The Walking Dead

[Wrong Element]

I'm not entirely convinced Carol actually did kill those two... I think it was the one of kids she was mentoring

Carol doesnt strike me as someone that would leave such a huge trail of evidence

I think she did burn the corpses, but she's covering for the kids

this would be the same eprson that's dissecting rat corpses all round the place and leaving them for the walkers

just think about it for a second.. the kid was told to stop being weak, doesnt really have a parental figure for guidance except Carol and she's telling them to shut their emotions down... they saw their dad sick and Carol told them to kill him.. so they see the two sick people, so they decided to prove they're " strong" and kill them


got a kid sociopath and Carol took the fall to protect them

My problem with this theory is that Carol's mentoring hadn't been all that extensive. There were those clandestine lessons on knife use, which from what we saw hadn't really gone into much detail, and then all hell broke loose. What was the period of time between when the girls' father was killed (and the daughter was unable to deliver the key blow), and the two sick people (the first two to get sick) were killed? Wasn't it later the same day, possibly the next day? That's an awfully narrow window for Carol's lessons to take hold.

Not saying you're actually wrong. The rat-feeder, the rat-dissector, and the killer of the two sick folks (if not Carol) has to be someone we've met, or else the producers haven't been playing fair with the audience.

I think it is pretty obvious the drunk is the guy feeding walkers etc...
Think back to the perfectly dissected rat. Kids couldn't do that and he has some medical training. ( I must have missed all his back story, as I do not recall them explaining where the medical training came from).

That does not mean the kids/little girl did not kill the two sick people.

Separate events IMO

add in all the other groups he has been with where he walks away the sole survivor, drunk, slightly weird and the evidence piles up.

Bob, the drunk, was an Army medic. I don't know much about their training, but I don't know that it gives one much more insight into actual anatomy than you would get from dissecting in high school biology.

But what I said above applies to Bob too. I sense there's a reason he's around other than just showing us that alcoholism doesn't take a break for the zombie apocalypse, and we haven't seen what that reason is yet. The point about his having been associated with other groups and being their sole survivor is a little bit suspicious, I agree.

 

[bg23]

Andrew Lincoln has done some good stuff here. Was in a fab spooky series called Afterlife. And Morrissey has been in tons of crime dramas. Didn't know about Maggie though.

she was in supernatural for a stint

 

[Fata Morgana]

she was in supernatural for a stint

Crikey. Didn't recognise her.

 

[bg23]

Crikey. Didn't recognise her.

i know!! she cleans up well. she was all femme fatale in supernatural but here she's all grimey and dirty all the time so hard to recognise.

i recognised the mouth though. i have a fixation on mouths.

 

[remy_lebeau8]

I think in the cast Hershal is/was the only true blue good ol Georgia boy.

My cousin lived in the city they filmed the first two seasons in. A lot of the cast lived in his apartment complex. The pictures he showed me when they made thr sets were cool as hell

 

[Sean Renaud]

Maggie does clean up well, I didn't notice her until someone pointed her out. Like half the cast (I exaggerate it's only three of them) are in Steven Kings The Mist. I was watching it with friends and we all started cracking jokes about how if those three get together shits about to hit the fan. . .they should actually be praying for Zombies those are much easier to deal with than fifty foot tentacle monsters.

That said it wouldn't shock me if the writers aren't playing entirely fair with the audiance. I've always thought you should start dropping clues in cases like this before characters. I'm still sold that one of the girls who thinks the biters are sick people is the one feeding them rats, just like Herschel fed em chickens before they broke him of that belief. They fed them consistently at the same spot which was what concentrated em. (Which leads to the fridge logic that if they'd focused on that they could have herded the zombies where they wanted them, perhaps into pits for easy stabbing, then lighting on fire. (Note the Walking Dead has that awesome super fire where a few leaves on top is enough to burn the bodies not the incredible use of resources it would be otherwise.

 

[remy_lebeau8]

If I remember right the mist was done by Frank Darabont as well. Hes got a thing with using the same actors. I think mob city (badass show) has either 3 or 4 actors from walking dead as stars

 

[spacekowboy]

I wish Carl had blown The Governor's head off.

 

[Skiddles2014]

zombies

 

[Fata Morgana]

I wish Carl had blown The Governor's head off.

I'm warming to Carl since he became all stoic like. Hated him in the first two seasons, the annoying little cunt.

 

[Sean Renaud]

I think I'm the only person didn't hate Carl and thought the adults were twice as stupid twice as often with half the excuses that Carl had as a kid. Frankly I'm sick and tired of Rick. Dude has been a fairly big screw up since day one and some of it is shit he should have known was a poor idea from day fucking one.

 

[Fata Morgana]

He does act like a snivelling knobhead a lot of the time.

 

[Sean Renaud]

He just repeatedly makes poor decisions often because he's WAY too soft. Some are understandable ignorance especially at the beginning but really, the dude just keeps fucking shit up and or getting fantastically lucky.

 

[Beco]

I think I'm the only person didn't hate Carl and thought the adults were twice as stupid twice as often with half the excuses that Carl had as a kid. Frankly I'm sick and tired of Rick. Dude has been a fairly big screw up since day one and some of it is shit he should have known was a poor idea from day fucking one.

Love Carl...he asked the kid nicely, drop the gun, drop the gun. I mean, how many times does he have to repeat himself???

 

[Sean Renaud]

Love Carl...he asked the kid nicely, drop the gun, drop the gun. I mean, how many times does he have to repeat himself???

Not only that but considering much of the hatred of Carl in season 2 is that if he had killed that walker from the creek then old man would still be alive today (ignoring that he left the show cus he's tight with Darabont) had that kid buttstroked him, killed Hershel and the woman we'd all be throwing our hands up pissed that the pussy kid still didn't have what it took. He just can't win.

 

[remy_lebeau8]

Not only that but considering much of the hatred of Carl in season 2 is that if he had killed that walker from the creek then old man would still be alive today (ignoring that he left the show cus he's tight with Darabont) had that kid buttstroked him, killed Hershel and the woman we'd all be throwing our hands up pissed that the pussy kid still didn't have what it took. He just can't win.

Half the shows tight with Darabont. They kind of combined hershal and dale into one character.

 

[Sean Renaud]

Yeah, but my understanding both of the Comic and of the show is that in the comic Dale lives, and ultimately wanders off (right about now in fact) but they killed him because the actor didn't want to stick around after Darabont was fired. That's my understanding of the situation anyway. I generally don't pay much attention to the IRL drama of any show.

 

[Aquagal]

Maggie was on the Talking Dead show during finale week, she's very pretty. The accent was surprising. She got teary-eyed several times talking about the loss of Herschel. He was also on the episode, they seemed to have a close relationship.

 

[spacekowboy]

I'm warming to Carl since he became all stoic like. Hated him in the first two seasons, the annoying little cunt.

If he would have just stayed in the damned house....

That said, I have a newfound respect for Carl. That kid has been born again hard. He knows what it takes to survive in this world even moreso than his father.


And I must say, the first time I heard Andrew Lincoln speak for the first time out of character, it threw me for a loop.
All of these beans and toast eating MFers invading my pristine 'Merican airwaves!

 

[Beco]

Maggie was on the Talking Dead show during finale week, she's very pretty. The accent was surprising. She got teary-eyed several times talking about the loss of Herschel. He was also on the episode, they seemed to have a close relationship.

They have a lot of other actors on the cast from other countries. The Gov, even Rick, not American

 

[Sean Renaud]

Just curious why does anybody care? After Hugh Laurie and Hugh Jackman I'm no longer at all impressed by actors managing to conceal their natural speaking voices and other than that I could care less if Maggie's from the moon or not. She's still not half as sexy as Bella. Which is odd, they have so much in common in the face and body areas, just one has long black hair, is British and once volunteered for angry hate sex. Oh that last part might be what makes the difference though.

So what is everybody expecting for the second half of the season? I haven't read the comics much past this point but I know they eventually find another city but it seems that after . . .whatever the Governors city was called that they aren't going to plop Rick back into a city where people look to him as the leader again too soon. If they wanted to do that they could have done that already.

I'm calling it now by the way, that psycho bitch and Carl are gonna start making moon eyes at each other and if the show lives long enough she's gonna get get the dick.

 

[Beco]

Just curious why does anybody care? After Hugh Laurie and Hugh Jackman I'm no longer at all impressed by actors managing to conceal their natural speaking voices and other than that I could care less if Maggie's from the moon or not. She's still not half as sexy as Bella. Which is odd, they have so much in common in the face and body areas, just one has long black hair, is British and once volunteered for angry hate sex. Oh that last part might be what makes the difference though.

So what is everybody expecting for the second half of the season? I haven't read the comics much past this point but I know they eventually find another city but it seems that after . . .whatever the Governors city was called that they aren't going to plop Rick back into a city where people look to him as the leader again too soon. If they wanted to do that they could have done that already.

I'm calling it now by the way, that psycho bitch and Carl are gonna start making moon eyes at each other and if the show lives long enough she's gonna get get the dick.

I just wish they would talk in their native tongue....whats the big deal

 

[ms_ann_thrope]

The Walking Dead Season 4 Returns

 

[Aquagal]

So the Herschel head. I thought once decapitated, it wouldn't turn zombie. Or is it just when the brain has been punctured? Are there tons of zombie heads scattered around in the woods after all the ones that Michonne took out?

Also, she sure cleans up well! That dream sequence and then she was on Talking Dead, she was quite beautiful.

 

[VaticanAssassin]

So the Herschel head. I thought once decapitated, it wouldn't turn zombie. Or is it just when the brain has been punctured? Are there tons of zombie heads scattered around in the woods after all the ones that Michonne took out?

Also, she sure cleans up well! That dream sequence and then she was on Talking Dead, she was quite beautiful.

Yes, The brain has to be damaged for them to die. Remember all the moving heads in the governors aquarium?

She sure does. It will make it easier to visualize when her and Rick finally fuck.