Voting "Rights"

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
Spinning off from the "Ginsberg" thread.

It appears that no one is aware of the fact that there is no particular "Right to vote" granted by the constitution. As originally written it was up to the various states to determine who could vote, it at all. Over the years amendments have been added to the constitution prohibiting the states from discriminating re. the ability to vote based on race, gender, age, and the imposition of a poll tax. Outside of those boundaries the states could determine any parameter at all regarding who could vote.

That is until the "Voting Rights Act" of 1964. The federal government took charge of the parameters required as to who could vote, but only in a select number of states or in select areas of a state. That was contained in title V of the act, the title recently declared unconstitutional. And it was blatantly unconstitutional, so much so that I'm amazed that it survived as long as it has.

Regardless the law stood for 50 years and served its purpose. Many of the states targeted by the law had outlandish statutes on the books for the sole purpose of trying to prevent blacks from voting. Such as requiring a literacy test, then handing the applicant a ball point pen and a sheet of wax paper and asking them to write out the preamble to the Constitution. And only requiring the applicant that happened to be black to take that particular test with the provided materials. Obviously something had to be done.

Now the 'hand-wringing' is over the fact that many of those states that have had that particular yoke removed from their necks dare to require the individual to do nothing more than to be able to prove who they are. It seems to escape the hand-wringers that the state of Indiana imposed that requirement some time ago and that that requirement passed court muster. While those states effected by title V could not do so, even though it had been deemed constitutional already. Clearly a case of Orwell's edict of all being equal, but some being more equal than others.

The imposition of the requirement that the citizen be able to furnish proof of identity is NOT an undue burden in today's society, especially when that requirement applies to ALL citizens. Preserving the integrity of the vote overshadows those few anecdotal cases of individuals that may feel unduly inconvenienced. And the fact that such laws may impose an undue burden on those that shouldn't be voting not only doesn't phase me in the least, it delights me.

Ishmael
 
that's the problem with you, you want all the great things about America but unwilling to do shit for it, then you whine about "its my right for free shit" as your ignorant ass thinks obama care is free and along with all the other entitlements

get off your ass and at least support yourself!

stop bitching about more free hand outs. grow a pair of balls and become a man, not a bitch





 
The stated purpose of the requirement for government issue "voter id" is to combat fictional "voter fraud", which has been proven time after time to be a manufactured controversy.

The real purpose of requiring government issued "voter id" is to place as many roadblocks as possible to keep voter turnout down, which gives well-organized fringe groups a statistical edge at the polls. This is especially beneficial to fringe groups in "off year" (i.e. non-presidential) elections.

"Voter ID" is the all-important first step towards voter disenfranchisement.
 
The stated purpose of the requirement for government issue "voter id" is to combat fictional "voter fraud", which has been proven time after time to be a manufactured controversy.

The real purpose of requiring government issued "voter id" is to place as many roadblocks as possible to keep voter turnout down, which gives well-organized fringe groups a statistical edge at the polls. This is especially beneficial to fringe groups in "off year" (i.e. non-presidential) elections.

"Voter ID" is the all-important first step towards voter disenfranchisement.



derp derp derp, it has been proven that fraud exist. however, obama needs every vote to keep his regime in power. here, smoke some obama juice
 
LOL...just heard this on a Sunday morning show:

There's only one 'problem' voter ID solves: Non-Republicans voting.
 
the 14th, 15th, 19th and 24th amendments all mention 'The Right to Vote'.

If the right does not exist, why is it mentioned 4 times in the constitution?
 
LOL...just heard this on a Sunday morning show:

There's only one 'problem' voter ID solves: Non-Republicans voting.

From The Voting Wars, by Richard Hasen:

If I wanted to steal an election using voter impersonation fraud, I'd have to recruit a bunch of people to vote at the polling place using fake names. But they might not follow my directions. They might go into the polling place and not vote, they might vote under their own names, or they might vote for someone other than the candidate I paid them to vote for. This is the problem with any elections crime scheme based on voters using a secret ballot in a polling place.

But impersonation fraud represents an even greater hurdle. There are two ways to impersonate. One way would be to have people claim to be somebody else listed on the rolls. This is obviously problematic: If I send you in and direct you to claim to be Thor Hearne, who I know is registered to vote in that precinct, but Thor has already showed up to vote, you would be immediately subject to arrest.

You might be arrested even if Thor has not yet voted. In many precincts, poll workers are local individuals. One of them could well know him. "You're not Thor" could also land you in jail. Moreover, many places do a signature match. Your signature would not match Thor's.

The other way of doing impersonation fraud would be for me to get you to fill out a registration card with a false name and address. The voter registration card would be turned into election officials, who will check the name and address against existing records. These forms have to be turned in weeks before the election. I'd then need to recruit people to go to the polling place on Election Day and falsely claim to be a person on the list. And federal law already provides that first-time voters must supply a driver's license or Social Security number if they register first to vote by mail -- or provide identification to election officials when they vote for the first time.

Either gambit requires assembling enough coconspirators to affect the outcome of the election. Could I do it, even in a very small election, without getting caught? We don't have a single recent example of anyone even attempting it. Why try such a risky scheme when absentee ballots are so much safer and more reliable? [N.B.: Hasen is not talking about fraudulent absentee ballots but bought absentee ballots; as he notes elsewhere in the book, absentee voting is the one area where vote-buying still happens sometimes, because, unlike voting a secret ballot on e-day, it leaves a paper trail which the buyer can check if he has the right inside connections, or simply check in person by watching the voter fill out the ballot.]

The chance that impersonation fraud can effect a presidential, statewide, or even large city or county election is miniscule. Missouri had about four million registered voters in the 2000s. The idea that impersonation fraud could be done on a large-enough scale to affect the outcome of any major race, without detection by government officials, is ludicrous.
 
Spinning off from the "Ginsberg" thread.

It appears that no one is aware of the fact that there is no particular "Right to vote" granted by the constitution. As originally written it was up to the various states to determine who could vote, it at all. Over the years amendments have been added to the constitution prohibiting the states from discriminating re. the ability to vote based on race, gender, age, and the imposition of a poll tax. Outside of those boundaries the states could determine any parameter at all regarding who could vote.

That is until the "Voting Rights Act" of 1964. The federal government took charge of the parameters required as to who could vote, but only in a select number of states or in select areas of a state. That was contained in title V of the act, the title recently declared unconstitutional. And it was blatantly unconstitutional, so much so that I'm amazed that it survived as long as it has.

Regardless the law stood for 50 years and served its purpose. Many of the states targeted by the law had outlandish statutes on the books for the sole purpose of trying to prevent blacks from voting. Such as requiring a literacy test, then handing the applicant a ball point pen and a sheet of wax paper and asking them to write out the preamble to the Constitution. And only requiring the applicant that happened to be black to take that particular test with the provided materials. Obviously something had to be done.

Now the 'hand-wringing' is over the fact that many of those states that have had that particular yoke removed from their necks dare to require the individual to do nothing more than to be able to prove who they are. It seems to escape the hand-wringers that the state of Indiana imposed that requirement some time ago and that that requirement passed court muster. While those states effected by title V could not do so, even though it had been deemed constitutional already. Clearly a case of Orwell's edict of all being equal, but some being more equal than others.

The imposition of the requirement that the citizen be able to furnish proof of identity is NOT an undue burden in today's society, especially when that requirement applies to ALL citizens. Preserving the integrity of the vote overshadows those few anecdotal cases of individuals that may feel unduly inconvenienced. And the fact that such laws may impose an undue burden on those that shouldn't be voting not only doesn't phase me in the least, it delights me.

Ishmael

To understand days gone by you gotta know something about those days. As G.K.Chesterton said, BEFORE YOU GO TEARING DOWN FENCES YOU MIGHT OUGHTA FIND OUT WHAT THE FENCE IS FOR.

Take my lil Southern hometown. We didn't hate blacks, in fact we elected a black to the city council before the Voting Rights Act passed. The man was exemplary by any measure, and we elected him. It didn't keep us from disrespecting the mass of black people in town, but we weren't so disabled we couldn't distinguish quality from trash.

That is, if any black man could graduate school, graduate college, serve as a captain in the army during a war, marry the mother of his children, and improve his community while avoiding prison, etc. he was okay.
 
Give William O Douglas another year of life and he could discover any "right" you want in some constitutional penumbra.
 
It appears that no one is aware of the fact that there is no particular "Right to vote" granted by the constitution.

Thank you so much for putting your finger on the problem! Yes, we do need a constitutional amendment!
 
The UK has a problem too. A different problem about who has the right to vote.

Every year each household is sent a form to complete, listing those living there who are old enough, or nearly old enough, to vote. If that form isn't returned, or is incomplete, or is lost in the post - then the voter is not registered.

It is up to the voter to check that their name is on the electoral roll where they live. That usually means visiting a council office during working hours to check the printed list.

If the person moves home between the form being completed and the election, they will not be able to vote in their new location - unless they have taken action to remove themselves from the old voting list, and put themselves on the new one. It isn't on most people's check-lists for moving home.

In urban areas of cheap apartments the number of people moving each year means that registered voters might be as low as 50% of the actual population. Even in affluent suburbs only 80% could be registered.

For local government elections the turnout is usually low, even lower if the weather is bad. Some electoral wards might have a 20% turnout of the 50% registered so those elected are chosen by 10% of the population of that ward. A few votes might mean the difference between being elected or not i.e. 10 votes or less.

When I consider how many men fought and died in WW2 to protect the principles of democracy and the ability to choose our governments, I think that many of us in the UK fail to appreciate what our unused votes actually cost in blood.

Unlike in the US, in the UK the numbers of people who are not registered to vote affects all three major parties.

And yes, UK voters have to prove that they are on the voters' list, preferably by producing the voting card sent to their registered home address, or some other ID. Even so, fraud is possible and every election seems to produce some few instances of detected fraud.

Our politicians are just as remiss about not dealing with the problems of our voting systems.
 
As I said in this thread:

Look, guys, if you really want to make absolutely sure no noncitizen or felon ever votes illegally, there's only one way: A national ID card (issued free of charge so there's no question of it being a poll tax) combined with a national database. Your file on this database would be referenced and accessible by any of your ID numbers (national ID, SSN, DL, passport, etc.). It would include scanned copies of every documentary record of every personal interaction with American government you ever have had on any level -- birth certificate, school records ("I hope you know this will go down on your permanent record." It will! :)), DL applications, welfare or unemployment applications, any records of arrest, conviction, restoration-of-rights, naturalization record if applicable, military record if applicable, etc., etc. Any time you interact with government, the paperwork will be emailed to the agency running the database automatically. Including, at the last, your death certificate, and then your file will be marked "DECEASED."

This would eliminate the need for voter registration. If you are legally eligible, your ID -- any ID -- would be your registration; everyone who is in this database is registered to vote automatically. Just walk in and show it to the poll workers. They'll slide it through a credit-card reader and be able to see any disqualifying points right in front of them; if it turns out you can't vote, you will not be arrested but simply be politely turned away, no harm, no foul. If the system is done right, you'll be listed on the precinct-rolls already, just because government has a record of your current address. A problem arises only if you have not interacted with government since the last time you moved; that would be the only case where a "provisional ballot" might be in order.

Otherwise, the only purpose of voter registration is to let you register as D, R, or I, and the only point of that is which party's primary you get to vote in; but that could be an election-day choice, why not. If you maliciously want to vote in the other party's primary for strategic reasons -- well, you can do that now, just register for that party.

This database would also make identity theft much harder, and fugitives or anyone under an arrest warrant easier to catch. Undocumented immigrants, too -- and those who employ them. And, of course, the database would be an important source of accurate statistics. Heck, it might even substitute, to some limited degree, for the Census.

Apart from the expense, I see no objections to such a system. "You have zero privacy anyway. Get over it."

But I think some will object. It just doesn't sound American, y'know? "Are hyour paperz in order, mein Herr?"

But, look, we've already gotten used to a system where, when you're driving, a cop can pull you over for any reason that seems good to him, and demand to see your DL, and check it against a database with his onboard computer, and if you have any arrest warrants you'll be arrested.
 
Over in The Constitution Thread, the framers are currently adjourned until Monday, August 6, so that the Committee of Detail "might have time to prepare & report the Constitution" based on the Resolutions already offered up to the day of adjournment, Thursday, July 26...

...once they reconvene, the framers will still debate another month+ before finally agreeing to the Constitution we know today (or, at least the Constitution some of us know today).

Everything about Voting "Rights" is all there, and it is revealingly informative reading first-hand what the framers had to say on the issue, and why they finally agreed the way they did...

...the Convention began on May 25 and Madison's Notes covering from then to now count-in at over 125K words - it's so very sad that so few care to read the framers' own thoughts, yet very useful in discerning the bozos who have no idea what they're babbling about.
 
Back
Top