Pollitical Corectness

Dougy said:
I think no one is buying into your original question. The premise is bad. Is political correctness taken overboard at times? Certainly. But at the same time, society does not change it's views just because it wants to. Political correctness is, theoretically, the front of a change in society to a more accepting manner.
This just may force me to start an annoying thread some time...

Oh horse shit modern PC isn't the "front of a change in society to a more accepting manner" it is the fear of looking like a bigot or offending someone simply because they claim minority status or claim to be persecuted in some way it is pollitical bullshit. Plain and simple.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Pollitical Corectness

Dougy said:

I am not saying that isn't to a great extent what we have now, but you seem content with that.

Look I don't think it's a good thing but I think it isn't going away.

What I don't like is people wanting freedom for themselves but not granting equal freedom for everyone!

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
PC hmmm

- think it is quite interesting and the person below said it better than me

Quote
the fact that in today's society where we believe in free speech, the right to an opinion.. People who don't believe in being non-sexist, non-ageist, non-racist and non-everything else are shunned in society ... they are in fact discriminated against!

So where the fairness in that.

Hypothetically, I'm not allowed to tell people jokes that rely on people's differences for their humour without being discriminated against. I'm not allowed to call a blackman (I'm white) a nigger..

Yet his friend (also black) can!

A girl can tell people she's a slapper, but If I mention it, I get called a sexist bigot!

As you can tell, this annoys me!

I'm allowed to vote for any political party I want, but should I decide the National front are the best party to serve my interests, I'm automatically a Nazi. Yet, I could vote for the extreme left and not suffer half the abuse from the general public!

I could decide that hunting is a good idea, due to benefits it brings the area that it is practised, and I would be deemed a heartless thug who scores lower than a child eating cannibal - This world has gone insane!

Political correctness is an evil that the general public have been subjected to for far too long. Unfortunately, its believers are in a role that puts them out the debating distance of the public. They are the media, the academic establishments, the people who work within our social services. The jobs that they are paid for is done very well within the confines that they have to work with, unfortunately, they have also helped teach their warped sense of right and wrong to people who are unable to get a balanced view.

I was taught at school that there is no difference between black and white, between male and female, and in a very simplistic way, there isn't. But, it's the little differences that are not being honoured. The differences between one cultures work ethic and another's sense of balance between what's important and what isn't. Political correctness stops this from being broadcast.

Ask a girl at the age of 8 what she wants to do when she grows up, and the answer is get married and have kids. How sweet! Should you ask an 18yr old the same question and get the same answer ... we will hear a much harsher reaction.

Much the same happens when a small white 10yr old boy points and stares at a black man.. Its considered cute.. Do the same at 20 and it's a Nazi salute! Not everybody lives in a Multicultural City.. And it seems unfair to make everybody conform to the beliefs of those who do.
 
meop79 said:
Oh horse shit modern PC isn't the "front of a change in society to a more accepting manner" it is the fear of looking like a bigot or offending someone simply because they claim minority status or claim to be persecuted in some way it is pollitical bullshit. Plain and simple.

But at the same time, we have a generation of children that are growing up with these PC ideas rooted in society. The process of change is a slow one. That some people attempt to exploit the situation for political or personal gain is an unfortunate side effect.

I think for this discussion to continue in a valid direction, you need to narrow it down a bit. What is your real issue here?
 
Gord said:
the fact that in today's society where we believe in free speech, the right to an opinion.. People who don't believe in being non-sexist, non-ageist, non-racist and non-everything else are shunned in society ... they are in fact discriminated against!

You mean it's hard being a bigot in the year 2002? When they start rounding up all the bigots, make them worth 7/8 of a person, deny them the vote, and force them into slavery, they will have my heartfelt sympathy. Until then, I'm not particularly sad that when a person makes a racist comment, other people tell them they disagree.

Hypothetically, I'm not allowed to tell people jokes that rely on people's differences for their humour without being discriminated against. I'm not allowed to call a blackman (I'm white) a nigger..

You're not allowed? I forget...what's the jail sentence for telling a Black joke these days? Is making a sexist joke a misdemeanor or a felony?

The plain fact is that in the US right now, you are legally free to be as prejudiced and racist as you like, and I think that's as it should be. But it's ridiculous for you to expect that you and only you are allowed to have opinions, and that other "PC" people should not be allowed to express theirs. You can tell a racist joke, and they can either laugh or criticize or whatever. They too are free to have their opinion, just as you are.

There was a time when a large segment of the US population couldn't vote, couldn't own property, couldn't earn a living wage, and were legally considered sub-human. To try to claim that the fact that you may or may not get upbraided for telling a racist joke in public makes you all "oppressed" makes me want to buy you all sense of perspectives for your birthdays.
 
Gord, the fact is that there is no overriding morality out there. It is determined by your actions and the reaction of those around you. That is just how society works...you do something and people think it is bad, or that they should think it is bad, and they will react. If your intentions are misinterpreted, so be it...you have the chance to defend yourself, but don't expect the process of socialization to hold people back from disapproving.

The fact that what people buy into is controlled by the media to a great extent is certainly not good, but mass dispersal of messages has always been an issue...we just have much larger numbers we are dealing with now.
 
Laurel said:




You're not allowed? I forget...what's the jail sentence for telling a Black joke these days? Is making a sexist joke a misdemeanor or a felony?

Its is actually against the law in the UK - people have lost jobs etc

the point I am making - it is Ok to make jokes against Irish, polish, scots, austrians australians, south africans etc but then certain nationalities sometimes have a sense of humour breakdown and the PC police are called out.

It is a difficult subject to talk about but it deserves debate - after the Stephen Lawrence killing in the UK - the country went through a bit of soul searching - according to certain commentators Britain as a whole is institutionaly a racist country as are the police etc

the above quote was taken from a site called www.ironic.org.uk -
 
Last edited:
Ah...okay. I know the UK and places like France have hate speech laws, and that's unfair. I don't support that at all. I think controlling what people say only worsens the problems and deprives people of their right to an opinion. Uncool.
 
Laurel said:
Ah...okay. I know the UK and places like France have hate speech laws, and that's unfair. I don't support that at all. I think controlling what people say only worsens the problems and deprives people of their right to an opinion. Uncool.

it is a minefield sometimes - I appreciate the history of oppression for many nationalities throughout the world. But I do get a bit exasperated ( ? ) sometimes

You can tell jewish jokes but only if you are jewish, black jokes but only if you are black, white anglo saxons are fair game to anyone ! - the scots well we are all tight arses who eat deep fried mars bars and drink a bottle of whisky a day, the Irish - enough said
 
So instead of simply coming out and making a law you tell everyone that anyone who thinks that way is automatically evil... shit that's where those laws come from.

We here in the good old us of a ren't that far away from it....

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
I really don't understand it PC, the entire Idea screms opression... what do you really want an orwelian state? 1984 scared me but that book is in at least some instances already true!

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
meop79 said:
I really don't understand it PC, the entire Idea screms opression... what do you really want an orwelian state? 1984 scared me but that book is in at least some instances already true!
There's no enforcement...you can't act like there is something Orwellian going on when there isn't anything behind it.

1984 scared me too...the Reagan years were terrifying.
 
meop79 said:
So instead of simply coming out and making a law you tell everyone that anyone who thinks that way is automatically evil... shit that's where those laws come from.

We here in the good old us of a ren't that far away from it....

Who is "you", and who is "everyone"?

Why is it okay for "you" to express your opinion, but no one else is allowed to say you're wrong?

You're saying that you should be allowed to express yourself and if anyone else disagrees, that's tantamount to legal oppression. Am I wrong here?
 
3/5ths of a person, kitty mama. they were counted as 3/5ths of a person. the 3/5ths Compromise.

that just makes it even worse.
 
Heather has two mommies - very funny

and the three of them go to the Zoo Rainforest Education Center together
a children's book sponsored by the Massachusetts Institute of Appropriate Inclusivity (formerly "Political Correctness" until that term was co-opted by the white power elite as a tool for attacking multiculturalism).

Crystal Spirit Wolfrunner, one of Heather's mommies, took Heather on a photo safari to the zoo rainforest education center one day. There were a lot of people crowding around the animals because it was Memorial Day weekend. Crystal, a woperson of noncolor, doesn't like to wait on line because she is a little bit bitchy patience-challenged.
"How come you are so mean, mommy?" Heather asked.

"Don't say 'mean', Heather; I prefer 'aggression-enhanced.'" Crystal corrected. "It is probably because I used to be a man's girlfriend, er... unpaid sex worker. Actually, the best term to use is probably acquaintance rape survivor."

"How come that man next to us has such a big lens," Heather asked. "Is he sexually inadequate?"

"Remember not to be judgmental, Heather," Crystal replied. "Just because a white oppressor has a lens that costs and weighs more than a used car, that doesn't mean he is performance-challenged."


"That polar bear is really lazy, Mommy."

"Just as all lifestyles and all people are equally good, so are all animals. Try to put aside the shackles of the phallocentric Dead White European Male indoctrination that you get in school. The bear might just be a tad energetically-challenged. You haven't seen him in his other moods.. Maybe he just finished reading a long book."

"Bears are illiterate!" Heather insisted.

Crystal slapped physically encouraged her. "Don't use that word. He might be alternatively schooled. He's not an ignoramus, just a knowledge-base nonpossessor."

"'Illiterate', 'alternatively schooled', whatever. He has body odor," Heather sniffed.

"That's only nondiscretionary fragranant
"But mommy, aren't some animals superior to others?" Heather asked. "I mean some are a lot prettier than others."
"Of course not dear. They don't have any worms here," Crystal responded, "but here's an exhibit comparing the aesthetic qualities of the flamingo and the average MIT student. Can you even tell which is which?"

"Isn't the MIT student the one lying on the rock picking his nose?" Heather answered.

"Very good, darling. Now I'm sure you see that the world isn't quite as black & white (African-American & genetically oppressive) as the Republicans would have you believe."




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"When you grow up to be a womyn," Crystal began, "you'll definitely want to have a little kitty. Would be choose a striped one?"
"No!"

"How about spotted?"

"No!"

"What about the world's second-fastest land animal?"

"I don't want any cat. Want a doggy," Heather insisted.

"Why, Heather! Didn't we teach you that dogs are the traditional pet of the oppressive white male establishment? You just need a little kitten with a good appetite that will grow up to be big and strong."

"I want a pet with more than a 2-volt brain," Heather wailed. "Besides, cats are mean killers who wait for cute little birds."



"I don't even understand why God created cats," Heather continued.

"Created? Where did you learn that," Crystal scowled.

"In my public school!"

"Don't you know that Creationism shouldn't be taught in public school?" Crystal asked.

"Why not?"

"Because it isn't scientifically proven, like everything else you are learning, e.g., "poor people are stupid, which is why they are poor; rich people are smart," "you will die if you smoke marijuana," "Internet is 80% pornography," "war is bad because it hurts people," "universities are ivory towers of intellectual inquiry," "the government is your friend," "tax increases [revenue enhancements] are good because they help teachers," "Bill Clinton is a great humanitarian."

"But I don't believe in evolution!" Heather insisted.

"Why not?" her mommy asked. "Didn't I introduce you to those nice MIT graduate students who explained it to you."

"They said we evolved from apes, but just looking at them, I could tell the process was far from complete

"You shouldn't be so obsessed with body shape," Crystal corrected. "All womyn, for example, are equally beautiful as they perform the unpaid work of social reproduction of the labor force. If you don't agree, you are a looksist."

"What's a looksist?"


"Someone who believes that people look different," Crystal explained. "Take this rhino and cougar for example. One might look more wrinkled (differently smooth) than the other to your untutored eye, but after statistical species norming methods are employed they are just the same."

"What else can you do with statistical species norming methods?" Heather wondered.

"Oh, many, many things my dear..."

"You can show that these two quadrupeds are equally good with children..."


"... or that these two are the same weight."


Heather says she hopes you have learned something from this little book, that you didn't have to hop from one section to another, that you didn't get into a fight with your little brother or that if you did, you made up .
Thank you for visiting the zoo wildlife preservation center.
 
Your problem is probably not with political correctness, but it’s parent, moral relativism. That movement which says that it is incorrect to blame others, that expecting people to be responsible for their actions somehow infringes upon their personal freedom. The things you cannot say about others tend to be in the nature of value judgments. If you judge someone, then you have victimized them.

When you look around and see moral-less leaders, business people, clergy, teachers, cops, government workers, health-care workers, etc…

Then you see what happens in a world with no moral code. What’s the Latin? Caveat Emptor?
 
sigh being political correct isnt a law or anything it doesnt infringe on anybodys freedoms ... its about having respect and being polite ... if you dont want to be polite then fine dont be call me whatever kind of horrible names you want to for being a lesbian ... but you will lose my respect


that is what political correctness is i dont understand why people have such a hardtime with it or understanding it ... its usually people that object to it in the first place that make up all these stupid storys about how its destroying freedom of expression
 
That's typical of my post. If you are tolerant of others and their weaknesses, you will let names roll off you back instead of society fixing whatever has hurt recently, so to speak. Plus, they probably don't give a damn about your respect if they don't respect you in the first place. Some people just broke, wired wrong as Vonnegut might pen...

Not to attack you, I don't intend for things to get personal, just playing off a point of view. Thanks.
 
Dougy said:

There's no enforcement...you can't act like there is something Orwellian going on when there isn't anything behind it.
1984 scared me too...the Reagan years were terrifying.

You're a fool and if you think there is no enforcement you are a stupid one. There simply isn't any official enforcement.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
sexy-girl said:
sigh being political correct isnt a law or anything it doesnt infringe on anybodys freedoms ... its about having respect and being polite ... if you dont want to be polite then fine dont be call me whatever kind of horrible names you want to for being a lesbian ... but you will lose my respect

that is what political correctness is i dont understand why people have such a hardtime with it or understanding it ... its usually people that object to it in the first place that make up all these stupid storys about how its destroying freedom of expression

I would never do such a thing and anyone who called somsuch names because they were the way they were would lose my respect but as SINthysist said it is becoming almost impossible to make any moral judgements ALL

It's a shame you feel that way because as the freedoms are lost your freedomgo with them.... even if you don't see it.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
meop79 said:


I would never do such a thing and anyone who called somsuch names because they were the way they were would lose my respect but as SINthysist said it is becoming almost impossible to make any moral judgements ALL



Meop79@yahoo.com

Impossible to make moral judgements?....people in this country do it every day...

the difference is that now those who you judge come right back and give it back to you...

The interesting thing about political correctness is that, in the past, if you called some one a fag....they would run away and cower...now they come back at you full force.

In this country you can still say just about anything you want (still can't yell fire in a movie theater) but better get ready for reprisals
 
meop79 said:
You're a fool and if you think there is no enforcement you are a stupid one. There simply isn't any official enforcement.

You still haven't answered my question.

Why is it okay for you to have an opinion on other people's actions and words, but no one is allowed to criticize your actions and words?
 
Laurel said:

You still haven't answered my question.

Why is it okay for you to have an opinion on other people's actions and words, but no one is allowed to criticize your actions and words?

Criticism is fine but the point is it doesn't stop their I would love it if it did because you might actually get open discussion of issues instead of the fragmand cliquishness this country is developing. Instead as aformer poster put it you get "reprisals" you could lose your job, or be sued. Or simply be slandered in a way that is impossible to combat.

Meop79@yahoo.com
 
Mountain Man said:
In this country you can still say just about anything you want (still can't yell fire in a movie theater) but better get ready for reprisals

Exactly.

People want to be able to criticize gays, Blacks, the Church, people with short legs, whoever. You can do that. You should ALWAYS be able to do that. However, to then allow no one else to criticize YOU is against the concept of Free Speech.
 
meop79 said:
Criticism is fine but the point is it doesn't stop their I would love it if it did because you might actually get open discussion of issues instead of the fragmand cliquishness this country is developing. Instead as aformer poster put it you get "reprisals" you could lose your job, or be sued. Or simply be slandered in a way that is impossible to combat.

The person who mentioned getting sued or losing their job resides in the UK, where hate speech IS an actual crime. I think that's wrong.

What do you mean "be slandered in a way that is impossible to combat"?
 
Back
Top