Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
This is how you answer when you do not have cogent arguments to defend your position.
This is how you answer when you do not have cogent arguments to defend your position.
My positions require no defense, nor was I answering you. I was merely pointing out your magnificent obsession with what you describe as 'the Left.'
It is.And English is supposed to be your first language?
They played fast and loose with commas in those days.The subsequent but for some reason less quoted edit, from around the time of ratification iirc, cleared it up.
For persons interested in resolving issues of constitutional intent and
interpretation, this is an essential reference. It makes clear what some
of the terms mean that are used in the Constitution, words that are not
commonly heard today, or whose meanings have changed.
Mr. PINKNEY & Mr. GERRY, moved to insert a declaration "that the liberty
of the Press should be inviolably observed."
Mr. SHERMAN. It is unnecessary. The power of Congress does not extend to
the Press."
Then, since that was the style of the time, it doesn't.A comma can change the meaning of a sentence rather dramatically.
No, they don't. Unless you're desperately nit-picking.That comma doesn't change the meaning of the sentence. Or if it does I'm not sure how exactly it does. The commas in the second (not to mention 200 years worth English Evolution) leave quite a bit in question.
What a stupid thing to say.Not that it matters, the Constitution is really only something people bring up when they don't have a quality argument.
No, they don't. Unless you're desperately nit-picking.
What a stupid thing to say.
The Supreme Court agrees with me. Case closed.Constitutional Lawyers disagree with you.
It's stupid and it's not the truth.It may be a stupid thing to say, but it's the truth. For whatever reason you find the truth stupid. It's a common enough trait.
The Supreme Court agrees with me. Case closed.
It's stupid and it's not the truth.
You must think you're stupid yourself for arguing about the Constitution.
Your assertion is laughable, and fallacious to boot.Fair enough that the Supreme Court agrees with you (to whatever extent that's true)
And yes it is the truth, I didn't bring the Constitution into the debate, so no I don't feel stupid. Besides I'm just entertaining myself. It's a way to pass the time. It doesn't change the fact that the Constitution is only brought up by people who have no solid argument to make.
Your assertion is laughable, and fallacious to boot.
You didn't bring the Constitution into the debate? You're posting in a thread about the Constitution!! Gods, I'd be embarrassed to be you right now...
You're just Bad Luck Shleprock, aren't you?Yep. I'm the OP. I didn't notice that, thanks for outing an alt though.
You're just Bad Luck Shleprock, aren't you?
Even stupider that you're waiting for that.Nope. I'm still waiting for you to show me how I started this thread.
In the Congressional Statutes at Large, Vol. 1, Page 97, at http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llsl&fileName=001/llsl001.db&recNum=220, the first and third commas are omitted, so that it reads:
A well regulated Militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.
The question remains open of where those additional, and grammatically spurious, commas came from, but they do not change the legal meaning of the provision, and it would not be erroneous to omit them.
^ red herring alert: nobody cares who started it.Unless I'm the one who started the thread I'm not the one who brought the Constitution into this. I might be commenting on it, but that's not the same as starting it.
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State . . ."
This thread should've been childed under the "equality" thread...
...because a subjective, how do you feel about "strict constructionism" stab thread like this presumes, erroneously of course, that everyone's opinion on such a supremely objective topic is somehow equal.
As usual, though, degree of education and the true knowledge retained and furthered by more education is the actual determinant of the objective value anyone has to offer - particularly on such a staunchly objective concern as this Constitution for the United States of America.
Everyone has an opinion just like everyone has a butthole...
...butD) very, very few can offer anything else when it comes to objectively discussing the Constitution.
A crazy concept, I know, right? The less you know of a subject, the more bull you have to sling...
...so, mostly because I am such a compassionate person and care immensely for my fellow man (men only because I hate women), I bring to this playgrounder-started thread the most glorious gift which could be bestowed upon it:
The Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787 by James Madison
Did you click?
What a perfectly practical tool freely available for any one who sincerely wishes to objectively educate themselves from the prime source...
...and the prime source is no exaggeration at all: what you see on that beautifully simple webpage is the only detailed information the world has in regards to what was actually discussed during that unique summer of 1787.
Linked below the calendars is Madison's Introduction, PREFACE TO DEBATES IN THE CONVENTION: A Sketch Never Finished nor Applied; read it, study it, comprehend it...
...and revel in the political-revolutionary righteousness of Americana.
In the link next to that, Editor's Introduction, compiler Rowland states:
Don't be misled: retracing what was discussed during the Convention with only Madison's hand to guide one can be difficult, at times, to decipher; and continuing to plow through what 99.5% of human beings would consider a waste of time isn't, needless-to-say, for everyone.
For just a morsel of enticement, let me quote an occurrence that Madison noted which happened on Friday, September 14, the next-to-last day of the Convention (Saturday being the wrap-up day, Monday being the ceremonial signing day), because it relates directly to where this subjective thread evolved from (the ongoing, hyperbolicly-emotional, subjective Oprahization "debate" on gun-control)...
...it directly relates because throughout the Convention various delegates would move to include inherent rights (like an individual's unalienable right to arm himself) in the text of the Constitution. But every single time the majority would counter that those rights were no business of the new federal government, and that the whole purpose of this new Constitution was to specifically limit the power this new federal government could exert, and so any power not specifically granted to the federal government by the C was prohibited to it by its very exclusion.
And, thus, at the very same time, all inherent rights of the People were guaranteed - negatively - by their exclusion from the specifically enumerated powers of Congress, and thus - automatically - the other 2 branches of federal government...
...(always keep in mind: only Congress can make federal law; Congress (the Legislative branch), the President (the Executive branch), the Supreme Court (the Judicial branch), and the People are all subject - EQUALLY - under those federal laws. And if no constitutional law exists, all 3 branches and the People are totally free to do as they wish - at least that's how it's supposed to be, if "equality" has any literal chance to exist among mankind at all).
Anyway, back to Friday the 14thD):
One last time, a couple of delegates moved to get what they considered a vital right inserted into the original text of the Constitution...
...and one final time the moved was immediately countered by the same argument all likewise attempts had been met with throughout the Convention:
("Mr. PINKNEY" is Charles of South Carolina; "Mr. Gerry" is Elbridge of Massachusetts and gerrymandering fame; and "Mr. SHERMAN" is, of course, Roger of Connecticut):
"The power of Congress does not extend to the Press"...
...how in the world can anyone but the disingenuous and subjectively ignorant (which are redundant in relation to the truth and objectivism) misinterpret that simple, flat-out dictate?
You can go to the webpage I've offered, click on September 14 (see what nice guy I am?), and read how the vote on the motion to protect freedom of the press in the Constitution itself turned-out.
I won't link to the precise point in Madison's notes on Friday the 14th in negative encouragement that you'll start at the beginning of the day and read yourself to it - that would be educating yourself to begin objectively understanding this prototypically objective thingy called America's Constitution...
...yet, I equally understand, that most reading this - if you do click the link, if you do get past the first couple of paragraphs of the 14th's notes, if you do read the entire day's offerings - probably won't care to trouble themselves with reading the rest of Madison's Notes.
Which is sad for truth because if you don't take the opportunity to practically educate yourself why and how stuff happened during the Convention, you have absolutely no chance of every understanding - objectively - why George Mason, one of the 3 main conspirators in adjourning the Convention in the first place (the other 2 being Geo. Washington and Madison himself) refused to sign the Constitution (along with 2 other delegates) on the final day of the Convention, Monday the renowned September 17, 1787...
...and why Mason toiled so strenuously for the incorporation of a Bill of Rights thereafter, one of which - the 2nd - was conceived to simply underscore objectively that the right to bear arms shall not be infringed upon by the federal government.
Alas, I am truly such a nice guy that I continually advise on this Board that you posers simply get started on effectively trying to do what you disingenuously deem to do...
...get to work on a 28th that'll take the inherent right bite out of the 2nd.
Personally, I do not believe you'll be successful and, even if there became a 28th, Constitutional War over it is still a distinct possibility...
...but Constitutional War is all but guaranteed, in my worthless and unarmed opinion, if you choose to continue to illegally infringe upon a right that was ratified to be beyond your - and government's - business to do so.
What's cool, again in my worthless and unarmed opinion, is that you do inherently understand how intrinsic the unalienable right to bear arms is concreted into American political consciousness - that's why there exists absolutely no serious effort to repeal the 2nd...
...but you don't feel it should be such an inherent right so, knowing a 28th effort isn't feasible - now at least - you simply continue to champion the illegal infringement upon the very fabric of constitutional law itself, disingenuously insisting all along you're really not infringing at all on an individual's unalienable right to bear arms.
Sorry if holding-up Madison's Notes as an absolute standard for objective debate re: the Constitution doesn't agree with anyone's subjective preference(s)...
...but I'm definitely a perfectionist when it comes to this, one of the most important of the very, very few American political cornerstones.
If you choose not to educate yourself to the same standard, but still expect - nay, demand - your ignorant opinion to be worth anything but giggling matter even to Oprah...
......well, good luck with that.
Let those who have eyes, see the truth I have posted here...
...let those who have brains, discern that truth from the rest of the baloney I habitually contribute.
Ok...
...I'm done.