"Trusted computing" - an oxymoron?

The Heretic

Literotica Guru
Joined
Oct 26, 2002
Posts
28,592
Yep - I'm on a Register kick this morning:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/4/28016.html

For those not speaking nerd, what the article is basically talking about is the capability of future MS operating systems to be able to control the content you can view - all in the name of "Trusted Computing" (as differentiated from secure computing). I especially found telling the remark that 'Anderson insists that TCPA has an underlying agenda of "fixing the software theft problem, dealing with free software and satisfying the NSA-FBI," '

Ummm, I don't know about you, but I personally don't trust the NSA-FBI any more than I trust Disney to have my best interests at heart, and I don't want either one to have control over the content on/in my computer.

This, combined with some other trends I see in future MS products (including operating systems), makes me seriously consider giving up the power of the Dark Side and going over to Linux or something similar.

And Mac users, don't go on about the MacOS being immune to this - OH PLEASE! - if you believe that then I have a bridge in Brooklyn I would like to sell you.
 
The Heretic said:

And Mac users, don't go on about the MacOS being immune to this - OH PLEASE! - if you believe that then I have a bridge in Brooklyn I would like to sell you.

If you do find someone so gullible can you please mention that we have a certain Mr & Mrs Windsor and family that some of us are rather anxious to off load.:D
 
The Heretic said:
Yep - I'm on a Register kick this morning:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/4/28016.html

And Mac users, don't go on about the MacOS being immune to this - OH PLEASE! - if you believe that then I have a bridge in Brooklyn I would like to sell you.

Immune? Of course not. Resistant. Apple is already being scrutinized and shunned by the entertainment industry for not implimenting DRM already.

Sadly, it'll come.
 
There is significantly more to "Trusted Computing" than the small section of that entire article that deals with software licensing. Even that is only a possible use - not the main core of the concept. Switching your OS isn't going to get away from it either.

If the technology advances far enough your ISP will be using it to authentic your login to the Internet and every WWW site out there will build their pages around it. All of the app makers will start incorporating hooks into their applications as well so you'll be dragged into it kicking and screaming just like hundreds of thousands of us were dragged into Windows OSs to begin with.
 
ma_guy said:
There is significantly more to "Trusted Computing" than the small section of that entire article that deals with software licensing. Even that is only a possible use - not the main core of the concept.
I am aware there is more to it than that, but this is the bent that MS is coming from, and since 90-something percent of computer users run MS products, especially MS operating systems, this is a very troubling aspect of "trusted computing". If I can't trust my computer to do what I want it to do, if someone else has control over it, then I don't consider it "trusted computing" regardless of the rest of the paradigm.

Switching your OS isn't going to get away from it either.
Not completely - but an Open Source OS where such content/copy protection will not be present (except possibly in the hardware), you can get away from the parts that I object to.

I am all for people being able to maintain their rights to own the content the create or buy rights to, but I am against content providers mandating that technology enabling and mandating such protection be built into our hardware and software.

The article also raises the troubling aspect of what happens to the Gutenberg principle when this happens? If the government can control what content you have on your computer, then can they implement censorship that much easier?

We already know that the US government has compromised other country's encryption products in order to snoop on their comms, and that they have asked various US providers of encryption/privacy products to provide them with similar backdoors so they can snoop on us. Add to the ability to not only listen to what we have to say, but to control what we listen to and read, and I see a very dark future.
 
Back
Top