Phony diversity

Sandia & HSJ: nice posts. ;)

And, Never: you still rule my lesbian fantasy life. I'm not sure that's praise, but it's the truth. :heart:
 
Originally posted by 70/30
. . . A reason true democracy won't survive is that is exactly what Redwave wants. There are more have nots than haves, we'll vote to fill our own pockets.
As I've said before in this forum, democracy is nothing more than a futile attempt to legitimize mob rule. That is the fundamental reason the founders chose to eliminate it as a governmental mechanism for the United States of America.

What you state here is the recgnition of that fact. And this is precisely the reason why our Federal government was designed as it was. The intent was to minimize the potential for the thuggish behavior of a purely democratic system.

This is the underlying reason behind the specific enumeration of powers granted it

Today's ills in America are the direct result of the past 150 years of the Federal government gradually encroaching on freedom a bit at a time until it has become a monolith difficult to oppose or contain. The government has become the criminal the individual is forbidden to be and punished for being. Yet it continues with impunity to increase its power and abuses, partly for the very reason you state; it has recruited the thugs in society as beneficiaries of its plunder hence, these thugs vote to perpetuate its illegitimate authority.

The fault is not so much in the founders' lack of a cohesive and coherent morality as it is in the total absence of principles and morality in those who have blatantly violated the fundamental law of the land to endow themselves with the power of life and death over other people, a self-annointed royalty of sorts.
 
Unclebill said:

Today's ills in America are the direct result of the past 150 years of the Federal government gradually encroaching on freedom a bit at a time until it has become a monolith difficult to oppose or contain. The government has become the criminal the individual is forbidden to be and punished for being. .
I assume you mean, then, that the "ills in America" primarily affect white men.

I have a feeling that several large groups/identity categories might disagree:
*women (granted enfranchisement less than 100 years ago)
*Black men (granted largely nominal voting rights within your time frame)
*Native Americans (removed to Reservations thanks to lovely thieves like Jackson and only starting to see reparations within the last 75 years)
*Mexicans/Californios (summarily dispossessed of their rights during Western expansion and only declared citizenship-worthy in the last 100 years)
*Asians (actively blocked from rights, and dispossessed of their belongings by ruinous laws like the Foreign Miners' Tax, not fully overturned until after WWII)

They may be somewhat less one-sided in their view of how the last 150 years have changed the country. And I suspect that not all of it would be seen by those parties as the "gradual encroaching on freedom"--they may even, in fact, see it as the gradual winning of freedom.

Possessive individualism sets up the mythology that the person left holding the goods at the end of production is the person most directly responsible for creating it. Thus, the historical Plantation owner profits exponentially on exploited labor; until very recently housewives do the majority of the work to maintain working (and even middle) class homes while remaining politically disenfranchised. And also, privileged and enfranchised white men tend to get very threatened by the possibility of not holding all the cards and writing all the rules of the game.

Collectivity, the great Satan pointed to by Possessive Individualists in "Objectivist" clothing, is nothing more than a recognition that human lives are fundamentally interwoven. The advantage of one, and this is borne out in repeated patterns by history, comes at the disadvantage of another when we lose sight of this fact.

Exploitation is never freedom.
 
70/30 said:
George Washington hated few people more than Thomas Jefferson. John Adams hated Jefferson during the time in question but not as much as Hamilton. Madison lurks around somewhere in between. Frankin was on his own while he was alive. Average 'em out and that is basically what the Founders intended. I don't like picking Jefferson as a model, its an extreme. A reason true democracy won't survive is that is exactly what Redwave wants. There are more have nots than haves, we'll vote to fill our own pockets.

Just addressing the "have/have not" thing. There is no such thing as true and rampant poverty in the United States. When you are defined as being poverty striken when you have only two color TV's and one automobile is not a definition of poverty in my book.

Yes, I see the homeless on the streets. All the time. Most are there for one of two reasons, chemical dependencies (drugs or alcohol, alcohol being the most prevelant reason) and mental illness. In many cases both. I have a great deal of sympathy for both. But most of all for the mentally ill. In that dept. we are not doing as well as we should. But the government took that task over from the charitable organizations long ago and has dropped the ball. With respect to those with dependencies. You cannot cure them unless they really desire to be cured. You can put them in rehab and dry them out, but unless the will is there as soon as they hit the street they'll be right back where they started. Incarceration works, but it's hardly justice and is damned expensive to boot.

The greatest pockets of poverty are within the immigrant community. (Particularly the Latins.) And the fact of the matter is that they are living better here than they were where they came from, or else they'd go home. Wouldn't they? They may not be educated, but they aren't stupid either. But even they eventually start business's and grow out of the immigrant ghetto.

It is a truism that all men aren't created equal. If we were, we'd all be equally smart, equally good looking, equally hung like a mule, or built like a brick shithouse, equally wealthy, healthy, and wise. But we aren't. So the best that can be offered is equality of opportunity and justice. We cannot offer, or expect, equality of outcome.

Freedom has it's cost's. Just as we are free to invest in a company that produces the latest and greatest pain killer, we are also free to invest in Enron. If we are free to make good choices, then it is axiomatic that we must also be free to make bad choices too. We revel in our good choices and pay for the bad ones. A society that does not pay for it's bad choices is a society in which nothing is learned. (A fine example of this is the various state lotteries. The winners have been tracked by various study groups and it has been found that a winner from the lower income groups invariably is impoverished within 3 years of winning the lottery. Why? The consensus is that it was for the very reason they were at the bottom of the income ladder to begin with. Poor choices, the first being education.) Or to put it another way, when Communism became the international rage and the concept of income redistribution and egalitarianism was the topic of the day, John D. Rockefeller the senior was asked about it. He said, "I don't care if you take all the money in the world, put it in one pile and divide it equally among all the peoples of the world. In one year I'll be as wealthy as I am today."

There are people out there that suffer temporary misfortune. But they generally recover. Why? They make good choices.

But the media makes good play out of it. I'm reminded of the wild fires in Ca. last year. Million dollar houses in the canyons burning and one local reporterette opinning, "Oh this is horrible. These people have lost everything they own. They're now homeless." And I remember thinking that if you live in a million dollar house and you're to fucking stupid to get insurance, you deserve to be homeless.

Ishmael
 
RisiaSkye said:



Exploitation is never freedom.

ROFLMAO

This is the culmination of all you said before. And guess what? It's not new at all. It is based on the idea that all transactions necessarily involve a 'winner' and a "loser". That all commerce between men is neccessarily exploitive in nature.

The concept is over a hundred years old and is outlined in a book. "Das Kapital", by Karl Marx.

I thought that discredited crap had finally been put to rest. But then again, REDWAVE is still around.

:rolleyes:

Ishmael
 
The Blind Who Will Not See . . .

Ishmael said:


Just addressing the "have/have not" thing. There is no such thing as true and rampant poverty in the United States.

Hi Ishmael,

Perhaps you haven't travelled enough . . . they say travel broadens the mind . . . gives you experiences beyond your normal daily life . . . you can see different things to your usual environment . . . but you must open your eyes and perceive the images . . .


Hi Risia,

Great post . . . where corporations have profit shared with the workers there has been less industrial problems and greater productivity from a happier work force. In Oz the Fletcher Jones Clothing Company has been an industry leader for years because of this principle. There are other examples.

However, does your housewife example challenge the concept of the family unit dividing work into complemantary roles as opposed to the rights of an individual to be fulfilled in their choice of careers regardless of the domestic needs of the family group??

In Oz, women in South Australia got the vote in 1892 then at Federation in 1901 other states were forced to concede the vote to Europeans. But not Aborigines who were specifically excluded, then totally excluded by the 1905 decision of Isaac Isaacs CJ the first Chief Justice and a rabid anti-Aboriginal campaigner. The Aborigines remained non-citizens subject to genocidal eugenic government policies until the 1967 referendum granted them citizenship (in their own country) and the 1975 Racial Discrimination Act gave them the legislative tools to accept their rights.
 
Great points from three sides but reform isn't likely no matter how shiny the arguments sound,

"The science of government it is my duty to study, more than all other sciences; the arts of legislation and administration and NEGOTIATION..." John Adams

I'm for a compact goverment (that includes less intrusive police) but answers to things I care about: preserving the environment, education (I feel I'm aware of many of the real hardships encountered in urban schools), and ways to ensure corporations and the military don't gain unchecked power. Until things of that nature are addressed, status quo wins-and I am glad to let the perpetual left and right war even things out enough.
 
Re: The Blind Who Will Not See . . .

Don K Dyck said:


Hi Ishmael,

Perhaps you haven't travelled enough . . . they say travel broadens the mind . . . gives you experiences beyond your normal daily life . . . you can see different things to your usual environment . . . but you must open your eyes and perceive the images . . .


I've traveled the United States more than most, and the world as well. You might try the same.

Ishmael
 
RisiaSkye said:
Sandia & HSJ: nice posts. ;)

And, Never: you still rule my lesbian fantasy life. I'm not sure that's praise, but it's the truth. :heart:

Risia: So... were my posts nice or not? Your winkie is confusing me.
But don't you dare try to steal Never away from me, sweetie. She's mine MINE MINE...
(At least in fantasy.)


I liked this:
Possessive individualism sets up the mythology that the person left holding the goods at the end of production is the person most directly responsible for creating it.... And also, privileged and enfranchised white men tend to get very threatened by the possibility of not holding all the cards and writing all the rules of the game.

I agree entirely that the wealthiest people are not the ones who contribute most to society or the economy. They are the ones who are in a position - for whatever reason - to benefit the most.

However, I want to pick a bone with you on the "privileged and enfranchised white men. I'm not sure white men are as privileged and enfranchised as they seem.

7) The single largest student population on my campus, and the ones with the most money and access to facilities and educational advancement opportunities like internships (based on the enrollment statistics, application stats, and tabulated student cost) is white males.

Here in Cali, the quota system was instituted as a Conservative response to calls for un-biased entry standards. Instead, campuses got quotas, which--contrary to what I keep hearing--actually help to ensure that one of the least-white states in the nation still has mostly-white student populations. I live fifteen miles from Mexico, and have had two Mexican-descended students. I'm sure that's *entirely* about performance and aptitude, right?

These are the stats for Berkley:

Undergraduate Diversity
African American 4%
Asian American 44%
Chicano/Latino 10%
White 32%
Other/Unknown 10%
Female 53%
*Fall 2001 data

http://www.ucop.edu/news********s/ucb.pdf

California as a whole, on the other hand is only 12% Asian American.

UC-Irvine:

Indicative of most California campuses, Orange County's highly respected UC Irvine boasts a 52% Asian population. Asian Americans are twice as likely as whites to have an advanced college degree.

http://goldsea.com/Features/California2k/california2k.html

Asian's also have a higher average household income than whites:
With a median household income of $45,249 in 1997 Asian Pacific Islanders hung onto the top spot, according to the U.S. Census Bureau... White households had a median household income of $38,972...

http://goldsea.com/AAD/income.html
 
70/30 said:
Great points from three sides but reform isn't likely no matter how shiny the arguments sound,

"The science of government it is my duty to study, more than all other sciences; the arts of legislation and administration and NEGOTIATION..." John Adams

I'm for a compact goverment (that includes less intrusive police) but answers to things I care about: preserving the environment, education (I feel I'm aware of many of the real hardships encountered in urban schools), and ways to ensure corporations and the military don't gain unchecked power. Until things of that nature are addressed, status quo wins-and I am glad to let the perpetual left and right war even things out enough.

My God, are we back to the old military paranoia trip?

A few facts. THere has never been a military coup in a primarily capitalistic society. That distiction has been reserved for dictatorships and socialist societies.

If the US ever was a candidate for such, it was during Viet Nam where the civilian leadership pissed away 50,000 lives with inept leadership. The military was pissed, but they still followed orders.

Contrary to popular myth, the military is the group least likely to want to go to war. They are the sharp end of the stick and the ones that will die. If you find the time, you should read "Once an Eagle" by Anton Myrer. It is required reading at the Army War College and it's re-publishing was commissioned by the same body.

Ishmael
 
Sandia said:


Risia: So... were my posts nice or not? Your winkie is confusing me.
But don't you dare try to steal Never away from me, sweetie. She's mine MINE MINE...
(At least in fantasy.)


I liked this:


I agree entirely that the wealthiest people are not the ones who contribute most to society or the economy. They are the ones who are in a position - for whatever reason - to benefit the most.

However, I want to pick a bone with you on the "privileged and enfranchised white men. I'm not sure white men are as privileged and enfranchised as they seem.





These are the stats for Berkley:

Undergraduate Diversity
African American 4%
Asian American 44%
Chicano/Latino 10%
White 32%
Other/Unknown 10%
Female 53%
*Fall 2001 data

http://www.ucop.edu/news********s/ucb.pdf

California as a whole, on the other hand is only 12% Asian American.

UC-Irvine:



http://goldsea.com/Features/California2k/california2k.html

Asian's also have a higher average household income than whites:


http://goldsea.com/AAD/income.html

Good post Sandia.

An observation here.

The Asians worship knowledge. Educatuion means a great deal to them as a culture. In that respect the number are very much in line.

The other point is that the Asians are more likely to major in the hard sciences (engineering, math, etc.), medicine, or law. As a group they stay away from the lower paying less challenging professions. So the income levels are not much of a surprise either.

What I find distressing is the number of people that major in non-challenging fields and then expect the same pay as the rocket scientist.

Go figure. :rolleyes:

Ishmael
 
Sandia said:


Risia: So... were my posts nice or not? Your winkie is confusing me.
But don't you dare try to steal Never away from me, sweetie. She's mine MINE MINE...
(At least in fantasy.)


I liked this:


I agree entirely that the wealthiest people are not the ones who contribute most to society or the economy. They are the ones who are in a position - for whatever reason - to benefit the most.

However, I want to pick a bone with you on the "privileged and enfranchised white men. I'm not sure white men are as privileged and enfranchised as they seem.





These are the stats for Berkley:

Undergraduate Diversity
African American 4%
Asian American 44%
Chicano/Latino 10%
White 32%
Other/Unknown 10%
Female 53%
*Fall 2001 data

http://www.ucop.edu/news********s/ucb.pdf

California as a whole, on the other hand is only 12% Asian American.

Well, Berkeley (like Stanford) is disproportionately representative of Northern California residents as well as Asians. Interestingly, there are more second and third generation Asian families in Northern California (especially the Bay Area and Silicon Valley) than in the rest of the state.

Also, you'll notice that when talking about my own (SoCal) campus, I separated by both race and gender. Your statistics don't do the same. Asian women conveniently fill two "diversity" categories, for example...and on my campus, they're the second most numerous populace of students, after white men.

But, thanks for the stats nonetheless.
 
Ishmael said:


My God, are we back to the old military paranoia trip?

A few facts. THere has never been a military coup in a primarily capitalistic society. That distiction has been reserved for dictatorships and socialist societies.

If the US ever was a candidate for such, it was during Viet Nam where the civilian leadership pissed away 50,000 lives with inept leadership. The military was pissed, but they still followed orders.

Contrary to popular myth, the military is the group least likely to want to go to war. They are the sharp end of the stick and the ones that will die. If you find the time, you should read "Once an Eagle" by Anton Myrer. It is required reading at the Army War College and it's re-publishing was commissioned by the same body.

Ishmael

You thought that's what I meant but it's not. I think there is something to the old Military Industrial Complex. I don't think constantly building weapons and finding somewhere to use them is the right way to help keep an economy afloat.
 
:) Hi there. Hey Ish, I'm still reading.

I think the same people that argue that there's not a "collectivist" bias on college campuses, would also argue that overall the media is objective also (which is, in fact, the media's perception of themselves).

You make the point that many of the campuses have a strong "collectivist" bias, and I think a couple people specifically point to ivy league schools. In spite of the "leanings", it does seem that many if not most of the graduates that don't go into teaching, become conservatives. I think that this was the gist of one of the many "Atlantic Magazine" articles I've read on the topic. I'm generalizing, but I think I'm accurately reflecting the demographic trends that I've read about (which is generalizing of course).
 
Last edited:
This is a good thread. Certainly thought provoking. I'm too tired to read too much more tonight though, so I bid y'all adieu.
 
Does anyone have the stats for UC Irvine or UCLA. I'll bet they're not too far different than Berkley, but I'd like to see the stats.
 
A Rare Point of Agreement

Ishmael said:


My God, are we back to the old military paranoia trip?

A few facts. THere has never been a military coup in a primarily capitalistic society. That distiction has been reserved for dictatorships and socialist societies.

If the US ever was a candidate for such, it was during Viet Nam where the civilian leadership pissed away 50,000 lives with inept leadership. The military was pissed, but they still followed orders.

Contrary to popular myth, the military is the group least likely to want to go to war. They are the sharp end of the stick and the ones that will die. If you find the time, you should read "Once an Eagle" by Anton Myrer. It is required reading at the Army War College and it's re-publishing was commissioned by the same body.

Ishmael

Re MILITARY COUPS

The is a long history of military coups in Greece, Chile, Argentina and many other western hemisphere countries . . . the presence of the CIA was a prerequisite.


Re THE SECOND REVOLUTION

Kissinger, considered a war criminal by many non-Americans, considered that we achieved the Second American Revolution with the overthrow of the Vietnam campaign. I won't argue right/wrong here, that is pointless. Rather, just note that our generation changed history because we questioned the right of governments and those business entities who control them, to slaughter the youth of the country to generate corporate profits. The younger people may look at the musical "Hair" to see the killing chain established by the out-of-control military.


Re MILITARY LAST IN

I agree. Anybody who has seen active duty will speak out against going to war unless it is absolutely essential.

That is why the four most senior military advisors to Dubyah STRONGLY ADVISE AGAINST going to war with Iraq. But there is a hidden agenda in place . . .


Hi 70/30. I agree - there are better ways of stimulating the economy . . . Clinton seemed to find them for eight years, why did they suddenly vanished in February 2000??
 
Last edited:
LovetoGiveRoses said:
:) Hi there. Hey Ish, I'm still reading.

I think the same people that argue that there's not a "collectivist" bias on college campuses, would also argue that overall the media is objective also (which is, in fact, the media's perception of themselves).
No, I wouldn't.

In fact, I wouldn't even try to make the claim that "the media" has any meaning whatsoever, not to mention attempt to blanketly comdemn or endorse it. Not all images, sources, and means of communication are equivalent.
 
70/30 said:


You thought that's what I meant but it's not. I think there is something to the old Military Industrial Complex. I don't think constantly building weapons and finding somewhere to use them is the right way to help keep an economy afloat.

Actually, there was some truth to it. And who raised the issue and waved the red flag?

Now as to "finding somewhere" to use it. You leave the impression that the military was some how clandestinely creating wars in which to try out it's new hardware. Not true at all. Not Eisenhower, nor Kennedy, nor LBJ, nor Nixon were 'puppets' of the military. They were their own men for better or worse and they are the ones that made the decisions regarding the use of the military.

The advantage of having a strong military is that you shouldn't have to use it all that often. A would be aggressor thinks twice before taking on a strong military. (Terrorists do not think in these terms unfortunately, and in some cases the opponent having a strong military works for them.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:


<SNIP>

Now as to "finding somewhere" to use it. You leave the impression that the military was some how clandestinely creating wars in which to try out it's new hardware. Not true at all. Not Eisenhower, nor Kennedy, nor LBJ, nor Nixon were 'puppets' of the military. They were their own men for better or worse and they are the ones that made the decisions regarding the use of the military.

The advantage of having a strong military is that you shouldn't have to use it all that often. A would be aggressor thinks twice before taking on a strong military. (Terrorists do not think in these terms unfortunately, and in some cases the opponent having a strong military works for them. Ishmael

Evening Ishmael,

I agree that conventional military holds that a strong military repels invasion as you describe.

However, I think the evidence shows that Kennedy was dubious about going into Vietnam and that was part of the reason he was assassinated. LBJ had the US into Vietnam very quickly after he was installed, within a week if I remember correctly. Of course there was no conspiracy here . . . especially as Lady Bird was alleged to receive several million shares in the barge company shipping munitions across the Pacific to the war theatre.
 
Re: A Rare Point of Agreement

Don K Dyck said:


Re MILITARY COUPS

The is a long history of military coups in Greece, Chile, Argentina and many other western hemisphere countries . . . the presence of the CIA was a prerequisite.

LOL, you give the CIA far more credit that it's due. It really is your 'boogey man', isn't it. Of course the KGB doen't figure into the equation at all, does it?


Don K Dyck said:
Re THE SECOND REVOLUTION

Kissinger, considered a war criminal by many non-Americans, considered that we achieved the Second American Revolution with the overthrow of the Vietnam campaign. I won't argue right/wrong here, that is pointless. Rather, just note that our generation changed history because we questioned the right of governments and those business entities who control them, to slaughter the youth of the country to generate corporate profits. The younger people may look at the musical "Hair" to see the killing chain established by the out-of-control military.

The military wasn't "out of control". There certainly was an administration in power in Washington that was inept in matters of foriegn policy and the use of the military as an extension of that policy. Popular opinion certainly did play a role. Hence LBJ's decision NOT to seek re-election and Nixon's agenda to extricate us from that mess. (The issues concerning whether we should have been there to begin with started long before the 60's.) You are also wrong that the civilian authorities did that in the interests of the large corporations. One of the first lesson's of politics and statesmanship is that war depletes the national treasury, not increases it.


Don K Dyck said:
Re MILITARY LAST IN

I agree. Anybody who has seen active duty will speak out against going to war unless it is absolutely essential.

That is why the four most senior military advisors to Dubyah STRONGLY ADVISE AGAINST going to war with Iraq. But there is a hidden agenda in place . . .

Yes, it's all a great conspiracy and there is a small group of men somewhere that meet occasionally to decide the fate of the world and all it's peoples.


Don K Dyck said:

Hi 70/30. I agree - there are better ways of stimulating the economy . . . Clinton seemed to find them for eight years, why did they suddenly vanished in February 2000??

Sure, Clinton knew that Gore was going to lose and wanted to make sure the economy was in the tank when the new Republican admin. took over the reins of power. :rolleyes:

Ishmael
 
Don K Dyck said:


Evening Ishmael,

I agree that conventional military holds that a strong military repels invasion as you describe.

However, I think the evidence shows that Kennedy was dubious about going into Vietnam and that was part of the reason he was assassinated. LBJ had the US into Vietnam very quickly after he was installed, within a week if I remember correctly. Of course there was no conspiracy here . . . especially as Lady Bird was alleged to receive several million shares in the barge company shipping munitions across the Pacific to the war theatre.

Kennedy was cautious. Especially after the Bay of Pigs thing. History certainly would have been different had he lived, how much so is any one's guess. The facts are that Kennedy was building up in Viet Nam, however slowly, building none the less.

I discount all of the theories concerning JFK's death. The 'conspiracy' theorists have been stymied on every particular. But the discussion holds popularity and gives people something to talk about I suppose.

The chances that Lady Bird, or any other American, made a bundle in the shipping business at that time is remote. American tax policy and maritime policy at the time had effectively gutted the maritime shipping industry as far as US owned companies were concerned. A great many foriegn shipping companies benefited though.

Ishmael
 
RisiaSkye said:

No, I wouldn't.

In fact, I wouldn't even try to make the claim that "the media" has any meaning whatsoever, not to mention attempt to blanketly comdemn or endorse it. Not all images, sources, and means of communication are equivalent.

No, I wouldn't either. If by "the media" you are referring to the handful of corporations that own and produce over 90% of the media content, you must acknowledge that they, like any other corporation, are motivated by one factor: maximizing profits.

And, like any other corporation, they are fundamentally anti-democratic in their politics. (Not speaking about the Democratic party, of course, but about the fact that a corporation is not a democratic institution.)
 
RisiaSkye said:

No, I wouldn't.

In fact, I wouldn't even try to make the claim that "the media" has any meaning whatsoever, not to mention attempt to blanketly comdemn or endorse it. Not all images, sources, and means of communication are equivalent.

"The media" is run by corporations and those corporations don't "vote" to promote people into management positions, except for senior management positions (who have their positions courtesy of the board of directors). Is it a bad thing that people promoted based on capability rather than by a vote?

Your response isn't very clear, but I guess you're saying that there is no "The media" and therefore they are politically neutral?
 
Hamletmaschine said:


No, I wouldn't either. If by "the media" you are referring to the handful of corporations that own and produce over 90% of the media content, you must acknowledge that they, like any other corporation, are motivated by one factor: maximizing profits.

And, like any other corporation, they are fundamentally anti-democratic in their politics. (Not speaking about the Democratic party, of course, but about the fact that a corporation is not a democratic institution.)

Profit is certainly a motive, but they are still very liberal in how they present the news and other information to the general public.
 
Back
Top