Pollitical Corectness

Hi Cry...welcome back.

Lets not use Oppression then. It does have specific meaning to lots of people who might look at the thread.

Maybe lets look at the reasons for the difference and try to understand them. If there are things that can be changed for the better we can go on a letter writing campagne to our respective governments.

BTW, I took a picture of the Canadian Embassy today. It's for my "Sis", but I thought you'd appreciate it too. I'll post it tomorrow after I shrink it etc. to fit in Lit.
 
That's it...

Go to bed, Crys!

This time I'll have you remove all your clothes to make sure you're not hidding anything to help you cut the ropes. And I'll also keep you pinned down to the bed with my own body, if needed be... :mad: :devil:
 
Do you agree to my proposal to stay away from victim/victimization terms until we find specific examples?

Good night:)
 
Cool, I'd like to see that - I've never actually seen our embassy.

Shall we be politically correct and use 'grue' then? No one could possibly be offended by that. :D (hehehehe)
 
crysede said:
Cool, I'd like to see that - I've never actually seen our embassy.

Shall we be politically correct and use 'grue' then? No one could possibly be offended by that. :D (hehehehe)

OK..grue then means "causal factors"?

It's 11:58, I turn into a pumpkin at midnight.
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
Do you agree to my proposal to stay away from victim/victimization terms until we find specific examples?

Good night:)
I don't care what terms we use, but I can't explain my position without using terms like disadvantaged, benefited, etc. If you consider these 'victimization' terms, we'll have to come up with some other ones I can use to stand for the same concepts.
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:


OK..grue then means "causal factors"?

It's 11:58, I turn into a pumpkin at midnight.
No, grue means exactly what I used to be calling 'oppression': ie, the systemic injustice/disadvantaging/or-what-have-you of certain groups within society.
 
Crys, you're one post away from becoming the top poster in this thread. Do it and come to bed... :cool:
 
Lauren.Hynde said:
Works for me :p
Now look here you nasty, wicked varletess; 'Pinning down' sounds like a victimization term to me. :mad:

OK, OK, I'll go to bed - but only if you come grue me :devil:
 
crysede said:
I don't care what terms we use, but I can't explain my position without using terms like disadvantaged, benefited, etc. If you consider these 'victimization' terms, we'll have to come up with some other ones I can use to stand for the same concepts.

I have to go to sleep.

If examine the causal factors and find a cause and effect relationship, then you can use "disadvantaged"

Is the woman who gave up a medical school education because her Mom advised her to marry Joe "disadvantaged" because her income isn't very high now? Did I, as a white male "benefit" from this?

You're also implying that having a lower income is a "disadvantage" when it is not necessarily so. Examples are the artist who creates art for it's own sake and sells something now and then as the situation arises or the woman who has a masters in accounting who takes a part time job doing accounting at the local school so she can be home when her kids come home. Is she "disadvantaged"

If (I'll even grant "when") we find specific instances of discrimination..we can use victim/victimizor terms. But lets not start with it. Everyone who has a lower income is not "disadvantaged." It's a broad generalization and you have said how you don't like to use broad generalizations.
 
crysede said:
No, grue means exactly what I used to be calling 'oppression': ie, the systemic injustice/disadvantaging/or-what-have-you of certain groups within society.

In this case, I humbly withdraw. I don't want to participate in a discussion where it's presumed I'm guilty of something without a specific accusation and solid evidence.

Good night.
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:


In this case, I humbly withdraw. I don't want to participate in a discussion where it's presumed I'm guilty of something without a specific accusation and solid evidence.

Good night.
Now you're confusing me - my definition of systemic oppression was that it was part of society, not a masculine/white/etc. conspiracy - you objected to my use of 'oppression' since you feel it implies intent - we've gotten rid of the term: so now my definition does not imply intent, and the term does not imply intent. What is it that makes you continue to feel I'm accusing all men of intentionally disadvantaging women? :confused:
 
Just a note. If the word that you want to use definition isn't satisfactory, by all means find another word. If we start redifining words it won't be long before we're all talking gibberish.

If you start redifining words, especially emotionally loaded words, then communication breaks down rather quickly.

Ishmael
 
My logic is thus:

1) Women and men are created equally with intellectual capability
2) There is a difference in the average income earned between women and men.
3) There are many factors that could result in this situation and those factors should be examined and understood.

(We should examine the causes and take special note to discuss any that we find that are systematically causing a disadvantage to women).

The logic that I object to is:

1) Women and men are created equally with intellectual capability
2) There is a difference in the average income earned between women and men.
3) Having a lower average income is a disadvantage (to all)
4) Having a higher average income is a benefit (to all)
5) Women are (all) disadvantaged in some sort of a systematic way

This makes it sound as if every woman is a victim. It makes it sound like every man has an "advantage" and are "benefiting" due to some mysterious force. That leads into a blame game and I don't want to play a blame game, at least until such time as it's warranted. And, I don't count "evolutionary coping strategies" as a "disadvantage", especially if you try to tell me that the woman (in my example above) is some how "disadvantaged" because of a "evolutionary coping strategy" that caused her to take a lower paying part time job at the school keeping books so that she has time to be with her kids.

I'll grant that some women are disadvantaged. But, how many and by what factors?

I propose that victim/victimizor terms be used only when we find a specific situation in which it is warranted and we can determine the specific actions that lead to it. (Example...a pattern where school counselors recommend to every female student that she attend hair styling, nursing, teaching or secretarial school)

We also have to take time into consideration because I think 40 years ago, there was this type of pattern on the part of school counselors. However, it is not the case now and it wasn't the case 20 years ago when I was in high school.
 
Hope you had a good's night sleep LTGR :), and thanks for clearing that up: I'm fairly sure I understand what you're saying now.

My Reasons For Rejecting Reliance on Biological Explanations
As I explained in my first response to you, I cannot agree with the 'biology made me do it' argument. I can see no earthly reason for society continuing to assume that women naturally need to dedicate themselves to their children, and men don't. I have often heard fathers saying that they deeply regret not being able to spend more time with their children - why do we (as a society) take this regret seriously only when it is expressed by women? There is certainly no evidence to support the notion that women are naturally better caregivers - men love their children just as much as women do, and feel the need to protect and nurture them; children do not suffer if they are raised by a single father rather than a single mother (being raised by both parents is, of course, preferable).

In Defense of Guilt by Virtue of Privilege
'Privilege' in this context is a special advantage or favour that is granted to some individuals or groups of individuals and not to others. I recognize my unearned privilege and concomitantly I recognize that the unjust denial of privilege to others is the result of the 'normal' workings of the social order.

In my own case, the unearned privileges I enjoy are white-skin privilege, class privilege, and heterosexual privilege. As a woman I am denied male-gender privilege, but this denial is tempered by the facts that male-gender privilege has been decreasing rapidly in our society, that I am heterosexual, that I come from an upper middle-class family, and that I am white. Thus, when my position is viewed in its entirety, I am a privileged member of society by virtue of things that were outside my control (mere accidents of birth), and thus my privilege in these respects is unearned.

I see nothing mysterious about the privileges I enjoy, nor do I feel personally responsible for them in any way - since my birth was not under my control. However I recognize that they are unearned, and to benefit from unearned privileges goes against my moral principles (hence you can see why I disagree with affirmative action). The fact that I cannot choose to give up these privileges does not alter the fact that they violate moral principles of fairness that I value.

Why I Find Your Suggestion That We Assume No Oppression Exists Problematic
You are, of course, absolutely free to disagree with me, and I welcome being engaged in debate over whether any such privilege exists. But to say we should assume that such privilege does not exist unless we can empirically show that it does is not reasonable (just as it would be unreasonable for me to say we should assume that it does exist unless we can empirically show that it does not) - one of the few things Ishmael and I have been in agreement upon is that this is not an issue that can be resolved through mere observation of empirical facts.

I do not think the facts in question logically entail their causes - and these causes, which we cannot determine empirically, are what the issue rests upon. So all we can do here is present our theories, and give our arguments as to why we hold our theory to be the most reasonable - which is something I value in and of itself for the intellectual stimulation. We cannot hope to come to any factual resolution either way on the issue of systemic oppression - as with most moral questions, it just isn't that sort of issue.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, yes, I did get some rest and feel a little better. I have a consistent headache, but one more nights rest should take care of that. I hope things are going well for you.

crysede said:
Hope you had a good's night sleep LTGR :), and thanks for clearing that up: I'm fairly sure I understand what you're saying now.

My Reasons For Rejecting Reliance on Biological Explanations
As I explained in my first response to you, I cannot agree with the 'biology made me do it' argument. I can see no earthly reason for society continuing to assume that women naturally need to dedicate themselves to their children, and men don't. I have often heard fathers saying that they deeply regret not being able to spend more time with their children - why do we (as a society) take this regret seriously only when it is expressed by women? There is certainly no evidence to support the notion that women are naturally better caregivers - men love their children just as much as women do, and feel the need to protect and nurture them; children do not suffer if they are raised by a single father rather than a single mother (being raised by both parents is, of course, preferable.


I don't subscribe to the "biology made me do it" argument either. I grant you that in some cases women are pressured to take that role, most often by family, often their mothers. I also think that many (not all) women choose not to work or to work in less demanding/lower paying jobs. Of the 12 homes in my little corner of the neighborhood, 6 of the 12 women don't work. Of the six that do work, one is a unmarried woman with grown children, two must work to afford the home but would prefer not to work, one is married but has no children and the other two have children and work because they prefer to work. Society doesn't make a "ruling" that they must or must not work, they can choose freely. In many cases, these women are making a choice. Since they are responsible adults and they make these choices, then they are not "oppressed", "discriminated against" or "disadvantaged" in any way.

In the case of the mother pressuring the daughter to not work and to raise kids, I haven't resolved in my mind whether that's part of your systematic "oppression" or not. After all, the daughter, if over 18, has reached the point of majority and has a voice and a choice. She still has the right to a choice, she can only be "railroaded" if she lets it happen to herself.

Is there a biological component to this pattern..maybe. It doesn't really matter, the fact is that they have choices, they are adults and are capable of making choices and they have responsibility for their choices. If they have a choice, they are not "oppressed".

If we were talking about women's choices 50 years ago, I might agree to "disadvantaged" with some specific definitions, but I'd still be uncomfortable with 'oppression' because it connotates malicious intent and I don't think that there was malicious intent.

In Defense of Guilt by Virtue of Privilege
'Privilege' in this context is a special advantage or favour that is granted to some individuals or groups of individuals and not to others. I recognize my unearned privilege and concomitantly I recognize that the unjust denial of privilege to others is the result of the 'normal' workings of the social order.

In my own case, the unearned privileges I enjoy are white-skin privilege, class privilege, and heterosexual privilege. As a woman I am denied male-gender privilege, but this denial is tempered by the facts that male-gender privilege has been decreasing rapidly in our society, that I am heterosexual, that I come from an upper middle-class family, and that I am white. Thus, when my position is viewed in its entirety, I am a privileged member of society by virtue of things that were outside my control (mere accidents of birth), and thus my privilege in these respects is unearned.

I see nothing mysterious about the privileges I enjoy, nor do I feel personally responsible for them in any way - since my birth was not under my control. However I recognize that they are unearned, and to benefit from unearned privileges goes against my moral principles (hence you can see why I disagree with affirmative action). The fact that I cannot choose to give up these privileges does not alter the fact that they violate moral principles of fairness that I value.
[/b]

If we're restricting this conversation to men and women, then priveledge isn't a factor because there are both men and women that are "priviledged" and "not-as-privileged". Though I don't want to talk about this aspect of it now, I would say that anyone born in the United States, Canada, Australia, UK or any other part of the "Western World" is priviledged. However, I don't want to talk about that until later (after we get the men/woman earnings averages discussion taken care of).

Why I Find Your Suggestion That We Assume No Oppression Exists Problematic
You are, of course, absolutely free to disagree with me, and I welcome being engaged in debate over whether any such privilege exists. But to say we should assume that such privilege does not exist unless we can empirically show that it does is not reasonable (just as it would be unreasonable for me to say we should assume that it does exist unless we can empirically show that it does not) - one of the few things Ishmael and I have been in agreement upon is that this is not an issue that can be resolved through mere observation of empirical facts.

I do not think the facts in question logically entail their causes - and these causes, which we cannot determine empirically, are what the issue rests upon. So all we can do here is present our theories, and give our arguments as to why we hold our theory to be the most reasonable - which is something I value in and of itself for the intellectual stimulation. We cannot hope to come to any factual resolution either way on the issue of systemic oppression - as with most moral questions, it just isn't that sort of issue. [/B]

As we've decided, "oppression" means To crush or burden through an abuse of power , which includes "malicious intent". In understanding the wage differential between men and women, I believe that very little if any oppression or malicious intent exists because by far and away, the largest component of the differential is caused by choices people make.

That women are free to become high earning doctors and lawyers and other professionals means that high-earning careers are open and available if people make that choice (for the last 20-25 years anyway). In fact, for many years now, there have been more women enrolled in higher education than men. In fact, there was an article in the Atlantic Magazine a year ago talking about the "crisis in education for boys and men".

If you argue that women don't have choices, then you can make the argument that they're "victims". If they make a free choice, then they are not a victim. I am purposely avoiding priviledge / non-priviledge between men and women because that is a class/race etc thing and men and women are both well represented across that spectrum. It's not that I don't want to talk about that, it's just that I prefer to concentrate on only one "resolution" at a time (the income differential between men and women).

I thought we agreed that "oppression" included malicious intent and we agreed that intent wasn't there and so that "oppression" isn't a word we would use in this discussion. Of course, if we were talking about race relations over the past 100 years, I wouldn't have a problem talking about 'oppression', but we're not. If you're going to still claim that the difference in average income between men and women is due to some sort of malicious intent, even as part of a qualitative argument then I'm not going to participate in these discussions any longer because that premise is unreasonable and unsubstantiated, it's foolish to say that men or even women are maliciously abusing "all women".

Priviledge exists, but it exists for both women and men. If a person is "priviledged" (using your definition of being born into a middle or upperclass background) then that doesn't mean they automatically have "malicious intent", especially directed towards "all women".

Gotta run. Talk to you later.
 
At no point was it established that oppression includes "malicious intent". This is not a witch hunt.
 
Glad you're feeling better today. I actually managed to get a solid 7 hours of sleep - I feel down right human again :D

LovetoGiveRoses said:
As we've decided, "oppression" means To crush or burden through an abuse of power , which includes "malicious intent".
Huh? When did we decide this?! I have consistently claimed exactly the opposite: that oppression does not include malicious intent.
 
Lauren.Hynde said:
At no point was it established that oppression includes "malicious intent". This is not a witch hunt.
Hello there little witchie, you look like you need a lil'hunting *malicious, but sexy, smirk*
 
Lauren.Hynde said:
At no point was it established that oppression includes "malicious intent". This is not a witch hunt.

If the dictionary definition "To CRUSH or burden by abuse of power " is correct then it certainly includes malicious intent. Now, I know that you've said that you've "redefined" oppression to fit y'alls needs, but that just isn't done, its not good form and causes confusion.. The English language is rich and full of lots of words, find one that does fit so the many hundreds of people who are lurking and reading this thread have an commen reference point (our language) and don't use a word that already has a specific meaning.
 
LovetoGiveRoses said:
If the dictionary definition[/i] is correct then it certainly includes malicious intent. Now, I know that you've said that you've "redefined" oppression to fit y'alls needs, but that just isn't done, its not good form and causes confusion.
I was redefining 'oppression' to fit your needs (because you felt 'oppression' carried with it the assumption of intent) - I'm quite happy using the definitions in the dictionaries. And although you may not approve of it, 'it' is actually 'done' regularly within religion, science, philosophy, mathematics, literature, politics, you name it.

Alright, let's talk about the dictionary again then:

Webster's defines 'to oppress' as: to crush or burden by abuse of power or authority. This does not assume intent, malicious or otherwise: you can burden someone through abuse of power without intent to do so. For example: suppose I am a dictator of a poor country, and in order to buy fancy gifts for my husband I raise taxes to a level that burdens my people (perhaps most can no longer even make ends meet). I am oppressing my people - yet there is no malicious intent: I did not raise taxes for the purpose of making them suffer, I didn't even consider them, I was thinking only of how much I wanted to give my beloved husband everything he'd ever dreamed of.

(NOTE: the above example was not meant to assert anything about systemic oppression or male/female inequality, or any other serious issue: it was just to illustrate that 'to oppress' does not imply malicious intent. Furthermore, all people and countries portrayed were works of fiction, and any similarity to actual dictators, husbands, or poor countries is purely coincidental.)

Webster's defines 'oppression' as: a. unjust or cruel exercise of authority or power b. something that oppresses especially in being an unjust or excessive exercise of power. This does not assume intent, malicious or otherwise: in the example of 'crysede the dictator,' the excessive tax burden I have imposed upon my people is unjust, and therefore constitutes oppression.

The English language is rich and full of lots of words, find one that does fit so the many hundreds of people who are lurking and reading this thread have an commen reference point (our language) and don't use a word that already has a specific meaning.
You want me to find an English word that fits my concept, but I can't use a word that already has a specific meaning? How can I possibly satisfy these dual conditions - all English words already have specific meanings, if they didn't they wouldn't be words.
 
Last edited:
crysede said:

You want me to find an English word that fits my concept, but I can't use a word that already has a specific meaning? How can I possibly satisfy these dual conditions - all English words already have specific meanings, if they didn't they wouldn't be words.

LOL...I was late for an appointment and didnt write very well. As I ran out the door, I knew that I'd left something unfinished. Don't want a word that has a specific meaning different from what we/you intend. Don't pick "apple", it already has a specific meaning.
 
Back
Top