Supernatural!

It just occurred to me.

Why didn't Sam and Dean just set up a campsite, bring some hunters, draw a devil's trap around the crossroads and just keep summoning them and killing them until they were all dead?

Can't they just do the same now with angels? Bury a...a kitten or something and wait for an angel to show up and just gank it within a circle of backlit angel fire?
 
It just occurred to me.

Why didn't Sam and Dean just set up a campsite, bring some hunters, draw a devil's trap around the crossroads and just keep summoning them and killing them until they were all dead?

Can't they just do the same now with angels? Bury a...a kitten or something and wait for an angel to show up and just gank it within a circle of backlit angel fire?

It seems implied in most cases that summoning a demon is a matter of it essentially picking up the phone and coming. They don't HAVE to do anything so. Note in the finale of season 7 when Crowley doesn't show they immediately jump to he betrayed us not Crowley's in trouble (which he was.) And again when they need a demon to forgive Crowley's response is just to keep demons away from the two. So I don't think they can summon them against their will.

There are lots of practical questions though. Like if I were them I would literally have dozens of roll out rugs with demon traps on them. It would be absolutely bananas.
 
It seems implied in most cases that summoning a demon is a matter of it essentially picking up the phone and coming. They don't HAVE to do anything so. Note in the finale of season 7 when Crowley doesn't show they immediately jump to he betrayed us not Crowley's in trouble (which he was.) And again when they need a demon to forgive Crowley's response is just to keep demons away from the two. So I don't think they can summon them against their will.

There are lots of practical questions though. Like if I were them I would literally have dozens of roll out rugs with demon traps on them. It would be absolutely bananas.

I need to know more about the rules and flow charts of organizational theory in hell.

Throughout most of history you can summon a demon against their will. From Faust to Terry Pratchett, you summon demons and bid them do your will and such. They have to stay inside the magic circle.

They also haven't resolved where angels go now when they get ganked.
 
Each fiction has it's own rules. Supernatural seems clear that you don't summon demons so much as contact them and hope. There are plenty of problems that I already lsited, oh and Lillith back in seasons 3 and 4 that would have been easy to deal with if just yanking her into your basement was a viable plan.

No they haven't really explained where Angels go. They probably go to some kind of anti-purgatory or cease to exist. They haven't really explained what happens to demons either, normal monsters go to Purgatory and they haven't explained what happens if you die in Purgatory. Though considering we mostly saw Leviathan and decapitation isn't fatal for them it's possible you simply CAN'T die in Purgatory. Some of this will likely never be answered.
 
Each fiction has it's own rules. Supernatural seems clear that you don't summon demons so much as contact them and hope. There are plenty of problems that I already lsited, oh and Lillith back in seasons 3 and 4 that would have been easy to deal with if just yanking her into your basement was a viable plan.

No they haven't really explained where Angels go. They probably go to some kind of anti-purgatory or cease to exist. They haven't really explained what happens to demons either, normal monsters go to Purgatory and they haven't explained what happens if you die in Purgatory. Though considering we mostly saw Leviathan and decapitation isn't fatal for them it's possible you simply CAN'T die in Purgatory. Some of this will likely never be answered.

And when demons go back to hell, how do they get out? Are their day passes? Who authorizes it? Why wouldn't ALL the demons be up here making us all do bad stuff so that Hell wins?
 
And when demons go back to hell, how do they get out? Are their day passes? Who authorizes it? Why wouldn't ALL the demons be up here making us all do bad stuff so that Hell wins?

It's never particularly well defined how demons get out of Hell. Crowley and the upper tier can clearly come and go as they please but aside from the occasional Hell Gate (like in Season 2's finale) it's entirely unclear how anybody gets out.

As for Hell winning I suspect that it might be like in Angel and Buffy. They are winning, they know they are winning and they have absolutely no interest in changing much. Or at least that's their story and they're sticking to it.
 
It's never particularly well defined how demons get out of Hell. Crowley and the upper tier can clearly come and go as they please but aside from the occasional Hell Gate (like in Season 2's finale) it's entirely unclear how anybody gets out.

As for Hell winning I suspect that it might be like in Angel and Buffy. They are winning, they know they are winning and they have absolutely no interest in changing much. Or at least that's their story and they're sticking to it.

Also, Sam and Dean's dad has been wandering the Earth for how long after being extra special tortured in Hell...I wonder how much of an angry spirit he is now.
 
Also, Sam and Dean's dad has been wandering the Earth for how long after being extra special tortured in Hell...I wonder how much of an angry spirit he is now.

It's implied that John Winchester went to Heaven following Season 2. It's established that ghosts cannot exist on earth without some physical object to bind their spirit and they burnt his bones and considering it's been eight fucking years if it's revealed that he was bound to his Diary I won't be the only person fucking rioting.

That's essentially the same thing that happened to Bobby when they rescued him from Hell in season 8, he'd been a ghost in 7 but when they destroyed his flask he went to Hell (cus Crowley's a prick) and when they rescued him he couldn't stay on Earth as a ghost because he had no anchor. Presumably the same thing happened to John. One way trip to Heaven. The only question is why they didn't visit him in Heaven but that could be as simple as nobody from the Roadhouse liked him overmuch. John was a bit of a tool.
 
It's implied that John Winchester went to Heaven following Season 2. It's established that ghosts cannot exist on earth without some physical object to bind their spirit and they burnt his bones and considering it's been eight fucking years if it's revealed that he was bound to his Diary I won't be the only person fucking rioting.

That's essentially the same thing that happened to Bobby when they rescued him from Hell in season 8, he'd been a ghost in 7 but when they destroyed his flask he went to Hell (cus Crowley's a prick) and when they rescued him he couldn't stay on Earth as a ghost because he had no anchor. Presumably the same thing happened to John. One way trip to Heaven. The only question is why they didn't visit him in Heaven but that could be as simple as nobody from the Roadhouse liked him overmuch. John was a bit of a tool.

I was wondering if it was a casting issue actually...in rewatching season 2, he wasn't in the Djinn episode where Dean had an unspoken wish granted. And he didn't actually speak when released from hell so I was wondering if they recycled some footage.

Did he show up at all after that with dialogue? I don't remember...they showed him as a young man...

He started showing up on Gray's Anatomy by season 2...and then they killed him ><

Typecast!

He even shows up as a ghost on Gray's Anatomy...in an episode written by Marti Noxon from Buffy...
 
He also shows up in Angel, he scams Angel into helping him get a watch back from a nest of vampires and then can't pay him.

That guy exists so that he can get killed, I think Angel is the only role I've seen him survive. The chick who plays Darla (her name escapes me at the moment) dies in everything too. She's in a scary Movie knock off, DEAD, Buffy DEAD, Angel DEAD TWICE, Dexter DEAD and I forget the other two things I've seen.

It may have been a casting issue, you never know and I certainly can't recall the last time they even really referenced him other than very breifly when they met their other grandfather. That I don't know. Still that guy dies a whole lot and he's almost always someones Dad.
 
He also shows up in Angel, he scams Angel into helping him get a watch back from a nest of vampires and then can't pay him.

That guy exists so that he can get killed, I think Angel is the only role I've seen him survive. The chick who plays Darla (her name escapes me at the moment) dies in everything too. She's in a scary Movie knock off, DEAD, Buffy DEAD, Angel DEAD TWICE, Dexter DEAD and I forget the other two things I've seen.

It may have been a casting issue, you never know and I certainly can't recall the last time they even really referenced him other than very breifly when they met their other grandfather. That I don't know. Still that guy dies a whole lot and he's almost always someones Dad.

Julie Benz. And then she got a superhero show that died in one season. It wasn't very good, so there you go.

Also she was in the first episode of the sci fi thing this year that was supposed to be huge and didn't interest me at all...

It's interesting how his character is portrayed as everything from a paragon to a psycho to a completely ordinary human being.
 
This is a fairly pointless post, but one of my all time fave films is In The Name of the Father starring Daniel Day Lewis where he plays Gerry Conlon. Now I re-watched it again recently and one of the Birmingham Six is played by Crowley!

Can't believe how young/different he looked.
 
This is a fairly pointless post, but one of my all time fave films is In The Name of the Father starring Daniel Day Lewis where he plays Gerry Conlon. Now I re-watched it again recently and one of the Birmingham Six is played by Crowley!

Can't believe how young/different he looked.

I love...LOVE...love...Mark Sheppard.

That is one of my favorite things about the show. The casting is exquisite and they do great things with who they have.
 
I love...LOVE...love...Mark Sheppard.

That is one of my favorite things about the show. The casting is exquisite and they do great things with who they have.

That's his name then! He cropped up in Medium a lot too, as some evil ghostie type serial killer (maybe its in this thread, not read it all).
 
Julie Benz. And then she got a superhero show that died in one season. It wasn't very good, so there you go.

Also she was in the first episode of the sci fi thing this year that was supposed to be huge and didn't interest me at all...

It's interesting how his character is portrayed as everything from a paragon to a psycho to a completely ordinary human being.

I suck at names, thank you Julie Benz. I think the last time I remembered those names was when I was pissed off that they were talking about making an Alice movie based on American McGee's Alice and somehow Sarah Michelle Gellar was in the running and I was practially screaming go watch Buffy you tards?! Juliet Landau was practically sculpted from clay to play the role of American McGee's Alice and if you insist upon star power go summon Wednesday Adams. . .I mean Christina Ricci. . .no I was right the first time. I think Christina is just who she pretends to be so nobody catches on that the Addams family movies were actually documentaries.

Julie was on Defiance wasn't she. It was okay, I made it through the season. Its sad, I like the world. There was an MMO made of it and they were supposed to work in the top players into being recurring extras or something like it but I have no idea how they would manage that but it sounded cool as fuck but I agree it wasn't that good and for me Mondays is already WWE night and between that and 2 Broke Girls and now Sleepy Hollow that's just nto a spot where I have time.

Wasn't he in Red or the Losers? That year they released so many high profile team ups with Red, Losers, A-Team, and Expendables 2 that I'll admit they all kinda run together a bit for me.
 
That's his name then! He cropped up in Medium a lot too, as some evil ghostie type serial killer (maybe its in this thread, not read it all).

Yeah, he's great. I would happily replace him for nearly any other actor in any other part.

Do you watch Supernatural at all or have you?
 
I suck at names, thank you Julie Benz. I think the last time I remembered those names was when I was pissed off that they were talking about making an Alice movie based on American McGee's Alice and somehow Sarah Michelle Gellar was in the running and I was practially screaming go watch Buffy you tards?! Juliet Landau was practically sculpted from clay to play the role of American McGee's Alice and if you insist upon star power go summon Wednesday Adams. . .I mean Christina Ricci. . .no I was right the first time. I think Christina is just who she pretends to be so nobody catches on that the Addams family movies were actually documentaries.

Julie was on Defiance wasn't she. It was okay, I made it through the season. Its sad, I like the world. There was an MMO made of it and they were supposed to work in the top players into being recurring extras or something like it but I have no idea how they would manage that but it sounded cool as fuck but I agree it wasn't that good and for me Mondays is already WWE night and between that and 2 Broke Girls and now Sleepy Hollow that's just nto a spot where I have time.

Wasn't he in Red or the Losers? That year they released so many high profile team ups with Red, Losers, A-Team, and Expendables 2 that I'll admit they all kinda run together a bit for me.

Right! Defiance. Is that still going to run?

I haven't seen Juliet Landau in anything else, I don't know if she can do anything other than crazy bloodthirsty waif, but that would have been PERFECT for American McGee

I watched Face Off and they do a lot of tie-ins to shows and they had a Defiance challenge. That's a great show too and it leads me to catch up on a bunch of other stuff.

I don't know, I don't think I watched anything but Reds #1 and I am not the biggest fans of that genre.
 
Yeah, he's great. I would happily replace him for nearly any other actor in any other part.

Do you watch Supernatural at all or have you?

I do indeed. I think I'm two seasons behind though. I got a bit bored with all the angel/demon stuff for a while but it drew me back in and I do love it. And I will admit to getting a massive frisson when it's the last episode and they crank up Carry On My Wayward Son!
 
Crowley was a regular on a show called Leverage which if you didn't watch was kinda like Burn Notice just with thieves not spies. I think he was still playing Crowley too, same look same attitude, same frenemy relationship with our protagonists.
 
I do indeed. I think I'm two seasons behind though. I got a bit bored with all the angel/demon stuff for a while but it drew me back in and I do love it. And I will admit to getting a massive frisson when it's the last episode and they crank up Carry On My Wayward Son!

I am happy with the angel stuff if it has Misha Collins. I follow him on twitter and that guy is hilarious.

The sense of humor always gets me. It's the smart and funny that makes me happy.

Supernatural Shake:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNdwABWTcA8

Eye of the Tiger

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cb3G5Qj_Lo8

I am on the reddit Supernatural group, and the subscribers are called "iddjits" YAAAY!

http://i.imgur.com/4mQAjto.jpg?1
 
Crowley was a regular on a show called Leverage which if you didn't watch was kinda like Burn Notice just with thieves not spies. I think he was still playing Crowley too, same look same attitude, same frenemy relationship with our protagonists.

I did watch him on Leverage...and I adore Parker. I lost interest somewhere along the way when they ran out of ideas for good stories, but it's really good for the first few seasons.
 
I came into the show a little late so I had to chase down the earlier stuff. They did kinda run out of stuff just like Burn Notice they probably should have called it quits a season or two earlier than they did but hey we're Americans, we don't stop until the money does in most cases. I've long argued that it would be nice to see what would happen if at least on occasion shows could get an X-Seasons contract where they had to be doing really bad to lose it but it would stop anyway at that point. Cus I feel like we lose a lot of shows not because they are bad but because they want to do a good story and unfortunately that often means starting with laying groundwork.
 
I came into the show a little late so I had to chase down the earlier stuff. They did kinda run out of stuff just like Burn Notice they probably should have called it quits a season or two earlier than they did but hey we're Americans, we don't stop until the money does in most cases. I've long argued that it would be nice to see what would happen if at least on occasion shows could get an X-Seasons contract where they had to be doing really bad to lose it but it would stop anyway at that point. Cus I feel like we lose a lot of shows not because they are bad but because they want to do a good story and unfortunately that often means starting with laying groundwork.

Yeah, that's true. I was shocked as hell to find out that "Firefly" was "too intellectual" and "too hard to follow"

WTF? How?
 
Firefly was shown out of order. Of course it was difficult to follow when the episodes were just thrown on however Fox fucking chose.

That said in general I didn't find Firefly particularly hard to follow by any reasonable standard. But people are kinda weird. I find Doctor Who to be frustratingly difficult to keep sorted and I swear it feels like they expected that you were at least kinda familar with the 1970's series since they don't explain who the Master is they just dump him in your lap and expect you to respect him like he's the fucking Joker or Darth Vader or something.

Still that's a common problem for anime is they might spend almost the entire first year just introducing all the characters and their back stories and not doing anything that's particularly fun, once the story gets going it can be awesome but damn.
 
Back
Top