I'm in a sharing kind of mood

steve44uk

Baleful
Joined
Jul 4, 2010
Posts
4,128
So I'm sitting on the train home, writing. A song from my teenage years pops into my head. In the early '80s, David Bowie starred in a TV adaptation of Bertolt Brecht's Baal, a play about an unpleasant, nihilistic itinerant singer and poet in early 20th century Germany.

I was already deeply in man-love with Bowie, and the sensibilities of the play (bleak doesn't even come close) resonated deeply with the angry young man I was becoming.

One song, though, particularly stayed with me. It's called 'Remembering Marie A'. and while it's pretty melancholy (and, if I'm honest, mysogynistic), it's also to my mind a song / poem of great beauty. So here you are...

It was a day in that blue month September
Silent beneath the plum trees’ slender shade.
I held her there, my love so pale and silent,
As if she were a dream that must not fade.

Above us in the shining summer heaven
There was a cloud my eyes dwelled long upon.
It was quite white and very high above us,
Then I looked up and found that it had gone

And since that day, so many moons in silence
Have swum across the sky and gone below.
The plum trees surely have been chopped for firewood
And if you ask, "How does that love seem now?"
I must admit, I really can’t remember.
And yet I know what you are trying to say.
But what her face was like, I know no longer.
I only know I kissed it on that day.

As for the kiss, I long ago forgot it,
But for the cloud that floated in the sky
I know that still and shall forever know it.
It was quite white and moved in very high.
It may be that the plum trees still are blooming.
That woman’s seventh child may now be there.
And yet that cloud had only bloomed for minutes.
When I looked up it vanished on the air.
 
Last edited:
So I'm sitting on the train home, writing. A song from my teenage years pops into my head. In the early '80s, David Bowie starred in a TV adaptation of Bertolt Brecht's Baal, a play about an unpleasant, nihilistic itinerant singer and poet in early 20th century Germany.

I was already deeply in man-love with Bowie, and the sensibilities of the play (bleak doesn't even come close) resonated deeply with the angry young man I was becoming.

One song, though, particularly stayed with me. It's called 'Remembering Marie A'. and while it's pretty melancholy (and, if I'm honest, mysogynistic), it's also to my mind a song / poem of great beauty. So here you are...

It was a day in that blue month September
Silent beneath the plum trees’ slender shade.
I held her there, my love so pale and silent,
As if she were a dream that must not fade.

Above us in the shining summer heaven
There was a cloud my eyes dwelled long upon.
It was quite white and very high above us,
Then I looked up and found that it had gone

And since that day, so many moons in silence
Have swum across the sky and gone below.
The plum trees surely have been chopped for firewood
And if you ask, "How does that love seem now?"
I must admit, I really can’t remember.
And yet I know what you are trying to say.
But what her face was like, I know no longer.
I only know I kissed it on that day.

As for the kiss, I long ago forgot it,
But for the cloud that floated in the sky
I know that still and shall forever know it.
It was quite white and moved in very high.
It may be that the plum trees still are blooming.
That woman’s seventh child may now be there.
And yet that cloud had only bloomed for minutes.
When I looked up it vanished on the air.


You gloomy blighter.
 
They say 'misery loves company;' thanks for sharing, Steve.

(Just joking, though...I always do enjoy, if that's the right word, Brecht.)
 
They say 'misery loves company;' thanks for sharing, Steve.

(Just joking, though...I always do enjoy, if that's the right word, Brecht.)

He had his moments, before he got overly didactic. Baal's still my favourite, but I have a soft spot for Der gute Mesch... and, Of course, Die Dreigroschenoper. Can't beat a bit o' Brecht and Weil.
 
They say 'misery loves company;' thanks for sharing, Steve.

(Just joking, though...I always do enjoy, if that's the right word, Brecht.)

Go on, then! share a bit of Brecht.

The Bowie song is lovely, like a Chinese brush and ink painting.

I've always liked this Elizabethan poem which I came across doing Part I of my degree, in English Literature. I wasn't quite sure what it meant back then. If only Literotica had been around to educate me so I didn't have to rely on callow fellow undergraduates. :rolleyes:

WHEN as the rye reach to the chin,
And chopcherry, chopcherry ripe within,
Strawberries swimming in the cream,
And school-boys playing in the stream;
Then O, then O, then O my true love said,
Till that time come again,
She could not live a maid.
(George Peele)
 
Go on, then! share a bit of Brecht.

The Bowie song is lovely, like a Chinese brush and ink painting.

I've always liked this Elizabethan poem which I came across doing Part I of my degree, in English Literature. I wasn't quite sure what it meant back then. If only Literotica had been around to educate me so I didn't have to rely on callow fellow undergraduates. :rolleyes:

WHEN as the rye reach to the chin,
And chopcherry, chopcherry ripe within,
Strawberries swimming in the cream,
And school-boys playing in the stream;
Then O, then O, then O my true love said,
Till that time come again,
She could not live a maid.
(George Peele)

Yes, as when in high school I first realized what "Comin' Thro the Rye" was about...:eek:
 
Go on, then! share a bit of Brecht.

The Bowie song is lovely, like a Chinese brush and ink painting.

I've always liked this Elizabethan poem which I came across doing Part I of my degree, in English Literature. I wasn't quite sure what it meant back then. If only Literotica had been around to educate me so I didn't have to rely on callow fellow undergraduates. :rolleyes:

WHEN as the rye reach to the chin,
And chopcherry, chopcherry ripe within,
Strawberries swimming in the cream,
And school-boys playing in the stream;
Then O, then O, then O my true love said,
Till that time come again,
She could not live a maid.
(George Peele)

"Like a Chinese brush and ink painting" - that's a fabulous analogy. For all the world-weariness and malcontent that the song portrays, the lyrics (or, rather, in this case the translation, masterfull done by Dominic Muldowney) are so obviously deployed with meticulous care and skill. Probably why it can still move me to tears after 30 years

Bowie's delivery is amazing, too. I prefer the recorded version to the one in the play itself, which is why you got that slightly naff YouTube montage... :eek:
 
I've loved that song since I heard it in the eighties! :rose:
I've sung it onstage a couple of times, even. It's really difficult to keep an audience's attention-- very little in the way of musical dynamics, no crescendo. Brecht wasn't a musician, but was a hella poet.

The whole BBC production can be seen here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD6QpE68S5U
 
I've loved that song since I heard it in the eighties! :rose:
I've sung it onstage a couple of times, even. It's really difficult to keep an audience's attention-- very little in the way of musical dynamics, no crescendo. Brecht wasn't a musician, but was a hella poet.

The whole BBC production can be seen here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD6QpE68S5U

Cheers, Stella. A friend of mine... erm, procured a copy on disc for me a while back. I'm astonished the BBC don't put it out as a DVD - there'd a squillion Bowie fans who'd jump at it...

Was it shallow of me that I loved the trousers Bowie wore (kind of plus-fours with braces) almost as much as I loved the music and the play? Well, I was only 16... :eek:
 
Cheers, Stella. A friend of mine... erm, procured a copy on disc for me a while back. I'm astonished the BBC don't put it out as a DVD - there'd a squillion Bowie fans who'd jump at it...

Was it shallow of me that I loved the trousers Bowie wore (kind of plus-fours with braces) almost as much as I loved the music and the play? Well, I was only 16... :eek:
Are you kidding? It was always about clothing with him. I am a child of the glamrock seventies, and still am a plus-fours, braces, cravats enthusiast. If you happen to be a fetlife member, look for the group; "What Would Oscar Wilde Wear?" ;)
 
Better to have loved and lost, than to have loved and lost your love's head to the guillotine.

Very well done, anyway.
 
Double: The Captain of Her Heart

Comment on Youtube says "I feel like I own a beautiful jewel inside me", having grown up hearing this song.

I still love those words: The Captain of her heart. I loved the idea so much that I gave my favourite character a Captain of his heart.

:heart:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top