Ishmael
Literotica Guru
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2001
- Posts
- 84,005
Spinning off from the "Ginsberg" thread.
It appears that no one is aware of the fact that there is no particular "Right to vote" granted by the constitution. As originally written it was up to the various states to determine who could vote, it at all. Over the years amendments have been added to the constitution prohibiting the states from discriminating re. the ability to vote based on race, gender, age, and the imposition of a poll tax. Outside of those boundaries the states could determine any parameter at all regarding who could vote.
That is until the "Voting Rights Act" of 1964. The federal government took charge of the parameters required as to who could vote, but only in a select number of states or in select areas of a state. That was contained in title V of the act, the title recently declared unconstitutional. And it was blatantly unconstitutional, so much so that I'm amazed that it survived as long as it has.
Regardless the law stood for 50 years and served its purpose. Many of the states targeted by the law had outlandish statutes on the books for the sole purpose of trying to prevent blacks from voting. Such as requiring a literacy test, then handing the applicant a ball point pen and a sheet of wax paper and asking them to write out the preamble to the Constitution. And only requiring the applicant that happened to be black to take that particular test with the provided materials. Obviously something had to be done.
Now the 'hand-wringing' is over the fact that many of those states that have had that particular yoke removed from their necks dare to require the individual to do nothing more than to be able to prove who they are. It seems to escape the hand-wringers that the state of Indiana imposed that requirement some time ago and that that requirement passed court muster. While those states effected by title V could not do so, even though it had been deemed constitutional already. Clearly a case of Orwell's edict of all being equal, but some being more equal than others.
The imposition of the requirement that the citizen be able to furnish proof of identity is NOT an undue burden in today's society, especially when that requirement applies to ALL citizens. Preserving the integrity of the vote overshadows those few anecdotal cases of individuals that may feel unduly inconvenienced. And the fact that such laws may impose an undue burden on those that shouldn't be voting not only doesn't phase me in the least, it delights me.
Ishmael
It appears that no one is aware of the fact that there is no particular "Right to vote" granted by the constitution. As originally written it was up to the various states to determine who could vote, it at all. Over the years amendments have been added to the constitution prohibiting the states from discriminating re. the ability to vote based on race, gender, age, and the imposition of a poll tax. Outside of those boundaries the states could determine any parameter at all regarding who could vote.
That is until the "Voting Rights Act" of 1964. The federal government took charge of the parameters required as to who could vote, but only in a select number of states or in select areas of a state. That was contained in title V of the act, the title recently declared unconstitutional. And it was blatantly unconstitutional, so much so that I'm amazed that it survived as long as it has.
Regardless the law stood for 50 years and served its purpose. Many of the states targeted by the law had outlandish statutes on the books for the sole purpose of trying to prevent blacks from voting. Such as requiring a literacy test, then handing the applicant a ball point pen and a sheet of wax paper and asking them to write out the preamble to the Constitution. And only requiring the applicant that happened to be black to take that particular test with the provided materials. Obviously something had to be done.
Now the 'hand-wringing' is over the fact that many of those states that have had that particular yoke removed from their necks dare to require the individual to do nothing more than to be able to prove who they are. It seems to escape the hand-wringers that the state of Indiana imposed that requirement some time ago and that that requirement passed court muster. While those states effected by title V could not do so, even though it had been deemed constitutional already. Clearly a case of Orwell's edict of all being equal, but some being more equal than others.
The imposition of the requirement that the citizen be able to furnish proof of identity is NOT an undue burden in today's society, especially when that requirement applies to ALL citizens. Preserving the integrity of the vote overshadows those few anecdotal cases of individuals that may feel unduly inconvenienced. And the fact that such laws may impose an undue burden on those that shouldn't be voting not only doesn't phase me in the least, it delights me.
Ishmael