This Deplorable tactic of attacking LGBTQ people under the guise of caring about women's rights...

Let me start by saying that it's awesome that you're a long standing fan of womens' sports. So you probably know that the highest a male has ever scored in a game of bowling is 300, and that's also the highest score a woman has ever scored. With all these advantages no male has ever scored higher than a woman.

So there's your answer.
You’re the consummate contrarian, any angle to win an argument.
 
I realize phrodeau, that you are not an educated human and that we must take that into account for not understanding "science". Like I said if they dig up your old bones a 1,000 years from now they are not going to classify you as intersex, but as a male or female. Look it up. Of course since most wokes don't know what a male or female is and hate the idea of females having rights, we can not excuse such stupid dark age wisdom. And if you agree with old child molester, sex pervert Biden that the drag queen freak is your hero above all others too, then you are one sick puppy.
 
I realize phrodeau, that you are not an educated human and that we must take that into account for not understanding "science". Like I said if they dig up your old bones a 1,000 years from now they are not going to classify you as intersex, but as a male or female. Look it up. Of course since most wokes don't know what a male or female is and hate the idea of females having rights, we can not excuse such stupid dark age wisdom. And if you agree with old child molester, sex pervert Biden that the drag queen freak is your hero above all others too, then you are one sick puppy.
Oh you might be right about the bones, but I have heard, and I might be wrong so don't quote me on this, that their are reported cases of individuals who have been born with both female and male sex organs. The dictionary definition of intersection is what is described just now, but I also concede that I might be wrong, and you also don't have to take this as truth either, but I just like to look at the facts that are around so as to help me, and others who would like to understand the world.
I wish you good health either way my good sor
 
OK, you say you believe in Science. Here is a question. Suppose you are like 74 or Rory and are a trans and yet you haven't had your ah, thing chopped off. Not that makes a difference to science. You see a thousand years from now some member of science is going to dig up your bones and make a study. They will find that human's come in two sexes. It's science. Look it up. They will determine that becasue of your bone structure and other data they can retrieve, that you were born either a male or a female human. (hey they don't know you like we do) They won't be able to say, "Oh, this fool thought he was a woman so he forced his way into women's rest rooms, took over their sports, made them into third class people (like in some of the countries you are so proud of) and then we can class "it" as "different". No it is not science. Your bones, for what they are worth, will be classified as either "male" or "female" regardless of what foolishness is in your mind, either confusion, forced mutilation or you were just a pervert. Like Mr. Biden says, "It's science man."
Uhm okay but also what does that have to do with current society. You are talking about the future when we are all dead, so what does it matter then?
 
If you are talking about me...then yea...you don't get it.

Name one physical competitive sport...one...should be simple because you can pick from hundreds...where the woman's record exceeds or betters the man's. One. One and i go away.

Then ask yourself...at what age (give or take) does this differention between sexes occur? Why does this happen? This is not saying women athletes are crap...fuck anyone of them are better than I ever will be. But I am not trying to compete against them.

If a male goes through puberty...their body is built different. There are people with genetic abnormalities that never go through puberty. You can see the difference. Does this difference provide a physical competitive advantage? Well...let's see if anyone here can come up with one example out of hundreds of possibilities where a female record exceeds the male. Hell...dig deep...look at high school records too.

So the advantage is real. This is why we have different teams for different sexes. Fairness. Title Nine was built on this understanding.

Now, if people want to say...well the hormone therapy equalizes this competitive advantage...then...why do we not see a decrease in competitive times or whatever criteria measures the sport?

It can't be both ways.

Now, as for the rest of the Republican led attacks. They are bullshit. Restricting insurance. Firing. All wrong. Maybe the issue with public restrooms? I can see both sides here. But if a trans woman is allowed to use a woman's restroom...why not everyone. Same is true reversed. Why does it matter? Why is the right of one greater than someone that would be uncomfortable?

This is a huge problem that didn't exist. Just like Republicans making laws saying they are protecting children...when they do nothing to protect children from guns. Now...it is an issue. And because of sports and restrooms...all other restrictions happened. Was that worth it? We are just as much to blame as them. Why? Because both sides view it as all or nothing. Find a middle...move on
Are you unaware that to Transition, you need to switch your hormones?
So to become a male you need to switch to testosterone, and to become a women you need to switch to estrogen, and also it has Ben disproven that trans female have an advantage over cisgendered female
 
Drivingto, thank you for your comments. I will research what you have said as it is the correct thing to do as you point out. As to your second comment, "what does that have to do with current society"? It has to do with science. I realize there was a time when people thought the world was flat and science has proved it wasn't. And I am sure at the time, people then asked the same question you did, but is that an excuse for being incorrect? In this case the future and the present and the past all agree that there are two sexes in the human race. There are mutations and birth defects of course, but science shows that as far as the sex of the two beings that make up the human race, one is female and one is male.

Right now, in order to cause social unrest, mainly for political reasons, there are "humans" who wish to mutate and confuse and molest our young. The governor and his wife in CA are good examples of that. That behavior is now part of "our current society", but that does not make it right, legal or proper. I know in a dictator ship, families are evil and parents have no right to their own children. They belong to the state and their minds and bodies belong to the leader (king, chairman, or whatever they wish to call themselves). But again, just because it is part of "current society" doesn't make it right. People use to be cannibals. Do you say that is OK if people want that now as it was a "current society" at one time?

As Mr. Biden says "its science man" so we should explore the science and look at the true evidence. Not only a 1,000 years from now, but if they dig up your bones in six months time they will still find the same "scientific" fact that those bones belong to a male or a female. Regardless of "current society" myths.
 
Someone want to call 'science central" and explore what skills our friend Rory might have? :)
 
Just for the record, science is not a cult or religion, so belief in it would be ill-advised. By definition science is the pursuit of knowledge, but it should never close its doors to challenges based on new evidence.

It is quite difficult to ascribe sex from skeletal remains unless certain bones are present, namely the pelvic ones. Guesses can be made based on bone sizes, much their growth and bulk can be affected by diet and lifestyle. There is virtually no difference in the skeletal structure until well into puberty. Here's a sciencey link.

There are as many (1 - 2%) Intersex people as there are transgender or redheads in the US population ie if you've seen a red head, the chances are you've also seen an intersex and trans person. Frightening thought huh - they're everywhere. Human sex isn't neatly divided into male and female any more than it is in the animal kingdom - it is 'current society' that has made that assumption.

Here's a few examples of animals that change sex during their lifetime ( but some may have both male and female sex markers )
  • Hawkfish
  • Green Sea Turtles
  • Clownfish
  • Copperhead Snakes
  • Butterflies
  • and various others...
'Current' society is a good term, because society is continually evolving: women can now own property and vote. Our 2023 society is generally accepting of gender variation, but some parts of society would prefer things not to change. We'll just have to wait a few years for those views to pass on. 2/3rds of Americans oppose new anti-trans legislation but that's based on a poll, so you can nitpick over the exact number.

'Current society' does not mean looking back to cannibalism and claiming it to be acceptable. I'm not sure which society was intended, but the clue is in the word 'current'. How did cannibalism come up? It's not very sciencey to tout hysterical nonsense, because it raises the suspicion you might be unable to discern fact from fiction.

There have been trans folk mixing with society for many years without any problem, but it has only recently become a political issue both sides of the Atlantic. The UK govt recently used a discussion on a false claim that a child identified as a cat in order to block the next debate on the looming recession.

As I pointed out in an earlier reply, a number of sports bodies have now banned transgender athletes from competing in major competitions. There is still not enough data to provide meaningful guidance, so sports have generally erred on the side of caution because 'nobody is sure yet'. Athletes regularly give blood samples in many international sports, but they can only provide a snapshot of their hormone levels. If a trans woman has gone through male puberty, then bone density and limb length may give them advantages, although conversely their muscles bulk will have declined.

Blood samples are also now used to identify intersex athletes and four have been banned from events because although they were AFAB, their genetic variation gave them an advantage, particularly for track events such as 400m. So cis gender women are already being asked to 'prove they are women'. The Swedish women's soccer team were required to show their genitals to a doctor before the 2011 World Cup.

The slur that transgender people are pedophiles is as ridiculous now as it was when gay people were accused with the same phoney claim. Change isn't always easy to accept but transgender people have always been around: it is politicians and the media that have put it under scrutiny. There is nothing to fear from trans folk - we're here, no amount of legislation will make us go away, so we'd best work out how to get along.

Tribal fear is an emotive force, just as it was when people circled the wagons. Parents are fearful for the kids. Some parents are transgender, so are some kids, but they're not here to invade women's spaces - never have been. It's overwhelmingly men who are the problem for all women and commit 99% of sexual crimes, so where are the laws restricting them? Why are less than 2% of rapists convicted? Why is no one speaking out against that?

I've enjoyed putting that together and I hope it makes a decent read. Thanks for the opportunity :)
 
Right now, in order to cause social unrest, mainly for political reasons, there are "humans" who wish to mutate and confuse and molest our young. The governor and his wife in CA are good examples of that.
What does that even mean?! If you're referring to the state statutory rape law, all they did was remove a double standard that allowed for lenient sentencing in the case of vaginal sex but not oral or anal.
 
There was a British female cyclist named Beryl Burton. In 1967, she set the world record for the 12-hour time trial of 277.25 miles. This surpassed the men's world record by 0.73 miles. Burton's world record was not beaten by a man until 1969.
If being trans gave cyclists an unfair competitive advantage, Lance Armstrong would have tried it already.
 
Chromosomes XX, XY and variants such as XXY, XX and XY, X0 and refer to sex, not gender.

"Gender refers to the characteristics of women, men, girls and boys that are socially constructed. This includes norms, behaviours and roles associated with being a woman, man, girl or boy, as well as relationships with each other. As a social construct, gender varies from society to society and can change over time."

I looked it up
 
There are only 2 Genders. XX & XY! Look It Up!
^^^Great example of how a little bit of knowledge in the hands of an ignorant fool is a dangerous thing.

Reminds me of when BoBo, who bragged about his academic credentials in biology, used to totally ignore epigenetics and all factors affecting the expression of genes.

There is a very good reason why gender expression conforms to the bell curve of statistical distribution and not the rigid binary virtual world of Deplorables.
 
Back
Top