Why do Liberals HATE This Graph/Chart?

Why do Liberals HATE this Graph/Chart

  • It shows what a liar Obama is

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • They actually do pay less taxes than Romney

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • That they are all Derps for Believing Obamaloney

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    1
  • Poll closed .
I don't hate it. I think working-poor families should have little or no income tax burden. And there are shitloads of them as the middle class disappears.

And Romney wants to hike takes on the middle class and working poor now. The man should not get your vote.
 
I don't hate it. I think working-poor families should have little or no income tax burden. And there are shitloads of them as the middle class disappears.

And Romney wants to hike takes on the middle class and working poor now. The man should not get your vote.

And how is Romney going to this raising of taxes on the poor and middle class?
 
And how is Romney going to this raising of taxes on the poor and middle class?

Nonpartisan analysis of Romney's plan:
http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/UploadedPDF/1001628-Base-Broadening-Tax-Reform.pdf

Basically he's going to cut marginal rates but keep things revenue-neutral by eliminating deductions. But there's no mathematical way he can do that without eliminating more in deductions for the middle/working poor class than they would save in lowered rates.
 
Nonpartisan analysis of Romney's plan:
http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/UploadedPDF/1001628-Base-Broadening-Tax-Reform.pdf

Basically he's going to cut marginal rates but keep things revenue-neutral by eliminating deductions. But there's no mathematical way he can do that without eliminating more in deductions for the middle/working poor class than they would save in lowered rates.

And which, prey tell, deduction(s) is he going to cut?

And have you looked at the chart?

Do you see all those non-tax payers?

You seriously think they use deductions to figure their taxes?

Home owners yes, but I'll bet dollars to donuts that the home owners deduction won't be touched.
 
And which, prey tell, deduction(s) is he going to cut?

And have you looked at the chart?

Do you see all those non-tax payers?

You seriously think they use deductions to figure their taxes?

Home owners yes, but I'll bet dollars to donuts that the home owners deduction won't be touched.

First off, I'd like to request that you remove those charts from your signature. For those of us on tablets or netbooks it makes Lit very hard to use. I don't want to iggy you but every time I load a page I have to scroll around to find the text. Maybe put links to the charts in your sig? Thanks for considering it.

Secondly, yes they use deductions to figure their taxes because several of the most common deductions do not require itemization.

Thirdly, no we don't know what deductions Romney would eliminate because he's too afraid to tell America what his policy really is. He knows people wouldn't like his tax plan so he's asking voters to back it without knowing what it is and how it would impact them.

But it doesn't matter. The Tax Policy Center's analysis worked the scenario where Romney would only repeal deductions from the rich and then from the middle class on-down only as necessary. And they still concluded that it's a tax hike for anyone making less than $200,000 per year. And the thing is, we know Romney isn't going to take money from the rich first - even if he wanted to, his party wouldn't allow it. So the extra tax burden on the middle class and working poor is likely considerably worse.
 
You gotta understand, this report is THE HOLY GRAIL it's independent assumptions are ALL IN ROMNEY's favor, that makes its conclusions un-fucking-questionable...

You're going to lose this argument too because merc knows everything and you know everything else, just ask him.

While he's at it, he can explain to you how you can actually, in full fairness, tax the wealthy and not have them pass any of the costs on to the poor and the middle-class hidden in the goods and services they provide to them...

That one always gives me the giggles.

I wonder if they speak Austrian in OIHO, the 57th state, and if that's where we get the pronunciation of corpse-man...

The best plan of all was actually the Obama plan, but the Senate communized him by giving it zero votes of confidence. Perhaps if they had has an optimistic report from The Tax Policy Center and some models from Zandi, like the ones that proved the Super Senior housing derivatives were solid gold, the actual Holy Grail in which to bury banking debt so that they could expand unheeded under TIMMAH! Geithner's omniscient all-seeing Fed eye...

I see DEAD Heroes!

:eek:
 
You gotta understand, this report is THE HOLY GRAIL it's independent assumptions are ALL IN ROMNEY's favor, that makes its conclusions un-fucking-questionable...

I'm sure there's room to question the study. But you're not doing that.

It's kind of like how you told me my knowledge of the medical system is inaccurate "because your wife said so" while being unable to dispute anything in specific.
 
You see, what we have to do is tax the rich.

You see, that's the answer, why we can cut and cut and cut and cut and it won't add up to anything significant because of entitlements, so you see you add a meaningless tax hike (that gets passed on to the poorest among us) to the meaningless cuts and voilà! 7% unemployment and 2% growth and the Middle Class begins to grow!

It's VOODOO!!!

Zandi has a model for that!
 
First off, I'd like to request that you remove those charts from your signature. For those of us on tablets or netbooks it makes Lit very hard to use. I don't want to iggy you but every time I load a page I have to scroll around to find the text. Maybe put links to the charts in your sig? Thanks for considering it.

Secondly, yes they use deductions to figure their taxes because several of the most common deductions do not require itemization.

Thirdly, no we don't know what deductions Romney would eliminate because he's too afraid to tell America what his policy really is. He knows people wouldn't like his tax plan so he's asking voters to back it without knowing what it is and how it would impact them.

But it doesn't matter. The Tax Policy Center's analysis worked the scenario where Romney would only repeal deductions from the rich and then from the middle class on-down only as necessary. And they still concluded that it's a tax hike for anyone making less than $200,000 per year. And the thing is, we know Romney isn't going to take money from the rich first - even if he wanted to, his party wouldn't allow it. So the extra tax burden on the middle class and working poor is likely considerably worse.

A one day reprieve on the sig, just 'cuz you axed so nice.

If would look at the chart you will see almost half (50%) of earners have no tax liability to begin with, so how will limiting deduction, most of which they don't use in the first place, increase their tax burden.

Then there are those in the next piece of the pie who might use deductions to reduce their liability. What deductions they use is anyone's guess. But, a renter earning $95K a year really only has the basic standard deductions, unless he is throwing half his earning at a charity.

Then again, all this has to be approved by congress, unless he pulls an Obama and skirts the Constitution, which he won't do.
 
I don't hate it. I think working-poor families should have little or no income tax burden. And there are shitloads of them as the middle class disappears.

And Romney wants to hike takes on the middle class and working poor now. The man should not get your vote.

The O-Conomy: How President Obama's Economy is Crushing the Middle Class
Peter Morrison, The American Thinker
August 23, 2012

You know it is election season when you start hearing the phrase "middle class" in every sound bite from every candidate. Both the Obama and Romney campaigns are going to try to cast themselves as protectors of the middle class.

The reason for this campaign messaging is simple: everyone in America wants to think of himself as middle-class. The very concept of middle class fits into the Norman Rockwell depiction of the American experience.

...

Gas prices have gone up sharply under the watch of President Obama. In November of 2008, the average cost of a gallon of unleaded fuel in the U.S. was $2.151. The price of gas subsequently dropped to $1.689 in December 2008, and when the president was inaugurated in January 2009, the average price was $1.787 per gallon. We have not seen gas below $3.00 per gallon since December 2010. In 2011, the annual average was $3.527, and in 2012, the average so far is $3.652. According to a 2011 CNNMoney data analysis, the average American household spent $368.09 per month on gasoline. This is would equate to $4,417.08 over the course of the year. This is more than the $3,100 average that the Consumer Federation of America estimated in a study.

...

The rising cost of food also hits middle-class families directly in the pocketbook. According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion's most recent data (June 2012), for the moderate-cost food plan for a family of four, the average cost per week is $236.60. AOL's DailyFinance.com explains not only how this impacts a family's bill currently, but how the rising food prices and recent drought are only going to make the matters worse.

...

At a minimum, the average family of four is looking at over $17,500 a year in combined grocery and restaurant bills. Using the same median annual income amount of $50,945, this means that the average family of four is spending 34.4 percent of its income on combined food costs.

During a growing economy, the rising cost for families at the dinner table and at the pump would be unpleasant, but American families are being forced to pay these higher prices and have much less money to do so than when President Obama was inaugurated. According to Sentier Research, in January of 2009, the median annual household income was $54,962. In June of 2012, the median annual household income was, again, $50,945. This means that since President Obama's inauguration, the exact middle family in the United States has lost $4,017 in annual income.

Links at: http://www.americanthinker.com/2012...mas_economy_is_crushing_the_middle_class.html

Yeah, it's ROMNEY that's the clear and Present danger to the middle class.

Yet, he managed to save an Olympics as well as saving and creating actual jobs some of them actually in the middle-class, while Obama and Rezko were building substandard slums for poor that neither lifted them out of poverty or propelled them into the Middle-Class...
 
A one day reprieve on the sig, just 'cuz you axed so nice.

If would look at the chart you will see almost half (50%) of earners have no tax liability to begin with, so how will limiting deduction, most of which they don't use in the first place, increase their tax burden.

It's because a rate deduction on people with an already low rate doesn't help much. And the reduction of their credits and deductions will exceed the value of what they gained in the rate change.

The entire philosophy here is to "broaden the base" - a term which you may have heard quite a lot. That means raising taxes on the lower middle and working poor class. And somehow it doesn't violate the Grover Norquist no-tax-hikes-4-life pledge. (?)
 
It's because a rate deduction on people with an already low rate doesn't help much. And the reduction of their credits and deductions will exceed the value of what they gained in the rate change.

The entire philosophy here is to "broaden the base" - a term which you may have heard quite a lot. That means raising taxes on the lower middle and working poor class. And somehow it doesn't violate the Grover Norquist no-tax-hikes-4-life pledge. (?)

Then why has Obama raised taxes on the middle class and poor?
 
Then why has Obama raised taxes on the middle class and poor?

Because he can, but he didn't, don't you know the party line?

He gave them GAZILLIONS in targeted tax relief.

Things like ca$h for clunkers...

The 6K you get for taking on an additional 60K in new employee costs...

The gifts to people who got to buy homes they could not afford to keep them in the homes they could not afford until after the 2010 elections...

Look President Obama is the best friend the middle-class ever had because the Republicans want them to have dirty water, dirty air, sick parents, dead grandparents and if they're black to be back in CHAINS!
 
That's funny. Exactly what Bush Sr. said about Reagan's trickle down theory. The theory Romney is operating on.

Prove it.

Which school of economics does "trickle-down" come out of?

You can look, but you won't be able to find it because it is a made-up phrase designed in the slogan format to relieve Democrats of the burden of doing any real thinking about economics that keeps them comfortable with the "bottom up" poverty of centralized planning.
 
Then why has Obama raised taxes on the middle class and poor?

Obama's payroll tax cut exceeds the value of the tax hikes. And he extended the Bush tax cuts beyond the sunset date Republicans wrote into the law. And there were tax breaks in the stimulus to factor in as well. ~$280 billion of them.
 
Back
Top