Teaching...... By not teaching.

See what happens when they aren't forced to sing the obama songs. :cool:
 
I disagree. The purpose of a public education by the state serves the same purpose as a private education administered by the Catholic Church...

Ok. You lost me. What are you disagreeing with? The only thing I said is it would probably would not work in the US. Are you saying it would? Or are you disagreeing with the "free" learning style from the article.
 
"We teach to the lowest common denominator..."

No, we do not. We teach to the ignorance of every student equally in order to indoctrinate them to a *ahem* respect for government and Social Justice. I have a kid in school now and these memes permeate every subject including math. They do not even care if the kids possess basic skills; they just regrade the tests, dumb down the material and double down on the Social Justice aspect of the material being presented. There would have to be some actual teaching going on to teach to the LCD, but all that is being done is a presentation of the material with an emphasis on keeping the free Federal lunch and breakfast funding coming in.
 
Interesting Idea.

But it would never work in America. We teach to the lowest common denominator, to the detriment of all.

http://www.wired.com/business/2013/...buffer&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=Buffer

It would never fly in America to try it, nobody in America is remotely close enough to liberal enough to try that. And I highly doubt it's a workable plan in general from reading it but it certainly isn't anything Americans are ready for, you're right about that.
 
Nuthin is easier than learning.

The problem is, school has no prestige.
 
Nuthin is easier than learning.

The problem is, school has no prestige.

"... the human animal is a learning animal; we like to learn; we are good at it; we don't need to be shown how or made to do it. What kills the processes are the people interfering with it or trying to regulate it or control it."
John Holt
 
"We teach to the lowest common denominator..."

No, we do not. We teach to the ignorance of every student equally in order to indoctrinate them to a *ahem* respect for government and Social Justice. I have a kid in school now and these memes permeate every subject including math. They do not even care if the kids possess basic skills; they just regrade the tests, dumb down the material and double down on the Social Justice aspect of the material being presented. There would have to be some actual teaching going on to teach to the LCD, but all that is being done is a presentation of the material with an emphasis on keeping the free Federal lunch and breakfast funding coming in.

I agree with a lot of this, but that does not make it that much different from my statement.

Sometimes leaving one behind is the best for all.
 
I agree with a lot of this, but that does not make it that much different from my statement.

Sometimes leaving one behind is the best for all.

No, your premise seems to be that our schools are teaching.

My experience tells me that they are indoctrinating and as long as you are doing that, you cannot teach. What you seem to be applauding is the state not setting the curriculum and I am 100% jiggy wid dat...

;) ;)
 
Dear Suddenly-the-Voice-of-Education:

I'm guessing you didn't read far enough to find the part of the article that talked about how this is being done in the US. In lots of places in fact.

Kind of ironic, you have to admit.

Signed,
A guy who read the whole article
 
"We teach to the lowest common denominator..."

No, we do not. We teach to the ignorance of every student equally in order to indoctrinate them to a *ahem* respect for government and Social Justice. I have a kid in school now and these memes permeate every subject including math. They do not even care if the kids possess basic skills; they just regrade the tests, dumb down the material and double down on the Social Justice aspect of the material being presented. There would have to be some actual teaching going on to teach to the LCD, but all that is being done is a presentation of the material with an emphasis on keeping the free Federal lunch and breakfast funding coming in.

Which of your state standards includes social justice in Math?
 
I skimmed the article until I came to the part with the world rankings. That's a pet peeve of mine because it invariably compares ALL kids in the US with the STUDENTS of other countries.

Quite a few countries kick out the dummies, but in the US all kids are required to stay in school until (usually) they are 16. It's not a fair comparison.
 
Which of your state standards includes social justice in Math?

I refer to the Common Core textbooks and the word problems contained within as well as the grading standard which I have discussed in depth before with examples including how the teacher does not care if the students get the wrong answers and the many wrong answers I discovered in the text.

You should also have a disclaimer when you post about education that you are dependent upon government funding for your livelihood.
 
I skimmed the article until I came to the part with the world rankings. That's a pet peeve of mine because it invariably compares ALL kids in the US with the STUDENTS of other countries.

Quite a few countries kick out the dummies, but in the US all kids are required to stay in school until (usually) they are 16. It's not a fair comparison.

Was that a typo?

Did you mean 26 or PhD, whichever comes first? :devil:
 
No Child Left Behind is pretty much phased out in every state (or altered so much it isn't the same) & even when it existed, it wasn't a standard.

It speaks to the top-down mentality of the National Government and it wards.

One-size fits all and all must pass the national tests.

No room to try other methods...
 
I refer to the Common Core textbooks and the word problems contained within as well as the grading standard which I have discussed in depth before with examples including how the teacher does not care if the students get the wrong answers and the many wrong answers I discovered in the text.

You should also have a disclaimer when you post about education that you are dependent upon government funding for your livelihood.

The word problems are written by a private publishing company. The wrong answers you claim to have discovered were also written by a private publishing company.

It's math. I imagine the teacher is concerned with getting the right answer, but is also concerned with what steps the students take to get the right answer.

Since when am I dependent on government for my livelihood?
 
I don't have a problem with national standards. A high school diploma should mean the same thing everywhere.

Of course, the taxes on the Savage Estate pay for the #1 school district in the country. So I'm a bit biased toward holding the kids to a high standard.
 
The word problems are written by a private publishing company. The wrong answers you claim to have discovered were also written by a private publishing company.

It's math. I imagine the teacher is concerned with getting the right answer, but is also concerned with what steps the students take to get the right answer.

Since when am I dependent on government for my livelihood?

I'm sorry. I forgot. Your employer is dependent on government funding; he works in the public sector and because he pays you, you work in the private sector.

Which textbooks does the government print?

Or..., is it a matter of which meet its standards and is that not the same political decision-making that got us Solyndra?
 
I don't have a problem with national standards. A high school diploma should mean the same thing everywhere.

Of course, the taxes on the Savage Estate pay for the #1 school district in the country. So I'm a bit biased toward holding the kids to a high standard.

It should mean something, but since some minority kids refuse to fucking meet that standard, it's just not cool, it's all white and stuff, it means almost nothing at any college you apply to which now has to teach retroactively the material that should be know by all applicants.
 
I skimmed the article until I came to the part with the world rankings. That's a pet peeve of mine because it invariably compares ALL kids in the US with the STUDENTS of other countries.

Quite a few countries kick out the dummies, but in the US all kids are required to stay in school until (usually) they are 16. It's not a fair comparison.

Even on a grade by grade basis we suck.
 
Back
Top