How does one dump a submissive ?

@}-}rebecca----

not enough discipline ...
Joined
Oct 31, 2005
Posts
13,063
Ohh I'm in color. Temporarily.

This is a current article from Dan da man Savage's Column, though appears to be answered exclusively by Matisse ( as a side note has her own podcast as of a week ago, not bad so far ) .



How Do I Dump a Submissive Who Does My Dishes and Gives Me Blowjobs?
Weekly sex advice from Dan Savage
by Dan Savage


Q: At first glance, I am the guy your mother wants you to marry: successful, sweet, clean-shaven. Below the surface, I am the guy your mother warned you about: pierced tongue, tattoos, a ton of kinks. A couple of months ago, I met a woman who wanted to be a sex slave. We talked about relationship expectations, and because of a few deal-breakers—she is older than me, she has kids from a past marriage, our career goals differ—we said that this wasn't going anywhere beyond a temporary fling. Now she comes to my house a couple of times a week, puts on lingerie, blows me, does my dishes, blows me, gets tied up/spanked, picks up my dirty laundry, blows me again, and then leaves. Needless to say, I am quite happy with the situation.

Now I have met a great woman whom I like, and am looking to start a "normal" relationship with (read: still hot kinky sex, just no need for her to crawl on all fours when she enters my house, as fun as that is to watch). She has been hurt before and wants to spend a long time "getting to know each other" before we move toward anything physical. We have both acknowledged that we are interested in pursuing a relationship, just not yet. Given my situation, i.e., all those blowjobs from the submissive, I have no problems waiting as long as girlfriend material wants before we start something physical.

My question is on dom/sub slave etiquette. Assuming that things with this new woman work out, at what point should I break up with my sub? Should I tell her about the other woman? Should I tell her in advance we are ending ("Your next visit will be our last"), or should I just ask her to come over and break up then ("We both knew this was only going to last so long")? Do I help her find a new dom? This isn't a regular breakup, so I'm not really sure how to do it. My sub loves to serve, so would it be cheating on my next girlfriend if I let her keep doing domestic tasks for me, but nothing sexual? Should I tell my next girlfriend that I had a sex slave for a while? —Deciding On Method

A: Hmm. My mother never warned me about guys with piercings, tattoos, or kinks. My mother did, however, warn me about guys who think a hidden tattoo or a discreet piercing somehow makes them more interesting than they actually are. "Those guys are always douchebags," my mother used to say. Still does. But, hey, my mom isn't the guest expert you need.

"The fact that you're having a dominant/submissive relationship with this older woman is immaterial," says Mistress Matisse, a pro dom, expert flogger, and prolific blogger (mistressmatisse.blogspot.com). "It's an intimate sexual relationship, so forget d/s in your handling of this. It's clear that you'd be happy to continue on with them both, at least for a while, so the question is more polyamory skills than BDSM etiquette."

So what does Matisse think you should do? "Tell both women exactly what's going on, immediately," Matisse continues. "Your girlfriend-to-be wants to get to know you? Well, if she can't handle the fact that you've been having a d/s relationship, you better find that out now. Her response will certainly give you a clue as to how kinky your future sex life with her might be. But full disclosure, pronto, is best. Anyone who has been 'hurt before' is apt to be touchy about discovering perceived dishonesty down the road." And what about your sub? "Your submissive is also deserving of your honesty," says Matisse. "She may decide she wants to end your relationship, or she may be willing to continue in a nonsexual arrangement if that's offered her. If you are extremely lucky, your submissive and your GF-to-be may decide they can co-exist in some fashion, at least for now. God knows I've dated men who really needed someone to pick up after them, and I sure as hell wasn't going to do it."

And how does one properly break up with a submissive, if it comes to that?

"Make a date with your submissive and respectfully inform her that you are ending the relationship," says Matisse. "Wish her well and say goodbye—no last blowjobs for the road. And do not offer to find her a new dominant—trust me, she'll have no trouble at all finding another dominant to accept an arrangement like the one you've described."

-------------------

Oops here I am again in living color, just doing this really to cleary discern between the article and me.

Ahh this is better. So .......


And how does one properly break up with a pyl, if it comes to that?


There are add-ons being that for some D/s or M/s is involved, surely they apply when things aren't too fabulous. My opinion for what it's worth is when relationships deteriorate some very common relationship dysfunction traits seem to come into play , very human , very average, dare I say 'vanilla'. Though the wounded ' X owned' souls seem to carry around this extra little aura. Do we still keep the ever championed communication open or are we simply dismissed ? Where's the respect people, behavior codes, relationship mandates/terms, from compliance to free for all. I used the word dichotomy in the art thread earlier, it certainly also applies here. Nothing going on in the rafters with me either, just throwing this open for discussion. Perhaps I'll add more later.

Any thoughts ?

I was deliberate in instigating this thread in the Cafe as opposed to Talk. I think it's a topic that can certainly bare a little humor of expression in part & while a more formal examination would be appreciated I think it pays not to imply boundaries as to how that is conveyed in this instance.
 
Last edited:
Miss Rebecca

I know I have not been here much but, but, but, but....


Are you dumping me??

*cries*
 
Miss Rebecca

I know I have not been here much but, but, but, but....


Are you dumping me??

*cries*

No I'd rather keep you on a little string to amuse myself from time to time.

How does that fit in with your personal feed into masochism sweety : chuckles :

Ohh you should be so lucky. I am never dumping you, you hear me ?

: stalker mode :
 
No I'd rather keep you on a little string to amuse myself from time to time.

How does that fit in with your personal feed into masochism sweety : chuckles :

Ohh you should be so lucky. I am never dumping you, you hear me ?

: stalker mode :

:)

Oh Thank you Miss Rebecca

But could you tell me, should I be relieved or scared by the news that you are never dumping me:confused:
 
How do you feel about a poll ?

Does that sound bitter, because really I'm Zen like :cool:

*starts backing away from the scary submissive*

Miss Rebecca have we de-railed your thread?

I should read the article and try to get it back on track.

But I read the thread title and instantly panicked.

Oops:eek:
 
I guess this is why I don't write advice columns. I would have left him at douchbag.
 
*starts backing away from the scary submissive*

Miss Rebecca have we de-railed your thread?

I should read the article and try to get it back on track.

But I read the thread title and instantly panicked.

Oops:eek:

It's cool Miss Shy, there is a comprehensive list of people most welcome to de-rail most anything I instigate, you're quite a header on that list.

Nice big tin of worms this topic, I wonder where it will go ....
 
Ahh this is better. So .......


And how does one properly break up with a pyl, if it comes to that?


There are add-ons being that for some D/s or M/s is involved, surely they apply when things aren't too fabulous. My opinion for what it's worth is when relationships deteriorate some very common relationship dysfunction traits seem to come into play , very human , very average, dare I say 'vanilla'. Though the wounded ' X owned' souls seem to carry around this extra little aura. Do we still keep the ever championed communication open or are we simply dismissed ? Where's the respect people, behavior codes, relationship mandates/terms, from compliance to free for all. I used the word dichotomy in the art thread earlier, it certainly also applies here. Nothing going on in the rafters with me either, just throwing this open for discussion. Perhaps I'll add more later.

Any thoughts ?
No partner I have ever had would be able to relate to the situation presented in the opening paragraph of the Q&A. That's just not a flavor or form of "D/s relationship" that I have ever embraced.

As for your observation in the sentence I've underlined here, I'd say that someone who displays a "wounded" aura, when an agreed upon "temporary fling" turns out to be just that, is displaying the behavior of an immature and irresponsible drama queen. This has nothing to do with being submissive - or at least not the kind of submissive whom I would respect.
 
No partner I have ever had would be able to relate to the situation presented in the opening paragraph of the Q&A. That's just not a flavor or form of "D/s relationship" that I have ever embraced.

As for your observation in the sentence I've underlined here, I'd say that someone who displays a "wounded" aura, when an agreed upon "temporary fling" turns out to be just that, is displaying the behavior of an immature and irresponsible drama queen. This has nothing to do with being submissive - or at least not the kind of submissive whom I would respect.

Understood.

I apologize, apparently I have not been very clear. While the article was a catalyst for the idea of starting the thread. The comment you have underlined wasn't intended to be considered on the exacting terms of the relationship as described in the article. When I noted D/s & M/s I was inferring a relationship with more projected longevity. You're so literal Mr Mohegan, you always catch me out that way. ( said with a smile )
 
Understood.

I apologize, apparently I have not been very clear. While the article was a catalyst for the idea of starting the thread. The comment you have underlined wasn't intended to be considered on the exacting terms of the relationship as described in the article. When I noted D/s & M/s I was inferring a relationship with more projected longevity. You're so literal Mr Mohegan, you always catch me out that way. ( said with a smile )
Take my response relating to the relationship described in the article, and apply it overall. Responsible people (on both sides of the coin) understand the terms of the relationship into which they are entering, and behave accordingly.

Assuming that both parties are behaving like responsible adults, the idea that one partner would necessarily be more "wounded" than the other at termination of the relationship is an idea I do not support.

As for your question about the "proper" way to terminate a relationship, that's up to the individuals in a specific D/s or M/s relationship to decide. The terms and conditions I've heard of in this regard really vary quite widely.
 
Last edited:
Take my response relating to the relationship described in the article, and apply it overall. Responsible people (on both sides of the coin) understand the terms of the relationship into which they are entering, and behave accordingly.

Assuming that both parties are behaving like responsible adults, the idea that one partner would necessarily be more "wounded" than the other at termination of the relationship is an idea I do not support.

As for your question about the "proper" way to terminate a relationship, that's up to the individuals in a specific D/s or M/s relationship to decide. The terms and conditions I've heard of in this regard really vary quite widely.
All sounds appropriate and reasonable. Curious to me though that what is perceived/designated/applied as best practice & ideal rarely resonates as the status quo. How many people actually mutually define how a relationship will end when the premise is longevity I wonder. I certainly never have. Hmmn interesting. To further clarify I used the wording 'wounded aura' not to project either screaming banshee nor perpetual wilting victim. Now I need to redefine something almost intangible. I think about that in the course of my day and perhaps try and articulate it more clearly later.
 
I just think the guy is a total idiot for thinking that this second relationship is going to work for him.

If you are enjoying having someone crawling around on all fours, but think you are going to magically get over it when you stick your dick in a pussy missionary style, you are so sorely mistaken.


He'll be cheating on this nice new girl with someone like the person he's playing with now in months. He has MUCH bigger issues than letting his fuckbuddy down gently.
 
How does one dump a submissive?

Oh, I know the answer to this question.

One proposes to one's other girlfriend and doesn't bother to tell one's submissive. One lets one's submissive find out about the engagement on MySpace and then acts all shot in the ass about it when one's submissive calls one at 1 in the morning to interrogate. Then one never speaks to said submissive again until five months later, a whole three weeks before one's wedding, whereupon one apologizes to the submissive and says one never meant to put her through hell like that. One then proceeds to tell submissive how unfulfilled one is and insinuate how unhappy one has become.

When one's fiancee finds out that one is talking to one's on-again, off-again submissive yet again, whom she has tried to keep one away from for the duration of both relationships, one disappears again. One goes through with one's wedding, in spite of misgivings on both sides, flying in the face of all logic. Once one has been married for about two weeks, one realizes that one has fucked up and starts appearing online on Yahoo messenger to one's ex-submissive (whom one never appeared online to throughout this entire fiasco) in hopes that said ex-submissive will talk to one yet again.

Ex-submissive says, "It'll be a cold day in hell...."

I'm sorry. Did that sound bitter? Because it kind of was. :mad:

/end hijack of Miss Rebecca's thread.

ETA: And while I was posting this, one used one's "couple" profile on CollarMe to view one's ex-submissive's Domme profile with all her pictures plastered all over it. One thinks stalking and fucking with one's ex-submissive's head is amusing. :mad:
 
Last edited:
In my very humble opinion I think that one who would behave in such a way to one's submissive should go to hell where one may wait there for it to get cold so that one may fully appreciate the impact of one's bahaviour.
 
In my very humble opinion I think that one who would behave in such a way to one's submissive should go to hell where one may wait there for it to get cold so that one may fully appreciate the impact of one's bahaviour.

I like the way you think. :p
 
In my very humble opinion I think that one who would behave in such a way to one's submissive should go to hell where one may wait there for it to get cold so that one may fully appreciate the impact of one's bahaviour.

Hmm. I don't think that's quite harsh enough for the situation BiBunny was describing.
 
I just think the guy is a total idiot for thinking that this second relationship is going to work for him.

If you are enjoying having someone crawling around on all fours, but think you are going to magically get over it when you stick your dick in a pussy missionary style, you are so sorely mistaken.


He'll be cheating on this nice new girl with someone like the person he's playing with now in months. He has MUCH bigger issues than letting his fuckbuddy down gently.

I. love. you. period.

*crawls back in hole*
 
I tried to think from his submissive's PoV and the new girlfriend to be... and I guess... all I can say is

First, he's a dickhead for even THINKING about not telling either of the women about the other. Emotionally and physically, that's just not healthy. Go to the submissive first, explain he's met someone and that she needs to prepare that their relationship as D/s may have to end. Then he goes and tells the gf to be about his feelings.



For God's sake he needs to be a grown up about it and accept responsibility for his actions.
 
I just think the guy is a total idiot for thinking that this second relationship is going to work for him.

I have to agree with you here.

I also think he was an idiot when he entered into a temporary D/s relationship without some kind of time-constrained/renewable written contract in place. Having a verbal agreement is nice, as far as it goes, but having to sit down and re-sign a contract at the first of every month does a very effective job of hammering home exactly what the expectations of that relationship are. Without some kind of external corrective force (e.g. a contract), almost any temporary D/s (or sexual) relationship of any significance will inevitably drift towards some kind of longer-term emotional commitment.

The new woman in this idiot's life in an unknown commodity and may just be one in a series of infatuations. It's hard to tell from here. He's better off getting his current house in order and start communicating better with the woman he's with. Because, ultimately, it is his failure to communicate properly that turned him into the indecisive idiot that he has become. He should know what to do in this situation, especially if he is a Dom. Idjit.
 
What is the question? I'm a little confused. Do kinky people dump people differently than vanilla people? Not that I've witnessed.
 
What is the question? I'm a little confused. Do kinky people dump people differently than vanilla people? Not that I've witnessed.

Or perhaps should they? Is there a greater responsibilty attached to the dynamic of a D/s relationship when it comes to ending a relationship?
 
Back
Top