Genital Mutilation

Emerald_eyed said:
... I have never met a man upset with his parents about havng foreskin removed.

Actually I'm not speaking to my mother for that very reason.

Every litle bit helps and I think of that when I can't measure up ...lol
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Bravo Zip!!

A woman Loves staying power;)

Staying power goes more with the person than the penis (my experience).

I gotta learn how to use that *search* feature.
Thanks Emerald.
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Bravo Zip!!

A woman Loves staying power;)

Perhaps Woody is so sensitive because he couldn't personally afford to lose a few millimeters of extra skin (every drop helps when you're small).

Unlike you Woody, I am not advocating circumcision, I am only saying it is a parent's choice.

Your reasoning about why not to do a poll applies equally to your position, how do you know it's not better to be circumsized?

My point was to see how many people resented not having the choice, not which felt better.
 
woody54 said:
In my book, circumcision falls into the latter caragory

Right here is the crux of the debate. This is your opinion Woody. Your thoughts on the matter. It doesn't make it wrong, but it doesn't make it right either.

When asked if you were circumcision you stated:
Hell no!!!!
But I'm interested in the motivation for doing this
If you are interested in the motivation, it would probably be more readily responded to if you were less judgemental about the process being practiced.

Imediately declaring it "mutilation" in the same style as FGM practiced in some Eastern countries is ridiculous. It is not. It is a regligious tradition for some and for others it is a medical practice that has been tought out by the parents. I seriously doubt that ANY parent here made the decision lightly. They have thought about it in depth before the child was born and afterwards before the procedure. Some opted for it, and other opted not. Using the argument "let the child make the decision whether they want to or not" could be used, yes. But parents also have to make other medical decisions also for children at a young age (i.e. vaccinations). I know of no child out there that doesn't cry and scream at the time of injection or even at the thought of getting a shot. (and no, I'm not say that circumcision is on the same level of importance as vaccinations, so don't try that route) It is the just one of the many decisions of that people have to make while raising a child.

Would it be better for them to have foreskin? Maybe....but maybe not. You, being a person with foreskin, would say it would be better. Others out there that have been cut would say that it's (pun intended) no skin off their nose. The point is that since YOU haven't been cut, you don't know how good or bad it is being cut. You can give an opinion but you can't make an informed decision because you don't know both sides from actual experienc. And NO ONE can. Except for those few that were left intact and later decided to be cut. You will also find that those people will have different ideas too. Some will say don't do it and others will say do it.

The procedure is promoted by religeous nutcases with no valid justification except for their own crazy ideas.

This is the only part of your arguement that I actually find a bit disturbing. Just because you don't happen to agree with the practice of circumcision doesn't make the Jewish religion and it's believers "nutcases". This is a part of their religion, a promise that was made ages ago and that in their faith and belief they continue to uphold. That does not make them "nutcases". Please try not to allow your particular viewpoint of one small portion of that religion's practice to cloud your overall view of that religion. This practice is along the same lines as the Catholic practice of eating fish on Friday during Lent. Only a small aspect of a large picture.

The cruelty is they inflict it on their young before the child has any say and it is hardly reversible.


In the US (where 90% of all circumcisions occur), the child is under a local anesthetic during the procedure and only lasts approx. 10 min. Hardly cruel.
However, in Sierra Leone (for instance) where FGM is practiced, the girls (approx. 8 years old) are held down by other female family members, not given any anethesia, not told what is about to be done to them. The person doing the procedure is not a doctor but a town elder or yet another female family member, uses a sharp object (including sometimes jagged glass or a sharpend stone) to cut away the clitoral hood and in some cases completely cutting out the clitoris and then sewing the entire genital area up leaving only a small opening for urination. At the time of marriage it is the groom's "gift" to open his bride on their wedding night by forcing back open the vaginal opening. THAT is cruel.






and does anybody besides me find it funny that a thread on circumcision would be started by a person calling themselves "Woody"?
 
Emerald_eyed said:
when you profile spmeone, in the upper right habd corner is a "search for all posts by this user" option.

I use "ice blue" so mine is on the bottom. Also, there is the search at the top so you can search lots of different things. I had never noticed the calendar before...
 
Thanks, got the search.

* checks out calendar *



ksmybuttons said:
I use "ice blue" so mine is on the bottom. Also, there is the search at the top so you can search lots of different things. I had never noticed the calendar before...
 
I like to think of myself as open minded, but FGM seems a little out there even for "cultural norm" arguments.
 
So lets round things up then shall we.

1. I dont agree with the practise of circumcision for non medical reasons.

2. I dont think parents have the right to have it done.

3. I live in a society where it no longer occurs often and this shapes my views

4. The US has a strong Jewish and to a lesser degree Muslim influence that promote this practice as a religeous requirement

5. People take a position on this issue and stick with it because it is basically religeous based

6. WE will never agree
 
Back in my day, genital mutilation was dating a girl with braces.


Anyone ever hear the phrase

"Black & decker pecker wrecker"??
 
Emerald

I have never really considered it from that point of view. I suppose it makes no difference. I would have prefered at birth. I do feel that some sensitivity is lost, but is it worth getting uptight about? No, not really. Life is too short and there are so many other things for one to be passionate about that truly matter.

I try to take a laid back attitude about things I have no control over. I (unlike some others here) work hard on anger control and stress management.
 
Honestly Emerald

It is not a decision I will ever have to make.

When I married my wife, she had four children, two boys (already cut) and two girls. We never had any of our own.
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Nobody is asking you to agree, but to actually consider thier views.
YOU NEVER HAVE TO circ your sons, so why freak about it?

AS I have said much earlier in this thread, my intent was to understand why this is done. The responses received have left me no better off than when I started. It does seem a scenario of entrenched positions.
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Several people gave you "thier" reasons. Smeone posted a link to the American Academt of Pediatrics.
You must have chosen not to read that.

You wont agree that valid points were made. You chooseto ignore them over fear of being wrong?? We have stated there is no right or wrong here.
You are not wrong, we are not wrong. Why do you insist everyone who doesnt agree with you is wrong??


Yes I did read it and have no problem with legitmate medical interventions.

My veiw is that it is wrong. Nothing I have seen here gives me cause to change that
 
Last edited:
Back
Top