Constructive Living

I have memory of my past lives but I am not typical. I am able to live in this place and time so that I can have the life I am supposed to have here and now. Most people don't have the ability to separate those lifetimes which is why the forgetting exists. In order to be able to accomplish what you must now, you have to focus on now.

Has your past life memories helped you with your current life problems or situations in any way, shape or form?
 
Right. Pain is bad. I'm clear on this.

It's a learning tool, but it's paradoxically not a teaching tool.

You can learn from pain, but the results are entirely spotty if it's all about oneness. It is however very effective in making people more separate.

Seriously, the fastest way to ultimate oneness is suicide, and that just seems wrong somehow.

I can see that I have no hope of winning here, I am out matched. I do enjoy reading your words for they are well woven. Good and evil? The meaning of life? I have given up seeking the answers to these questions long ago. I am fascinated by those still seeking and will join in occasionally. Is there a light at the end of the tunnel? There is only one way to find out, yet most of us run away kicking and screaming from the answer's source, which of course is death itself. Pain is there to ultimately force us to accept death. I have heard loved ones ask for the relief death offers.

I will be the one kicking and screaming right up to the last gasp.
 
Again all this is a matter of perspective. The world is what it is because of the combination of our choices and decisions. The idea that it's a mess is a perspective. I don't see it as a mess. I see it as a combination of everyone's outcomes, and effecting change in the world comes from everyone learning and experiencing and growing and passing the knowledge of experiences in the here and now on to those that come after. Not all lessons have to be learned through pain. They can be learned through joy, and they can be learned through watching and listening to others and applying what we've learned, even things we've learned in a past life which are so ingrained in our soul that they can't be forgotten.

I have memory of my past lives but I am not typical. I am able to live in this place and time so that I can have the life I am supposed to have here and now. Most people don't have the ability to separate those lifetimes which is why the forgetting exists. In order to be able to accomplish what you must now, you have to focus on now.

I don't think it's about perspective. I think it can come down to what's comfortable to believe, what makes it seem like there's a purpose and a path, when there really may not be one.

Are you positive those are memories and not fantasies? Are you sure that your mind didn't make up some comfortable cocoon for you to shield you from some fairly nasty truths?

I'm not as sure as you. I have no problem believing that the Akashic records can be accessed, but I am not so sure that the ability to read them means you yourself lived those things.

I think you sound like someone who is filling in the blanks with certainties that are not self evident and are faith based. I'm not big on faith.

Are you sure you're not simply reading a book about the past due to your connection to all things, and then assuming you lived the book?

I believe that time, all existence, is available NOW. We can intuit it and access it, even if we only appear to travel in one direction that's the illusion.

But I think we over-identify with each detail as if it were all about us. I think that's a design flaw.
 
I can see that I have no hope of winning here, I am out matched. I do enjoy reading your words for they are well woven. Good and evil? The meaning of life? I have given up seeking the answers to these questions long ago. I am fascinated by those still seeking and will join in occasionally. Is there a light at the end of the tunnel? There is only one way to find out, yet most of us run away kicking and screaming from the answer's source, which of course is death itself. Pain is there to ultimately force us to accept death. I have heard loved ones ask for the relief death offers.

I will be the one kicking and screaming right up to the last gasp.

Oh.

Dude, I'm not trying to win. I'm just talking here.

I can't wait to die, it sounds cool. I have to restrain myself from rushing the process.
 
I can see that I have no hope of winning here, I am out matched. I do enjoy reading your words for they are well woven. Good and evil? The meaning of life? I have given up seeking the answers to these questions long ago. I am fascinated by those still seeking and will join in occasionally. Is there a light at the end of the tunnel? There is only one way to find out, yet most of us run away kicking and screaming from the answer's source, which of course is death itself. Pain is there to ultimately force us to accept death. I have heard loved ones ask for the relief death offers.

I will be the one kicking and screaming right up to the last gasp.

i'm not really sure that we are supposed to know how we will react until that moment arrives.

i am scared shitless right now but i watched my dad face death with grace, dignity and a certain amount of calmness. i hope to God i inherit some wonderful gene from him, so that i can go so gracefully.


.
 
Last edited:
i am not sure i agree with this. the external world cannot be known entirely. it is impossible. knowing everything is not something anyone could ever achieve, we are just not the centre of it all. we have to work with the little information that we are given and that we find along the way.

I'm not talking about knowing everything or knowning it entirely. I'm talking about being open to what signs there are in the external world that provide that information. Concrete facts that are there if you look for them, divine how to find them, and are able to see them as what they are.

As a scientist you form a hypothosis because you see a reaction and wonder if something else was done what the possible outcomes could be. Many times a scientist misses what is there because they are looking for another possible outcome. It's not until they go back and rethink what the answer could be and test for it that they find it. It's the same in the introspection. Sometimes I have to look at and then act on something see that it's wrong, and then rething it and act again until you get it right.
 
Last edited:
Ahahaha thanks Reci perhaps you are right and I appreciate you asking me to quesition that.
But I know what my own experiences have been. I've been questioning all these things for some time now and this is the path I have come down. Whether you follow me there is up to you. Plus that, I think I've hit your wall.

Let me expain something to you. This is no comfortable cocoon I sit in. Right now, for the first time in my life I'm out of the cocoon that I was in for the first 40 years of my life. I'm allowing myself to feel and to understand. What I'm learning provides me no comfort and no shelter (that's something I have to create for myself or accept it from those willing to offer it when I can) it only makes me far more aware of how alone in this process of living my life am.

I have read a number of books but the only way that I can understand the truth of what is in them is through seeking and experiencing for myself, and trying not to hold life at bay. It is what it is.

ETA: What I'm doing is not coming up with faith based ideas to fill in the blanks. I'm using logic to try and dermine what the possible answers are. After having worked through each one this is where I've landed.

I don't think it's about perspective. I think it can come down to what's comfortable to believe, what makes it seem like there's a purpose and a path, when there really may not be one.

Are you positive those are memories and not fantasies? Are you sure that your mind didn't make up some comfortable cocoon for you to shield you from some fairly nasty truths?

I'm not as sure as you. I have no problem believing that the Akashic records can be accessed, but I am not so sure that the ability to read them means you yourself lived those things.

I think you sound like someone who is filling in the blanks with certainties that are not self evident and are faith based. I'm not big on faith.

Are you sure you're not simply reading a book about the past due to your connection to all things, and then assuming you lived the book?

I believe that time, all existence, is available NOW. We can intuit it and access it, even if we only appear to travel in one direction that's the illusion.

But I think we over-identify with each detail as if it were all about us. I think that's a design flaw.
 
Last edited:
Ahahaha thanks Reci perhaps you are right and I appreciate you asking me to quesition that.
But I know what my own experiences have been. I've been questioning all these things for some time now and this is the path I have come down. Whether you follow me there is up to you. Plus that, I think I've hit your wall.

Let me expain something to you. This is no comfortable cocoon I sit in. Right now, for the first time in my life I'm out of the cocoon that I was in for the first 40 years of my life. I'm allowing myself to feel and to understand. What I'm learning provides me no comfort and no shelter (that's something I have to create for myself or accept it from those willing to offer it when I can) it only makes me far more aware of how alone in this process of living my life am.

I have read a number of books but the only way that I can understand the truth of what is in them is through seeking and experiencing for myself, and trying not to hold life at bay. It is what it is.

ETA: What I'm doing is not coming up with faith based ideas to fill in the blanks. I'm using logic to try and dermine what the possible answers are. After having worked through each one this is where I've landed.

Yes, oh Great Oz.

Seriously, lighten up. I'm debating ideas, not your life.
 
Yes, oh Great Oz.

Seriously, lighten up. I'm debating ideas, not your life.

Then if you're debating ideas why did it descend to an attack on how I've drawn my conclusions?

As it happens, I'm not offended at all. I've actually been enjoying it.
 
Then if you're debating ideas why did it descend to an attack on how I've drawn my conclusions?

As it happens, I'm not offended at all. I've actually been enjoying it.

Me too. I thought the Oz thing would crack you up.

I'm questioning your logic.

What for you is entirely solid ground for me is fraught with peril.

Peril, I say.

The peril here is truly one of thinking you're much more clear on something than you actually are.

Divination and assuming what is forward is clear because of what's gone before...has no real historical precedent.

Historically that's called Hubris. Greek thingy.
 
Last edited:
Has your past life memories helped you with your current life problems or situations in any way, shape or form?

I'm very sorry that I missed this before.

Yes. It's helped me to understand some of why certain things are happening in this lifetime now. It's also helped me to understand why I am the way that I am. For anyone else though, I'm not certain that remembering them is the best thing. It can cause your focus from the here and now to drift recking havoc with your life. For me it's part of my here and now, something I need to know exists.
 
Me too. I thought the Oz thing would crack you up.

I'm questioning your logic.

What for you is entirely solid ground for me is fraught with peril.

Peril, I say.

The peril here is truly one of thinking you're much more clear on something than you actually are.

Divination and assuming what is forward is clear because of what's gone before...has no real historical precedent.


LOL The Oz thing did crack me up.

Yes I know, but I didn't get here overnight Reci. The Spirtual side of me has been trying to get me to acknowledge it for years. Once I did start to accept the floodgates opened and everything made sense. That doesn't mean that I still don't struggle, I do.

I never assume what is forward is clear. I see all the possible paths one can be going down and in particular the one they are on now if they stay on it. We do, however, have free will as do others and these things can change.
 
LOL The Oz thing did crack me up.

Yes I know, but I didn't get here overnight Reci. The Spirtual side of me has been trying to get me to acknowledge it for years. Once I did start to accept the floodgates opened and everything made sense. That doesn't mean that I still don't struggle, I do.

I never assume what is forward is clear. I see all the possible paths one can be going down and in particular the one they are on now if they stay on it. We do, however, have free will as do others and these things can change.

Okay.

It's just that you were expressing being in a difficult position early in the thread and then got all "you know all the answers" thingy and then started to say something about my wall, which totally just seemed silly.

You wobble between your faith in knowing the answer and lamenting that you don't know the answer exactly and I find that to be a little bit of yarn that I play with like a kitten until you unravel.

I'm saying that less certainty, not more, is not "giving up" or "unrealistic" - but it's human.

The human brain has lots and lots of flaws. I don't think you're always taking yours into account, and you want your brain and the universe to be perfectly logical and accountable. I find that to be...charming and Ozlike.

I can understand yet not agree.
 
That sounds a lot to me like what you're trying to do is bring awarness to your life. To not simply go through the motions but to be fully present.

That is also the basis of Eckhart Tolle's teachings (The Power of Now and A New Earth), which I started reading recently.
 
Yes, I think guilt is optional. It's a sign that you need to fix something. It's not an end in itself.

I really don't believe that "being wracked by guilt" means anything, unless you do something. I don't care. You don't get credit.

No credit for good intentions, either, if you persist in taking credit for the good intention, yet can't carry through.

Tangential to this is "the Four Agreements" by Don Miguel Ruiz from Olmec traditional teachings.

Agreement 1:

Be impeccable with your word - Speak with integrity. Say only what you mean. Avoid using the word to speak against yourself or to gossip about others. Use the power of your word in the direction of truth and love.

Agreement 2:

Don’t take anything personally - Nothing others do is because of you. What others say and do is a projection of their own reality, their own dream. When you are immune to the opinions and actions of others, you won’t be the victim of needless suffering.

Agreement 3:
Don’t make assumptions - Find the courage to ask questions and to express what you really want. Communicate with others as clearly as you can to avoid misunderstandings, sadness and drama. With just this one agreement, you can completely transform your life.

Agreement 4:

Always do your best - Your best is going to change from moment to moment; it will be different when you are healthy as opposed to sick. Under any circumstance, simply do your best, and you will avoid self-judgment, self-abuse and regret.

I think Western tradition believes too much in cause and effect as absolutes.

Doing good actions sometimes has horrible outcomes. And doing evil actions can be entirely rewarded on earth and I don't believe in heaven and hell, only here and now.

So the concept of Justice (which is a moral idea for me) is a human construct. Balance in nature takes place over time, and humans just are too small of a part of it to really have perspective.

Balance isn't in our inherent natures, balance is what's done to us.

Trying to achieve balance is bloody hard, because we've got that whole second law of thermodynamics working against us.

But trying to achieve balance I think it's the name of the game if I want to understand how and why things work, and the best way I can spend my time.


I've been reading the Four Agreements and have been trying to put them in to practise. It's been quite difficult allowing four seemingly straightforward statements direct my choices and shape my actions.

But what it does - as I think much of what has been discussed here - is take away the chaos, the drama of everything around you. Rather than reacting - sort of like a pinball bumping wildly all over the place - you are making deliberate, mindful choices.

Not taking things personally and not making assumptions have been the most difficult. It seems so natural to react to what others think/say about me. I'm validated (either postively or not) by how I think others see me.

At the risk of sounding totally wimpy, the idea of being aware, of being mindful and deliberate can be scary. Ignorance is bliss and all that...
 
Okay.

It's just that you were expressing being in a difficult position early in the thread and then got all "you know all the answers" thingy and then started to say something about my wall, which totally just seemed silly.

You wobble between your faith in knowing the answer and lamenting that you don't know the answer exactly and I find that to be a little bit of yarn that I play with like a kitten until you unravel.

I'm saying that less certainty, not more, is not "giving up" or "unrealistic" - but it's human.

The human brain has lots and lots of flaws. I don't think you're always taking yours into account, and you want your brain and the universe to be perfectly logical and accountable. I find that to be...charming and Ozlike.

I can understand yet not agree.

And you're starting to condescend. The whole charming and OZ like thing. I'm not living a fantasy. If I were I could change it at will. Unfortunately what I have is with me day in and day out whether I want it there or not. It's been there in small ways through out my life and not accepting it as I should has been my problem all along. As far as saying I've hit your wall I meant you're wall of acceptance. You aren't able to accept what I accept because your path has taken you a different way. That's free will in action.

I'm not saying that I know all the answers. What I've said is not about knowing all the answers, it's about finding them and continuing to learn and grow. That doesn't mean that I don't have struggles and my confusion earlier in the thread was about not knowing which direction to turn which choice to make based on the information that I have. I have to do more soul searching and acting until I get to a place where I have a solution that works for me.

Yes the human brain does have lots of flaws. I know that better than most because I've spent the last 14 years working with people who are developmentally and intellectually disabled. These people have a lot to teach the world about what is important and about what is real because they aren't as hampered with the construct we as humans have created. They teach me everyday something new about myself and about the world. I do take into account my flaws and look for more so I can understand why I am the way that I am.

That's how it is for me.
 
I've been reading the Four Agreements and have been trying to put them in to practise. It's been quite difficult allowing four seemingly straightforward statements direct my choices and shape my actions.

But what it does - as I think much of what has been discussed here - is take away the chaos, the drama of everything around you. Rather than reacting - sort of like a pinball bumping wildly all over the place - you are making deliberate, mindful choices.

Not taking things personally and not making assumptions have been the most difficult. It seems so natural to react to what others think/say about me. I'm validated (either postively or not) by how I think others see me.

At the risk of sounding totally wimpy, the idea of being aware, of being mindful and deliberate can be scary. Ignorance is bliss and all that...

So many of these concepts are like being introduced to the game of Chess. You can grasp the simplicity, but the complexity and variation has to reveal itself through experience.

What amazes me is reading books like "The Four Agreements" over and over through the years and hitting some sort of bit of revelation that makes me think "Was that there before? Did I actually read that before and forgot it or totally missed it?"
 
And you're starting to condescend. The whole charming and OZ like thing. I'm not living a fantasy. If I were I could change it at will. Unfortunately what I have is with me day in and day out whether I want it there or not. It's been there in small ways through out my life and not accepting it as I should has been my problem all along. As far as saying I've hit your wall I meant you're wall of acceptance. You aren't able to accept what I accept because your path has taken you a different way. That's free will in action.

I'm not saying that I know all the answers. What I've said is not about knowing all the answers, it's about finding them and continuing to learn and grow. That doesn't mean that I don't have struggles and my confusion earlier in the thread was about not knowing which direction to turn which choice to make based on the information that I have. I have to do more soul searching and acting until I get to a place where I have a solution that works for me.

Yes the human brain does have lots of flaws. I know that better than most because I've spent the last 14 years working with people who are developmentally and intellectually disabled. These people have a lot to teach the world about what is important and about what is real because they aren't as hampered with the construct we as humans have created. They teach me everyday something new about myself and about the world. I do take into account my flaws and look for more so I can understand why I am the way that I am.

That's how it is for me.

I'm not actually condescending. I'm disagreeing. And I'm doing so in a way that is just pointing to the moon. My moon. If you don't see it, I'm still doing my best to point.

I've had a whole conversation about human nature in general, crack babies and limitations on humans in general, and you're making it about you and your life.

I'm pointing out that that's a function of ego, not being able to apply general principles to anything but yourself.

My point is this - what gives you these special abilities, sets you up as special and makes you more Beloved and special to the Universe than a crack baby?

I'm saying that's not fair. You can take it as a criticism of yourself, I'm directing it toward the Universe at large, you're taking it personally.

I'm saying that your philosophy excuses everything as being a part of a larger plan, while somehow minimizing the suffering of others as "part of a plan" that they can't comprehend or understand.

If you can "understand" all of that, why aren't you outraged on their behalf. Would you really tell someone who is suffering that it's their karma, to their face? That they're diseased, disabled and messed up because they screwed up before and somehow it's all fair?

I don't think it's fair. I resist being led in that direction because I think it minimizes the true immediate nature of suffering to diffuse it over some learning process of a billion years when what it really is is inexplicable and unfixable suffering RIGHT NOW.

I'm not opposed to long-term planning. I'm opposed to applying it to other people to make it all seem like a zero sum.
 
This became about my life when you began attacking my beliefs and how I came to them. I'm not taking anything personally except to respond to personal attacks.

I don't see myself as different or more special than anyone else. I simply see us all as being equal in
our struggles. What is important to you is not necessarily important to anyone else. As far as the crack baby, I'm I outraged? Certainly I am. I'm outraged at the mother for choosing to take crack and for not considering that child. What I have to accept from this is that other people make decisions that make no sense to me but are about other people's logic. Logic I don't understand, but can't change I can try to influence her but that's all. In the end It's up to her
 
I wouldn't know if you were since I dont have a clue what that means.
It means preaching with the intent to convert. Spreading the word with an agenda. I have none here; I just thought people might find the stuff interesting, and I wanted to get back into it myself.
In other words:
Help me to accept the things I cannot change,
Change the things I can
and
the wisdom to know the difference.


Interesting.........



Comshaw
The Serenity Prayer is absolutely in line with most of CL. What a CL instructor does is work with you on the details.
Good stuff here, man. Really.
Thank you.
very interesting reading.
thank Perg.
Many Thanks , Recidiva.
Indeed. Reci and H have kept the thread alive and fascinating.
That sounds a lot to me like what you're trying to do is bring awarness to your life. To not simply go through the motions but to be fully present.

That is also the basis of Eckhart Tolle's teachings (The Power of Now and A New Earth), which I started reading recently.

I'll check them out. Thanks.




I certainly don't mind the tangents and conversations that have taken place here. I really enjoyed reading the thread. But I want to ask if anyone has a specific question or issue they're curious about. What is the CL take on this issue? Anyone wondering anything?
 
Last edited:
This became about my life when you began attacking my beliefs and how I came to them. I'm not taking anything personally except to respond to personal attacks.

I don't see myself as different or more special than anyone else. I simply see us all as being equal in
our struggles. What is important to you is not necessarily important to anyone else. As far as the crack baby, I'm I outraged? Certainly I am. I'm outraged at the mother for choosing to take crack and for not considering that child. What I have to accept from this is that other people make decisions that make no sense to me but are about other people's logic. Logic I don't understand, but can't change I can try to influence her but that's all. In the end It's up to her

A logical challenge in certain circumstances is a different thing from an attack.

Equal in our struggles is what I am disagreeing with. I am asking you to provide evidence or rational thought that backs up how we are equal.

The same way I ask people to explain to me how the concept of heaven, hell, karma, spirit, eternity, redemption, punishment...are practically applied in their lives.

Ultimately I think that there's a place for patience, sense and understanding, and an equal and valid place for anger, waste and cluelessness.

I think they're all part of it, and to value patience, sense and understanding over all, is not (in my opinion and tactics) the choice I make because I don't think they're always valid.

I don't think equality is real. I think it's a comforting thought. I try to eliminate comforting thoughts in my own practice, because if I rely on them, I start to fill in too many blanks. The human mind has evolved to recognize pattern and solve problems. Sometimes the pattern is there. Sometimes it's not and I obsess on the piece of an imaginary puzzle that if I could just get it, all things will make sense, but the puzzle itself is an imaginary construct. It's pretty, and it might even be real, but ultimately it's not useful to anything but my own ego. My forays into abnormal psychology can make myth and dogma seem too much like delusion when it's taken literally. Taken in smaller doses, it's of value. Made absolute and sure, I think it becomes a crutch.

Patience, understanding and forgiveness for the long term, yes. I think that the key to progress isn't absolute closure or understanding, but the tactical ability to accept less than an absolute, forgive life and myself for its imperfection, and move on.

That's the point of this thread. Constructive Living. The difference between what we think and what we do, and which one is of more ultimate value to the beings around us. I discarded karma and "the big picture" because it made me feel insulated from the true horror that I see around me and that I experience. I used the idea like a drug, to give me a destiny and a focus. This is what I did, I'm not saying you're doing it. I'm pointing out how certain thoughts can lead to delusion if you rely on them too much without swapping out other thought processes that are more practical.

This is me living and being constructive in the thread spirit. The thoughts you are expressing, I've encountered in my spiritual path, and I've questioned them and challenging them as I'm questioning and challenging you. It is not personal. It's theoretical.

I would like you to consider that in my own particular way, I'm not attacking, but attempting to provide an insight into a process that I worked long and hard on, and I am presenting a solution to the problem, not more problems.

Paradoxically I believe that the key to being of true service here, is that less is more. Focusing on real problems. Hunger. Pain. Suffering. Relieving those. That's my practice. Not telling people that their hunger, pain or suffering means something. Allowing it to be just what it is, horrible and meaningless and deserving of compassion, not judgment that makes it all okay somehow.

Because people expect a BIG paycheck for all their hunger and suffering and pain. And I don't think they're going to get it, and I think that sucks.

You have to give up your paycheck for it to be service to individual, unique human beings and not service to an idea that's going to pay off like the Karmic Lottery someday.
 
Last edited:
So many of these concepts are like being introduced to the game of Chess. You can grasp the simplicity, but the complexity and variation has to reveal itself through experience.

What amazes me is reading books like "The Four Agreements" over and over through the years and hitting some sort of bit of revelation that makes me think "Was that there before? Did I actually read that before and forgot it or totally missed it?"

I just discovered that book about a year ago, maybe? An easy read, and I feel the same way about reading it and forgetting it.

I need to dig it out again. I'm only half agreeable.

Perg: Good thread. Awareness is something I definitely need to work on.
 
I just discovered that book about a year ago, maybe? An easy read, and I feel the same way about reading it and forgetting it.

I need to dig it out again. I'm only half agreeable.

Perg: Good thread. Awareness is something I definitely need to work on.

I just read it again a few months ago. It's quick and I keep wondering how I miss SO MUCH damned content in such a little book.

But the same happens with "Being Good" by Hsing Yun, "The Tao Te Ching" by Lao Tzu and "Nothing Special" by Charlotte Joko Beck.

I've read them all over and over, I'm totally used to being a dense idiot by now. But it's comforting that there are lots of folks out there a lot smarter than me, even if I can't fit it all in my brain at once.
 
Back
Top