Supernatural!

Thing is in Buffy God is probably Real and most likely a twat. Still we don't know enough to make informed decisions and not about him, just about life and death and the morality of that.

In Supernatural we've met five different beings who've met God face to face, Lucifer, Micheal, Gabriel, Metatron, Joshua and Death (sorry six). So he's not a rumor. We know.

The boys have been to Heaven though. I'd be all "fuck you that's why!" Next time Crowley tried something. No serious conversation needed just two guys who don't care about death until for plot contrived reasons someone explains that suicide really is a mortal sin and taunting the King of Hell and not fighting back is suicide even if he rips out your spleen.
 
Thing is in Buffy God is probably Real and most likely a twat. Still we don't know enough to make informed decisions and not about him, just about life and death and the morality of that.

In Supernatural we've met five different beings who've met God face to face, Lucifer, Micheal, Gabriel, Metatron, Joshua and Death (sorry six). So he's not a rumor. We know.

The boys have been to Heaven though. I'd be all "fuck you that's why!" Next time Crowley tried something. No serious conversation needed just two guys who don't care about death until for plot contrived reasons someone explains that suicide really is a mortal sin and taunting the King of Hell and not fighting back is suicide even if he rips out your spleen.

Yeah, but all those guys are assholes and by season 14 could be revealed as avatars of the great Hamster Singularity.
 
If the Hamster Singularity controls Heaven that's good enough for me.

I would completely love to hang out in the Hamster Singularity though I assume the food wouldn't be all that great. "C'mon guys, let's go to the lettuce bar!"
 
Crap.

Hey Crowley, come pick me up. These fuckers live off granola. So lets skip the part where I'm on the table and start figuring out how many pieces I can hack off a vamp before he goes all dust bunny.
 
Crap.

Hey Crowley, come pick me up. These fuckers live off granola. So lets skip the part where I'm on the table and start figuring out how many pieces I can hack off a vamp before he goes all dust bunny.

Yeah, I might love the hamsters, but I might not suit the Hamster lifestyle.

Angels and Demons are interesting because they have conflicts we can write about and think about. God is...complete indifference to conflict. Not a good story in the long road. Profound, but difficult to write about in a drama basically about being hot and killing stuff.
 
God is indifference in what mythology?

Judeo-Christian-Islamic myth, which involves all the demons and angels we're discussing here.

The idea of "God" as a united entity, which in my opinion is deeply wise, is simply all of creation, everything together. The Universe.

The flaw comes in when you think It cares. It clearly does not.

You can break the Universe down into Avatars, who represent different ideas who do care about a certain part, water or love or war. They care.

But the overall being can't actually care and have the Universe be as it is, because the Universe just doesn't. The Universe is Physics.

So Physics is kinda God and Physics is awesome and amazing and wonderful, but does not give a damn, even if I'm made up of it. Everything's made up of it. I'm not special.

I think modern sensibilities get that and although the demons and angels put a human face on ideas...God can't.
 
Judeo-Christian-Islamic myth, which involves all the demons and angels we're discussing here.

The idea of "God" as a united entity, which in my opinion is deeply wise, is simply all of creation, everything together. The Universe.

The flaw comes in when you think It cares. It clearly does not.

You can break the Universe down into Avatars, who represent different ideas who do care about a certain part, water or love or war. They care.

But the overall being can't actually care and have the Universe be as it is, because the Universe just doesn't. The Universe is Physics.

So Physics is kinda God and Physics is awesome and amazing and wonderful, but does not give a damn, even if I'm made up of it. Everything's made up of it. I'm not special.

I think modern sensibilities get that and although the demons and angels put a human face on ideas...God can't.


The Judeo-Christian God most certainly cares. He's a prick don't get me wrong but you don't take the special time out of your day to make sure that all people speak different languages and bicker amongst themselves because you don't care. You don't flood the earth and kill everybody because you don't care. You don't take special time out of your day to make being Jewish Suck I mean suck, sold to the Egyptians, wander the desert until two full generations die off, constantly dicking them around after that, giving them to the Romans and that's just the stuff in the book. Assuming he's real I assume Hitler and the current Middle East is part of his sadistic game plan.

A twat yes, but uncaring hell the fuck no.

Unless there is a being above him that is physics. . .but the Bible seems to suggest in several places that physics can be told to fuck right off if that's the more convienent thing. Part a sea, get way too many animals onto a relatively small boat, feed a a crowd with a few loaves of a bread and a few fish. Walk on Water, that kind of stuff.
 
The Judeo-Christian God most certainly cares. He's a prick don't get me wrong but you don't take the special time out of your day to make sure that all people speak different languages and bicker amongst themselves because you don't care. You don't flood the earth and kill everybody because you don't care. You don't take special time out of your day to make being Jewish Suck I mean suck, sold to the Egyptians, wander the desert until two full generations die off, constantly dicking them around after that, giving them to the Romans and that's just the stuff in the book. Assuming he's real I assume Hitler and the current Middle East is part of his sadistic game plan.

A twat yes, but uncaring hell the fuck no.

Unless there is a being above him that is physics. . .but the Bible seems to suggest in several places that physics can be told to fuck right off if that's the more convienent thing. Part a sea, get way too many animals onto a relatively small boat, feed a a crowd with a few loaves of a bread and a few fish. Walk on Water, that kind of stuff.

Taken literally, yeah, no doubt.

Taken philosophically, it's just an inability to give up an idea of a benign creator, because to do that for many people is one of those "that way leads to madness" and there are parts of the brain that reject this outright in many people.

Unfortunately for many people, not having a "pattern" and a "reward" leads to complete nihilism. I would prefer that they kept their "benign" ideology and worked toward reward (whether or not that reward ever shows up isn't really the point) than be crushed under the actual weight of their irrelevance. People create their own relative meaning to life, this is just one way to do it and function.

They stuck in "free will" and "mysterious ways" to make it seem like it makes sense. It doesn't make sense.

The stories about people struggling with it are the sense part.

Supernatural rejects pretty much any ideology but does have a goal - stay alive, hunt things and then stay alive but not at all costs and all prices to pay, and hunt things, but hunt the right things. It's a refining of the process. They will accept help from any quarter to get these things done. I like it.

Dean is not going to give up whiskey and hamburgers, even if he thinks there is a God that wants him to have fish on Fridays.
 
I have a hard time figuring out where the Benign deity comes from in the first place. A benign deity at the worst would reward the good and punish the bad regardless of your religion and even the Christian myth doesn't go that far and it's sisters Judaism and Islam are generally viewed as harsher than that though I admit to being a little behind on Judaism on some of that stuff.

I disagree that Supernatural rejects any ideology when it's pretty damn clear that if not Christianity, certainly Judeo-Christian Myth is "true". We know enough about other Gods to know they aren't shit to Angels and angels aren't shit to God which pretty much at best confirms the other religions as sufficiently powerful demons. Some of whom under ideal circumstances are probably kinder than the real God but they aren't him.

Deans not giving up his vices because he's a stubborn prick and he figures, rightfully, that he's earned it and any God who doesn't want him after all this can get bent. Notice when Sam was in trouble at the end of Season 5 and again in the opener of Season 9 when the shit hits the fan he's down on his knees pretty quick to call for some help from Team Angel.
 
I have a hard time figuring out where the Benign deity comes from in the first place. A benign deity at the worst would reward the good and punish the bad regardless of your religion and even the Christian myth doesn't go that far and it's sisters Judaism and Islam are generally viewed as harsher than that though I admit to being a little behind on Judaism on some of that stuff.

I disagree that Supernatural rejects any ideology when it's pretty damn clear that if not Christianity, certainly Judeo-Christian Myth is "true". We know enough about other Gods to know they aren't shit to Angels and angels aren't shit to God which pretty much at best confirms the other religions as sufficiently powerful demons. Some of whom under ideal circumstances are probably kinder than the real God but they aren't him.

Deans not giving up his vices because he's a stubborn prick and he figures, rightfully, that he's earned it and any God who doesn't want him after all this can get bent. Notice when Sam was in trouble at the end of Season 5 and again in the opener of Season 9 when the shit hits the fan he's down on his knees pretty quick to call for some help from Team Angel.

It's somewhat fair to say that I can't understand "benign" in Godlike terms, that's true. I don't have a mind that big.

However, I can look at the behavior of God in the Bible and think that things like the Garden of Eden or the Flood were entirely tantrumey childish. I think it is less a story about infinite wisdom as a story of a flawed Creator who learns through their experiences, as parents do.

Judaism is more mystical. Islam is more practical. They both struggle with the idea of how humans treat each other being important to God, who judges.

In reality...it's there because brains have a tough time doing good for good's sake and a story tries to create a context to convince people to be "good" and that's not a bad thing.

Where the bad thing comes in is the stress points of the story. The idea that God judging people means you can judge people is powerful an appeals to the more selfish aspects of the brain. Say for instance, the conversation with julybaby saying that God will sort it all out and eternity is assured. Julybaby has pretty much written off all Non-Christians and Non-Republicans as not the "chosen ones" and she needn't bother. THAT is the drawback. To grab onto part of it as an "out" from responsibility and the tribal sense of "us" and "them" and that it's okay if "them" roast in hell, in fact we can't WAIT for "them" to roast in hell while we have heavenly cocktail hour.

It's a powerful tool like fire. Used well, it warms your home and cooks your food and give you comfort. Used poorly it wreaks total havoc and I can see why people would want to ban fire on that basis. But fire and good and evil and selfish and giving would still exist even if you tried to ban them. You have to learn how to control them and stop those from misusing it, within very specific limits.

Dean's just an established character who has done everything from torture most foul and grace most awesome.

He's pretty sure if he's going to hell, it isn't about the hamburger.
 
It's somewhat fair to say that I can't understand "benign" in Godlike terms, that's true. I don't have a mind that big.

However, I can look at the behavior of God in the Bible and think that things like the Garden of Eden or the Flood were entirely tantrumey childish. I think it is less a story about infinite wisdom as a story of a flawed Creator who learns through their experiences, as parents do.

Judaism is more mystical. Islam is more practical. They both struggle with the idea of how humans treat each other being important to God, who judges.

In reality...it's there because brains have a tough time doing good for good's sake and a story tries to create a context to convince people to be "good" and that's not a bad thing.

Where the bad thing comes in is the stress points of the story. The idea that God judging people means you can judge people is powerful an appeals to the more selfish aspects of the brain. Say for instance, the conversation with julybaby saying that God will sort it all out and eternity is assured. Julybaby has pretty much written off all Non-Christians and Non-Republicans as not the "chosen ones" and she needn't bother. THAT is the drawback. To grab onto part of it as an "out" from responsibility and the tribal sense of "us" and "them" and that it's okay if "them" roast in hell, in fact we can't WAIT for "them" to roast in hell while we have heavenly cocktail hour.

It's a powerful tool like fire. Used well, it warms your home and cooks your food and give you comfort. Used poorly it wreaks total havoc and I can see why people would want to ban fire on that basis. But fire and good and evil and selfish and giving would still exist even if you tried to ban them. You have to learn how to control them and stop those from misusing it, within very specific limits.

Dean's just an established character who has done everything from torture most foul and grace most awesome.

He's pretty sure if he's going to hell, it isn't about the hamburger.

The problem with your idea of what I believe is that it is YOUR idea of what I believe.

The fact is that my beliefs have nothing to do with whether God will save someone or not. I have nothing to do with that, other than sharing who God is. It is up to every single person every born or yet to be born on what they choose to believe.

God says there is one way to Him. NOT ME! You can be upset at me that I believe what God says to be true, but I did not make those decisions.

I believe, until the moment a person dies, that they have just as much reason/chance/opportunity to spend eternity in Heaven with God as I do. The ONLY thing that will set us apart is unbelief and acceptance of who God is, who Jesus is and what He did on the cross.

It is really very simple. No one is better than any other. It is about faith and the willingness to believe.....
 
The problem with your idea of what I believe is that it is YOUR idea of what I believe.

The fact is that my beliefs have nothing to do with whether God will save someone or not. I have nothing to do with that, other than sharing who God is. It is up to every single person every born or yet to be born on what they choose to believe.

God says there is one way to Him. NOT ME! You can be upset at me that I believe what God says to be true, but I did not make those decisions.

I believe, until the moment a person dies, that they have just as much reason/chance/opportunity to spend eternity in Heaven with God as I do. The ONLY thing that will set us apart is unbelief and acceptance of who God is, who Jesus is and what He did on the cross.

It is really very simple. No one is better than any other. It is about faith and the willingness to believe.....

Yeah, this is about my thoughts.

Do you watch Supernatural?

You were a shared example that Sean and I both experienced, so I used your name, it wasn't supposed to call you like Bloody Mary or Beetlejuice.

Regardless of whether or not I'm "right" about you, it wasn't intended as a personal insult but as an example.

My only real issue with you is that you justify your lack of compassion through your religion. This thread is more about your taste in TV, which would be welcome.

I am basing my conclusions on what you said to direct questions I asked and extrapolating that to other people I have asked direct questions to and seen their behavior.

In general I am not staying up nights worrying about you or trying to tweak you to get your attention. It's a discussion about how it is difficult to talk about God as a modern human being that is not, in fact, one of the faithful.

It is also occasionally difficult to have a conversation with the faithful when they're determined to take offense and be rude and dismissive.

However, there are plenty of faithful I get along with just fine.
 
Yeah, this is about my thoughts.

Do you watch Supernatural?

You were a shared example that Sean and I both experienced, so I used your name, it wasn't supposed to call you like Bloody Mary or Beetlejuice.

Regardless of whether or not I'm "right" about you, it wasn't intended as a personal insult but as an example.

My only real issue with you is that you justify your lack of compassion through your religion. This thread is more about your taste in TV, which would be welcome.

I am basing my conclusions on what you said to direct questions I asked and extrapolating that to other people I have asked direct questions to and seen their behavior.

In general I am not staying up nights worrying about you or trying to tweak you to get your attention. It's a discussion about how it is difficult to talk about God as a modern human being that is not, in fact, one of the faithful.

It is also occasionally difficult to have a conversation with the faithful when they're determined to take offense and be rude and dismissive.

However, there are plenty of faithful I get along with just fine.

I was reading posts.....I usually go to the last page when they are long and I read your post. I was only trying to share my beliefs as I thought you had me wrong.

As far as compassion, I am truly confused by your view, of me, on this. Just because I believe in rights/wrongs, blacks/whites does not it any way stop me from helping anyone I encounter who needs assistance. Simply because I am against National "helping" does not mean I am against helping people. I think the government screws everything up.....I don't think they need to be in charge of things they truly cannot handle.

So, my television viewing preferences tend to lean more toward sports (football, baseball in particular), the Pioneer Woman on the Cooking Channel, News Shows until I can't take all the arguing any longer then I move to the Andy Griffith Show to ease my mind.
 
I was reading posts.....I usually go to the last page when they are long and I read your post. I was only trying to share my beliefs as I thought you had me wrong.

As far as compassion, I am truly confused by your view, of me, on this. Just because I believe in rights/wrongs, blacks/whites does not it any way stop me from helping anyone I encounter who needs assistance. Simply because I am against National "helping" does not mean I am against helping people. I think the government screws everything up.....I don't think they need to be in charge of things they truly cannot handle.

So, my television viewing preferences tend to lean more toward sports (football, baseball in particular), the Pioneer Woman on the Cooking Channel, News Shows until I can't take all the arguing any longer then I move to the Andy Griffith Show to ease my mind.

I don't really need to rehash it. I don't have any ill will toward you and I apologize if using your name made you feel attacked. It wasn't intended.

Sports! *hiss*

Okay, now that is true evil. Begone!
 
I don't really need to rehash it. I don't have any ill will toward you and I apologize if using your name made you feel attacked. It wasn't intended.

Sports! *hiss*

Okay, now that is true evil. Begone!

You don't like sports?

(and thanks)
 
You don't like sports?

(and thanks)

No, really, they could all disappear off the earth and good riddance as far as I'm concerned.

Though I like the Olympics, it barely seems worth the expense and the lack of good will that are gained from having them, setting everybody off hating everybody else instead of bringing us closer together.

You're welcome. There's too much damned ill will, I don't have any.

Unless it's about sports.

Obviously I see that people all sorts of stuff that makes no sense to me.
 
No, really, they could all disappear off the earth and good riddance as far as I'm concerned.

Though I like the Olympics, it barely seems worth the expense and the lack of good will that are gained from having them, setting everybody off hating everybody else instead of bringing us closer together.

You're welcome. There's too much damned ill will, I don't have any.

Unless it's about sports.

Obviously I see that people all sorts of stuff that makes no sense to me.

I love watching sports.....I truly enjoy the Olympics (who doesn't love a good game of curling?..:D ). Football is so much fun to watch.....Baseball a very close second!
 
I love watching sports.....I truly enjoy the Olympics (who doesn't love a good game of curling?..:D ). Football is so much fun to watch.....Baseball a very close second!

My whole family is sports crazy and I couldn't ever get away from it and do something reasonable like play video games.

I'm clearly overstating it and I do like the Olympics. However, otherwise I never know what sports season it is and fortunately my husband also dislikes sports and likes to play video games so we have lots in common.
 
Can't you just say her name twice more so she'll go away? Fuck it I'll try it. If I end up in the Frightzone, Underwear, Netherverse or any other fucked up place I'm blaming you Reci!

Though I venture someplace scary
And I know I ought be wary
Thought she brings with her a fright
I seek to to experience the light
Julybaby, Julybaby Julybaby!
 
Back
Top