Former youth organizer for AOC busted after urging ‘attack’ on Jewish students at Brooklyn public high school

[JohnEngelman]

Are you trying to claim that if the majority of the voters in the genocidal authoritarian shithole known as Israel were to vote in favor of a referendum calling for the starvation of innocent Gazan children, that would somehow confer "legitimacy" on the current Holocaust being conducted in Gaza?

I would disagree with that.

As an aside, speaking of Holocausts, using your own logic above wouldn't the German people's voting in favor of Adolf Hitler as Chancellor of Germany in the 1930s confer the same sort of "legitimacy" to German extermination camps?

I do not see why there is so much fuss about Palestinian children. Are they cuter than the Israeli children killed by Palestinian terrorists?

 

[JohnEngelman]

You did not make a mistake. Israel uses bunker buster bombs regularly.

BrightShinyGirl reflexively lies, denies and obfuscates reality to preserve the sanctity of the genocidal Israeli narrative.

She refuses to admit that genocidal Israel is conducting a genocidal campaign in Gaza, despite Israeli officials admissions of doing so. Denying bunker buster bombs is so much easier by comparison.

She never admits to error, she doubles down and amps up the volume when confronted.
When cornered, she routinely plays the "Jewish victimhood" card and calls her opponents "antisemites".

She is BrightShinyExample of the desecration of the Jewish faith. Denialists such as her, Noor and JustPlainJeff, all unapologetic advocates of starving innocent children via government policy, are one of the main reasons the reason synagogues burn. This is all a word game to them.

Hitler simply needed "Good Germans" to look the other way while he exterminated "undesirables" in the 1940s.
Netanyahu simply needs "Good Jews" to look the other way while he exterminates "undesirables" in the 2020s.

Those who do not learn from the mistakes of the past yadda yadda yadda.

What you call genocide I call winning a war Hamas started,

The Jews are the Herrenvolk.

BrightShinyGirl does not have blood and soil support for the Children of Israel and the Land of Israel. I do.

 

[rainsol]

Fuck off


Why do I give a shit about your friends?

You dont give a shit about anything or anyone

 

[ll74]

You dont give a shit about anything or anyone

I do actually. Just not most the people here.

 

[glamorilla]

I do not see why there is so much fuss about Palestinian children. Are they cuter than the Israeli children killed by Palestinian terrorists?

If youre going on by production value than no.

 

[RobDownSouth]

I do not see why there is so much fuss about Palestinian children. Are they cuter than the Israeli children killed by Palestinian terrorists?

Always the attempt to pivot away via "whattaboutism" to deflect attention from the deliberate starvation of children.

You're a grotesque human being. The living embodiment of a Jerry Falwell "Christian".

 

[RobDownSouth]

What you call genocide I call winning a war Hamas started,

The Jews are the Herrenvolk.

BrightShinyGirl does not have blood and soil support for the Children of Israel and the Land of Israel. I do.

The two of you support the deliberate starvation of children as an official government policy as a means to accomplish political objectives.

The both of you are utterly devoid of basic human decency

 

[RobDownSouth]

First if my statement is so July 2025 I Was well ahead of the curve on this one. I'm not the expert on digging up ancient posts that the rest of you are but I'm pretty sure sometime around the first Christmas following the attack I was off board with Israel. When they started using bunker buster bombs I was pretty sure they didn't care about the hostages anymore.

I'm hesitant to call Israel genocidal. Right now I still want to blame Nehanyahu but I admit that's a tough sell these days. I'm not down with plague. Sanctions are great but won't happen and I'm not sure what the hell I buy that is made in Israel but I'm sure if it exists its also something where I have minimal choice in the mattter.

The tipping point for me was when guilt-ridden IDF soldiers went to the Israeli press detailing their mental decline after being given the direct order "civilian Project Hannibal". "Project Hannibal" has been a lightening rod for criticism in genocidal Israel for two decades now...."Project Hannibal" instructs Israeli soldiers to shoot to kill their captured fellow soldiers to avoid the inconvenience of the Israeli government being forced to bargain for their release from captivity. "They knew the risk when they signed up" (conveniently overlooking the fact that military service in the Israeli wehrmacht is required of virtually all men and women (36 and 24 months, respectively I believe) with exceptions for the mentally and physically disabled, as well as Orthodox Jews (whose blood is obviously too "sacred" to waste).

"Civilian Project Hannibal" expands Project Hannibal to include any and all Israeli citizens who may have been captured. In the immediate aftermath of the Hamas incursion, IDF soldiers shot and killed at least 15 of their own citizens.

Genuinely curious here: if the deliberate government-sanctioned starvation of innocent children to achieve political objectives does not rise to the level of "genocide" for you personally, what then in the name of God does? I ask this respectfully without rancor, as you seem to be nuanced in your worldview (unlike many of the "hurr durr" reactionaries here).

Does this at least rise to the level of "ethnic cleansing" then?

 

[JohnEngelman]

The two of you support the deliberate starvation of children as an official government policy as a means to accomplish political objectives.

The both of you are utterly devoid of basic human decency

Talk to Hamas about "basic human decency."

 

[JohnEngelman]

Always the attempt to pivot away via "whattaboutism" to deflect attention from the deliberate starvation of children.

You're a grotesque human being. The living embodiment of a Jerry Falwell "Christian".

I was a card carrying member of the Moral Majority, and one of the few who voted Democrat. I was also a charter subscriber of Rev. Falwell's magazine The Fundamentalist. Nevertheless, I have always believed in Darwinian evolution.

 

[JohnEngelman]

The two of you support the deliberate starvation of children as an official government policy as a means to accomplish political objectives.

The both of you are utterly devoid of basic human decency

BrightShinyGirl is a charming and beautiful contributor to the forum here.

You, sirrah, are as arrogant as you are impudent.

 

[Sean Renaud]

What you call genocide I call winning a war Hamas started,

The Jews are the Herrenvolk.

BrightShinyGirl does not have blood and soil support for the Children of Israel and the Land of Israel. I do.

Hamas didn't start the war though. I hate to tell you but history didn't start 10/6.

 

[Sean Renaud]

The tipping point for me was when guilt-ridden IDF soldiers went to the Israeli press detailing their mental decline after being given the direct order "civilian Project Hannibal". "Project Hannibal" has been a lightening rod for criticism in genocidal Israel for two decades now...."Project Hannibal" instructs Israeli soldiers to shoot to kill their captured fellow soldiers to avoid the inconvenience of the Israeli government being forced to bargain for their release from captivity. "They knew the risk when they signed up" (conveniently overlooking the fact that military service in the Israeli wehrmacht is required of virtually all men and women (36 and 24 months, respectively I believe) with exceptions for the mentally and physically disabled, as well as Orthodox Jews (whose blood is obviously too "sacred" to waste).

"Civilian Project Hannibal" expands Project Hannibal to include any and all Israeli citizens who may have been captured. In the immediate aftermath of the Hamas incursion, IDF soldiers shot and killed at least 15 of their own citizens.

Genuinely curious here: if the deliberate government-sanctioned starvation of innocent children to achieve political objectives does not rise to the level of "genocide" for you personally, what then in the name of God does? I ask this respectfully without rancor, as you seem to be nuanced in your worldview (unlike many of the "hurr durr" reactionaries here).

Does this at least rise to the level of "ethnic cleansing" then?

All citizens period. I didn't know any personally but my younger brother worked with a few when he was still working various mall jobs. Israelis living abroad are required to go home and do their time. I'm not certain what mechanisms they have in place to force them to return if they decide not to. Knowing how screwed up our government is I'm not comfortable saying the could claim sanctuary here.

Its not that I don't recognize what they are doing as a genocide. Its that while I acknowledge the mental gymnastics required here I'm trying to separate Netanyahu from Israel as whole. I sure as shit didn't sign off on stuff Trump is definitely green lighting in the region.

 

[Noor]

I intend to vote for Zohran Mamdani because I want to see what a democratic socialist can do. A lot of people are going to try to make Zohran Mamdani fail. I hope he has more sense than to anger Jews in a largely Jewish city.

He already has angered then and said threatening things in the past.

 

[JohnEngelman]

The two of you support the deliberate starvation of children as an official government policy as a means to accomplish political objectives.

The both of you are utterly devoid of basic human decency

What matters is that the Palestinians are losing a war that they provoked. They do not deserve any more sympathy than the Japanese did during World War II. Those who start unjustified wars should not expect food aid from those they attacked until they surrender unconditionally.

 

[JohnEngelman]

[Mamdani] already has angered [New York Jews] and said threatening things in the past.

As an old leftist, in both senses of the world "old," I find that highly unfortunate. During the War in Vietnam I joined the Democratic Socialist Organizing Committee. This later evolved into Democratic Socialists of America, of which Zohran Mamdani is a member. DSOC was strongly supportive of Israel. I even thought about joining Democratic Socialists of America until it came out in support of the Palestinians.

Virtually all contemporary leftists would feel more at home in Israel than in a restoration of Palestine.

 

[YDB95]

I don't want to go away because I like Jews.

If you really do respect them so much, maybe give it a rest with the fawning over them like they're superhuman or something. That can come to feel condescending before very long at all.

 

[JohnEngelman]

Are you trying to claim that if the majority of the voters in the genocidal authoritarian shithole known as Israel were to vote in favor of a referendum calling for the starvation of innocent Gazan children, that would somehow confer "legitimacy" on the current Holocaust being conducted in Gaza?

I would disagree with that.

As an aside, speaking of Holocausts, using your own logic above wouldn't the German people's voting in favor of Adolf Hitler as Chancellor of Germany in the 1930s confer the same sort of "legitimacy" to German extermination camps?

In 1932 Hitler lost a Democratic election to Paul von Hindenburg. Most Germans were unaware of the Holocaust while it was happening and voiced disapproval of it after they learned of it.

 

[JohnEngelman]

I do actually. Just not most the people here.

I am sad, very sad, that you do not appreciate my presence here.

I am glad you are here.

 

[JohnEngelman]

If you really do respect them so much, maybe give it a rest with the fawning over them like they're superhuman or something. That can come to feel condescending before very long at all.

Richard Lynn, The Chosen People: A Study of Jewish Intelligence and Achievement, Washington Summit Publishers, 2011, 408 pp., book review by Byron M Roth

The Chosen People: A study of Jewish Intelligence and Achievement is the most recent work of Richard Lynn dealing with group differences in IQ and their ramifications. As in all of his previous work over the past decade, he substantiates his arguments with huge quantities of empirical data. He advances his positions dispassionately and lets the facts speak for themselves, which they do in impressive, nearly irrefutable fashion. In his previous books he examined racial and ethnic differences in IQ for many groups. The Chosen People is a case study of one distinct group that has shown remarkably similar patterns of achievement in a wide variety of settings.

Professor Lynn begins by pointing out the extraordinary success of Jews in almost every field. In the 19th century the restrictions that had prevented most Jews from advanced nonreligious study began to be lifted in most of Western Europe, and by mid-century, “people began to observe that Jews were outstandingly successful, and began to speculate that this was attributable to their intellect.” (Unless otherwise noted, all quotations are from Professor Lynn.)

At that time the great bulk of Jews were still living in Eastern Europe, but owing to pogroms beginning around 1880, Jews began migrating to Western Europe and especially to the United States. They formed part of the massive immigration to the US in the period from 1880 to 1924.

Prof. Lynn writes:

They arrived as penniless refugees unable to speak the languages of their new countries; they were the “huddled masses” from the most backward region of Europe. Yet by the middle decades of the 20th century, the children and grandchildren of these immigrants were doing far better than their Gentile hosts on all indices of socioeconomic status and earnings and outperforming them by several orders of magnitude in obtaining elite academic distinction . . . .

The development of IQ tests confirmed the impression that Jews were unusually intelligent, and Professor Lynn’s extensive review of the literature indicates that Jews in the US have an average IQ of 110 compared to 100 for other Europeans. This would help account for their outstanding performance in a variety of fields. Though Jews are only about 0.2 percent of the world population, half the world’s chess grandmasters, for example, and 16 percent of Nobel Prize winners for science have been Jews. For Professor Lynn, the purpose of his book “is to document and explain such achievements.”

 

[JohnEngelman]

Hamas didn't start the war though. I hate to tell you but history didn't start 10/6.

The Palestinians are the only people I know who continue to demand unconditional surrender and extinction from a country that has defeated them many times in the past.

 

[YDB95]

Richard Lynn, The Chosen People: A Study of Jewish Intelligence and Achievement, Washington Summit Publishers, 2011, 408 pp., book review by Byron M Roth

Even Richard Lynn himself thought Richard Lynn was a racist. He literally identified as a "scientific racist", and he was editor in chief of a white supremacist journal, Mankind Quarterly. In other words, you are not helping your case at all here.

 

[JohnEngelman]

Even Richard Lynn himself thought Richard Lynn was a racist. He literally identified as a "scientific racist", and he was editor in chief of a white supremacist journal, Mankind Quarterly. In other words, you are not helping your case at all here.

 

[ll74]

I am sad, very sad, that you do not appreciate my presence here.

I am glad you are here.

If it has made you all the sads, perhaps you can start a GoFundMe for proper support. I've been told there are good people out there who will be there for you in your time of need.

 

[JohnEngelman]

Richard Lynn documents his arguments thoroughly.