Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Has your OCD fixated on Jenner for a few days? What's HRC been up to?
Shouldn't this thread be on the GLBT Chatter Forum?![]()
I think a lot of people have trouble understanding transgender issues because they try to see themselves as trans, but come at it from the wrong direction. i.e. a cis woman tries to understand transness by going, “what if I felt like/wanted to be a man” when she should be approaching it as “what if I, a woman, was so easily mistaken for a man that I had to pretend to be one”,
You are making the assumption that anyone who is critical of this does so because they don't understand. Most critical people do understand, but believe that what you are describing is a mental disorder which should not be celebrated and instead should be treated.
How is transgenderism any different than body integrity identity disorder? If I believe I will be more sexually fulfilled if I only I can have my legs amputated, and that deep down inside I am an amputee but were mistakenly born with legs, should a surgeon remove my limbs so that I can be who I really am?
Edit to give a relevant link: http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/becoming-disabled-by-choice-not-chance-transabled-people-feel-like-impostors-in-their-fully-working-bodies#__federated=1
I'm not making any assumptions of critics. In fact on the general whole, I'm leery of people who want to transition fully because of all the statistics out there that it doesn't really fix or help the core issues. It's not true for everyone but I just don't support a trendy change in gender like getting a tattoo. My comments were very directly geared towards those who don't understand transgenderism, not attacking people who are critical of the choice. There's a difference between "I don't understand" and "I understand but do not believe this is helpful".
You are making the assumption that anyone who is critical of this does so because they don't understand. Most critical people do understand, but believe that what you are describing is a mental disorder which should not be celebrated and instead should be treated.
How is transgenderism any different than body integrity identity disorder? If I believe I will be more sexually fulfilled if I only I can have my legs amputated, and that deep down inside I am an amputee but were mistakenly born with legs, should a surgeon remove my limbs so that I can be who I really am?
Edit to give a relevant link: http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/becoming-disabled-by-choice-not-chance-transabled-people-feel-like-impostors-in-their-fully-working-bodies#__federated=1
Those people are not on this thread, so surely you can understand why I find your post puzzling.
That's understandable, especially since I wasn't talking to you to start out with.It's good to know that you have a complete monopoly and control over the opinions expressed or yet to be expressed in this thread or on this topic.
Who knows, back in the day homosexuality was a mental illness and in the DSM. The Young Turks of the APA sorted it out. But if you dig into this you'll find that you are talking apples to oranges. Jenner's journey has little to do with sexual arousal/fulfillment.
I disagree. Transgenderism is body dysmorphia which needs to be treated by a mental health professional.
Homosexuality has nothing to do with transgenderism as most educate people will tell you.
I like you and won't waste our time trying to convince you, but I would encourage you to read up more before you profess.
I know. You missed my point.
Why are you being sarcastic and nasty when I have been polite to you and all others on this thread? Well I know why... your behavior is typical.