Harper Lee breaks her silence...

RoryN

You're screwed.
Joined
Apr 8, 2003
Posts
60,482
Oprah prints letter from Harper Lee
Sunday, June 25, 2006

By CONNIE BAGGETT
Staff Reporter

MONROEVILLE -- It's nothing unusual to see Pulitzer-winner Nelle Harper Lee on the golf course or at church or even shopping here, but many local residents were surprised to see the intensely private author featured in "O, The Oprah Magazine" this month in a letter to Oprah Winfrey.

"All I can say is lucky Oprah," said Dawn Crook, the sites manager for Monroe County Heritage Museums that features exhibits on Lee and produces an annual stage play of Lee's novel, "To Kill a Mockingbird."

The 1960 novel follows the search for justice and tolerance in fictional Maycomb, Ala., during the Great Depression as a black man is falsely accused of raping a white woman. The story unfolds through the eyes of Scout as she, her brother and a friend scheme to make a reclusive neighbor come out of his home.

The book won a Pulitzer Prize and was soon made into a feature film starring Gregory Peck that earned an Oscar. Lee granted interviews after the book was published and as the film hit screens across the country, but stopped granting interviews in the early 1960s.

In the years since, she has never published another novel, but has occasionally written letters or essays that were printed in magazines. The book is listed as the favorite novel of many celebrities and regular people around the world and still tops lists as the best-liked book by high school students.

The "O" magazine letter appears in the July issue currently on sale. Lee's picture appears on page 18 with three other writers who penned letters for the issue that focuses on reading. Lee's letter, dated May 7, details her earliest memories of reading, and being read to, from books and "The Mobile Press" as a small child. She details a system of book trading set up by youngsters in Monroeville, and of the love for reading that has grown over the years of her life.

Calls seeking comment from the magazine's spokesman were not returned.

Lee's letter says she has clung to books even when others carry "laptops, cell phones, iPods and minds like empty rooms." She closes with "Much love, Harper."

Far from reclusive, Lee has been described by friends and neighbors as "amiable," "serious about golf," "charming," and "at times cantankerous." She has shunned interview requests by reporters far and wide for decades, including big media names like Dan Rather. On occasion she has made public appearances, speaking at the graduation ceremonies for Spring Hill College a few years ago, collecting honors from the Legislature as a member of the Alabama Hall of Honor and the Alabama Humanities Foundation.

But she guards her privacy, and people in Monroeville are happy to help her ward off intruders.

"She wrote a letter to the New Yorker a few months ago," said the Rev. Thomas Lane Butts, a longtime friend. "It was very short as I recall."

Jane Ellen Clark, director of Monroe County Heritage Museums, said, "very few letters by Harper Lee have ever been published. She did write one a few years ago for a legal magazine, and she had an essay published years ago. There are many accounts of people writing to her and receiving a reply."

Clark said Lee seems to be particularly responsive to young readers and to the subject of reading in general. Winfrey, an iconic figure of daytime television talk shows, has for years listed Lee's novel as among her favorites and makes no secret about her respect for Lee, Clark said.

"Several reports recently describe a correspondence between Ms. Winfrey and Miss Lee," Clark said. "On a recent talk show, Ms. Winfrey said she had flown to Monroeville to have lunch with Miss Lee, so they apparently have been in contact."
 
So, do you think Oprah will land an exclusive interview with Miss Lee? Wouldn't that be a feather in her cap?
 
Wow. Interesting. I had no idea that she was even still alive. Some of the greatest writers are recluses- Pynchon, Salinger, or Solzhyeneitsen in his later years or at least avoid publicity. Since she never wrote anything else of great quality or importance, it's been rumored that she didn't write To Kill a Mockingbird, that it is was perhaps Truman Capote. Don't know why Capote with his narcissism wouldn't have wanted credit for it, though.
 
sundragon22 said:
So, do you think Oprah will land an exclusive interview with Miss Lee? Wouldn't that be a feather in her cap?

Frankly, I would like to see Miss Lee interviewed by someone more...cerebral.
 
Ham Murabi said:
al-Gore might be available.

He'd be better. At least he wouldn't weep and fawn all over her.

(Well, actually, he did - sorta - when brought face-to-face with Frank Zappa.)
 
I like what Oprah's done with her book club - it's nice to see some interest in literature thrust back into the popular culture. It would make for a better interview with someone else, but more people will likely read it with Oprah and be apt to read To Kill a Mockingbird.
 
It ranks up there with Huck Finn for me. And I'm with Ollie . I thought she was long since deceased.
 
Put her down all you want, but Oprah has made more people read for entertainment more than anyone else since most people have music, the internet and cable for entertainment purposes.

People bash her because she is famous and mainstream. I used to do it too. Snobbery, that's what it is about.

The indie bookstores (most of them) just don't get it, you walk in there and it is an intimidating environment for a person who doesn't read reviews etc. What do I buy? Who the fuck knows...

The chains are worse, because face out and end caps are all abotu the co-op, aka, who has paid for it.

Oprah picks a book, that damn thing in the front of the mall store, no kick backs needed, and that's 'cause it's been proven. She recommends, people buy.

And a hearty "fuck you" to people think that it is a shitty stamp of approval. When a person reaches the end of a book they loved, they want another book. It's like anything else.
 
Oliver Clozoff said:
Wow. Interesting. I had no idea that she was even still alive. Some of the greatest writers are recluses- Pynchon, Salinger, or Solzhyeneitsen in his later years or at least avoid publicity. Since she never wroteanything else of great quality or importance, it's been rumored that she didn't write To Kill a Mockingbird, that it is was perhaps Truman Capote. Don't know why Capote with his narcissism wouldn't have wanted credit for it, though.

I think you mean published, Doc, you have no idea what she "wrote."
 
LadyFunkenstein said:
Put her down all you want, but Oprah has made more people read for entertainment more than anyone else since most people have music, the internet and cable for entertainment purposes.

People bash her because she is famous and mainstream.

True. But that's not why I do.

LadyFunkenstein said:
And a hearty "fuck you" to people think that it is a shitty stamp of approval.

You protest too much on this subject. I think that says something.
 
Last edited:
RoryN said:
You protest too much on this subject. And it speaks volumes.

SOoo, you think I am some sort of GOD or something, and my opinion cuts deep within your soul.

I am flattered, I swear, but my opinion is hardly worth it.
 
LadyFunkenstein said:
SOoo, you think I am some sort of GOD or something, and my opinion cuts deep within your soul.

I am flattered, I swear, but my opinion is hardly worth it.

That was weak.

Aren't you even going to ask me to explain the reasoning for my position, and hold me accountable for it?
 
LadyFunkenstein said:
I think you mean published, Doc, you have no idea what she "wrote."

true dat. She could have a pile of masterpieces under her bed for all we know. And I agree with you about Oprah too. Not only does she encourage reading, but she's encouraging Americans to read good literature - Toni Morrison, Earnest Gaines, Alice Walker, etc.
 
Oliver Clozoff said:
...it's been rumored that she didn't write To Kill a Mockingbird, that it is was perhaps Truman Capote. Don't know why Capote with his narcissism wouldn't have wanted credit for it, though.
Well, he wasn't portrayed in a very flattering light; that certainly wouldn't have been his style, to be so self-effacing.
 
Oliver Clozoff said:
true dat. She could have a pile of masterpieces under her bed for all we know. And I agree with you about Oprah too. Not only does she encourage reading, but she's encouraging Americans to read good literature - Toni Morrison, Earnest Gaines, Alice Walker, etc.

Please don't lump Toni Morrison in with "Ernie" Gaines. She can't hold a candle to him.
 
kotori said:
Well, he wasn't portrayed in a very flattering light; that certainly wouldn't have been his style, to be so self-effacing.

Right. I was just reading on wikipedia that Dill was based on Capote. I hadn't realized that. I need to reread TKAM. In Cold Blood too. Both damn outstanding.
 
It looks like I'll have to buy my very first "O" magazine.
 
RoryN said:
Please don't lump Toni Morrison in with "Ernie" Gaines. She can't hold a candle to him.

Well, she's got a Nobel and a NYT #1 novel of the last 25 years (Beloved). At least as far as general critical consensus, she belongs in a class with anyone.
I love Earnest Gaines, though. My father took a creative writing course with him a decade or so ago.
 
RoryN said:
That was weak.

Aren't you even going to ask me to explain the reasoning for my position, and hold me accountable for it?

Not really... no offense, but the reasoning behind your position is of no consequence to me. You are entitled to have it, but I don't particularly care about your thought process on it.
 
Oliver Clozoff said:
Well, she's got a Nobel and a NYT #1 novel of the last 25 years (Beloved). At least as far as general critical consensus, she belongs in a class with anyone.

Sorry. "General critical consensus", sales numbers, and awards are not the final word on talent in literature. It's this sort of thinking which perpetuates the mediocrity in popular works today, IMNSHO.

Not easy to grow up with diamonds like Black Boy, Native Son, The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man, Giovanni's Room, etc., only to see cubic zirconias like Beloved get mounted on society's finger.

LadyFunkenstein said:
Not really... no offense, but the reasoning behind your position is of no consequence to me. You are entitled to have it, but I don't particularly care about your thought process on it.

You can't afford to.
 
I don't know if she's ever said why she never put out anything else but I've always assumed it was because a follow up would have been a disappointment no matter how good it was and she knew it. Some people would rather avoid that. I've also always thought that her friendship with Capote might have had something to do with it too. He was a bit of a tragic person, especially after In Cold Blood and maybe that did something to her. Maybe seeing what In Cold Blood did to him scared her away from more writing.
Just a thought.
 
RoryN said:
Frankly, I would like to see Miss Lee interviewed by someone more...cerebral.

I don't see it as a knock on Oprah to wish seeing Harper Lee interviewed by someone else. One of the objctives of her show is to promote celebrities. In that role, her fawning is perfectly appropriate. When it comes to interviewing Ms. Lee, someone with a greater understanding and insight into literature would be much more appropriate.
 
wazhazhe said:
I don't see it as a knock on Oprah to wish seeing Harper Lee interviewed by someone else. One of the objctives of her show is to promote celebrities. In that role, her fawning is perfectly appropriate. When it comes to interviewing Ms. Lee, someone with a greater understanding and insight into literature would be much more appropriate.

A voice of reason; thank you. And you also said it better than I.
 
RoryN said:
You can't afford to.

Makes no sense. And thus the reason why I have not requested your thought process. No consequence, and I stand behind that knee jerk reaction.
 
Back
Top