Will the computer replace the human teacher?

There was a time when MD's would be able to analyze urine simply by looking at it?

You've thrown out the word expensive a few times, but expensive isn't a metric.

So what is education's current business model? Consolidate and eliminate. Tell me again how it's not about the money.
 
There was a time when MD's would be able to analyze urine simply by looking at it?

You've thrown out the word expensive a few times, but expensive isn't a metric.

EXPENSIVE means not enough cash around here, and the schools are tossing teachers to find enough money to pay all the Assistant Supers, and we have a battalion of them on board. Last election we tossed the Super Duper Super. She had made homes for all the perverts and psychos flushed from the classrooms.
 
I think computers can be great for modeling & lecturing. They certainly have a place in education as they do in our lives. I think in a math course they might be able to outline why a kid is making a mistake because with math there are only a finite number of mistakes that can be made. I don't think computers would be able to do that with other subjects.

I think they can do a more than adequate job of teaching basic science and history as well. Obviously current computers wouldn't be able to do everything but honestly K-12 science and history are simply memorizing facts and regurgitating them properly. If kids can learn 550 different pokemon evolutions, types, and move lists I'm confident in their ability to memorize when Columbus "discovered" America and the names of his ships as well as 43 US presidents (most of which most adults can't recall off hand) and again if they can spit out what the best method is for taking down the Lich King they can learn how the food chain works. Most subjects have a point where this won't work anymore but certainly we can go along way.

I think you'd want a human teacher, just for surprise situations, but I think computers could be very beneficial for most classes.

As Yamauchi once explained, the whole world benefits from the top 1% of scientists and musicians and athletes, but only 1% of people benefit from the top 1% of teachers. If you could record those teachers and synthesize their methods into an electronic form, that could then be cheaply distributed across the world and used to help students learn. You'd still want a human present, for questions and more detailed explanation when students have problems, but how many of us wouldn't prefer learning from the world's best teachers, rather than whomever we random receive based on geography?

Yeah. . .he was wrong. The whole world doesn't benefit from the top musicians and athletes and it's debatable that we even all benefit from the top scientists. Not to mention his example is stupid. If you're going to record a teacher, someone you cannot directly interact with, then the teacher doesn't matter in the least. This is like saying that the best writers should be in the movies but that's absurd. There is a reason, a good one, why Robert Downey Jr is Tony Stark not Joss Whedon.

And what makes you think the system you're visualizing would be less expensive?

No longer having to maintain all the physical infrastructure for schools would in evitably be cheaper. You nix the school, a good chunk of the teachers, all the grounds keepers, no more buses, no more need to purchase physical books, desks, chairs, other office supplies. Even if you supplied the kids with lap tops you'd come out way way cheaper.

And parents leaving an 8 year old home alone while they work seems so illegal.

People do that anyway. Besides as someone else pointed out the lower costs (not just here) should free up more spare time. Worst case scenario though we worry about that when we get there. The purpose of school is NOT free babysitting. That's at best a side perk.

How would there be savings in property taxes? Again, what makes you think property taxes wouldn't go up?

They shouldn't go up. For the same reason that Kindlebooks don't cost MORE than real books and in many cases are much much cheaper (even free for those books that nobody techincally owns anymore) That said we all know how taxes work and it's unlikely that they would really go down significantly and if they went up it would be to pay for something, perhaps all the free wi-fi that is necessary to make this plan feesible. Perhaps (hopefully) to fund various extra curricular activities that.
 
I think they can do a more than adequate job of teaching basic science and history as well. Obviously current computers wouldn't be able to do everything but honestly K-12 science and history are simply memorizing facts and regurgitating them properly. If kids can learn 550 different pokemon evolutions, types, and move lists I'm confident in their ability to memorize when Columbus "discovered" America and the names of his ships as well as 43 US presidents (most of which most adults can't recall off hand) and again if they can spit out what the best method is for taking down the Lich King they can learn how the food chain works. Most subjects have a point where this won't work anymore but certainly we can go along way.



Yeah. . .he was wrong. The whole world doesn't benefit from the top musicians and athletes and it's debatable that we even all benefit from the top scientists. Not to mention his example is stupid. If you're going to record a teacher, someone you cannot directly interact with, then the teacher doesn't matter in the least. This is like saying that the best writers should be in the movies but that's absurd. There is a reason, a good one, why Robert Downey Jr is Tony Stark not Joss Whedon.



No longer having to maintain all the physical infrastructure for schools would in evitably be cheaper. You nix the school, a good chunk of the teachers, all the grounds keepers, no more buses, no more need to purchase physical books, desks, chairs, other office supplies. Even if you supplied the kids with lap tops you'd come out way way cheaper.



People do that anyway. Besides as someone else pointed out the lower costs (not just here) should free up more spare time. Worst case scenario though we worry about that when we get there. The purpose of school is NOT free babysitting. That's at best a side perk.



They shouldn't go up. For the same reason that Kindlebooks don't cost MORE than real books and in many cases are much much cheaper (even free for those books that nobody techincally owns anymore) That said we all know how taxes work and it's unlikely that they would really go down significantly and if they went up it would be to pay for something, perhaps all the free wi-fi that is necessary to make this plan feesible. Perhaps (hopefully) to fund various extra curricular activities that.

History & Science are certainly not just memorizing facts. If that's all it was when you were in school you were cheated. Students should be taught to evaluate history so they can learn from mistakes and learn how to repeat success. In Science they should also be learning how to solve a problem with a hypothesis. In both History & Science they should be learning how to read complex history & science text.

You raise some great points. Yes, there would no longer need to be as many physical buildings and school districts could sell them off. Every student would get a laptop, but they would also need to be able to connect to the internet. The laptops & internet connection would need to be maintained. I'm guessing each individual home where there is a student would need an internet connection. That's a lot of techs.

Schools would still need "books" as a resource for students. Yes, they wouldn't have to be physically printed out on paper (except in the rarest of cases), but you would still need to pay the authors, which is expensive.

Yes, some parents do leave their 8 year old home alone all day. It's extremely illegal. Not all parents would do this though, and that presents those parents with a cost. A cost that some of them may not be able to afford, which means it falls upon the taxpayer. Normally I wouldn't think twice about leaving a 15 year old home alone during the day, but would you leave a 15 year old home alone knowing that there are several other 15 year olds in town also home alone?
 
EXPENSIVE means not enough cash around here, and the schools are tossing teachers to find enough money to pay all the Assistant Supers, and we have a battalion of them on board. Last election we tossed the Super Duper Super. She had made homes for all the perverts and psychos flushed from the classrooms.

Nonsense, there's plenty of cash. You should stop voting for more administrators.
 
Nonsense, there's plenty of cash. You should stop voting for more administrators.

About 1/2 the money schools collect go for administrators (including set-asides for perverts and psychos removed from the classrooms).
 
The other day I heard on the radio that the schools are removing cursive writing from the curriculum, with text books being next and students will be required to have a tablet for school work. Seems to me pretty soon the kids aren't going to think for themselves any longer. They already need calculators for math, now they do not need handwriting ?? I am thinking pretty soon computers will replace a lot of things...
 
Last edited:
The budget is public record so it would be incredibly easy for you to cite since you've already done the work.

Then look at the Florida k-12 budget, divide it by the total number of students, then itemize expenses. Once you account for every dime the school plant and classrooms consume, 1/2 of the money is left.

You wont find the expenses itemized anywhere. But I'm talking construction, insurance, utilities, buses, fuel, salaries, pensions, books, libraries, etc.
 
History & Science are certainly not just memorizing facts. If that's all it was when you were in school you were cheated. Students should be taught to evaluate history so they can learn from mistakes and learn how to repeat success. In Science they should also be learning how to solve a problem with a hypothesis. In both History & Science they should be learning how to read complex history & science text.

I see your point (even if I think you are stretching to the point insanity). Very little of grade school science involves solving a problem. I'm not arguing that this shouldn't be taught. I'd go as far as to say that I would like to see MORE of that. (Though I'm gonna go right back to video games and tell you that if you don't think kids are doing just that when they play World of Warcraft it just means you've never played. They might not break it down into the proper steps and understand the terms but that can all be added to the program.) And I know I keep repeating this, it's just that you know Lit, if it's not in the latest post you never said it. I'm not saying eliminate teachers entirely, just maximize computers.

I'm not disagreeing that the things you say should be taught, should be. I'm saying they weren't where I went to school and aren't in any of the schools that I associate with. At least not in any great amount. I think you need the foundation first anyway though.

You raise some great points. Yes, there would no longer need to be as many physical buildings and school districts could sell them off. Every student would get a laptop, but they would also need to be able to connect to the internet. The laptops & internet connection would need to be maintained. I'm guessing each individual home where there is a student would need an internet connection. That's a lot of techs.

First, where I live in California has free wi-fi. It's crap wi-fi and I wouldn't recommend trying to stream a movie on it but it's fine for reading and writing kinds of things. Second, most families already have internet. Still solving both of these problems for most of the country doesn't sound nearly as expensive even with the techs as maintaining however many thousands of campuses and the personnel to run them.

To some extent this falls under, you have to try it to see how it'll function. I'd be willing to bet that the amount of money saved on transportation and grounds keeping alone would more than offset needing to get the techs up for wifi. (Especially since I'm also a fan of phasing out the post office, and look everybody has computer and internet access? I know that's a "seperate" subject so it's a bit unfair to drop it here but I tend to think in multiple directions.)

Schools would still need "books" as a resource for students. Yes, they wouldn't have to be physically printed out on paper (except in the rarest of cases), but you would still need to pay the authors, which is expensive.

I'm curious how expensive they really have to be. Again math books. . .math hasn't changed a great deal in a very very long time. (To say nothing of the benefits of children being able to move along at their own pace. I knew kids in first grade who could handle basic algebra. Anecdotal I grant you, but my point is there is no reason at all to force gifted children who might very well be capable of advancing in math, or any subject, to slow down.) Yes, you do have to pay authors, but even then that's not going to be as expensive as printing them. I'm suddenly curious what authors get on average for a school book. It seems absurd that most of them would get a lot of money for your average school book. I admit having no knowledge on that though.

Yes, some parents do leave their 8 year old home alone all day. It's extremely illegal. Not all parents would do this though, and that presents those parents with a cost. A cost that some of them may not be able to afford, which means it falls upon the taxpayer. Normally I wouldn't think twice about leaving a 15 year old home alone during the day, but would you leave a 15 year old home alone knowing that there are several other 15 year olds in town also home alone?

So change the laws, and or find a way to fix it.

As for leaving a 15 year old home alone during the day knowing there are several others in town home alone. I don't know about you, where I live they just called that Summer Vacation. Honestly if you can't trust your 15 year old not to do anything really stupid you've got a pretty big fucking problem since they are only three years away from being expected not to make mistakes.

Besides if THAT is your big gripe then while I disagree that's something worthy of discussion. I don't claim to have this entirely figured out. What I am claiming is that it seems like we have lots of wonderful technology and that we are still doing things today the same way our great grand parents did things because nobody will step up and start working to change those things.

I'm also a fan of integrating subjects when and where possible. I know that in my first grade class which was in theory bilingual, that they did a lot of math in Spanish. So we learned some very basic spanish (almost all of which is gone today) how to count to twenty, plus, minus a few words so we could talk about apples and pears and then it certainly didn't harm my math skills to be able to count in Spanish and later Latin and Japanese. (Though my Father was furious. Blah blah blah, Mexicans flooding our schools and now my son thinks uno plus uno= dos! At the time I didn't get it, today I just kinda shrug and also wish that as a Southern Californian that I knew enough Spanish to get by while also not caring enough to make an effort. I'd rather know Japanese and be able to important games.) Sorry, I ramble.
 
Back
Top