Supernatural!

We don't already have a supernatural thread? Odd. Great show, everybody should watch.
 
We don't already have a supernatural thread? Odd. Great show, everybody should watch.

I don't know, do we? I haven't seen it.

There's been a lot of really good new shows this season, I've been happily surprised.

This is just a great returning favorite.

Although no Crowley in the first episode? What's with that?
 
I'm glad to have that new guy though, I like him a lot. I can deal with Crowley being out of commision. Besides after the last time we saw him I'm a bit terrified he's gonna pop out all sunshine and rainbows.
 
I'm glad to have that new guy though, I like him a lot. I can deal with Crowley being out of commision. Besides after the last time we saw him I'm a bit terrified he's gonna pop out all sunshine and rainbows.

I was hoping he would, the same way I'm happy to have Bobby around as a memory or a ghost or a flashback. Don't care, as long as I get my Bobby.

I love Mark Sheppard. This guy was in Dollhouse and I didn't like Dollhouse.

I figured less sunshine and rainbows and more Spike with the chip in the head.
 
See I hope Chipped Spike but I'm honestly expecting moopy Angel. Hell even spiked and eventually souled spike eventually had Buffy telling him she liked him better when he was trying to kill her!

The worst part is I should have seen this coming early last season because I spent the whole season thinking, "gee Crowley is being such a dick. I mean he's the King of Hell I get it, he's been that for years now and he's usually not vindictive or petty. Now he's just mean for no reason!"
 
Wait...is this really the first Supernatural thread? Damn...

Do we have a Sherlock thread?
 
See I hope Chipped Spike but I'm honestly expecting moopy Angel. Hell even spiked and eventually souled spike eventually had Buffy telling him she liked him better when he was trying to kill her!

The worst part is I should have seen this coming early last season because I spent the whole season thinking, "gee Crowley is being such a dick. I mean he's the King of Hell I get it, he's been that for years now and he's usually not vindictive or petty. Now he's just mean for no reason!"

Yeah, but Spike was James Marsters. Didn't matter what you did to him, the dude was just awesome at everything.

Angel...eh. Not so much. Nothing terribly wrong with David Boreanaz, just nothing...really great either.

Buffy was an idiot. True. Sad but true. Shoulda given the amulet to Angel and run away with Spike. But that's me.

Now there's Sarah Michelle Gellar with Robin Williams (ROBIN WILLIAMS!) and she's trying to hold her own with him. I give the chick credit for saying her lines and not running away crying at how OUT OF HER LEAGUE she is. It's the most sympathetic role she's ever had.

Kelly Clarkson did a great job, but you see the appropriate reaction to being around Robin Williams in the blooper.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzlWeZVBi64
 
Wait...is this really the first Supernatural thread? Damn...

Do we have a Sherlock thread?

I have no idea. I probably started several, but I don't remember.

Sherlock or Elementary, I'm okay with either.
 
I have no idea. I probably started several, but I don't remember.

Sherlock or Elementary, I'm okay with either.
I never got into Elementary...I'm not even sure why though.

You know when the new season (3. Measly. Fucking. Episodes.) of Sherlock is coming out?
 
While I agree that Spike>Angel and James>David (and I like David just fine, he's great as Booth)

Buffy being an idiot is that situational. She made the best call she could. She didn't expect to survive but on the off chance that it did she wanted Spike within shagging distance. She had no idea what the amulet would do, she might very well have given it to Angel if she had. Hopefully she would have given it to her bratty sister who was more than human by that point. The comics though and her life in general show you can't walk away from your fate. The only thing you accomplish is pissing fate off.
 
I never got into Elementary...I'm not even sure why though.

You know when the new season (3. Measly. Fucking. Episodes.) of Sherlock is coming out?

A lot of fans didn't want to watch at all because of the fact that the REAL Sherlock was still alive. Which I sympathize with.

However, I really love both Johnny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu and it dearly feeds my love of trivia. Plus this season they had Rhys Ifans as his brother and how do I not LOVE that? The only time it really failed was in the last few episodes of last season which were dumb and unwatchable and fortunately they snapped out of it.

It sucks that there isn't enough real Sherlock to be had, it's a great series. But I do not get the six episodes done thing. Underachieving!
 
While I agree that Spike>Angel and James>David (and I like David just fine, he's great as Booth)

Buffy being an idiot is that situational. She made the best call she could. She didn't expect to survive but on the off chance that it did she wanted Spike within shagging distance. She had no idea what the amulet would do, she might very well have given it to Angel if she had. Hopefully she would have given it to her bratty sister who was more than human by that point. The comics though and her life in general show you can't walk away from your fate. The only thing you accomplish is pissing fate off.

She broke up with Spike. Unacceptable! Oh well. My universe does not go as Joss Whedon's would.

Dawn got good when she threatened Spike's life. "You sleep, right?" Otherwise I mostly hated her.
 
The lady who gets offended by rape jokes doesn't break up with her attempted rapist. :rolleyes: Don't get me wrong I'm part of the club who thinks that if your first time is so rough you literally destroyed the building you were in that each party gets at least once freebie where not understanding that no means no is pretty much a given but sheesh.

I hated Dawn in season 5, in 6 I didn't mind her for the most part (except in Once More with Feeling. Dear god she does this hip rolly thing and good goddamn I'd devour that) Season 7 I had Andrew to hate but then he started geeking out for me. I can totally see Candi as him. I also didn't really notice her over Willow's whining. By the Comics I wanted her dead again though.

Oh well I can come and go rather quick on some of these guys. Connor I spent a whole season hating. Fucker punched Hamilton once and you'd think I owned shares in the Team Connor Foundation.
 
The lady who gets offended by rape jokes doesn't break up with her attempted rapist. :rolleyes: Don't get me wrong I'm part of the club who thinks that if your first time is so rough you literally destroyed the building you were in that each party gets at least once freebie where not understanding that no means no is pretty much a given but sheesh.

I hated Dawn in season 5, in 6 I didn't mind her for the most part (except in Once More with Feeling. Dear god she does this hip rolly thing and good goddamn I'd devour that) Season 7 I had Andrew to hate but then he started geeking out for me. I can totally see Candi as him. I also didn't really notice her over Willow's whining. By the Comics I wanted her dead again though.

Oh well I can come and go rather quick on some of these guys. Connor I spent a whole season hating. Fucker punched Hamilton once and you'd think I owned shares in the Team Connor Foundation.

Yeah, I'm offended by it in some contexts, yup, jokes count as not a good context.

In this context maybe I just think the writing was so all over the place that certain scenes never made any damned sense to me and that was one of them. It was kinda like "50 Shades of Spike" and was just badly written about evil and BDSM and force and was unbelievably clunky. He was normally written so well and they tried to force the character somewhere he wouldn't have been to make some sort of point I didn't understand. It was like having her work at a burger joint when she could have done anything she damned well wanted to do to make money including pole dancing. Why be miserable and broke and stupid when you have options? Why be so damned uptight, I mean, you were dead. Can we let the huffy bit of our life go and maybe have some fun? Noooo. (*note, rape is not fun. nobody is allowed to say that I said that rape is fun. This is fictional. Fuck off.)

Connor started out SO COOL And then they broke him. Of course. That whole Cordelia thing with her pregnancy was just a clusterfuck.
 
I thought their relationship for the most part made sense. Buffy was ashamed, Spike was enjoying himself and part of the way they communicated was through physical force and with two super powered beings who have proven on multiple occasions (mostly her on him violence) but that a punch to the face was sufficiently acceptable between them that it wasn't a reason to stop a conversation. Just like later on Spike and Angel who have a much more interesting relationship would do the same thing. Hell my favorite was

Angel: You stabbed me.
Spike: There was a thing on your back!
Angel: I think you just like stabbing me with pointy objects
Spike: Well. . .yeah I do.
Angel: (This is the WB so I can't say thing but look into my eyes and gather context. There is CONTEXT!!!!)

Regardless I always felt Spike who may have been justified in his great guilt over it went way too far and Buffy should have flat out told him it was her bust when he returned. Cus it was her bust.

I hated Connor from the word Go. I was amazed my damn self how quickly I was able to go from "Oh stupid Connor on my stupid tv. Fas. . .fuck not a DVD!" to "BEAT HIS ASS! Go CONNOR GO!! Welcome to the Fang Gang, I love you bro!" and he's solid in the comics. So is Lorne until they get rid of him.

The Cordi pregnancy was all over the place, of course that was really Charisma's fault for getting ya know, pregnant.
 
I thought their relationship for the most part made sense. Buffy was ashamed, Spike was enjoying himself and part of the way they communicated was through physical force and with two super powered beings who have proven on multiple occasions (mostly her on him violence) but that a punch to the face was sufficiently acceptable between them that it wasn't a reason to stop a conversation. Just like later on Spike and Angel who have a much more interesting relationship would do the same thing. Hell my favorite was

Angel: You stabbed me.
Spike: There was a thing on your back!
Angel: I think you just like stabbing me with pointy objects
Spike: Well. . .yeah I do.
Angel: (This is the WB so I can't say thing but look into my eyes and gather context. There is CONTEXT!!!!)

Regardless I always felt Spike who may have been justified in his great guilt over it went way too far and Buffy should have flat out told him it was her bust when he returned. Cus it was her bust.

I hated Connor from the word Go. I was amazed my damn self how quickly I was able to go from "Oh stupid Connor on my stupid tv. Fas. . .fuck not a DVD!" to "BEAT HIS ASS! Go CONNOR GO!! Welcome to the Fang Gang, I love you bro!" and he's solid in the comics. So is Lorne until they get rid of him.

The Cordi pregnancy was all over the place, of course that was really Charisma's fault for getting ya know, pregnant.

Well, reality shouldn't intrude into my fantasy.

I guess that is also why I like Supernatural so much. Just as much humor, just as much gore, more actual human interactions that aren't prone to terrible melodrama.

The writing is more consistent and they don't shove characters into spots they shouldn't belong. They either write a new character or make a story to match.

I'm proud of 'em for the lack of actual melodrama while real drama is the background.
 
I don't know if the writing is more solid. Season 6 of both shows are pretty much worthless with a few redeeming qualities. And Supernatural is way more melodramatic than Buffy.

I'm just curious how many more trips Sam and Dean need to the afterlife before they get a free soft serve ice cream. At least this year it doesn't look like there will be any "Boo hoo, why did/didn't you save me!" I swear if I had to put up with that for another half a season I was going to shive myself in the eye just to alleiviate the pain.
 
I don't know if the writing is more solid. Season 6 of both shows are pretty much worthless with a few redeeming qualities. And Supernatural is way more melodramatic than Buffy.

I'm just curious how many more trips Sam and Dean need to the afterlife before they get a free soft serve ice cream. At least this year it doesn't look like there will be any "Boo hoo, why did/didn't you save me!" I swear if I had to put up with that for another half a season I was going to shive myself in the eye just to alleiviate the pain.

Awww...

I guess I don't see it. I see most of the writing done with some balance of humor in mind. There's less throwing under the bus and more honesty and genuine understanding. Maybe it's just more in tune with the way I deal with people.

I love Joss Whedon though. The S.H.I.E.L.D. thing isn't as good as I'd hoped.
 
There is plenty of good to decent humor, even occasionally some great stuff. I think I wouldn't be nearly as annoyed if the series wasn't literally
Season 2: Dean My daddy died so I could live, I don't deserve to be here
Season 3: Sam, you sold your soul for me?! What the fuck's the matter with you?!
Season 5: Dean, I'm back from hell and I remember it. All of it!
Season 6: Sam, I've got no soul but I'm still kinda annoyed you got a girlfirned while I was dead
Season 8: Dean, You didn't come save me? I know we agreed to stop saving each other from hell but. . .I meant that the same way I mean it when I say I'm gonna pull this car over right now if you don't stop that whiny crap!

I love the show. Hell between House of Wax and Supernatural Paris Hilton made it off my official I hate you list.

I think Shield's okay. Ep 1: had me with the premise, I like Coulson, it was great to see Augustus (I thought he was gonna be a regular!) but the writing to me was just a bit off.

Ep 2: Too many overplayed tropes. The team that doesn't get along even though thus far they have no reason not to tolerate each other, already making official pairs on the show.

I'll give it some more episodes though. Besides I have enough people watching it now that it might be fun just to pick at.
 
There is plenty of good to decent humor, even occasionally some great stuff. I think I wouldn't be nearly as annoyed if the series wasn't literally
Season 2: Dean My daddy died so I could live, I don't deserve to be here
Season 3: Sam, you sold your soul for me?! What the fuck's the matter with you?!
Season 5: Dean, I'm back from hell and I remember it. All of it!
Season 6: Sam, I've got no soul but I'm still kinda annoyed you got a girlfirned while I was dead
Season 8: Dean, You didn't come save me? I know we agreed to stop saving each other from hell but. . .I meant that the same way I mean it when I say I'm gonna pull this car over right now if you don't stop that whiny crap!

I love the show. Hell between House of Wax and Supernatural Paris Hilton made it off my official I hate you list.

I think Shield's okay. Ep 1: had me with the premise, I like Coulson, it was great to see Augustus (I thought he was gonna be a regular!) but the writing to me was just a bit off.

Ep 2: Too many overplayed tropes. The team that doesn't get along even though thus far they have no reason not to tolerate each other, already making official pairs on the show.

I'll give it some more episodes though. Besides I have enough people watching it now that it might be fun just to pick at.

http://i.imgur.com/tXP2S.jpg

I'll watch it, but last night we were watching it and I said "It's a gravity...wave...thing...with...tesseract...stuff"

Later on I started giggling. "Dude, I totally nailed it and I was JOKING."
 
That pic lines up pretty well yeah.

I have the most trouble with season 5 really. I have serious issues with Jo and Ellen dying. I get hung up on rewatching because I just don't want to be there for that at all.
 
I get why they blew up the Roadhouse, the writers flat out said they didn't want the brothers to have a home base, and to the extent that they did Bobby's place was to be that place. I didn't see Ellen as an alternate Bobby (and even if I had they could have ignored her and brought her back instead of skinny twerp to be the new Bobby) I like it.

My problem with Season 5 mostly comes down to the fact that once you know there is a heaven, you don't think, believe or have faith but you've been there and remember it and saw your loved ones. I would have returned from that trip knowing the good were getting rewarded, the pricks would go to Crowley and I could stop playing this crazy game, made sure the Angels intended to deposite me in Heaven after the fun and games and said yes. The entire battle after that to me is vastly different when you know for sure that there is something waiting for you.

Edit: That also changes how hard I try not to kill innocent bystanders. I might very well shoot through you once I know about Heaven.
 
I get why they blew up the Roadhouse, the writers flat out said they didn't want the brothers to have a home base, and to the extent that they did Bobby's place was to be that place. I didn't see Ellen as an alternate Bobby (and even if I had they could have ignored her and brought her back instead of skinny twerp to be the new Bobby) I like it.

My problem with Season 5 mostly comes down to the fact that once you know there is a heaven, you don't think, believe or have faith but you've been there and remember it and saw your loved ones. I would have returned from that trip knowing the good were getting rewarded, the pricks would go to Crowley and I could stop playing this crazy game, made sure the Angels intended to deposite me in Heaven after the fun and games and said yes. The entire battle after that to me is vastly different when you know for sure that there is something waiting for you.

Edit: That also changes how hard I try not to kill innocent bystanders. I might very well shoot through you once I know about Heaven.

Yeah, both Buffy and Supernatural can't actually deal with the idea of God well because...it makes very little sense in a narrative. You'd expect a profound conversation that would be fairly easily controverted by reality.

I even liked "Ghost Whisperer" and there was no God there either, just "crossing over" and no ideology behind it.

You just can't make sense out of the senseless in some facile way without a fairly sophisticated audience feeling entirely cheated. I know I couldn't go near it really. They just left God as absent essentially same as with Dogma. I don't see how you could do otherwise.

You'd think that Buffy would just pray a lot and not worry. She would get to go back, she's not immortal, kill the undead and get on with your life and try to do sacrificey things.

Yay! They have a clip from "This Is The End!"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSbKAggZfrU

Jonah Hill's possession. "The power of Christ Compels You!"

"Does it? Does it really?"
 
Back
Top