Spins
around an Axis
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2005
- Posts
- 26,075
In response to your first point, I understand what you are referring to: punishments like putting people in stocks or making them wear scarlet letters. However, in other ways, public shaming is back. Attacks on line on people for expressing unpopular opinions or failing to support one's point of view are rampant. There was a story in the Times this week about a girl who posted something on Snapchat when she was like 14 years old using the "n" word. The post surfaced 3 years later, when she was a senior in high school. The post was relevant and significant to show that school officials took no action to protect African-American students from racist statements and behavior from the whites in the school. That is all appropriate. But she became the target of a shaming campaign based on something that she had done when she was 14 fucking years old and had to withdraw from the college she had been admitted to attend. It sounded like most of the attacks came from white people wanting to feel holy and "woke" rather than confront their own biases.
This seems to have gotten rather off the point. But I was saying that I strongly feel that public shaming does not contribute much to human understanding or improving behavior.
On your other point, I do get that exchanges can lose their intensity. I still think there is usually a tactful way of telling the person you want to end it. Like saying "I think we've lost our heat," or "This doesn't seem to be going anywhere. I think we should drop it." (This seems better than "You've gotten boring," but even that would be preferable to just ghosting them, I think.)
You are likely right, but there is something to be said for countries where public shaming does make up a large part of their system of justice.
For instance...mask wearing!
However, the potential for a mob mentality and veering from shaming in order to protect the public good versus just the public being able to focus their own rage at something that likely isn't as serious as it is being made out to be...well your example is but one of hundreds.
Here on Lit is likely does not good at all. I certainly have always chosen not to air dirty laundry, both in public and in private. My days in the GeeBee used to frustrate the bigger gossip mongers cause I never said anything. That became fun in of itself!

