babiesmiles
elfpet
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2004
- Posts
- 1,898
TaintedB said:. I've seen this happen on a number forums that have the "popularity" or "karma" feature enabled for individuals. People decide they hate you for the pettiest reasons, and there's not need to be an out and out psycho to quickly get a really bad Karma, all you have to do is answer a rude person intelligently. :/
Tainted your point of view, was as usual a clever and articulate . And I appreciated all of it , besides I can understand DVS and Betticus point as well , as it's never pleasant to be ignored when your messages are polite and coherent with the requests people make on their profiles.
Considered all above the thing which hit my attention though was your statement about so called " Karma" points , and again I completely agree with you. And I'd like to add a few things about it .
I am a regular poster on another board , among others I casually go on, where there is that system of " karma" rating popularity .
It is not a "sex contents" nor a personals site, it is a small but rather international one mainly used to exchange opinions on several matters and different items ( from very serious political ones to silly fun others ) with people from all over the world , and notwithstanding it's not in my country some of us know each other rather well ( and some of us even met more than once ) ,
I must say there are really good friendships starting and growing , even if as in all places there are people one likes more and other one like less. But that is normal and physiological in every community , "net" or not (
lol) .All perfect you could say !
No, cause since that damn rathing thing was started , some people maybe for fun maybe with lower intentions started messing up with that rating feature using it for their lil petty revenges ( usually against the less shy , more witty or simply more grown up people ) just cause they disagreed with opinions or just for an envious bitching around .
Now in a small and usually friendly place , we can know ( and usually we dont mistake ) who is bitching in that moment as although the rating is anonimous , on a small scale knowing who is online and counting the karmas they used ( if you use karmas doesnt matter if + or - , they go subtracted from your "giving amount") we understand what is going on, keeping it someway under control if not replying with the same fence just for fun .
But I can easily imagine the impact of a similar thing on a large scale website . Lets just thing of the General Board here on lite !! . The horror !
That would mean to give trolls and kiddos (not an age but a mind matter ) a weapon to gang up some other people , without have a way to keep it under control . The karma war !!
So besides in closed, strictly supervised environments ( usually scientific and professional in identified fields ) a rating system can be useful to identify the most interesting articles or posts on a certain subject , in so called "entertainment" or personal site with a large amount of members who can easily hide in the mass or using alt , I find that feature with an high potential of bothering .. just cause "dangerous" seems to me a too big word in a similar context .
I am however against every form of anonimous rating , and that's why , even here when I read a story which I like or rate something , I never do it without sign it .
Hope I was able to express myself but its late here .


