The Walking Dead

[Libsam]

Who was the guy by the zombie trap that was looking at Rick & Carl's black & white photos?

Yeah, it was one of the wolf guys, he had a W on his forehead.

Did those pictures come from Morgan's pack or the gay guy's pack? (forgot his name)

p.s. Carol is my kind of tactician! I've always loved her, she has been the most rational character throughout the whole series.

 

[spacekowboy]

The pictures come from Aaron's pack.



Also, I would do bad, bad things to Carol.

 

[Wrong Element]

Yeah, it was one of the wolf guys, he had a W on his forehead.

Did those pictures come from Morgan's pack or the gay guy's pack? (forgot his name)

p.s. Carol is my kind of tactician! I've always loved her, she has been the most rational character throughout the whole series.

That was from the pack of stuff about Alexandria that Aaron shows to recruits.

 

[Libsam]

The pictures come from Aaron's pack.



Also, I would do bad, bad things to Carol.

Great, now the bad guys have intel on the layout of the town.
BTW, did anyone else find the backwards bracing of Alexandria's walls odd? I'm no architect, but that just doesn't seem logical.



skb, bad bad? or like sexy time good-bad?

 

[Sean Renaud]

Yeah, it was one of the wolf guys, he had a W on his forehead.

Did those pictures come from Morgan's pack or the gay guy's pack? (forgot his name)

p.s. Carol is my kind of tactician! I've always loved her, she has been the most rational character throughout the whole series.

What series were you watching? She was at best neutral in S1 vs Shane the most rational by far. In S2 she was batshit crazy until she faded into the background, vs Shane sane until he lost it near end. And still as we find out pretty much the second Shane dies Rick realizes that Shane was just a few steps ahead of him. Probably because Atlanta was BAD and Shane probably went through the same shit in two weeks that Rick went through in 9 months.

In Season 3 she acts on her own. Her decision was proper, but her execution (heh) left a lot wanting that nearly tore the group apart as they panicked about having a serial killer amongst them. Which leads to her getting exiled.

Season 4. . .okay quasi rational. I happen to agree with that cat from Terminus who told us that keeping a baby in a Zombie Apocalypse is something like grabbing an anchor when you're thrown overboard but we are grading on a curve here and nobody would have done otherwise.

Season 5. . .she caused more problems than she solved really. Pete's a surgeon in a zombie apocalypse, in a town that will exile you to protect its own (which it should.) Pragmatism tells us that if he wants to slap his wife around, or even the risk of him killing her REALLY doesn't equal out to the good he's going to do you in the long run. I'm sorry but it doesn't.

Not to mention no other solution was really attempted first.

Rick: Pete hits his wife.
Deana: Yeah, i know. He's surgeon. What are we gonna do?
Rick: Separate them.
Deana: What if he doesn't want to?
Rick: Why don't we try that first and then work on solutions after that fails?

Nope. Carol skips straight to murder.

 

[spacekowboy]

Great, now the bad guys have intel on the layout of the town.
BTW, did anyone else find the backwards bracing of Alexandria's walls odd? I'm no architect, but that just doesn't seem logical.



skb, bad bad? or like sexy time good-bad?

It's structurally sound, but that is not the smartest way to build a wall meant to keep others out. What they would need is a 6 foot deep concrete footer to anchor that wall to.

But that kind of material is scarce.


And sexy good time bad.

 

[Libsam]

What series were you watching? She was at best neutral in S1 vs Shane the most rational by far. In S2 she was batshit crazy until she faded into the background, vs Shane sane until he lost it near end. And still as we find out pretty much the second Shane dies Rick realizes that Shane was just a few steps ahead of him. Probably because Atlanta was BAD and Shane probably went through the same shit in two weeks that Rick went through in 9 months.

In Season 3 she acts on her own. Her decision was proper, but her execution (heh) left a lot wanting that nearly tore the group apart as they panicked about having a serial killer amongst them. Which leads to her getting exiled.

Season 4. . .okay quasi rational. I happen to agree with that cat from Terminus who told us that keeping a baby in a Zombie Apocalypse is something like grabbing an anchor when you're thrown overboard but we are grading on a curve here and nobody would have done otherwise.

Season 5. . .she caused more problems than she solved really. Pete's a surgeon in a zombie apocalypse, in a town that will exile you to protect its own (which it should.) Pragmatism tells us that if he wants to slap his wife around, or even the risk of him killing her REALLY doesn't equal out to the good he's going to do you in the long run. I'm sorry but it doesn't.

Not to mention no other solution was really attempted first.

Rick: Pete hits his wife.
Deana: Yeah, i know. He's surgeon. What are we gonna do?
Rick: Separate them.
Deana: What if he doesn't want to?
Rick: Why don't we try that first and then work on solutions after that fails?

Nope. Carol skips straight to murder.

Yeah, you right, S1 & S2 she was still coming out of her abused woman phase, but after that, I agree with all the decisions she's made.

Glenn is higher than Carol in my death pool.

 

[Sean Renaud]

Yeah, you right, S1 & S2 she was still coming out of her abused woman phase, but after that, I agree with all the decisions she's made.

Glenn is higher than Carol in my death pool.

Even though her plan would have gotten Rick killed if Michonne hadn't saved his ass? And if he'd listened to her plan again instead of Michonne again that at best they would have had to kill everybody in Alexandria and the only reason it would have worked is because their plot armor is so thick that being trapped beneath two walkers with no weapon or in a car with dozens around them is more annoying than deadly?

I can see how you might support her call in S3. Hershel would have shot her down and she wasn't smart enough to think quarantine which ultimately wasn't a good idea anyway. I'm on the fence there.

S4 I can't really blame her much either. But in S5 she's this bad ass fuck up who skips straight to violence instead of thinking and consulting with people she should trust and it nearly gets them all killed. Hell as of the finale the only reason any of this worked out is the dumb luck of walkers getting in and Pete going crazy.

 

[Libsam]

Pete should have been separated from his wife when those people found out what was going on. I would have locked his ass up and made him perform triage for his supper. And No Alcohol, what good is a drunk surgeon? Since Carol was a bystander who couldn't control those decisions, I think her threats were a good idea.

 

[Sean Renaud]

Pete should have been separated from his wife when those people found out what was going on. I would have locked his ass up and made him perform triage for his supper. And No Alcohol, what good is a drunk surgeon? Since Carol was a bystander who couldn't control those decisions, I think her threats were a good idea.

She doesn't even know that they know however. You know that but she didn't have that information. Carol's thought process is Step 1: Murder. Not Step 1: Go to Deanne.

and how often do you need a surgeon, let the fucker drink.

 

[Aquagal]

When's Daryl gonna finally wash his hair?

 

[Beco]

Who was the guy by the zombie trap that was looking at Rick & Carl's black & white photos?

Next season's conflict....

 

[remy_lebeau8]

Carol seems to be getting close to governor levels of manipulation.

 

[Sean Renaud]

Carol seems to be getting close to governor levels of manipulation.

The main difference being Carol almost TPK'd her own team here twice and the governor only lost because the plot hated him with a passion. I mean it starts in on him the moment Michonne and Andrea arrive. Here's how that conversation should have gone.

Michonne: I don't trust it. Nobody leaves.
Andrea: Duh. Do you remember like ten minutes ago. There are things out there that eat you and men who want to rape you, and groups who want to steal your shit.
Michonne: You're right, lets relax and give this place a chance!

Sure she was right but that was just the plot deciding to be nice.

 

[unregistered]

 

[Sean Renaud]

How many zombies is that?

All of them son. The good news is if we're not dead in the morning the apocalypse will be over. OF course the bad news is nobody is making it till morning. At least I got to stab a bitch. I really wanted to stab a bitch.

 

[ms_ann_thrope]

I'm just not a fan of the non-linear timeline.

 

[about_average]

I'm just not a fan of the non-linear timeline.

Yeah, my wife hated it too

 

[ms_ann_thrope]

Yeah, my wife hated it too

I only half watched it. I'll watch it again tomorrow. The show is forcing me to accept a lot of scientifically impossible scenarios...I'm mean, other than a zombie apocalypse. It's getting to the point that Sons of Anarchy or the Sopranos reached, that you just want everyone dead.

 

[Joeybagadonuts]

Did KR Cummings ever come back?

 

[Ulaven_Demorte]

How many zombies is that?

All of them son. The good news is if we're not dead in the morning the apocalypse will be over. OF course the bad news is nobody is making it till morning. At least I got to stab a bitch. I really wanted to stab a bitch.

What they needed was a nice big bonfire in that quarry. Zombie's should burn pretty well, you just need some accelerant and a match. I figure a few well placed barrels of burning kerosene or diesel fuel rolled down into the middle of the quarry would take out a large number of them.

 

[Sean Renaud]

Daryl and Beth tried burning zombies back in Season 4. IT just creates charred zombie. Though I think sitting on the edge with sling shots all day would eventually get the job done.

And no KRC is still gone unless he's here under an alt which is possible.

 

[Fata Morgana]

Why the fuck have we got two threads?

 

[Recidiva]

Why the fuck have we got two threads?

Harder for the zombies to find us.

 

[Sean Renaud]

Because someone named Killswitch didn't check before starting his own thread.