Step sis wants a DP from twins

[Brandnewbuddy]

Older stepsis comes home from college and can’t help but notice her younger stepbrothers (who are going to college next year) are checking her out. Once parents are away she approaches both of them and after teasing them says she’s happy to go all the way with them so they don’t go to college as virgins…but she doesn’t want to show favoritism so it will have to be as a Ménage a Trois. Brothers go through a whole range of wondering if she’s serious, then if it’s really okay, then wondering if they can go through with it knowing their brother will be joining in.

Thought it would be interesting to have her be a stepsister so it can go in the order of “well she’s our sister…well she’s not related by blood, wait what am I talking about I’m going to be in a three way with my brother, oh fuck.”

As well as play with motivations.

For example:

1. She’s a couple years older and they all became a family when the boys were 10 and she was 12. Despite being older, she was always close with them and never looked down on them. Due to their ages she was also their first crush though she never knew or reciprocated.

The idea to seduce them never entered her head till they came to visit her at her sorority house and all of the girls were talking about how they’d love to have a couple of boy toys like her stepbrothers and noted how Her stepbrothers kept checking her out. While she’s experienced, her sorority sisters love telling about their most scandalous hookups so to fit in, she decides to have the three way so she has a story to tell when she gets back.

 

[sirhugs]

I like this idea. I have never done a twins story i don't think. It would be different to do it with twin brothers. IHAVE done stepdaughter stories, so a step sister is logical.

I however would likely NOT make them close as teens... more a teasing rivalry for parental attention. Having been to college already, Big Sis now thinks she has the upper hand...but does she?

 

[Brandnewbuddy]

That could be a fun direction: sis comes back thinking her stepbros are virgins only to discover dating has changed significantly since she’s been gone at college. Her bros don’t have a long history of partners but they have quite a bit of experience as they always get laid when they go over or bring over a girl since in a pandemic you don’t really have time to go out for lots of dates. They also are perfectly fine with being naked around each other as they normally have to share girls.
So instead of being the experienced college girl, she ends up getting schooled herself.

 

[Carnevil9]

I have a very similar story with older twin sisters deflowering their slightly younger virgin brother. I didn't pussy out and make them step anythings; they are full blooded siblings. It is one of my highest rated stories! Literotica readers love incest, not incest-light.

 

[nonverbalcommunication]

I did this, but they were triplets.

LOL, one clueless commentator said that triplets were always the same gender...

 

[sirhugs]

I have a very similar story with older twin sisters deflowering their slightly younger virgin brother. I didn't pussy out and make them step anythings; they are full blooded siblings. It is one of my highest rated stories! Literotica readers love incest, not incest-light.

I dunno, my stepdaughter stories have done well.

 

[Brandnewbuddy]

I went with step because in both versions it allows the spark to be there.

In the first version bros feel a bit awkward but the thought of sex with their hot stepsister let’s them go “well…we’re not blood related” only to then realize “oh shit, I’m also here with my brother.” And navigating those feelings.

In both, but especially the second variety, sis is trading stories with her sorority sisters and realizes that a story about hooking up with her twin stepbrothers iSight on the line of proper levels of taboo: far enough it’s scandalous, not so far that she’s seen as a freak. Since they’re twins, the girls also fantasize about seeing them fuck each other even though they’re brothers…if she was blood related her sisters would be giving her a lot of distance and looks.

It also allows for it to go towards harder incest:

For example: first variant: brothers realize that the awkwardness is because they do have some attraction towards each other and start fucking. Second, bros reveal they have hooked up with each other and sis is the one surprised.

..and of course in both, parents could come home, discuss what happened and do some mutual exploration (still reluctant sis hooks up with stepmom then dad, boys hook up with step dad and then mom)

At the same time though I do know that in general a lot of people do prefer a degree of seperate on that step family allows. It’s why most porn, even when the characters are written as family will always throw in a “step” mention

 

[nonverbalcommunication]

Brothers... But they were not twins...