Here we go again.

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
The congress, in all it's wisdom, passed another 'feel good' piece of legislation, ie. the "Hate Crimes Act of 2007." Perhaps out of the fear that way too many crimes were being commited out of 'love'.

A column by George Will seems to have hit all the high points as to why this is a really stupid idea.

Hate crime laws
By George Will
Sunday, May 13, 2007

Political entrepreneurship involves devising benefits to excite or mollify niche constituencies. Hence H.R. 1592, the Local Law Enforcement Hate Crimes Prevention Act of 2007, which has passed the House, trailing clouds of sanctimony -- lots of members announced their hatred of hate.

Hate crime laws -- 45 states already have them; Congress does not mind being duplicative -- mandate enhanced punishments for crimes committed because of thoughts that government especially disapproves. That is, crimes committed because of, not merely accompanied by, those thoughts. Mind-reading juries are required to distinguish causation from correlation.

The federal hate crime law enacted in 1968 enhanced punishments only for crimes against persons engaged in a federally protected activity, such as voting. H.R. 1592 would extend special federal protections to persons who are crime victims because of their race, color, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity or disability. But there are many other groups, so there will be other hate crime bills.

Hate crimes are seven one-hundredths of 1 percent of all crimes, and 60.5 percent of them consist of vandalism (e.g., graffiti) or intimidation (e.g., verbal abuse). Local law enforcement organizations favor H.R. 1592, which promises money. Among the more than 200 organizations supposedly ardent for the bill are the American Music Therapy Association, Aplastic Anemia Foundation of America, Catholics for Free Choice, Easter Seals, Goodwill Industries, International Dyslexia Association, Rock the Vote, Women's Alliance for Theology, Ethics & Ritual. Who knew?

Hate crime laws are indignation gestures. Legislators federalize the criminal law in order to use it as a moral pork barrel to express theatrical empathy. They score points in the sentiment competition by conferring special government concern for more and more particular groups.

Laws hold us responsible for controlling our minds, which should control our conduct. But government increasingly wants to inventory and furnish our minds, removing socially undesirable desires. Law has always had the expressive function of stigmatizing particular kinds of conduct, but hate crime laws treat certain actions as especially wicked because the actors had odious (although not illegal) frames of mind.

This draws government steadily deeper into stigmatizing certain thoughts and attitudes, which incites more and more groups to clamor for inclusion in the ranks of the especially protected. And Timothy Lynch of the Cato Institute notes that prosecutors of supposed hate crimes must pry into defendants' lives -- books and magazines read, Internet sites visited, the nature of his or her friends -- to uncover evidence of unsavory thinking.

If H.R. 1592 makes it to the president's desk, he probably will veto it because it is moral exhibitionism by Congress with no constitutional authorization. H.R. 1592 justifies itself under Congress' enumerated power to regulate interstate commerce. The bill simply asserts that hate crimes affect such commerce and are committed using articles that have ``traveled" in interstate commerce.

The Supreme Court, however, has rejected ``the argument that Congress may regulate noneconomic, violent criminal conduct based solely on that conduct's aggregate effect on interstate commerce. The Constitution requires a distinction between what is truly national and what is truly local.''

By conferring special status -- enhanced protection -- on certain government-favored groups, H.R. 1592 traduces the principle of equality before the law. Yet Speaker Nancy Pelosi says it honors ``the tradition of our Founders, that every person is created equal.'' Here is another sample of the House debate, from Rep. Lynn Woolsey, D-Calif.:

``My granddaughter Julia is 3 years old. She goes to preschool. Even in preschool, they gang up and they bully. The parents at that preschool tell me that my Julia steps in and she stops it. She will not put up with bullying and unfairness. It is our turn. Be as brave as a 3-year-old. Vote for H.R. 1592.''

Plucky Julia aside, questions remain. Are all rapes hate crimes because rapists pick the victims because of their gender? When in 1989, a gang of black and Hispanic youths went ``wilding'' in Central Park, raping and savagely beating a white jogger, was this considered a hate crime? No, because the youths also assaulted some Hispanics, so their punishment was not enhanced.

When a surveillance camera recently taped a mugger beating and robbing a 101-year-old New York woman, he was charged with a hate crime -- presumably hatred of the elderly. His attack on a 51-year-old woman was not a hate crime. Complications multiply, protected categories proliferate. Next? People who wear fur or eat meat? Some writings by the killer at Virginia Tech expressed hatred of the rich, but they are not a category protected in this year's hate crime legislation. Perhaps in next year's.

Hopefully the Senate will excersize a little more sanity than the house.

Ishmael
 
Rape is a hate crime. Murder. It's just a shot away....

It's just a shot away...

There's Republican "crime" and Democrat "sloppiness."

They know it when they see it.

War, children...










...IS, just a shot away!
 
Ishmael said:
Hopefully the Senate will excersize a little more sanity than the house.
That could depend on the riders couldn't it?
 
Ishmael said:
You mean the attached 'pork?'
Of course. I'm a Southern girl and I love to eat pork but I only like paying for it at the supermarket, not in my taxes.
 
Lavared said:
Of course. I'm a Southern girl and I love to eat pork but I only like paying for it at the supermarket, not in my taxes.

You just don't appreciate the fine art of 'buying votes', do ya? *chuckle*

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
You just don't appreciate the fine art of 'buying votes', do ya? *chuckle*
No, I don't, I really don't. But I do appreciate what they do to political ads.

*Deep voice-over* "Jim Smith voted no to providing free milk to poverty-stricken toddlers. A vote for Jim Smith is a vote against children. "

When the free milk was a rider on a bill to mandate a 2000% pay increase for congress.
 
You can imagine what next years ads are going to sound like concerning those that voted against this 'Hate Crime' abortion.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
You can imagine what next years ads are going to sound like concerning those that voted against this 'Hate Crime' abortion.

Ishmael


Not a chance. All Iraq. All venom. All corruption, 24seven; just louder, which is what I've been saying. Lynch mobs, like Radical Islam, just keep getting louder and more insistant and BOTH of them are focused on the same goal, getting rid of the people who stand in their way.
 
I wouldn't bet on it not getting out of the senate. The Dems need something to point to as an accomplishment.

You remember all that legislation they passed in the first 100 hours? It's all stalled in the Senate. And the house itself is balking at the 'new' lobbiest rules. In other words, with much fanfare, they haven't really done shit yet.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
The congress, in all it's wisdom, passed another 'feel good' piece of legislation, ie. the "Hate Crimes Act of 2007." Perhaps out of the fear that way too many crimes were being commited out of 'love'.

Not "congress", Ishmcveigh. The House of Representatives. *shakes head* home schooled moron
 
Cap’n AMatrixca said:
Not a chance. All Iraq. All venom. All corruption, 24seven; just louder, which is what I've been saying. Lynch mobs, like Radical Islam, just keep getting louder and more insistant and BOTH of them are focused on the same goal, getting rid of the people who stand in their way.

Oh, it'll be used in local campaigns. Of that have no doubt.

Ishmael
 
Nor do they intend to. They want to make sure no Republican has a thing they can say they voted for, short of surrender, in order to go negative and demand a change of course...

They remember that it took a Sherman to win the last war, and this is the moment for the aging hippie class; Rand's Berkley Crue.
 
Ishmael said:
Oh, it'll be used in local campaigns. Of that have no doubt.

Ishmael


Won't need it, won't need specifics by that time as long As Al Qaeda and the Democrats can keep up the attacks (and the latter have to, or the Left-wing here will atack). It's Deja-Vu all over again. We are the horse that has to be put down...
 
Cap’n AMatrixca said:
Won't need it, won't need specifics by that time as long As Al Qaeda and the Democrats can keep up the attacks (and the latter have to, or the Left-wing here will atack). It's Deja-Vu all over again. We are the horse that has to be put down...

Seems that that's exactly what they have in mind. A nation of nuetered cowards would set well with the left leaning political class.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
You can imagine what next years ads are going to sound like concerning those that voted against this 'Hate Crime' abortion.
Oi.

I won't watch any television or listen to any radio for a year starting in about five months. It sickens me, it really does and all across the board, too.

Have you read the new Card book, Empire? He makes a good point in it about the rhetoric on both sides and how people aren't "allowed" to pick and choose what they are for or against without being suspect. Ex: if you're pro-environment you have to be anti-gun, if you're pro-choice you have to be anti-freedom of speech.
 
Lavared said:
Oi.

I won't watch any television or listen to any radio for a year starting in about five months. It sickens me, it really does and all across the board, too.

Have you read the new Card book, Empire? He makes a good point in it about the rhetoric on both sides and how people aren't "allowed" to pick and choose what they are for or against without being suspect. Ex: if you're pro-environment you have to be anti-gun, if you're pro-choice you have to be anti-freedom of speech.

The infusion of religious fervor into politics. Hell, you can see it here on the board. The secularist left have nothing on the fundamentalist right.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
The infusion of religious fervor into politics. Hell, you can see it here on the board. The secularist left have nothing on the fundamentalist right.
And it cuts both ways, Ish. This is what makes the book's premise of an American civil war between the red and the blue states so interesting. There is enough truth behind it to keep the notion out of the realm of total fantasy.
 
Lavared said:
And it cuts both ways, Ish. This is what makes the book's premise of an American civil war between the red and the blue states so interesting. There is enough truth behind it to keep the notion out of the realm of total fantasy.

Civil war? Yeah, it's possible. But I think what would precipitate it would be the red states calling for a constitutional convention. Should a serious leftist occupy the White House I can see them trying to be a new Lincoln and calling out the troops.

People seem to forget that the constitution not only contains within itself the method by which it can be changed, it also contains within itself the method by which it can be dissolved altogether.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
People seem to forget that the constitution not only contains within itself the method by which it can be changed, it also contains within itself the method by which it can be dissolved altogether.
Seems like my great-great-grandparents tried that once, unsuccessfully.
 
Back
Top