The final frontier...Legal Sex Work

Beandip478

Really Experienced
Joined
Jul 14, 2022
Posts
265
America has, for the most part, legalized weed. We have legalized gambling, in the Indian gambling casinos, mainly because the state and federal governments make billions in tax revenue from that. But sex work...This "old profession," as they say, although now legal in other Western countries like Denmark, Finland, Canada, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Spain, remains illegal in the U.S., with the exception of a few counties in Nevada.
Now I know what some of you are going to say: "That's because this country was founded by Puritans." That's the usual response. Actually, that isn't true, the Puritans were long dead well before this country was founded, but that is neither here nor there. It is true that the hysterical pseudo-Christians (the ones currently removing naughty books from public libraries) would be in an uproar at the suggestion of legalizing sex work.
However, a couple of generations ago, I think a majority of Americans would have had the same reaction to legalizing weed. It wasn't until the original, post-War Baby Boomers reached the age where they were the ones in charge of most sectors, that weed became decriminalized, because unlike their parents and grandparents who had been thoroughly sold on the "reefer madness" propaganda of their generations, the Boomers, who had spent their high school and college years smoking weed, knew that, first of all, weed was not going to turn people into communists or axe murderers, and, more to the point, that making weed illegal had never and would never stop people from smoking it, any more than Prohibition had stopped people from drinking it. So why not legalize it, tax it, and stop ruining people's lives by sending them to jail for smoking a joint.
Now, does anyone else feel that a similar moment will be reached with regard to sex work? I do. I don't think the Religious Right has the numbers to forever keep sex work illegal, and, as with weed, it is simply not practical to criminalize something which people have always and will always do.
 
Prostitution is not legal in Canada.
If caught purchasing sex, you face a fine and possible jail time.
 
again, i have no problem with adult individuals who wish to sell their sexual services for money. This scenario, with paying taxes and all that's involved with being self-employed should not be counted as illegal.

MOST prostitution is not this scenario, and involves sex workers being controlled and profited off by others in organised crime. It frequently involves the kidnapping/forced sexual enslavement/drug dependency of underage and vulnerable people taken from other countries and brought into America illegally through trafficking.
 
again, i have no problem with adult individuals who wish to sell their sexual services for money. This scenario, with paying taxes and all that's involved with being self-employed should not be counted as illegal.

MOST prostitution is not this scenario, and involves sex workers being controlled and profited off by others in organised crime. It frequently involves the kidnapping/forced sexual enslavement/drug dependency of underage and vulnerable people taken from other countries and brought into America illegally through trafficking.
There have been reports of sex traffickers at our local shopping mall trying to lure teenage girls.

Then there was that Saturday morning where I woke up to an entire SWAT team on my street. Neighbor busted for sex trafficking. šŸ˜®
I was oblivious to the fact that there had been a stake our car parked in front my house for several weeks. The neighbor who got busted lived 5 houses away.
Scary world.
 
The American dollar is losing value much faster than sex work is becoming legal or decriminalized. Barter sex may become more common than cash sex for centuries. Whatever is left of law enforcement then may not care about sex work, except for the officers that expect freebies.
 
I have experienced certain activities with professionals. All but one of eight or so were good experiences.
 
One thought I have had about this is that just as the indigenous peoples were able to introduce legal gambling on their reservations because they don't exactly have to answer to Uncle Sam there, and as I said, the state and federal governments love the taxes they collect from the casinos, the indigenous might be able to introduce legal sex work, as long as it is contained within the casino hotels, and Uncle Sam, again, rakes in tax dollars from it.
Someone else, quite rightly, mentioned the human slavery, human trafficking and pimps that plague the world of sex work. This is the best reason I can think of to legalize it. We could put all those monsters out of business overnight, if done right. Or at least, that would be the hope. If legal, in principle, the sex workers might even be able to turn to law enforcement for protection.
 
One thought I have had about this is that just as the indigenous peoples were able to introduce legal gambling on their reservations because they don't exactly have to answer to Uncle Sam there, and as I said, the state and federal governments love the taxes they collect from the casinos, the indigenous might be able to introduce legal sex work, as long as it is contained within the casino hotels, and Uncle Sam, again, rakes in tax dollars from it.
Someone else, quite rightly, mentioned the human slavery, human trafficking and pimps that plague the world of sex work. This is the best reason I can think of to legalize it. We could put all those monsters out of business overnight, if done right. Or at least, that would be the hope. If legal, in principle, the sex workers might even be able to turn to law enforcement for protection.
Well, again, in Canada any money generated on Indian lands is non-taxable. Any money earned by Indians who work and live on Indian land is non-taxable. So there is no government incentive here to allow sex workers associated with Indian casinos.
 
Well, again, in Canada any money generated on Indian lands is non-taxable. Any money earned by Indians who work and live on Indian land is non-taxable. So there is no government incentive here to allow sex workers associated with Indian casinos.

I see. Well, as for here in the United States, when the gambling casinos started appearing on reservations, because I knew gambling was illegal in America everywhere except a few counties in Nevada and on the boardwalk in Atlantic City, I could only guess that the reason the government had agreed to go along with it was that they had arrived at an arrangement with the indigenous that involved state and federal government collecting some of the profits in taxes. So I asked my father who is a lawyer and knows about this if this was the case, and he smiled and said "Oh yeah." ;-)
 
Makes you wonder if prostitution was legalized (taxed and controlled) how much sex trafficking would go down.
 
Nah I see no reason to make these harlots "work" legal. Pussy is everywhere. Makes as much sense as charging money for water.
 
I think you just made the point. Water isnā€™t always available or always clean yet you can buy it out of a vending machine or convenience store.
 
Sex work will remain illegal in large part because it's very profitable for the law enforcement establishment -- police officers on the take, prosecutors building and maintaining their empires and defense attorneys.
 
Last edited:
America has, for the most part, legalized weed. We have legalized gambling, in the Indian gambling casinos, mainly because the state and federal governments make billions in tax revenue from that. But sex work...This "old profession," as they say, although now legal in other Western countries like Denmark, Finland, Canada, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Spain, remains illegal in the U.S., with the exception of a few counties in Nevada.
Now I know what some of you are going to say: "That's because this country was founded by Puritans." That's the usual response. Actually, that isn't true, the Puritans were long dead well before this country was founded, but that is neither here nor there. It is true that the hysterical pseudo-Christians (the ones currently removing naughty books from public libraries) would be in an uproar at the suggestion of legalizing sex work.
However, a couple of generations ago, I think a majority of Americans would have had the same reaction to legalizing weed. It wasn't until the original, post-War Baby Boomers reached the age where they were the ones in charge of most sectors, that weed became decriminalized, because unlike their parents and grandparents who had been thoroughly sold on the "reefer madness" propaganda of their generations, the Boomers, who had spent their high school and college years smoking weed, knew that, first of all, weed was not going to turn people into communists or axe murderers, and, more to the point, that making weed illegal had never and would never stop people from smoking it, any more than Prohibition had stopped people from drinking it. So why not legalize it, tax it, and stop ruining people's lives by sending them to jail for smoking a joint.
Now, does anyone else feel that a similar moment will be reached with regard to sex work? I do. I don't think the Religious Right has the numbers to forever keep sex work illegal, and, as with weed, it is simply not practical to criminalize something which people have always and will always do.
Something else to consider when discussing the legalization of the sex trade is public health. With legalizing the sex trade, sex workers could then be required to have regular health screenings and be able to provide proof of such to prospective clients. Not as big of a "plus" as income taxes, but would likely help cut down on the spread of STIs.
 
NOT in the state, but only a very few places and one of them is NOT Vegas or Reno.
It is legal in 10 of 17 counties in Nevada. Clark and Washoe counties are among the seven which do not allow it.
 
Back
Top