Mental Illness

Yeah, I've read Sacks. He's a great read. I remember when I worked at the PA state loony bin, we had a resident (they call them "consumers" there, something that made me want to blow the place up) who was an asshole. Just a real prick, you know? Everyone sort of just shook their heads and tolerated his passive-aggressive bullshit, acting like it was some issue related to his disease. Until one day he pointed his artillery at me, and I asked him straight out, "James, do you realize that even though you're mentally ill, you can still act like a decent human being?" My boss hauled me into the office and gave me a tongue lashing. She later apologized, when James told her I was right, that he knew he was an asshole and used his dx to get away with it.

I remember 'consumers.' My hospital went so far as to make employees out of patients. They called them co-facilitators and paid them. After I chased a few of them out of my medical records file cabinets the shit hit the fan, and I dared management to fuck with me about it. Make my fucking day! They backed off with the lunacy. Cuz patients aint shrinks, and their status was entirely abitrary feel-good bull shit.
 
i would say we treat the mentally ill differently because they're occasionally very annoying/super fucking scary. they just make you feel deeply uncomfortable and that makes you want to avoid them and just pretend they don't exist or even matter. you can't really say the same thing for cancer patients. it's sad, but i think that's a huge part of it.

also, people take joy in being self centered cunts.
 
Last edited:
I remember 'consumers.' My hospital went so far as to make employees out of patients. They called them co-facilitators and paid them. After I chased a few of them out of my medical records file cabinets the shit hit the fan, and I dared management to fuck with me about it. Make my fucking day! They backed off with the lunacy. Cuz patients aint shrinks, and their status was entirely abitrary feel-good bull shit.
It made me crazy, because I came from emergency medicine, where a patient is a patient, and the mental health people kept agitating for what they call "parity," meaning treat mental health patients the same as other patients wrt insurance and policy and whatnot, which is certainly a worthy cause. But if that's what you expect, then use the same language as everyone else in medicine.
i would say we treat the mentall ill differently because they're occasionally very annoying/super fucking scary. they just make you feel deeply uncomfortable and that makes you want to avoid them and just pretend they don't exist or even matter. you can really say the same thing for cancer patients. it's sad, but i think that's a huge part of it.

also, people take joy in being self centered cunts.
Xenophobia is almost certainly the bulk of it. I guess there's a deep seated and primal fear of the ill in us, which makes sense as an evolutionary strategy.
 
stuff does nothing good for me. i hate feeling stoned and all i can think about are how pretty it would be to kill the irritating people around me.

my doc gave me the minimum dose, we tried 4 different meds before settling on one that did the trick. it was a short term measure and now i cope ok without. it worked.

Right on, gotta do what works best for you!
 
Xenophobia is almost certainly the bulk of it. I guess there's a deep seated and primal fear of the ill in us, which makes sense as an evolutionary strategy.

Xenophobia is perfectly normal.

Mental health issues do carry a stigma though.
 
People with addictions go to jail because they broke the law not because they are ill. Serial killers are ill but we don't let them roam free.
 
People with addictions go to jail because they broke the law not because they are ill. Serial killers are ill but we don't let them roam free.

This is of course true, but there's different kinds of crimes; possession of a drug is different from theft. Possession is harmless to society. This is the kind of thing I mean.
 
They do, that. I may leave my fortune to fund a foundation to remove the stigma.

joking aside, Mental health issues are misunderstood by most people, the stat that 1 in 5 people will get dandruff, but 1 in 4 will suffer from a mental health problem, yet society still finds dandruff easier to talk about, provokes mirth, yet its a true figure and highlights the stigma.
 
It made me crazy, because I came from emergency medicine, where a patient is a patient, and the mental health people kept agitating for what they call "parity," meaning treat mental health patients the same as other patients wrt insurance and policy and whatnot, which is certainly a worthy cause. But if that's what you expect, then use the same language as everyone else in medicine.

Xenophobia is almost certainly the bulk of it. I guess there's a deep seated and primal fear of the ill in us, which makes sense as an evolutionary strategy.

The whole deal was nutz.

They usta bring me depressed cross-dressers, and these men wanted on the female ward, and I said NO. Their therapists got seriously pissed off at me, and I made my policy very clear: BRING ME A CHANGE OF NAME COURT ORDER, AND LETS EXAMINE THIS OLD GAL AND SEE WHATS LURKING UNDER HER SKIRT. And a schlong always disqualified them. I didn't aid and abet delusions, or traumatize the females with whackerdoodles on their ward .
 
joking aside, Mental health issues are misunderstood by most people, the stat that 1 in 5 people will get dandruff, but 1 in 4 will suffer from a mental health problem, yet society still finds dandruff easier to talk about, provokes mirth, yet its a true figure and highlights the stigma.

Yes, indeed. I wasn't actually joking. I think it's a serious problem, and one no one likes to talk about. It needs some equivalent of pink ribbons for breast cancer awareness.
 
The whole deal was nutz.

They usta bring me depressed cross-dressers, and these men wanted on the female ward, and I said NO. Their therapists got seriously pissed off at me, and I made my policy very clear: BRING ME A CHANGE OF NAME COURT ORDER, AND LETS EXAMINE THIS OLD GAL AND SEE WHATS LURKING UNDER HER SKIRT. And a schlong always disqualified them. I didn't aid and abet delusions, or traumatize the females with whackerdoodles on their ward .

It never made sense to me to buy into delusions or hallucinations. While I'm completely sympathetic with pre-op transgender people, if you have a penis, then...you have a penis.
 
Politics, anecdotes, concepts. I thought a clearinghouse thread might be nice to have. I know there's a lot of experience on the GB from all perspectives.

Maybe as a start, the question, "Why do we treat mental illness differently from other illnesses?" would be worth discussing. One example: science is increasingly showing that addiction is an organic sickness of the brain. An organ is diseased, causing symptoms. Those symptoms, however, lead to prison, rather than treatment.

Addiction indeed changes the brain. Not every country handles this issue as America. Portugal changed their approach from punishment to helping the addicted with very good results.

Personally, I loved a woman with depression. It was the most difficult relationship experience I ever had. I told her that I look at depression the same way as diabetes. It can be treated and there are solutions available to deal with it. It was very hard to know she was suffering. She was like in a bubble and unreachable to me at times. I tried to the best of my abilities to encourage her to try solutions, but she just wasn´t going to do it. All the long talks, all the information I gathered didn´t made any difference whatsoever. I never told her to snap out of it. I am aware it´s a health issue and always emphasized she wasn´t crazy.

Honestly, I don´t think there´s anything another person can do as long as the other person isn´t motivated on her own to change something. It´s a catch 22. You love the person, but you can´t ignore the issue and every time it´s mentioned you inevitably make her feel like a sick person. No matter how you say it and what you say. I wish she had been able to listen to me. She simply wasn´t. When you love a person with such a problem it gets under your skin and has negative effects on your own health. Still, I do believe mental issues like depression should be regarded like any other.
 
Addiction indeed changes the brain. Not every country handles this issue as America. Portugal changed their approach from punishment to helping the addicted with very good results.

Personally, I loved a woman with depression. It was the most difficult relationship experience I ever had. I told her that I look at depression the same way as diabetes. It can be treated and there are solutions available to deal with it. It was very hard to know she was suffering. She was like in a bubble and unreachable to me at times. I tried to the best of my abilities to encourage her to try solutions, but she just wasn´t going to do it. All the long talks, all the information I gathered didn´t made any difference whatsoever. I never told her to snap out of it. I am aware it´s a health issue and always emphasized she wasn´t crazy.

Honestly, I don´t think there´s anything another person can do as long as the other person isn´t motivated on her own to change something. It´s a catch 22. You love the person, but you can´t ignore the issue and every time it´s mentioned you inevitably make her feel like a sick person. No matter how you say it and what you say. I wish she had been able to listen to me. She simply wasn´t. When you love a person with such a problem it gets under your skin and has negative effects on your own health. Still, I do believe mental issues like depression should be regarded like any other.

Wait till a crazy bastard you never met tries to stab you with a knife, cuz he aint taking his meds. Youll be singing I'M A BELIEVER!
 
a lot of it is straight up bullshit.
i can understand braindamage from what ever reason, or chemical imbalances.
most bipolar and schizophrenia is just people who have unresolved issues from their past. most of them are always talking about the bad shit from their past. soooooo...............
ptsd. i can understand if you were a soldier in the middle of the shit. but i've ran into a lot of ptsd claimers who are just drama queens. nothing more.
 
Yes indeed. I'm not entirely certain why we treat the brain so differently from other organs. I don't see Parkinson's as much different qualitatively from diabetes or CHF. Why doctors do is beyond me.


I'll rate addiction as a malady or an illness (of a sort), but most folks I know who have a bona fide disease will do everything in their power and what is recommended to recover from it . . . and addicts usually won't.
 
The bastardex has bipoar ll, along with several phobias.
I lived with it for many years before I left.
In the beginning, I waa all supportive and did everything I could to understand. By the end of our relationship, I was completely the opposite.
My motto now is if you are in a relationship with a menatally ill person, get the fuck out before it destroys you too. :(

I could handle the mood swings and the lifestyle changes we had to make to.accommodate his various issues - but in the end I could not handle the total abdication of responsibility for his actions.
I don't care what anyone says, having a mental health issue does not mean you suddenly can't tell the difference between what's right and what's wrong, nor does it erase your ability for common decency.

Now I'm watching a friend deal with her husband who has PTSD and bipolar.... and I see just how destructive his behaviour is to her and their 3 boys.
I see the very same patterns of behaviour I dealt with.
And I'm watching this formerly bright, vibrant, bubbly, confident woman disintegrate in the face of her husbands constant needs.
It's very sad. :(

eta: I left my ex in 2006, and I still carry a lot of anger at what the ex and his illness did to my children and me. I think I am equally as angry at myself for not recognising the damage and staying as long as I did. If I had left earlier.....
 
Last edited:
People tend to mock things they are afraid of and don't understand. There was a huge stigma about having seizures until it could be shown on testing the changes in the brain. Our brain is so mysterious yet. I always thought it was interesting as a physchiatric nurse that many of the medications that assist bipolar and schizophrenic people are anti-seizure medications. There is something in the brain that we will one day discover and people will see these disorders as the brain conditions that they are.
 
i have a cousin who has been diagnosed as bipolar. he is in control of everything he does. you can see it in his eyes. he's doing it to just do it. like a kid who has never had any boundaries set. i caught him doing stupid shit, and he said, i can't help it, i'm bipolar. i told , bullshit, and if i catch you doing it again, i'll kick a mudhole in your ass and stomp it dry. he stopped doing it.
his father was an abusive alcoholic and his mother as well as my mother were physically, mentally and sexually abused, by their father, they have a serious reason to have ptsd. they never resolved their issues. my mother is now in the early phases of dementia. she gets weird sometimes. but i can deal with it. and apparently my father can. my brother and sister have pretty much turned their backs on both parents.
 
i have a cousin who has been diagnosed as bipolar. he is in control of everything he does. you can see it in his eyes. he's doing it to just do it. like a kid who has never had any boundaries set. i caught him doing stupid shit, and he said, i can't help it, i'm bipolar. i told , bullshit, and if i catch you doing it again, i'll kick a mudhole in your ass and stomp it dry. he stopped doing it.
his father was an abusive alcoholic and his mother as well as my mother were physically, mentally and sexually abused, by their father, they have a serious reason to have ptsd. they never resolved their issues. my mother is now in the early phases of dementia. she gets weird sometimes. but i can deal with it. and apparently my father can. my brother and sister have pretty much turned their backs on both parents.

The Surgeon General has spoken.

:rolleyes:
 
Back
Top