hold that it does not exist in vestigals forms today among individuals.

However to equate historical societal norms to systematic oppresion is to ignore history in it's societal detail. Futher, to equate past norms to current practice is disengenuous. Societal standards with regard to gender realtionships is evolutionary. The basic practice of "pair bonding" is practiced in virtually all societies, from the aboriginal to the modern. Probably with more effect in aboriginal societies. The apportionment of tasks changes with societies needs. It is the apportionment that you are addressing. Modern science has also informed us that the brains of the two genders operate differently, and because of this brain developement, based on hormones it is suspected, the two gender approach and execute tasks in different ways. And that each has inate skills that are not naturally derived in the other. In other words, from a natural skill set perspective, neither gender is complete unto itself.

With regard to races, it is a matter of acceptance first. (Evolutionary also. 200 years ago the blacks in this country were considered "children" that must be cared for. Incapable of suceeding on their own. Wards of the slave owner. Quite frankly I can't see all that much of a change in attitude. Modern liberals consider the blacks disadvantaged and incapable of success without "their" support. They are treated like mentally retarded adults now and instead of being the ward of the slave owner, they have become the ward of the state. It's difficult for me to read anything like freedom and independence into that paradigm.) Capability second. Capability being defined as the raw material to undertake a position (education) and the ability to advance within that position (skills, natural and learned). There are some few that view a job as an entitlement. Nothing could be further from the truth.

My particular area is by nature multi-national, multi-cultural. I have not witnessed systematic exclusionary practices based on race or gender since the 60's. (But then again, my specialties are highly technical in nature and require an education in the sciences. These people are where you find them. Not in the color or gender of your particular choice. Discrimination is not an option, not if you want your business to succeed.)

The continual cries of oppression create nothing more than a welfare class. Not all that different from "reservation Indians". (Chime in anytime SIN) And welfare classes create sloth and ignorance.

Ishmael
 
Sorry I've taken so long to reply, I haven't managed to get on the computer till tonight. I'll address your demographic question first (I'll respond to your latest post tomorrow morning).

The data you present is completely meaningless. I'm sure you would have seen this had you reflected upon what the data actually was, but like most of us do, I expect you trusted the 'expert' source. If there is one thing I've learned, it's that these expert sources - on both the political left and right (sadly, there seem to be equal numbers of cheats and liars on both sides) - must never be trusted implicitly: far too often they engage in the sort of despicable tactic that your source has.

You are of course aware that your country has very tough immigration standards: a black person, or anyone else for that matter, cannot just become an American because they want to. Except for the small percentage that are granted citizenship as refuges, the remainder of blacks that are allowed in have skills and education far in excess of the average white American.

Because the demographic data did not go his/her way, your source decided to 'fake' some data, by comparing the mean income of the average white, to the mean income of the well above average black. Obviously, this is a ridiculous comparison - you have to compare the mean income of immigrant blacks to the mean income of immigrant whites! I'll bet he/she didn't bother separating out Hispanic whites either, just to make the income difference look even greater.

The kind of people that are willing to resort to this sort of blatant dishonesty (thereby giving all statistics a bad name) are a pet peeve of mine, if you hadn't noticed. lol

The best way to get accurate information, is to go to the source: the US Census Bureau. The Bureau has a vast amount of information online (click here to go to the Bureau's home page). For example, a proper comparison of the mean income of Americans by race and gender is (US Census Bureau, Income Tables, Table P-3, 2000):

----------------------- Men -------------- Women
Non-Hispanic whites -- 43,926 ------------ 23,254
Black -----------------28,395 ------------ 20,635
Hispanic whites ------- 25,863 ------------ 16,687

(If the Hispanic and non-Hispanic whites are combined, the mean salary for 'whites' becomes 41,727 for men and 22,564 for women.)
 
Last edited:
we are for the most part all adult ..... we can on our own identify a bigot ...a racist .... an ass. It used to be very easy to see someone for who they were, now to many who hold views that they are better or brighter keep their mouths shut ....they still do damage, its just tougher to see. I think political correctness has not changed anything except method of attack
 
Political Correctness
Political correctness is just wrong it is simply and truly the death of our country.

This nation (America for those of you outside ) was founded as a place minorities could come and think and do whatever the hell they wanted as long as they didn't force other people to do it. Period.

Political Correctness is the death of that. And I see a lot of it on these boards.

I would love someone anyone to explain why exactly they think it is a good thing. Because a great deal of you obviously do.

Hi Meop,

Crysede referred me to this thread. I know, I’m late as usual, but looking through all the posts here, I hope to get it back on track to your original intent.

Political Correctness is here to stay whether people like it or not. There are so many forms of PCs to so many different people. And that’s the crux of matters. There is no such thing as whose definition is right or wrong. Its just PC.

My own take on PC: Its OK. Just some people will take even that simple concept to extremes. They have their own agenda, and that’s fine too. It’s a free country, remember. If PC makes some people happy, and the rest angry or sad, then that’s OK too. No one and everyone is right or wrong, it just a free country…right?

PC is here to stay, but the extremes which some people will take PC to will make people weak. The extremes will make your children weak, and so on and so forth. Why? Think of some of the PC language around. You’re not blind but sight impaired. Blindness is a medical condition, not a state of mind. As such, the language such describe the medical condition, NOT the state of mind. Another example: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (I forgot what’s the new term coined during the Gulf War). The original was just Shell Shock. It was simple, and it quite accurately describe the condition. Now, it sounds mechanical and cold. This are indeed extremes, and that’s why I don’t like the direction of PC language is going. My point is, describe the condition as accurately as possible in the limited English language. Its like putting on knee-pads while walking. I fell a few times, but my knees are still all right. A few bruises and nicks were and are good for me. So too are defeats in competitions. Children will be insulated and protected so much that a small cut will seem like a huge gash. That’s why it will make us, our children, and their children weak.

PC is language used. So do you get the point here? People are still going to be racist if they want to be, or not. Only now, the racists have PC to hide behind. In the words of a friend: “I think the usage of PC language reflect discrimination. In places where racial discrimination's isn't an issue, nobody cares about racial slurs. I think the only reason this is even an issue in the US is because racism is still striving, only nobody wants to look and sound racist. it's all about the appearances…”

I haven’t met anyone yet with blue blood, and my language reflects that. I see you as a person. And so I hope that you’ll see me as a person too. I don’t expect you to, but hope is eternal. PC is not a death knell for the boards. It just a reflection of the posters around here. They view each other as persons, not a brand or a label. It’s an attempt at showing respect and gaining respect. All I accomplish by labeling or branding someone is their anger at me. And then what? I get enough anger and frustration in RL, that I don’t need anymore here in Lit.

And Laurel did not advocate censorship. In fact, I’m scared of her for actually advocating the extreme opposite. Hate Speech benefits only the perpetrators. I live in a multi-cultural society. A Hate Speech can wreck in mere matter of hours and days what took years to accomplish. Peace and neighborliness. So I’m a big advocate of Anti-Hate Speech Laws. Laurel wants them abolished, so that freedom of speech was be ‘Fully’ realized. For me, I don’t want my neighbor burning down my house, just as I don’t want to burn down his house. My parents have lived through a Race Riot, and it wasn’t pleasant. Since when do we actually need another Race Riot? I know that a little revolution now and then is a good thing, but…

Ishmael, PC has its own place in the workplace. I’m a manager myself, and PC gets in the way of profits. Nevertheless, PC is here to stay whether we like it or not. I’ve learnt to live with it, even used it for profits. There’s really no point in arguing the rest of your pseudoarguments. Use whatever means necessary to make profits. (I know. I’m a evil man who is out to drain every last penny from all of you…Muahahaha)

Z
 
obiter dictum

Ishmael brings up a point. Persons of African descent have ruthlessly invaded Detroit(80%+), Washington (75%+), Atlanta (67%+). They've succeeded where the JAPs failed in the early 1990's. So many are pretending to live in a cloaca and them sending their kids to schools specializing only in koniology, what a ruse. Meanwhile everyday they fill up another "high rise" apt building in our urban centers. Somebody needs to stop their empyrean ascension. But what do I know, I'm a mere deipnosophist.
 
Last edited:
Quid quid latine dictum sit, altum viditur

70/30 said:
Ishmael brings up a point. Persons of African descent have ruthlessly invaded Detroit(80%+), Washington (75%+), Atlanta (67%+). They've succeeded where the JAPs failed in the early 1990's.
That 80% figure has been artificially inflated by the study's unscrupulous author who is blatantly ignoring the fact that Japanese did not, in fact, make any move until December. And even if we take this into account, their incomes still fail to reflect this so-called empyreanism. Therefore you argument is worse than circular: it's polyhedronal.
So many are pretending to live in a cloaca and them sending their kids to schools specializing only in koniology, what a ruse. Meanwhile everyday they fill up another "high rise" apt building in our urban centers. Somebody needs to stop their empyrean ascension. But what do I know, I'm a mere deipnosophist.
I can't believe you are actually suggesting that "high rise" apt buildings are not oppressive - they are single handedly responsible for the lack of affordable cloacas. But you are forgetting that:
  1. the fact that a few black people are invading Detroit does not invalidate my pervious argument
  2. the exact size of most cloacas is still unknown to modern science
  3. and the history of human kind actually contains very few examples of urban centers
If you wish to continue to hold this rediculous position, explain to me how you can possibly affirm that koniology is a cultural product, while simultaneously claiming to be a deipnosophist?
 
Hey Zircon...

Your reply was interesting, and just reinforced my position against PC and the facists supporting it. At the end of your post you forgot to say, "Sieg Heil"!
Go to the thread on "what era would you live in?" You can then enter "Germany-1922 to 1939' you have a great mentality for "Krystal Nacht".
:D
 
I'm a commie, nazi pinko, socialist! Muahahahahah

Right, 'cause the Nazi's were so very, very against hate speech - oh, and were terribly PC too, insisting that all the death camps have affirmative action to make sure homosexuals and the mentally handicapped got proportional representation.

And Hitler, that tireless fighter for minority rights, was extremely concerned about the lack of Catholics in the camps as well. Those impassioned speeches he made, concerning the oppression within society that prevented Catholics from being gassed and incinerated would bring a tear to the eye of any advocate of PC.
 
Back
Top