When a story feels flat

It’s weird. The problems that led to me getting on a flight seemed intractable last week. But sitting together for most of yesterday and this morning and we find that there is light at the end of the tunnel. So I’m waiting on people doing / finding out stuff for a workshop tomorrow, instead of being busy. The stuff I thought I’d be doing myself has either now been done or picked up by someone else. All good I guess.

It’s interesting though that we didn’t make anything like the same progress over Teams, then the time difference doesn’t help.

Em


I'm at the job site im at right now only because the job I was supposed to do canceled last minute.

I'll probably spend most of my day standing around watching the other guy work and handing him tools.

It was either this, or waste a vacation day.

So yeah, boring day for me, too.
 
I'm at the job site im at right now only because the job I was supposed to do canceled last minute.

I'll probably spend most of my day standing around watching the other guy work and handing him tools.

It was either this, or waste a vacation day.

So yeah, boring day for me, too.
So you're being paid to handle another guy's tools?
 
Gotta get to work, but real quick wanna thank everyone for the advice/ replies.

I do have some ideas going forward, can't wait to get home at get back to writing it now.
So let’s review our helpful advice.

You need to add a nun in a crotchless wet suit, change the setting to some kind of creepy house, add a serial killer and Bruce Springsteen singing “BORN IN THE USA” over and over again, with a sexy hitchhiker and to make the sex more interesting add a broken bed, a pit and a whip.

Yep. I’d say that pretty much sums up our problem solving skills.

Good job, team. Good F’KIN job!

😂🤣😆
 
So let’s review our helpful advice.

You need to add a nun in a crotchless wet suit, change the setting to some kind of creepy house, add a serial killer and Bruce Springsteen singing “BORN IN THE USA” over and over again, with a sexy hitchhiker and to make the sex more interesting add a broken bed, a pit and a whip.

Yep. I’d say that pretty much sums up our problem solving skills.

Good job, team. Good F’KIN job!

😂🤣😆


This is gonna be the Greatest Fucking Story Ever.

Pulitzer, here I come.
 
I've been working on a Nude Day submission for months now.

Well, technically, I started it months ago then sat on it because of indecision on what direction it should go.

So now I'm back at it, and I've chosen a direction.

And I even almost finished it.

My problem is: it feels...flat.

It's not really a stroker, so not a ton of sex.

And that's due to the intentional choice i made.

It has a conflict. But I feel I just kinda jumped straight to resolving it.

I still like the concept. I even like what I've written.

I just don't LOVE it.

I still have time, can think it over, maybe find a way to spruce it up.

What do you do when a story feels incomplete, or just not right?

Scrap it? Get test readers? Just sit on it til an idea comes?

I don't wanna scrap it. There's a good story in here somewhere.

Maybe not a great one, but that's okay.

I'm ultimately afraid the thing is BORING.

And that's even worse than a bad story lol.

Gonna sleep on it. Kick it around. Try and figure out that special ingredient to give it a kick.

Just hoping it comes to me sooner than later lol.
Forgive me if I don't read all sixty entries on here; I have other things to do (like writing, for one!) I admit, I have several things I just abandoned and never posted. I even finished three chapters of a series and I think two of another one. They just weren't working, in my opinion, so I didn't delete them, I just left them.

There was an event on another site for which I tried, twice I think, to write something but I couldn't do it. I can't say if all these materials were bad, boring, implausible or whatever - I didn't like them, for sure. So don't scrap it, but don't overly worry about it . Now I have to see what you posted later here.
 
Forgive me if I don't read all sixty entries on here; I have other things to do (like writing, for one!) I admit, I have several things I just abandoned and never posted. I even finished three chapters of a series and I think two of another one. They just weren't working, in my opinion, so I didn't delete them, I just left them.

There was an event on another site for which I tried, twice I think, to write something but I couldn't do it. I can't say if all these materials were bad, boring, implausible or whatever - I didn't like them, for sure. So don't scrap it, but don't overly worry about it . Now I have to see what you posted later here.

Lol I get it. And as usual, the topic went off the rails a bit.

But I also did glean some good advice and a little inspiration.
 
Lol I get it. And as usual, the topic went off the rails a bit.

But I also did glean some good advice and a little inspiration.
I will read more later. I've got to do some other things first. And please don't say "off the rails" because that may encourage me to post more train wreck photos. I've got to rein in stuff like that. :(
 
To onehitwanda:

Who is that? I've never seen the show. Also, I usually don't post GIFs, but rather entire scenes. A bad habit I have to stop. :rolleyes:
 
I suggest getting an outside opinion. An unbiased beta reader might be able to identify what you feel is lacking… alternately, they might also be able to tell you it’s all in your head and what you have written is wonderful!

I find with many authors, it seems we are our own worst critics, so what may seem “flat” to you may not be the case. ☺️
 
To onehitwanda:

Who is that? I've never seen the show. Also, I usually don't post GIFs, but rather entire scenes. A bad habit I have to stop. :rolleyes:
I’m not @onehitwanda - or am I? - but…

That’s Alexis Rose (played by Annie Murphy) from Schitt’s Creek. Wonderful show, please try it. But expect to watch a few episodes before you really get into it. It hits its stride in season two and keeps up the momentum flawlessly to season six. Funny, moving, thoughtful, human and makes you care deeply about characters that appear irredeemably awful to start with.

Annie Murphy was a stand out for me.

Em
 
I’m not @onehitwanda - or am I? - but…

That’s Alexis Rose (played by Annie Murphy) from Schitt’s Creek. Wonderful show, please try it. But expect to watch a few episodes before you really get into it. It hits its stride in season two and keeps up the momentum flawlessly to season six. Funny, moving, thoughtful, human and makes you care deeply about characters that appear irredeemably awful to start with.

Annie Murphy was a stand out for me.

Em
Is it on cable or is it through a streaming service? Because I can't afford either one. (Probably helps me on Lit because I have to make up my own stuff.) But yeah, I'm that poor. :cry:

So I see that she was responding to Simon Doom's post. I have less than two seconds of footage to go, but my only impression of Alexis so far is that she's a bit annoying.
 
I suggest getting an outside opinion. An unbiased beta reader might be able to identify what you feel is lacking… alternately, they might also be able to tell you it’s all in your head and what you have written is wonderful!

I find with many authors, it seems we are our own worst critics, so what may seem “flat” to you may not be the case. ☺️


I do have a few friends here I've had beta read some stuff before; I know one at least has and would give me some honest feedback.

I'm gonna be working on it more this afternoon, I do have some tweaks in mind.
 
I'm at the job site im at right now only because the job I was supposed to do canceled last minute.

I'll probably spend most of my day standing around watching the other guy work and handing him tools.

It was either this, or waste a vacation day.

So yeah, boring day for me, too.
You'd probably enjoy my four-part series on taxi driving. I'm planning a fifth chapter finally. It's amazing what you can get away with on Lit. Anyway, the job wasn't exactly boring, although it could be at times. Mostly it was way too eventful, except the wrong kind of events.
 
I suggest getting an outside opinion. An unbiased beta reader might be able to identify what you feel is lacking… alternately, they might also be able to tell you it’s all in your head and what you have written is wonderful!

I find with many authors, it seems we are our own worst critics, so what may seem “flat” to you may not be the case. ☺️
It think after a while an author does get at least an educated guess of what is working and what is not. I usually don't seek opinions until after it's published. Usually, the opinions come in unsolicited, if only through the voting. djmac may see it differently, but don't want to have a beta reader online. I certainly don't know anybody in person who would even attempt it.
 
So let’s review our helpful advice.

You need to add a nun in a crotchless wet suit, change the setting to some kind of creepy house, add a serial killer and Bruce Springsteen singing “BORN IN THE USA” over and over again, with a sexy hitchhiker and to make the sex more interesting add a broken bed, a pit and a whip.

Yep. I’d say that pretty much sums up our problem solving skills.

Good job, team. Good F’KIN job!

😂🤣😆
There a lot of Springsteen songs that are better than that, depending on what mood dj is trying to convey. (I can't stop myself, I swear!) If it's ice-cold despair - and some people here want that in their stories, - I'd go with "Point Blank."

You grew up where young girls they grow up fast.
You took what you were handed and left behind what was asked
But what they asked, baby, wasn't right.
You didn't have to live that life.
And I was gonna be your Romeo, you were gonna be my Juliet
These days you don't wait on Romeos you wait on that welfare check.
And on all the pretty little things that you can never have
And all the promises that always end up point blank.
 
It think after a while an author does get at least an educated guess of what is working and what is not. I usually don't seek opinions until after it's published. Usually, the opinions come in unsolicited, if only through the voting. djmac may see it differently, but don't want to have a beta reader online. I certainly don't know anybody in person who would even attempt it.


To each their own, I suppose. There's no Right or Wrong about it.

I find a fresh set of eyes helpful; they see things you don't, think of things you may not, point out plot holes, or just offer a fresh spin on something.

Even if you wind up not using their ideas, it can sometimes guide your path in other ways. Or just help focus your own thoughts on it.

I don't get a beta reader for EVERY story, that would be too much to expect.

But if I'm struggling with something, it's nice to have someone to bounce things off of.
 
Back
Top