"Top Kill" fails

Regulations are specific, arbitrary and not fixed the way law is. Laws are general if they are just, objective, and within the framework of the Constitution. Laws are simple, basic protections of an individuals right, like association and pursuit of happiness.

The reality is that laws are most always subjective to some degree. They get changed quite often. Laws get very specific too. They can be quite arbitrary as well. Which leads too ...

Regulation at the Federal level is a direct attack on the right to association and the pursuit of happiness (property) just as by inserting itslef into the employer-employee relationship, it usurps the worker's right to association and self-regulation through unions and union training and industry regulations.

You're off in Randian lala land. There's a reason Rand is dead and mostly forgotten. And it wasn't just her lack of charm and good looks. This is Uncle Bill's drool all over again. It was tedious then, and it's no different now.

AJ, this world of yours that you want doesn't exist. It never existed. It never will exist. It's unrealistic and it always will be. You come across like a Trekkie with this stuff. Uncle Bill did too. You can rub all your conservative wishes together all you want. The Rand Fairy just isn't going to come visit and give you your special world.
 
The reality is that laws are most always subjective to some degree. They get changed quite often. Laws get very specific too. They can be quite arbitrary as well. Which leads too ...



You're off in Randian lala land. There's a reason Rand is dead and mostly forgotten. And it wasn't just her lack of charm and good looks. This is Uncle Bill's drool all over again. It was tedious then, and it's no different now.

AJ, this world of yours that you want doesn't exist. It never existed. It never will exist. It's unrealistic and it always will be. You come across like a Trekkie with this stuff. Uncle Bill did too. You can rub all your conservative wishes together all you want. The Rand Fairy just isn't going to come visit and give you your special world.

Are you ignoring the surge in book sales?

Or were you just unaware of it...

When laws become subjective, as they increasingly did under and after FDR, then the oligarchy emerges, and from it springs the strong man. Hayek was especially good on that (as was Rand).

It's a phenomenon as old as Aristotle, and no, we really have not evolved our culture due to technology since the bronze age...

They become apt to take because they wish to spend and cannot do this easily; for their possessions soon run short. Thus they are forced to provide means from some other source. At the same time, because they care nothing for honor, they take recklessly and from any source.
Aristotle
__________________
When under the pretext of fraternity, the legal code imposes mutual sacrifices on the citizens, human nature is not thereby abrogated. Everyone will then direct his efforts toward contributing little to, and taking much from, the common fund of sacrifices. Now, is it the most unfortunate who gains from this struggle? Certainly not, but rather the most influential and calculating.
Frederic Bastiat
 
I thought liberals were the rich eliteists. The ones with the fancy educations?

Two classes of liberals. The Ivory Tower Intellectuals that Dostoevsky and wrote about and the sons and daughters of the conservative rich whom have through education grown uncomfortable and guilty about their wealth and then the masses (Hoffer: True Believer, Alinsky) that they rally to their cause and infect with their purview.
 
And Pookie...





I'm not talking about the world. I'm talking about the Constitution as written and discussed in Federalist.

It did exist and gave the states the freedom to be as subjective as they wanted. But once the Federal Government left the Constitution, it put the individual on the road to serfdom. Regulation is it's way of "inflating" the political currency...
__________________
"Lenin is said to have declared that the best way to destroy the Capitalist System was to debauch the currency. By a continuing process of inflation, governments can confiscate, secretly and unobserved, an important part of the wealth of their citizens. There is no subtler, no surer means of overturning the existing basis of society than to debauch the currency. The process engages all the hidden forces of economic law on the side of destruction, and does it in a manner which not one man in a million is able to diagnose."
John Maynard Keynes
 
Are you ignoring the surge in book sales?

Or were you just unaware of it...

I said mostly forgotten. And for gawd's sake, don't make me repeat that.

Speaking of gawd, the Bible is still selling pretty well too. Quite popular actually.
 
Your cited example specifically targets theft by way of fraud or deception, no?

I have to go do ambulance stuff now, but I'd like to see if I can figure out where you draw the line between "specific target" and "murder" or "specific target" and "mineral extraction." Does the question make sense?

Or do they fear anything at all? I mean there's a lot of posturing going on and political "noise" but they are in bed with government in energy AND financial services (I have a BP points credit card) and they have a huge rolodex and war chest to use against the politicians who are cozy with them and have abdicated their role as law and order maintainers to the spin-off regulatory industry. This is why we saw all the howling in the recent SCOTUS decision on campaign contributions. The people paying protection now have a way to fight back if they aren't protected!

And no, Perg I don't see your question as making a lot of sense at the moment as you are asking it.

Try digesting this:

You can't get a law? Or better yet, you don't WANT a law because you can be stuck with it on your resume.

You create the EPA. Then you have them declare CO2 a poison.

You endlessly and arbitrarily change CAFE standards.

If something goes wrong, you don't take blame, you fire a regulator. To the public it's a promotion but to him it's an advancement as he takes his rolodex with him and becomes a lobbyist.

A law gets you no credit when you actually enforce it, take immigration, for example... ;) ;) You might take umbrage should someone else point out your lack of enforcement and embarrass you and accuse them of being a criminal...

Regulation, on the other hand has that Oooomph of theater, the aura of action, the appearance of responsibility, the allure of safety in the mind of the politically fickle and uneducated. Additionally when the stop sign is run, you get to point fingers, make new claims to better regulation and show why you should be re-elected as a tireless watchdog of the public's interests. Regulation is political POWER.

Under a system of Libertarian jurisprudence, there is little, if anything for the politician to do. That's the problem with the Founding Fathers for the altruistic "do something" socialist political class as politicians, they want to make a difference (and so does the reporter). There is no political future in standing up to an inflamed constituency and saying the issue is already addressed by law hence you get the superfluous law, the regulation, and the Executive order...

The problem that I have with you and kbate when it comes to LIbertarianism is that you consider the environment as your "neighborhood." You want your neighborhood to be safe from the "reckless drivers" so you think it is a good and prudent role for the city council to put up lots of stop signs. The twofold problem is it doesn't make your neighborhood "wreckless" and then when you try to go across town and the health care neighborhood is nothing but stop signs at every corner, and the business district is nothing but stop signs at every corner, then you have no moral ground to stand on when you discover it takes all day just to get somewhere...

1) Here's the question: How do you distinguish between a law that specifically targets "theft by fraud or deception" and one that specifically targets "theft by odometer tampering?" You stated you had issues with laws that "specifically target" stuff. Some laws "specifically target" murder. What's wrong with that?


2) In re: the EPA, I don't see health care and the planet we live on as the same thing. If we poison the planet enough, nothing else matters. All the king's liberals and all the king's libertarians and all the king's conservatives and all the king's socialists will just simply up and die. I have no problem with unusual and/or extraordinary measures being used to protect the planet. And before you start with the Gaia crap, no, I don't worship it.
 
Back
Top