SecondCircle
Sin Cara
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2012
- Posts
- 1,410
As for the whole literal or figurative tag thing, its been argued in the past about how someone can't "shrug" a word or "smile" a word.
Such as
"I thought it was pretty clever," Dan shrugged.
That's actually the wrong way to do it. One cannot shrug a word. To test this theory, shrug your shoulder and see if words come out.
BUT as a reader when I see stuff like this, I understand what's going on. I get that Dan shrugged as he said that, without having to see it written as robotic as
"I thought it was pretty clever," Dan said with a shrug.
Don't need that. I get it. The former is wrong but it painted the picture for me. So as a reader I'm gonna keep trucking knowing that Dan shrugged when he said that.
I actually prefer more figurative or creative ways of writing, as they paint a picture better than just writing something like a technical manual.
Usually I do avoid it though and go with something like
Dan shrugged. "I thought it was pretty clever."
Such as
"I thought it was pretty clever," Dan shrugged.
That's actually the wrong way to do it. One cannot shrug a word. To test this theory, shrug your shoulder and see if words come out.
BUT as a reader when I see stuff like this, I understand what's going on. I get that Dan shrugged as he said that, without having to see it written as robotic as
"I thought it was pretty clever," Dan said with a shrug.
Don't need that. I get it. The former is wrong but it painted the picture for me. So as a reader I'm gonna keep trucking knowing that Dan shrugged when he said that.
I actually prefer more figurative or creative ways of writing, as they paint a picture better than just writing something like a technical manual.
Usually I do avoid it though and go with something like
Dan shrugged. "I thought it was pretty clever."