Phony diversity

Ishmael said:


The problem is that diversity is defined, no not defined, worshipped, in all respects other than political leanings. The Conservative point of view is not to be tolerated. Why should a professor of mathmatics, or physics, or anthropology be questioned concerning his/her political leanings in a sob interview? That is exactly what is occurring today.

<snip>

Ishmael

This thread is becoming surreal. Okay it seems to have started out that way, but Hitler and Stalin? I just skimmed through, but I don't get it.

Anyway, I know Hamletmaschine has responded to this quote, but I feel I must add my voice. I have recently been through many job interviews and not once was asked a thing about my political leanings. It just didn't matter. I have never intimated any hint of my political opinions in my lectures. There just isn't time. I have never put a politically biased question on an exam. It just wouldn't make any sense - sort of like this thread.

I don't believe for a minute that what you claim is occurring today throughout our college campuses are actually happening. Do you really believe that a math professor wrote an exam based on his opinion of Bush's ability to govern? I don't think so.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
It's remarkable that those who have spent little or no time in the education profession all feel like they are experts on how it is and how it should be. Rather like me presuming to tell Bill Gates how he ought to run his corporation because I own a computer.

What do you teach?
 
Never said:
Hamletmaschine:
“Students are as they always have been. They want to get drunk and get laid. The only "ism" they're interested in is hedonism.”


Students want to get drunk and get laid as much or as little as anyone else. Most students don’t lead hedonistic lifestyles, more than a few would have no idea what that word means, and most are very concerned with various ‘ism’s.


You're going to the wrong school, Never.
 
alltherage said:
Both sides worry far too much about the influence of the right and the left. It seems to me that conservative thought and practice are quite strong in the U.S.
It could be argued that the the past 20 years has seen a strong move to the right in american politics. Even Mr. Clinton was no traditional liberal. For all the rants about college campuses being too liberal it would seem to have had little impact in the country. I think what happens is that those graduates from the top universitys begin to make very substantial incomes and suddenly all the ideals they held so close in college that now might cost them money( in the form of taxes) become secondary.

So, it's OK to spend thousands of dollars on your childrens education to have them taught (indoctrinated with) irrevelant and useless dogma so that once they are in the real world they have to learn for themselves?

My son did get some good education in his core courses, but as he once said to me concerning his "social" electives, "I wish that I could turn in my papers written on toilet paper. At least they'd be usefull for something once they'd been graded."

Fortunately I attended before the university systems had been 'dumbed down' with PC bullshit.

Ishmael
 
Sandia said:
Yes, yes, yes. I've heard about the forty million killed under Stalin (though last time I heard seems like it was twenty million.) And I heard about it in college.
Good for you.

But among other things, these people are not people who were killed in concentration camps, they're people who supposedly died due to Stalin's economic programs, right?
Wrong. Of the approx. 62 million people murdered during the Soviet regime of 1917-1987, approximately 40 million were murdered in camps (mostly Gulags) - under ten million died due to famine.

These numbers get thrown out because they supposedly prove something; but what do they prove? That you can assess the relative merits of conservatism and liberalism by the number of bodies laid at the feet of Hitler and Stalin?
That power concentrated in government is dangerous. The book "Death by Government" by Rummel, does a fairly good job of comparing governments that are totalitarian to governments which are more "democratic". The differences are dramatic.
 
CoolidgEffect said:


This thread is becoming surreal. Okay it seems to have started out that way, but Hitler and Stalin? I just skimmed through, but I don't get it.

There's that intellectual elitism surfacing again. We want the truth, bastards, not just your biased perspective!!!
 
70/30 said:


There's that intellectual elitism surfacing again. We want the truth, bastards, not just your biased perspective!!!

That was the truth based on my personal experience. Or didn't you read that far.
 
Sandia said:


What do you teach?

This semester I'm teaching:

"The Evils of Capitalism 101."
"Kill Your Parents 330."

And I'm offering a special topics course this semester for advanced communi-- err ... students: "George W. Bush is Dumber than Ronald Reagan, and Reagan has Been Brain Dead since 1976."
 
CoolidgEffect said:


That was the truth based on my personal experience. Or didn't you read that far.

It was sarcasm but I expect guys in tweed jackets and smoking a pipe not to get it.
 
CoolidgEffect said:


This thread is becoming surreal. Okay it seems to have started out that way, but Hitler and Stalin? I just skimmed through, but I don't get it.

Anyway, I know Hamletmaschine has responded to this quote, but I feel I must add my voice. I have recently been through many job interviews and not once was asked a thing about my political leanings. It just didn't matter. I have never intimated any hint of my political opinions in my lectures. There just isn't time. I have never put a politically biased question on an exam. It just wouldn't make any sense - sort of like this thread.

I don't believe for a minute that what you claim is occurring today throughout our college campuses are actually happening. Do you really believe that a math professor wrote an exam based on his opinion of Bush's ability to govern? I don't think so.

First of all, no. There is no little box on the application regarding political affiliation. But then there is the lunch with one of the faculty. "What do you think about such and the like." Offhand little questions like that.

And no, I don't expect the math professor to have anything like you described on the test. But most professor's like to chat about things in the class room and the podium is a powerful platform. I had but two professors that were all business every minute and both were in the sciences (as might be expected). So I acknowledge that that are some, such as you proclaim yourself to be, that leave their politics outside the classroom. But my experience (and both my son's) has been that they are few and far between.

However, I do have to give the writer of the article some credit for knowing of what he speaks being he is the former departmant chair for his college of the university and the people he routinely corresponds with are also in academia. He and one of his best friends, Thomas Sowell, are also traveling lecturers in their field, so both have the opportunity to visit many universities over the course of a year. While both are economists, neither are unintelligent or unobservant. Both are accomplished writers and both are emminently respected in their field. This does bestow on them a certain credibility.

Ishmael
 
Kill your Parents 330 sounds interesting. I'm certain it has many applications outside of a family relationship as well.

What elective or requirement does it fill?
 
Hamletmaschine said:


This semester I'm teaching:

"The Evils of Capitalism 101."
"Kill Your Parents 330."

And I'm offering a special topics course this semester for advanced communi-- err ... students: "George W. Bush is Dumber than Ronald Reagan, and Reagan has Been Brain Dead since 1976."

Oh Good. You're teaching similar courses. I am more familiar with the Brain Dead than the Evil Capitalism material. I hope your are sharing your notes on the double secret professors-r-liberals.edu site.

Oops, I shouldn't have said that.
 
Ishmael said:


First of all, no. There is no little box on the application regarding political affiliation. But then there is the lunch with one of the faculty. "What do you think about such and the like." Offhand little questions like that.

And no, I don't expect the math professor to have anything like you described on the test. But most professor's like to chat about things in the class room and the podium is a powerful platform. I had but two professors that were all business every minute and both were in the sciences (as might be expected). So I acknowledge that that are some, such as you proclaim yourself to be, that leave their politics outside the classroom. But my experience (and both my son's) has been that they are few and far between.

However, I do have to give the writer of the article some credit for knowing of what he speaks being he is the former departmant chair for his college of the university and the people he routinely corresponds with are also in academia. He and one of his best friends, Thomas Sowell, are also traveling lecturers in their field, so both have the opportunity to visit many universities over the course of a year. While both are economists, neither are unintelligent or unobservant. Both are accomplished writers and both are emminently respected in their field. This does bestow on them a certain credibility.

Ishmael

Well this explains a few things to me. First at my lunches, the concern was more about my ability to write a fundable grant and the ability to provide the prober resources than anything else. And being in the sciences, I don't take the time to take about the political world. It doesn't apply, and I pay little attention to it myself.

How separate are economics and politics? That speaks to Thomas Sowell as a source.
 
Originally posted by Ishmael
However, I do have to give the writer of the article some credit for knowing of what he speaks being he is the former departmant chair for his college of the university and the people he routinely corresponds with are also in academia. He and one of his best friends, Thomas Sowell, are also traveling lecturers in their field, so both have the opportunity to visit many universities over the course of a year. While both are economists, neither are unintelligent or unobservant. Both are accomplished writers and both are emminently respected in their field. This does bestow on them a certain credibility.

Then they are, by your lights, necessarily tainted with evils of the liberal-socialist agenda of academia. How in the world were they ever saved from such a horrid fate, I wonder? Do you think their family members staged an intervention?

We all have war stories about various outrages that have been committed by those in power in various professions. Most of us don't draw sweeping generalizations from them, however.

Originally posted by Never
Kill your Parents 330 sounds interesting. I'm certain it has many applications outside of a family relationship as well.

They don't call it the Liberal Arts for nuthin', ya know.

Originally Posted by CoolidgeEffect
Oh Good. You're teaching similar courses. I am more familiar with the Brain Dead than the Evil Capitalism material. I hope your are sharing your notes on the double secret professors-r-liberals.edu site.

It'll be discussed at the next Party meeting, Komrade.
 
Shy Tall Guy said:
I am glad you find it amusing, of course with all your years of experience with colleges of universities over the past 50 years you have much more informed point of view than I. Oh wait, I forgot, you haven't been around that long. Nevermind. :rolleyes:

I'm thoroughly embarassed, please do forgive me for thinking that I had an informed, intelligent mind.

I really thought more of you than this. Hell, I thought you thought more of me than this. I would have expected this from many people - I've gotten it from many people, but not you.

Thanks again for reminding me that because I'm 21, I don't know shit. Thanks a whole fucking lot.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
It's remarkable that those who have spent little or no time in the education profession all feel like they are experts on how it is and how it should be. Rather like me presuming to tell Bill Gates how he ought to run his corporation because I own a computer.
Amen, Hamlet. A-fucking-men.

Okay, a few things that disturb me here:
1) At my campus, the majority of the "multiculturalism" agenda was implemented under the Reagan administration, and irritates the shit out of the campus Liberals. Here in Cali, the quota system was instituted as a Conservative response to calls for un-biased entry standards. Instead, campuses got quotas, which--contrary to what I keep hearing--actually help to ensure that one of the least-white states in the nation still has mostly-white student populations. I live fifteen miles from Mexico, and have had two Mexican-descended students. I'm sure that's *entirely* about performance and aptitude, right?

2) "Liberal" is not just a political grouping that can be substituted with "Democrat." The Liberal ideology is for progressive thought and tranformation of knowledge. Look it up, and then be clear in the use of your terminology.

3) I'd be interested to see the voting statistics on those with the real power on campus--the Administration, Provosts, Deans, and Board of Regents.

4) Many people in education register Demo (in my admittedly limited experience) for reasons of platform priorities: Democrats consistently feature education and other social issues higher on the agenda. Teachers are, understandably, concerned to see education remain a high priority in public policy.

5) I've never given a grade based on a student's politics. I don't give a shit whatsoever about their politics, frankly. I care that they think and can make and support a coherent argument.

I have, however, had students accuse me of grading them down because they were white males. (Interestingly, I've tracked my grade statistics since I started, out of curiosity. To date, my highest percentage of A grades has gone to white males, followed by Asian males, then white women). I even had one student complain to my boss that they couldn't learn from me, because I wear too many black clothes. I've voluntarily had all of those grades (the ones that students bitched about) reviewed by outside panels--including the parents. Not one of my grades has ever been overturned.

In my experience, students have freedom of expression and belief. What they don't have, however, is a bully pulpit. This seems to annoy some of them, particularly those who've not had to work very hard thus far in their lives. Race, creed, etc. don't seem to unify grade-complaints nearly so much as money. Nearly all of the students who've complained about their grades (not just the ones I've given, but all those in my office) have been wealthy students. I've also been told by more than one student that their parents encourage them to complain about their grades, in hopes that just asking for it or saying "but I worked really hard" will ensure them a better grade.

6) The people I've most consistently seen complaining that they're being discriminated against on college campuses are white males.

7) The single largest student population on my campus, and the ones with the most money and access to facilities and educational advancement opportunities like internships (based on the enrollment statistics, application stats, and tabulated student cost) is white males.

8) I've never once heard a student complain that they may have been favored for their politics, race, religion, or other identity category. I've only heard it discussed when a student has decided they've been punished for such things--and such complaints are often, again only in my experience, a slipshod cover for lousy work done by the student. It's a remarkable system that way. :rolleyes: I've noticed that bias only works against students. And interestingly, it seems to work most aggregiously against white males. Who knew?

9) You can't have it both ways. If liberal-radicals managed to develop in the Eisenhower era of education, then conservative-radicals should be developing just fine, no matter what educational model they're currently under.

10) Political ideology and voter-registration don't correspond on a one-to-one basis. Just because someone registers Dem doesn't mean that they're only and always far-Left.
 
And a big Amen, to you, too, Risia. Excellent points, all down the line.
 
Last edited:
People, please don't bait me....I'll get angry and you wouldn't like me when I'm angry...
 
Shy Tall Guy said:
I did, until your snide remarks deriding my point of view.

Later - or rather, so long.

It is sad that you are so self absorbed that you took her post about the thread personally. So much so that you made a personal attack on her. I guess when she says, "...you people" she really means STG.

For someone that is insinuating age you are not exhibiting maturity.
 
Originally posted by Shy Tall Guy
. . . I didn't say they did - I inferred that they may be embaressed by it. Why? Because many are socialists (they call themselves "progressives" or "liberals", but they are really socialists) and the millions were murdered in the name of socialism.
Let's not lose sight of the fact that Hitler's Nazi Party was a contraction of the real name, the National Socialist Party.

And the differences between Socialism, Communism, Fascism and other collectivist systems is rhetoric, propaganda and window dressing.

The underlying principles are common to all: three primary tenets are the negation of individual rights, truth is whatever advances the benefit of the collective and the end justifies the means.
Originally posted by lavender
. . . Liberals, in this day and age, are mainly capitalists. . .
From all my exposure to the Liberal ideology and attitude, this is a contradiction in terms. Liberals are collectivists, mostly socialistic from my experience, and that is the antithesis of capitalists.
Originally posted by lavender
. . . Thus, conservatives feel the need to bash all the time. . .
I love how it's always bashing when you merely tell the truth about the liberal mentality.
 
Back
Top