Could you do it?

VaticanAssassin

God Mod
Joined
Jul 21, 2011
Posts
12,391
Hell, most the guys on this site could not. But are there any females who think they could?

The Marines are looking for females to go through infantry school. They are not lowering the bar for female recruits and they must pass the same physical requirements as the males. Only two have stepped forward so far and both washed out within weeks. While I am sure there are a few females out there who could do it, the % is so small it makes me wonder if it is worth it? Getting past the physical requirements, the logistics of having a female in the woods for 30 days + with no access to showers or bathrooms makes me queasy to my stomach....

Some basic physical requirements include:


Lifting a 72-pound machine gun above your heads while wearing a 71-pound rucksack, marching 12 miles in less than five hours carrying a 71-pound rucksack and evacuating a mock casualty weighing about 200 pounds. (The 71 pound rucksack is a joke and must be a marine thing.. basic combat load is closer to 150 depending on what you are caring. I jumped once with 190 pounds of gear)

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/nov/25/few-female-marines-step-forward-for-infantry/
 
You must be a really big dude otherwise your gear weighed more than you did.
 
Hell, most the guys on this site could not. But are there any females who think they could?

The Marines are looking for females to go through infantry school. They are not lowering the bar for female recruits and they must pass the same physical requirements as the males. Only two have stepped forward so far and both washed out within weeks. While I am sure there are a few females out there who could do it, the % is so small it makes me wonder if it is worth it? Getting past the physical requirements, the logistics of having a female in the woods for 30 days + with no access to showers or bathrooms makes me queasy to my stomach....

Some basic physical requirements include:


Lifting a 72-pound machine gun above your heads while wearing a 71-pound rucksack, marching 12 miles in less than five hours carrying a 71-pound rucksack and evacuating a mock casualty weighing about 200 pounds. (The 71 pound rucksack is a joke and must be a marine thing.. basic combat load is closer to 150 depending on what you are caring. I jumped once with 190 pounds of gear)

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/nov/25/few-female-marines-step-forward-for-infantry/

http://up.xhamster.com/000/022/787/376_1000.jpg
 
Hell

They dont needa teach da weemenz to shoot no weapon

JUST LET DA BITCHS NAG THE ENEMY TO DEATH:D
 
You must be a really big dude otherwise your gear weighed more than you did.

Out weighed me by about 10 pounds. Which is pretty typical of an 11-B load out. 11-C (60mm mortar maggots) weigh in over 200 all the time.

Like I said. I am sure there is a woman out there some were who can handle the weight. I just never met one.
 
I couldn't, I'm too wimpy...and old. Nor does it sound appealing.
 
I'll be damned if I can figure out a meaningful point to this thread. You're stronger than a woman? Fascinating:rolleyes:
 
I'll be damned if I can figure out a meaningful point to this thread. You're stronger than a woman? Fascinating:rolleyes:

Then we will add this to the long list of things you can not figure out.

Like how replying with a post with no point, complaining about not getting the point is rather amusing in a watch the idiot go kind of way.....
 
Women in traditional western infantry roles is a bad idea. Bottom line; Even if there are women who can meet the physical standards in the short term, long term there are going to be serious issues with pelvic stress fractures. Women, like it or not, are physically built different to men. Jumping out of an aircraft with those kinds of weights creates enough damage in men, let alone women.

As V.A pointed out, there are also the hygeine issues to consider. Poor hygeine will present much larger health risks regarding infection with women than men.

And you'd need a section of women. Put one woman in a section of men, there are going to be problems. It might be pointing out the obvious, but men think and act differently when working closely together without women. A single woman will change a section dynamic, and not for the better. Women are effective infantry. Countries like Israel have proved that. But there are good phsycological reasons why they separate their male and female sections.

That all said, there are some roles, with a little redefinition, women would be perfect for. Sniper would be one. Recconaisance patrolling. Jobs that require attention to detail, a large degree of independance and flexible thinking, patience and initiative, without the massively heavy weights involved.


Modern cavalry and explosive detection/disposal work is a level playing field and I see no reason why women can't do those jobs.
 
Last edited:
I think it's pretty funny that one of the objections to women in combat units is the way they would smell because of a lack of showers and toilets.
 
I think it's pretty funny that one of the objections to women in combat units is the way they would smell because of a lack of showers and toilets.

When you bleed from your genitalia, hygiene takes on a new importance.
 
If you are getting that from my OP then your reading comprehension is off.

Sure it is.

Getting past the physical requirements, the logistics of having a female in the woods for 30 days + with no access to showers or bathrooms makes me queasy to my stomach....

I guess the Marines will have to start screening for a few good men with strong stomachs.
 
Hell, most the guys on this site could not. But are there any females who think they could?

The Marines are looking for females to go through infantry school. They are not lowering the bar for female recruits and they must pass the same physical requirements as the males. Only two have stepped forward so far and both washed out within weeks. While I am sure there are a few females out there who could do it, the % is so small it makes me wonder if it is worth it? Getting past the physical requirements, the logistics of having a female in the woods for 30 days + with no access to showers or bathrooms makes me queasy to my stomach....

Some basic physical requirements include:


Lifting a 72-pound machine gun above your heads while wearing a 71-pound rucksack, marching 12 miles in less than five hours carrying a 71-pound rucksack and evacuating a mock casualty weighing about 200 pounds. (The 71 pound rucksack is a joke and must be a marine thing.. basic combat load is closer to 150 depending on what you are caring. I jumped once with 190 pounds of gear)

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/nov/25/few-female-marines-step-forward-for-infantry/

In my 20's - definitely
In my 30's - probably
In my 40's - No fucking way
 
Back
Top