Will the computer replace the human teacher?

Humans are too expensive. Plus computers don't fuck the kids or retire. And computers are smarter than teachers.
 
I don't think there's a right or wrong answer. I think in some areas of learning a computer can and has replaced teachers. In other areas, we will still need teachers to teach, offer guidance, interact and respond to children needs.

Computers have offered something in my school district we wouldn't have had the opportunity without. We had a five year program teaching Chinese. Students had the option to take it as an elective.... there was a waiting list for space. They joined students from across the country four times a week. They learned from one main site but exchanged information and interacted with other kids outside of the clsssroom.

The list for other electives was just as varied. One classroom was used but four or five classes were being held. Cooking, photography...even a Zombie lit reading class.

There is no reason that it has to be an all or nothing package.
 
Writing to a prompt. Keeping focus, using logic, grammar....etc.

I'm sure they could get a program up to worry about writing to a prompt if anybody cared.

Teachers don't teach focus or logic TODAY so that's right out and Microsoft Word checks your grammar. Sure it doesn't always adequately explain what the fuck you did wrong but it will tell you that you were wrong.
 
I'm sure they could get a program up to worry about writing to a prompt if anybody cared.

Teachers don't teach focus or logic TODAY so that's right out and Microsoft Word checks your grammar. Sure it doesn't always adequately explain what the fuck you did wrong but it will tell you that you were wrong.

Yes they do. ELA Standard 1 "Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence."
 
Last edited:
Yes they do. ELA Standard 1 "Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence."

I'll take your word for it. I don't recall any such thing from school (K-12, college doesn't count. If we were supposed to be talking college then I apologize) and even if I did I still suspect that basic addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, science and history could probably be taught perfectly well by a computer. (And I'm not honestly suggesting we try. I'm suggesting that using computers and teaching online is the way to go.
 
I'll take your word for it. I don't recall any such thing from school (K-12, college doesn't count. If we were supposed to be talking college then I apologize) and even if I did I still suspect that basic addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, science and history could probably be taught perfectly well by a computer. (And I'm not honestly suggesting we try. I'm suggesting that using computers and teaching online is the way to go.

I think computers can be great for modeling & lecturing. They certainly have a place in education as they do in our lives. I think in a math course they might be able to outline why a kid is making a mistake because with math there are only a finite number of mistakes that can be made. I don't think computers would be able to do that with other subjects.
 
I wouldn't trust a fucking robot doctor!

Your real MD does shit now; you pee in a cup, he lets the computer analyze it, and the computer spits out a treatment plan. So simple a Mexican can do it. Uh oh!
 
I think you'd want a human teacher, just for surprise situations, but I think computers could be very beneficial for most classes.

As Yamauchi once explained, the whole world benefits from the top 1% of scientists and musicians and athletes, but only 1% of people benefit from the top 1% of teachers. If you could record those teachers and synthesize their methods into an electronic form, that could then be cheaply distributed across the world and used to help students learn. You'd still want a human present, for questions and more detailed explanation when students have problems, but how many of us wouldn't prefer learning from the world's best teachers, rather than whomever we random receive based on geography?
 
And parents leaving an 8 year old home alone while they work seems so illegal.

With the savings in property taxes alone, both parents would no longer need to work. That's a win/win, unless you are a teacher. I don't expect to see change initiated by those it would displace.
 
With the savings in property taxes alone, both parents would no longer need to work. That's a win/win, unless you are a teacher. I don't expect to see change initiated by those it would displace.

How would there be savings in property taxes? Again, what makes you think property taxes wouldn't go up?
 
Your real MD does shit now; you pee in a cup, he lets the computer analyze it, and the computer spits out a treatment plan. So simple a Mexican can do it. Uh oh!

There was a time when MD's would be able to analyze urine simply by looking at it?

You've thrown out the word expensive a few times, but expensive isn't a metric.
 
Back
Top